Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Point of View: Prison: To Punish or to Reform?

Good Essays
553 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Point of View: Prison: To Punish or to Reform?
Deterrence is one of the primary goals in the criminal justice system and it is described as special or specific deterrence and general deterrence. The purpose of special/specific deterrence is to instill fear on the offender so that they will not commit future crime. General deterrence is based on punishing offenders to instill fear in society, otherwise known as teaching society a lesson and showing the consequences of committing crime. Punishment has always been imposed based on the idea that it will deter individuals from committing crime or repeating criminal acts. Incapacitation has been the most common form of punishment, however research demonstrates that recidivism amongst convicted felons following release from prison is as high as 63% and that most prison inmates had arrest records and convictions prior to their current offense. (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 1989) Punishment through incarceration is a temporary fix to crime while the offender is confined. The maximum sentence of life in prison and the death penalty has even been debated on whether they are deterrence to crime. There are so many underlying factors within the criminal justice system that may contribute to why punishment has not been as effective as anticipated such as the appeal process in death penalty cases and the length of time that an offender sits on death row.

Others argue that rehabilitation is a more permanent fix in deterring crime. Rehabilitation through community supervision can have a more lasting effect on individuals and deter them from committing future crime if they learn how to adapt in society by gaining academic or trade skills. These programs can help offenders find employment and secure an important role in the community and give them a sense of being. Therapy is another form of rehabilitation needed to help deter individuals from committing future crime. Some examples of therapy include drug therapy to those offenders addicted to drugs and psychological counseling to those offenders who grew up in an abusive household. Rehabilitation is based on creating a change in the criminal's attitude or resources so that crime is neither a desired nor necessary activity. When an individual is sentenced to probation, it gives them the opportunity to remain self-supporting within the community and not using the taxpayer and states money to house them in a correctional facility.

Victim Impact

In many cases, victim rights tend to be overshadowed by the rights of the accused. The courts are obligated to give a defendant their Constitutional rights including the right to a speedy trial, the right to counsel, the right to confront witnesses, and due process under the law. Up until recently, victim's rights were never recognized as an important role in the criminal justice system. In the past, victims and their families were often treated as inconveniences, ignored throughout trial proceedings, and sometimes even forced to stay out of the courtroom as the proceedings went on. These issues have caused many victims to feel neglected and even re-victimized by the courts. On October 30th, 2004, The Crime Victims' Rights Act was signed into law by President Bush to guarantee rights to victims of federal crime. These rights include, to be reasonably protected from the accused offender and to receive reasonable and timely notice of any public proceeding involving the crime or of any public proceeding. (feinstein senate.gov/booklets, n.d)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Would you believe me if I told you that prisons were originally built to reform prisoners? With they way the criminal justice system works and how high the rates of mass incarceration are, in today's day and age, I, myself, would not believe that prisons were built with a positive outcome in mind. If someone would have told me that in the eighteen hundreds prison were used as a place to reform individuals, I would have given them a nasty looking face full of disbelief. But now that I have this information, the question is, what changed? Why is this method still not being practiced in today’s society? However, while asking these question, I realize that it is absolutely amazing the way things change and how easily things are tainted.…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Philosophy Of Sentencing

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The complexities of human nature, emotions, thought, morals and ethics have been debated for centuries, and the dilemma of sentencing another human to a form of corporal punishment, incarceration or death, requires a firm foundation in the laws of the land, tempered by years of study and dedication to the law one has sworn to uphold. The several reasons for sentencing of a crime is: Revenge, for an actual or perceived need for vengeance on a violation, usually one that is very personal and emotional in nature. Incapacitation, which is to prevent the criminal from repeating crimes against society by placing them into a correctional facility on a long term or permanent basis. Restoration, is a form of sentencing when the convening authority is attempting to protect the victims by helping them to feel safe and secure. Deterrence is a sentence where the courts attempt to prevent the subject of a crime from offending again. Retribution, which is probably the oldest reason for sentencing was utilized for equal punishment to the crime, drawing from the old adage “eye for an eye”. Lastly is the sentence of rehabilitation, which in societies modern view, the ideal and preferred sentence,…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another sentencing goal is deterrence. You have specific deterrence and general deterrence. Deterrence is a correctional goal focused on future actions (or the avoidance of certain actions) by both individuals and society. The expectation is that, as a result of offenders receiving punishment , both they and others will be deterred or discouraged from committing crimes in the future. Specific deterrence is the effect of punishment on an individual…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Prison Reform in America

    • 1903 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In the essay "Prison "Reform" in America," Roger T. Pray points out the much attention that has been devoted to research to help prevent crimes. Showing criminals the errors of their ways not by brutal punishment, but by locking them up in the attempt to reform them. Robert Pray, who is a prison psychologist, is currently a researcher with the Utah Dept. of Corrections. He has seen what has become of our prison system and easily shows us that there is really no such thing as "Prison Reform"…

    • 1903 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay On Prison Reform

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages

    George W. Bush once said, “America is the land of the second chance - and when the gates of the prison open, the path ahead should lead to a better life.” Reforms have been used throughout history to implement new regulations and make changes in order to improve the lives of those impacted. Before the Prison Reform Movement, the United States Prison system was overflowing. Anyone, who was jailed for any offense, big or small, was placed in the same prison. This means that a small child committing a minor offense could have been placed in the same prison, or even cell, as a sex offender. Also, the jails had horrendous conditions due to the lack of attention to prison and most prisoner were beat for no reason. The movement of prison reform has involved many important people and events, affected America economically, socially, politically, and has had success and failures throughout the span of the reform.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    According to Barlow, general deterrence is the idea that, "people refrain from crime because they fear the punishment that others have received" (2000). This means that one might be deterred from committing a crime if he or she knows it carries a harsh punishment. This points out that many criminals do not take the time to consider punishment. Many of them do not believe they will be the one to get caught. Also, general deterrence…

    • 1734 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As previously mentioned, if the punishment is not harsh enough the result is repeated offense. If a criminal relishes in committing a crime and the court system does not properly punish them for it, then they actually have no reason not to repeat the crime over again. The National Institute of Justice, part of the U.S department of Justice, studied how likely criminals are to relapse after being released, claiming that “Within five years of release, about three-quarters (76.6 percent) of released prisoners were rearrested” (Durose, Cooper, and Howard). This statistic proves that there is a significant chance that a criminal will indeed carry out the same action as before. The most significant way that an offender is punished is through what…

    • 207 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Prison Reform

    • 1091 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Three inmates could be released from prison today. Two of them will end up right back in the system within three years. This statistic should be enough to conclude that America's prison systems are failing miserably with the rehabilitation of inmates. How is it plausible for every correctional facility to think isolation, segregation, and overcrowding could possibly benefit the crime rate? Instead of converting these inmates into proper citizens, the system has found ways to hold them down. To suppress their inspiration to change. For many inmates, those bars do not only imprison their bodies, but their motivation and determination as well. US prisons are breeding grounds for violence. These places are supposed to reform inmates into law abiding people. Instead, they turn even the harmless criminals into the most violent ones. One man is sentenced to one year due to drug trafficking. Another man is sentenced to life without parole for several brutal murders. Despite the different levels of their crimes, they could possibly be bunked together in the same cell. This right here is a prime example of what the DOC will do to hold an inmate down. By involving non-violent criminals with heinous ones, they are creating a situation of fear and defense. The man who is in for excruciating violent behavior could easily try to hurt his cell mate. He has nothing to lose. Is the man with minor charges expected to not defend himself? No. That's where the violence sets in. When you mix completely different criminals together on purpose, there is going to be an outbreak of violence. Everybody has those weeks where you just feel like you need to get out of the house. As if staying home doing nothing one more day would just make you rip your hair out. Imagine having to do that for anywhere up to six months or longer. Not just in a wide open house, but in a small, confined cell. No human contact, nothing to keep you busy, sometimes even going hours without food. This happens daily in…

    • 1091 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are three theories or models of criminal justice. The first is the retributive theory, the second is the rehabilitative theory, and the last is the restorative theory. The first basically concerns itself with the punishment of people by putting them in boot camps/prisons or away from people, in order to deter their ways. Such acts instill discipline and fear, which in turn reduces crime. The second one believes that working with these people change their ways reduce crime (The U .S. Penal System: Restorative and /or Retributive Justice).The third restorative theory aims to reintroduce and re-incorporate the persons back into the community after retribution or rehabilitation.…

    • 1929 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ron Fridell states, "The basic principles of deterrence are that punishments are necessary to deter crime and encourage law abiding behavior. Punishment must also fit the crime with more serious crimes requiring more serious punishments. (61) I agree with the author because capital punishment serves as a device to discourage certain forms of behavior by making the consequences of these actions unpleasant. Capital punishment is acceptable under those terms and it is necessity to the betterment of society. Micheal Kronwetter said, "No other punishment deters men so effectively…as the punishment of death."(19) As an example, murder peaked in 1990 with 2,200 deaths, when New York did not have the death penalty. In 1997, when capital punishment was reinstated the murders for the year totaled 767. Deterrence obviously worked in relation to these crimes. There seems to be a direct relationship between deterrence and the effects of capital…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rehabilitation Paper

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Rehabilitation is defined as a return to a previous form. In criminal justice, rehabilitation is referred as a designed attempt to change attitudes and behaviors of inmates, concentrating on the prevention of an inmate's future criminal behaviors (Seiter, 2011). Since the creation of prisons, the focus on prisons in the United States was based on redemption. Inmates were expected to read the Bible and reflect on their offenses. As time progressed, labor by inmates became a main focus due to the demands of products created by inmates. During the middle of the twentieth century, corrections embraced a medical model where crime was assumed to be the effect of an underlying pathology of offenders that could be analyzed and treated (Seiter, 2011). Offenders were thought to be sick and in need of treatment to get ready to return to the community as useful, law-abiding citizens. There is now an applied variety of treatment programs used by correctional agencies to improve offenders and to provide them with the tools needed to be positive members of society (Seiter, 2011). These programs for inmates include job training, drug treatment, and mental health services.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Just Desserts

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The goals of the criminal justice system are retribution, incapacitation, deterrence, and rehabilitation (Wald, 2001). Unfortunately, retribution in many cases is the only goal that is really accomplished by some of the harsh punishments that are handed down under the “just deserts” doctrine. Deterrence may be accomplished by deterring others from committing the same crime; however it often fails to deter the offender that was punished. One report showed that within three years 24.2% of convicted offenders were reconvicted of a new crime after their release…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Three Criminology Databases

    • 2345 Words
    • 10 Pages

    1990). In contrast to the community programs based on the rehabilitation model, deterrence programs do nothing to address the criminogenic needs of offenders nor their anti-social cognitions (MacKenzie 2011). Instead, proponents of this approach believe that the severity of the treatment will, in itself, deter people from committing future crimes (Patterson 2012). However, all of the studies chosen for this report concluded that treatment based on a deterrence model did not lead to a significant reduction in recidivism rates and, in some cases, even led to an increase in offender recidivism. In their 1990 study, Andrews et al. concluded that, to their knowledge, not a single study had linked criminal sanctions to lower rates of recidivism and, over twenty years later, MacKenzie (2011) proclaimed that there was still “no evidence” (p. 8) linking increased punishment and control to reduced recidivism. Lipsey and Cullen went one step further and analysed several studies that have linked deterrence methods to an increase in recidivism rates. Spohn and Holleran (2002) found that people sent to prison had higher recidivism rates than those placed on probation; Petersilia and Turner (1993) found that offenders placed on…

    • 2345 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, I’m sure that you have heard of the deterrence theory. Deterrence is basically the fear of punishment; and even though it doesn’t prevent all crimes, the results are still undeniable. The deterrence theory is when criminals think about the consequences of each crime, they weigh the pros and cons before they commit it, and if the consequence is death, the crime is usually avoided.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people, especially victims of various crimes, desire justice to be exercised, they want punishment for criminals. Throughout the history of human society, there have always been various kinds of punishments for criminals. Top ten brutal corporal punishments were very well-known torture for criminals in ancient China. The point is: over time, there have been different types of punishments, but crimes never stop. It is nearly an impossible task to wipe out all crimes, because the occurrence of crime depends largely on social circumstance. When the society is in a fine state, crime rate drops; the other way around, it increases. Therefore, in order to prevent reoffence, using punishment for the purpose of deterrence is necessary. Moreover, Over time there have been shifts in penal theory, and therefore in the purpose of punishment due to a complex set of reasons including politics, public policy, and social movements. Consequently, in a cyclical process, an early focus on deterrence as the rationale for punishment gave way to a focus on reform and rehabilitation. This, in turn, has led to a return to punishment based on the notion of retribution and just deserts. Above are several technical terms for criminal punishment. However, I think the ultimate solution for this problem is to create a system to help criminals find their inner goods back. This is the sustainable way to keep our society safe.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays