Topics: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Legal death Pages: 20 (24537 words) Published: April 21, 2015
1. Saves Lives
2. Increases Scientific Knowledge
3. Curbs illegal activity 

Currently, in the United States, 114 827 people are on a wait list, waiting for an organ. Everyday, 18 people die waiting for an organ. Furthermore, just donating 1 organ donor can save 8 lives


Heart/Lungs: Can be preserved for up to 4 - 6 hours after death Pancreas: Can be preserved for up to 12 hours after death
Liver: Can be preserved for up to 24 hours after death
Kidneys: Can be preserved for up to 48 - 72 hours after death Corneas: Can be preserved for up to 5 - 7 days after death
Heart Valves, Skin, Bones: Can be preserved for up to 3 - 10 years after death [2]

Donated organs have resulted in an increase of understanding and research for these disease:
Heart Disease
Spinal Injuries
Joint Replacements
Cancer Research
Colon and Liver Treatments
Breast Cancer
Reproductive Advancements
Advanced Drug Delivery
Paramedic Training
Alzheimer's Research
Cochlear Implant Development [3]
In the current desperation of those who are impoverished, one of the options is to donate one of their kidneys on the black market. In Bangladesh, those who donate a kidney on the black market receives around $1500 [4]. Furthermore, in American these organs can be taken by force when the body is waiting for cremation. Organs and tissue is taken from these bodies and donated to hospitals and research facilities around the country. When these tissues are donated, tissues that have diseases are often passed off as "healthy" with forged papers. Illegal tissue from a single cadaver has reached 90 tissue transplant recipients. Clearly, the black market organ donation is very dangerous to the health of those who need organs.

So, what have we learned today? Organ donation saves lives and has been associated with advanced research and knowledge in the field of medicine. Furthermore, mandatory organ donation curbs the need for black market organ donations. For these reasons

Transplant success rates vary from 50%-90%.......​
So even if everyone is forced o give up their organs upon death there is no way that here is going to be a guarantee that its going to save 18 lives a day because with organ transplants re not always successful so no this mandate will not guarantee that 18 people will be saved a day.


Why is pro now suggesting that we donate our whole bodies after death? This is not in accordance to the resolution.
2. What if I want to be cremated after death.
3. It would not further scientific research. Maybe centuries ago there may have been body donation shortages but today there really isn't......More than 17,500 people donate their bodies to science each year


The only reason this would happen is because your making an illegal action now actually legal. This isn't really a valid contention. Also pro said this, When these tissues are donated, tissues that have diseases are often passed off as "healthy" with forged papers​

Wouldn't a mass supply of organs make people not want to check these organs and do the same thing? Also this happens in doctors offices as well my friend. his phenomenon is not exclusive to the black market. The only thing that's going to happen here is that the black market would be called the white market after this mandate would be passed. But those illegal actions would now be considered legal. One last thing. These body donations how would we know our bodies would got to scientific research and not some pervert who wants to violate dead bodies?

SO I believe that I have pointed out the many flaws of this mandate. There proves to be too many problems for this mandate to actually be made a law. For these reasons a con vote proves to be a logical response to this debate. I also want to mention that i beleive it is obvious that pro has the BOP and dont quite think that...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on Understand How to Support Positive Outcomes for Children and Young People
  • positive Psychology Essay
  • Positive Psychology Essay
  • Positive Attitude Research Paper
  • Positive Attitude Essay
  • Essay about Positive Thinking
  • Always be cheerful and positive Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free