Preview

Prescriptive Privilege: A Stand Against Granting Psychologists

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1162 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Prescriptive Privilege: A Stand Against Granting Psychologists
Prescriptive Privilege: A Stand against Granting Psychologists Prescriptive Authority

Prescriptive Privilege: A Stand against Granting Psychologists Prescriptive Authority

In this age of globalization, businesses are racing to combine products to offer one-stop-shop services. The profession of psychology has secured a place on the track by championing prescriptive privileges to psychologists. The shortage of psychiatrists to prescribe psychotropic medication is one of the leading reasons that drive proponents within the field of psychology to advocate the movement to grant prescriptive authority to psychologists. Although obvious implications of psychologists having prescriptive authority may include positive results for public mental
…show more content…
This leaves many psychologists wondering why the same privilege cannot be given to their profession. The fundamental concerns with prescription privileges are neither the client convenience nor marketability of psychologist’s profession, but education and training. For most of the lay community, the only thing that differentiates a psychologist from a psychiatrist is the ability to prescribe psychotropic medications. This is untrue. There are significant differences in undergraduate, pre –doctoral, and post-doctoral training of each discipline. More specifically, psychiatrists are required to complete a considerable number of hours in physical science and pharmacology coursework. This academic disparity puts psychologists at a severe disadvantage for competently prescribing psychotropic medications. According to Robiner, Bearman, Berman, Grove, Colon, Armstrong, Mareck, and Tanenbaum (2003), “strict continuing education requirements would be warranted to keep psychologists up-to-date with the burgeoning formulary of psychotropic and nonpsychotropic medications (with which they may interact) and to assist them in overcoming gaps associated with their condensed training” (p. …show more content…
The barriers they encounter could also differ. This attempt to maximize the effectiveness of psychology is yet again missing the mark. In this push to provide better services, proponents are neglecting to consider the effects on different race groups. As mention earlier, the shortage of psychiatrist, mainly in rural areas, is the driving force for prescriptive privileges. It is logical to assume that because psychologist charge less than psychiatrists a large portion of their clients are of African descent. Despite unique barriers these clients are receiving non-medication therapy. The simplest mention of medication could deter a client from returning to therapy or worst sentence a client to a life of drug dependability and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Drug treatment has been found to be effective in relieving the symptoms of mental disorders in many people. Despite the claims made for some modern drug treatment, however, there are critics and the use of drugs remains controversial. Fisher and Greenberg (1989) believe they have…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The psychologist faces many issues in the presented vignette. The first is the breach in confidentiality between the clinician and patients. Acknowledging the issue could potentially identify the patient. The psychologist also has the responsibility of providing an informal resolution to the ethical issue. The issue potentially harms the profession by instilling distrust of the public. The psychologist could provide discuss the violation with the offending psychologist to confirm if the misconduct has occurred and recommend ways to end it.…

    • 1611 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many concerns for therapists when treating clients from a multicultural population. Learning how to effectively work and communicate with clients from a culturally diverse population is part of the therapeutic process of the therapist. Therapists have received special training in areas of expertise that helps to improve the outcome and the performance of their client dramatically, simply because they have gain insight about the client, and the ability to address the client’s needs. This paper is intended to highlight these concerns in three different setting. The first setting will discuss how client from a culturally diverse population might be affected when receiving medical treatment. The second setting will discuss the therapy…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the mental health field we have an ethical responsibility to only use therapies that have been shown to be effective. In the western world, it is a rite of passage for all physician’s to take the Hippocratic Oath which can be summed up with the phrase “Primum non Nocere” which means, “first, do no harm”. The purpose of such an oath is for doctors and psychiatrists to practice medicine honestly and ethically; however, with the emergence of physicians endorsing and using PHTs, physicians are straying from their code of ethics and putting the lives of thousands of people at risk. The use of PHTs has not spawned out of a desire to hurt clients but, instead, the lacks of discipline within the mental health field to allow treatments that have not been proven effective. This is exemplified through a lack of government oversight over treatment. In the medical field prescription medication must pass through a battery of tests before it can be cleared for the general public’s use;…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “I think that the medical industry, regardless of its intentions, has acquired far too much power over our inner lives; the power to name our pain and then sell us the cure, one pill at a time” (Greenberg, 1). I’m no stranger to antidepressants. I’ve struggled with depression and anxiety my entire life and after failed attempts at going through the counseling process, my family and I finally decided I needed something more. After calling a few places, I booked an appointment with a local psychiatrist’s office. I’d had an idea in my head of what it was like to see a psychiatrist. I figured I’d be psychoanalyzed in some comfy chair whilst relating words to strange pictures of blotched ink. Like in the movies. But it was nothing like that.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Karon, B.P. (1995). Provision of psychotherapy under managed health care: a growing crisis and national nightmare. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 26(1), 5-9.…

