Throughout the article, Goldstien provides examples of different versions of the AIDS legend. There are significant motifs used in these versions that distinguish the versions generated. There is the coffin version in which the man usually lures the woman into getting involved with him, and when she leaves to return home he hands her a box which has a coffin inside with the message “welcome to the world of AIDS”. The lipstick version generally suggests the opposite; the woman lures the man into getting involved with her and in the morning the man will go to the bathroom with a message wrote on the mirror in lipstick “welcome to the world of AIDS”.
The version chosen will reflect cultural assumptions and values, which is what is described as cultural variability. Goldstien provides facts that the coffin version is more prominent in Newfoundland than the lipstick version; 74% of random sample knew about the coffin legend versus the 26% that were aware of the lipstick legend. The original version may not have made sense to Newfoundlander’s, so it was altered to be understandable and meaningful. They often use mainlanders, which are the outsiders, as scapegoats. The Newfoundland version suggests an innocent, hardworking woman goes away on a trip, meets a man, falls in love and engages in sexual intercourse. If they engaged in sexual activity in Newfoundland and retrieved AIDS, the mainlanders would be blamed for the disperse because they are strangers. Newfoundlanders are good, mainlanders are bad. Newfoundland is safe, mainland is a threat.
In part II of the article is where Sider’s main points start. This is where he beings to outline his main points on mummering. He begins with a definition on what mummering is, in case the reader is unaware. If the reader is completely unaware of the aspect of mummering, they would read Sider’s first description and probably be totally confused. “Loud banging at the ‘victims’ kitchen door.” When seeing the word “victim” they may think there is some kind of illegal activity going to happen when they enter the house. “Loud banging” may constitute for an aggressive person or group. They both relate. In trying to avoid this conclusion, Sider quickly exemplifies the fact mummers are always lifelong neighbors and are never strangers even though they would appear to be.
What happens when mummers enter the house? Sider continues to illustrate huge points that unfamiliar readers need to be aware of. Mummers do not enter households and “trash” the place. They enter and dance around, have sociable drinks, eat food and wait for the household to guess their identity. There is no illegal occurrence that takes place during this activity and Sider makes this point very clear.
The second point Sider makes is the aspect of Scoffing. Upon reading this article, I was unfamiliar with what scoffing was. Sider makes a main point regarding scoffing when he describes the term “scoff”. A scoff is formerly known as a meal, usually one that consists of a large amount of food. Another description that he gave was that scoff refers to a party for people from several different families, for which all the food is stolen or “bucked” which in Newfoundland means something a little different than stealing. Sider makes another huge point when he says that food is only taken from another family living in the same community and who is the same “social class” as the person taking the food. An individual who comes from a poor fisher family would not take from a wealthy family, and a wealthy individual would most certainly not take from a poor family.
Sider also acknowledges the connection between mummering and scoffing which is another huge point made in this article. He notes that they lie at the intersection of different forms of alliances within and between families. These alliances can include sentiment and emotion, but also kinship or work and production. These activities basically hindered or helped social relations. In order to further illustrate the alliances, Sider goes in to talk about the organization of the village inshore fishery during the period when the family was the unit of work for the fishery, which is Part III of the article.
In Part IV of the article, Sider describes the truck system and the tal qual system. Due to reading the first article “In Between History and Tomorrow: Making and Breaking Everyday Life in Newfoundland.”, I am very familiar with both of these systems, but he describes it because not all of the readers would have read that previous article. He thoroughly describes each system which is important so that the reader will know what these systems are and what they were used for.
In Part V of the article, Sider illustrates the diminishing of the two customs (mummering and scoffing). This is a major point because readers may understand why they haven’t been familiar with either of them and it would be due to the fact that hardly anyone participates in them anymore. For example, I knew what mummering was because it still occurs in my area but not very often. I was completely unaware of scoffing upon reading this article because it was not something that I was introduced to. It did not happen in my area and if it did, it would not go over well. These customs are diminishing and if we ask people in generations from now, they probably will not know what either one of these customs are.
The last main point that Sider presents in this article is answering “Why do outport Newfoundlander’s mum and scoff?” He answers by illustrating that customs do things. They are connected to people who participate in them. It becomes their social root for some people. The second answer that he illustrates is the connected between customs and culture. It is important for Sider to illustrate this because reader’s may often times wonder while interpreting this article why people do the things that are being described. They may not realize it, but it is a true statement when people say it is part of you inheritance.
Aside from the main points outlined in this article, which are relevant in understanding the article, I have generated a few questions based on a couple aspects that were discussed.
1.) Why doesn’t Sider talk more about the women during that era? He did mention in Part I that the mothers, wives, sisters and young children salted and dried the fish, preparing them for fall delivery to the merchant. He also mentioned them again during the explanation of kinship organization. The women were part of the shore crowd, there were usually three or four needed, and they were not paid directly (it depended on their father or brother’s catch) Sider continues to describe how men interact during the off season, but what about the women? What do they do during off season? How do they manage work life with home life? (because everyone knows back then the women did all the cooking and cleaning). In my opinion, there is too much focus on the men, although it is proven they worked extremely hard and it is important to put emphasis on that, but it almost feels like women were minor in this article.
2.) In the context of scoffing, how would people actually steal the goods? Sider gives a thorough description of scoffing, but fails to mention anything about how the goods would be stolen, or bucked. Why didn’t Sider expand on this context and provide an in-depth example? Would people wait until early hours in the morning? Would they do it in broad daylight? Would they go back numerous times in one scoff? Would they get someone else to do it for them just in case they get caught? What do they bring with them? Does anyone get really hurt or angry buy having their food stolen? Sider mentions that the individual(s) buck enough for it to hurt, but how hurt do they get? Do they seek revenge other than stealing back from them? A lot of unanswered questions came to me when reading about scoffing and it may be because I am so unfamiliar with the custom. I will definitely do more research into it because it seems very interesting.
Overall, I really enjoyed reading this article. I can relate to the mummering where I am from. Although it is not a common thing, my family still sometimes go downstairs, dress up and come up dancing like mummers would. I really appreciated the point in the article when Sider referenced the “abundant Sunday dinner”. The traditional Sunday dinner is still a huge thing in my family. My grandmother faithfully cooks every Sunday, either for a small or big crowd. Sider’s descriptions are very thorough and interesting to read, which is why this article appealed to me more than the others. He covers most aspects that are needed in order for the reader to understand the points he is attempting to make. This is extremely important when trying to keep the reader interested and informed, and Sider productively does that. As a new reader of Sider’s work I am impressed with his systematic descriptions and approach in his work and I look forward to reading more of his writing!
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The notion of A Whisper of Aids is extremely straightforward to what it refers to, which is the silence of the people to this worldwide deathly epidemic. The whisper of Aids seems constantly hushed in our society, a taboo, covered by the shouts of shameful accusations aimed at its helpless victims. This turns into the deaths of millions worldwide. In our modern society even mentioning AIDS still manages to cause an increasing feeling of discomfort.…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Tuesday September 24th Topic: AIDS in Historical Perspective: The US Context Reading Assignment: The Secret Epidemic, Pp.…
- 1690 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
In the book Aids and Accusations: Haiti and Geography of Blame, author Paul Farmer discussed the rise of AIDS in Haiti and the various accusations as to why it was occurring there. In addition to this, he also shows how racism became a factor due to the theories of the American media and the Center for Disease Control. Inthe introduction he points out that when the virus became more recognized in Haiti and the United States, “Haitian researchers claimed that North American physicians and scientists had erroneously painted Haiti as a source of the worldwide AIDS pandemic”(Farmer 5). This was believed to be due to tourism that occurred there and people having relationships with Haitian people. Soon,“the Haitian scholars asserted that such a hypothesis…
- 798 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The period between 1980- 1999 was bad for Canada. Many people in Canada experienced unemployment. Devastating disasters ended in death and loss of resources. HIV and other diseases were discovered and spread throughout the country. HIV is a virus that attacks the body’s immune system, this virus also leads to obtaining AIDS.…
- 619 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Mary addressed her argument by appealing to the audience that despite any belief or denial they have about AIDS is the truth is that anyone can contract HIV/AIDS. She spoke with a very un-emotional voice but used fear, and rightfully so, as the premise of her argument. She proved her claim by presenting statistics at the beginning of her speech stating 200,000 Americans have died of AIDS up to 1992. She showed the opposition of her claim by presenting the various stereotypes that medicine, society, and the media have placed on AIDS and HIV. (Fisher, 1992).…
- 385 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
AIDS is a worldwide epidemic that has affected and is affecting millions of people. Even though it was not discovered until 1982 many stereotypes have come along with it. Mary Fisher is an AIDS community member and is not afraid to stand up and say so. Defending and helping those with HIV/AIDS and helping them spread the word instead of keeping silent. In 1991 she found out that she had contracted the disease from her second husband and now Fisher is one of the world’s leading activists in the fight against HIV/AIDS. (Newman, 2010)…
- 1209 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The speech titled “A Whisper of AIDS” was given by Mary Fisher on August 19th, 1992 in Houston Texas at the 1992 Republican National Convention Address. Mary Fisher is an American political activist, author, artist and daughter of a wealthy and powerful republican, Max Fisher. Mary Fisher has become an advocate on AIDS prevention and education after she contracted the disease from her second husband. In the speech “A Whisper of Aids”, Mary Fisher uses the rhetorical appeals of ethos, logos, and pathos to express her opinions about how AIDS is not something to be ashamed of.…
- 928 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the 1992 speech by Mary Fisher titled “A Whisper of AIDS” she speaks to not only the people attending the 1992 Republican National Convention, but the world and all who can listen to her speak. She speaks of a condition known as “AIDS” (Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome) that springs from the origin HIV (Human Immunodeficiency Virus) and is the cause of thousands of deaths every year. She uses pathos to persuade her audience that AIDS is a concern in our nation by using the emotions fear, anxiety, and sympathy. She uses anxiety and fear interchangeably, making her argument strong; all the while, she talks to her young sons directly to spark a resilient sympathy from her audience. The speaker is HIV positive herself and uses that to make the audience sympathize with her. She is an ordinary wife and mother that appeals to those who are in denial they’re at risk. AIDS is a disease that is lurking quietly at our doorstep.…
- 1214 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In the 1980s, the words “AIDS” and “HIV” were not on the radar for most of American society. The words were just something people might occasionally hear when someone passed away, but these the deaths almost never occurred close to home. America would quickly become confronted with the threat of AIDS as a very serious health epidemic. If one were to ask someone during the 1980s their thoughts, they might reply with a vague response that AIDS was just a marginal disease affecting a remote section of the world. Discovery of AIDS was not the biggest news that happened in America, for they saw it more as an outside threat that they would not believe that AIDS to spread into the United States.…
- 1991 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Statement of Central Idea: AIDS is a disease that has a history dating back to the 1920s. AIDS has a history that can be described in three main parts.…
- 996 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Farmer’s article begins with the history of Haiti. The author stated, “Haiti is based people living in the rural areas, and is known as the poorest country through political dislocations and that is conspired to the risen of HIV infection (Paul Farmer, 1999, p.242). Throughout the article, the author state a village name Do kay that have accounted of a 3 types of diagnosed HIV Haitians ; Anita, Dieudonne ,and Acephie. For example, taking the story of Dieudonne, he had been sleeping with different type of females and wasn’t careful and later died of AIDS and it also mentioned that each of the 3 Haitians slept with many partners which is related to their history of sexual…
- 536 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Thesis: The decisions I have to make in choosing college courses, depend on larger questions I am beginning to ask myself about my life’s work.…
- 269 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Shah, Anup. "AIDS around the World." Global Issues: Aids Around the World. N.p., 29 Nov.…
- 648 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
It is unknown exactly where it originated but has been speculated that it started as a virus among apes where it spread through humans during consumption of contaminated meat. The AIDs epidemic increased rapidly through Africa as early colonizers, looking for wealth and opportunity, were able to spread this virus sexually and sometimes through cross-blood contamination. As most people know, this is a terminal disease because of its ability to completely shutdown the immune system. This is a double edged sword in Africa because those who have AIDs are instantly more susceptible to diseases; if the individual is also in famine and has no access to clean water or medical care at all, then they are highly likely to acquire a disease such as Cholera, Malaria, or any sickness which could be fatal. When thinking about the AIDs crisis in Africa, viewers must understand the cultural divide that the virus causes on families and communities. AIDs is arguably the most stigmatized disease in Africa, surpassing Ebola as those infected with Ebola were pitied and cared for at home often. Daniel Jordan Smith quoted a Nigerian migrant on the view of people with AIDs who said, “it is the worst thing that can effect a migrant” and that if you leave for a better future and return with AIDs you are immediately seen as a failure with no hope. It is a much less loving of a scenario than we are accustomed to…
- 1144 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
...to promote a multidisciplinary view of the religious, spiritual and esoteric phenomena. What´s New About Us Links Search Contact…
- 18418 Words
- 74 Pages
Good Essays