top-rated free essay

Predoom of the Press in Malaysia vs the Western Countries

By Opocotbaby1 May 07, 2013 715 Words
From what I gather from my readings, the western world has 2 models that they follow in the modern-day world of media.

1) The social responsibility system
~ In the social responsibility theory of the press, the media is driven to benefit the public. It expects journalists to answer society's need for truth, requires an open and diverse debate on public issues, and honest updates of current events. In this model, media ethics is automatic because the press is free to serve its purpose for the public, as opposed to special interest groups or advertisers. Another condition of the social responsibility model is that news reporting cannot be dependent on groups that may encourage bias and unethical practices in exchange for financial support.

2) The Libertarian system
~ The Libertarian model is more popular in than the social responsibility model. In this system, the freedom of the press is endless; it is not constrained by the government, by society, or by media ethics. Instead of being a sea of different ideas, opinions, and voices however, news reporting in the Libertarian system is indeed restricted. It may not be as limited and biased as the media found in an authoritarian society, which would serve the government's interests, but it is still constrained by its financial dependence. Western media outlets, particularly television stations, rely heavily on advertisers for money, and therefore design their news reporting to support and never conflict with the will of their financial supporters. Also, because of the deregulation movement of the past fifteen years, Congress and the FCC have allowed more freedom within the telecommunications field, loosening laws that were at one time designed to ensure social responsibility and ethics in the media. Today, a large percentage of Western media outlets, especially those in America, are part of a handful of media conglomerates, companies that have to focus on increasing their profits every year. Back to this discussion and through my understanding and also readings, what differs between the “social media responsibility model” between Malaysia and the western countries is, Malaysia’s press freedom is constricted. While Malaysia has kept up with the rest of the world in technology and a prosperous economy, a truly free press in does not exist in this Southeast Asian country. Little has changed. The government still views the media as a means for promoting the government. It believes the press should not be sensational but should be a watchdog for society.

Journalists in Malaysia have to contend with many obstacles that journalists who live in other countries do not. The local and foreign journalists in Malaysia have to contend with various press laws and publications acts, as well as libel suits. It seems little change can be expected in the years to come so long as the government associates gains with a press controlled by the authorities.

The era of which Tun Mahathir Mohamed reigned as Prime Minister of Malaysia has actually curtailed and censored all “free speech” that the media wants the public to know. (In May 2001, on "World Press Freedom Day," the Committee to Protect Journalists meeting in New York City put Mahathir Mahamad on the "Top Ten Enemies of the Press" list.)

In Malaysia two opposing positions define the newspapers. The Barisan National, the ruling coalition, contrasts directly with its opposition. Press accounts suggest the Barisan is moderate and its opposition is extreme. Barisan promotes harmony among ethnic groups while the opposition creates ethnic conflict. The press in Malaysia fluctuates between ideas about democracy as ideal and the elitism that is the fact in this classist society.

In a nutshell, you can’t simply write anything under the sun without having consequences thrown back at you (hey, you could have a permanent resident at some jail if you’re not careful! Who knows?), especially on sensitive issues pertaining to the government. I have read somewhere, a survey conducted on freedom of the press for 2011, Malaysia was ranked number 144 out of so many countries worldwide, even Papua New Guinea was ranked at number 70 something.

So, the models of social responsibility media do not apply in Malaysia, for now, until the government changes the laws. After all, from what I see, we are suppressed and oppressed in that context when it comes to free speech.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • formation of malaysia

    ...MALAYSIA CONSTITUTION The Constitution is a document that contains all of the order of rules and regulations constitute an important policy for removing a country's governance and administration. Determining the constitution of the Kingdom,a form of government and the rights of the people. The Constitution also contains principles that fo...

    Read More
  • Challenges Facing Western Countries

    ...Challenges Facing Western Countries The global community as whole faces many problem, with developing nations having to confront a different set of issues than those of developed nations. Western societies have the luxuries of a high standard of living and general prosperity, but these luxuries also come with their own set of challenges and o...

    Read More
  • Globalization of Non-Western Countries

    ...As globalization continues to spread over the world, many countries are beginning to feel its effects. One example is the auto industry. The automobile business is evolving rapidly on a worldwide basis. Car and parts manufacturers are merging, component design and manufacture are now frequently outsourced instead of being created in-house, brand...

    Read More
  • Malaysia a Multi-Cultural Country

    ...Malaysia is a tropical country with around 25million people. Malaysia located at Southeast Asia, peninsula bordering Thailand and Northern one-third of island of Borneo, bordering Indonesia, Brunei, South China Sea and South of Vietnam. Malaysia separated in two islands just similar as New Zealand, the only difference is West and East Malaysia a...

    Read More
  • The Traditional Food in Western Countries

    ...The traditional food in western countries Each culture, ethnic group or region has specific traditions. When we talk about culture, especially in western countries, the religious beliefs and literature often take up our minds. But actually, the food culture contributes a lot to the construction of a region’s civilization and it also plays ...

    Read More
  • Malaysia, a Multiracial Country

    ...community at the end of the day • jobs are race-related Living in a multiracial society is complex. It requires an insight into the other races psyche and culture. It requires one to transcend stereotypical behaviors assigned to an ethnic group and see a person of another race as an individual, not by their race. SEGMENTAL DIFFERENCES...

    Read More
  • English vs. Bahasa Malaysia

    ...English vs. Bahasa Malaysia A German friend of mine once asked me why I did not use Malay as an every day language when I am Malaysian. What piqued his curiosity was when I had a Malay friend over and both of us had a conversation in flawless English. My German friend could not help but to ask us why the national language was not used. ...

    Read More
  • Eastern vs. Western Culture

    ...WHICH CULTURE IS BETTER: WESTERN OR EASTERN “The Last Supper,” the painting of Da Vinci illustrates the mental states of each subject and the expressions in a vivid manner and bring the subjects to life. Qi Baishi, a renowned painter of traditional Chinese painting, famous for painting shrimps could bring subjects to life within se...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.