    • 2280 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chpt 12

    • 4494 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Psychologists who do psychotherapy have usually completed a doctoral program in clinical or counseling psychology, sometimes with additional specialized training. Except for New Mexico and Louisiana, psychologists in the United States may not prescribe drugs. However, many other states are currently considering granting prescription privileges to specially trained psychologists.…

    • 4494 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mental illnesses are more readily labeled today than at any other time in history. Today it is estimated that approximately 26 percent of the American adult population suffers from some mental illness. Growth in this number will likely skyrocket as a younger generation grows out of the category of the age of onset ‘teens’ into young adults. When it is commonplace for patients to hesitate before questioning their doctors, the possibility of becoming overwhelmed in a sea of side effects that are worse than the threat they encounter from the disorder grows. While it is difficult to narrow medicine down to a one size fits all answer, a look at a specific personality disorder, in which the patient is often misdiagnosed or labeled as normal…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When deciding if Clinical Psychology is the field and profession that a student will choose and follow, he or she will first look into what the history and evolving nature of Clinical Psychology. Looking into the history of Clinical Psychology one will see that Clinical Psychology has been around since the early times beginning in 2500-500 BC (Jones, 2004) until today. In the early years there was a belief that mental illness and any physical illness could be treated by herbs and reasoning (Jones. 2004). The history and evolving of Clinical Psychology began to sharpen into the belief of the body being one, St Thomas Aquinas believed that scientific thinking would and could explain illness of either mental or physical form (Witmer, 1907-1908). Like anything else, there is always a shift of thinking and people who feel there are other ways of looking at something, this was seen with…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racial bias creates barrier between nurse and patient relationship preventing effective and collaborative care of vulnerable excluded minority groups. Nurses need to work collaboratively with carers and families so that the can learn what is culturally normal and abnormal in a patient’s behaviour. In order to minimise the problem nurses need to be informed on how to intervene to reduce the damaging impact of racism and discrimination and tailor interventions to better address the specific needs of ethnic minority groups. There is need to increase effort to promote cultural competency in Mental Health services through maybe mandatory training on cultural competency issues which can also be incorporated in academic and professional mental health training programmes. There is urgent need to better communication that promotes and appreciate cultural differences while at the same time acknowledge the increasing diversity of our society.…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A client's culture can contribute in a big way when it comes to personal bias and diagnosis. In the African American community specifically mental illness is a disease that is not discussed and something that you definitely do not go to see a doctor about. African Americans are presumably more affected by mental than any other culture does to reasonings such as ongoing racial discrimination, high poverty, and constant segregation(Clifton, D, 2015).Those in the African American community tend to rely heavily on religion in hopes to heal their ones.Also, the stigma that is associated with the disease also deters those who may be suffering from mental illness for fear of being shunned by family and those in the community. Also, lack of accessibility and affordability prolongs diagnosis to a point where health begins to deteriorate, causing mounting issues to the point where making some form of diagnosis difficult.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mentally Ill Population

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Page

    Psychotropic medication training and dual treatment of comorbid diagnoses lead to fewer hospitalizations for the mentally ill. Individuals in need of psychotropic medication can benefit from learning the importance of complying with taking…

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article written by Jeffery J Arnett focuses on the arguments and criticisms on “why American psychology needs to become less American”. The main concept that Arnett argues is that modern psychology is secluded to the United States rather than being based on a broader section of the human population. This idea comes from analysing the current world population and noticing that “psychological researchers in the United States restrict their focus to less than 5% of the world’s total population” (Arnett 2008) therefore resulting in 95% of the world population being neglected, hence Arnett’s choice in the title of this article. He believes that in order for psychology to become an accredited science it needs to represent the entire world population,…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Psychology at Work

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many people think of psychologies either as therapist or as teacher psychology as a profession can be traced back only to the turn of 21st century through the writings of Sigmund freud, John Dewey, and others. During the founding of the American Psychological Association in 1892 the member were chiefly academic psychologist-teachers of psychology and person engage in research in psychology principles. At that time, psychology was almost entirely a “pure” science, relatively uninvolved with social application.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    We stay in a developing country filled with poverty (Hickson, Kriegler, 1991). Those who stay in poverty stricken areas are forced to face things such as illness, crime and death and are more exposed to things such as mental illness and educational problems. These all affect people, not just physically, but also psychologically. Psychologists play an important role in the treatment of individuals psychologically affected by these things.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays