Preview

Plato vs Aristotle's View of Women

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1405 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Plato vs Aristotle's View of Women
Women: Counterparts or Subordinates Women are often overlooked in how they add to society. However, they are a crucial part in defining relationships, roles, and families, all which contribute their share to forming a society. In order to understand what distinct part they play, let us first look at Plato's views of women, in which equal chance between the sexes give women the potential to achieve, similar to men. Aristotle, whom we will next look at, believes the contrary, that women are subsidiary to men due to natural characteristics. Let us then look into how both Plato's and Aristotle's views of society are constructed by their apparent beliefs of women. For Plato, gender is such a minute detail that for the most part it can be neglected when compared to the goal of the society. In the just society, women are equal in ability because they have the same opportunity as men. They are given the same upbringing and education (music, poetry, and physical activity). It is unreasonable to think that women's natural abilities should be limited by something arbitrary, like their sex. Women are comprised of the same three desires as men, the appetitive, spirited, and rational, so they are equal in all abilities except physical strength, Plato claims. Thus, it would be likely to have female coworkers. "Various natures are distributed in the same way in both creatures. Women share in every way of life just as men do (Bk V, 455 d-e)." Hence women will have the rightful opportunity to share in every task, including producers, rulers, and guardians, the breakdown of Plato's society. On the contrary, Aristotle firmly believes that women are inferior to men. It is a sociable recognition of a natural fact that men run the households. Women lack the spirited part of the soul, the part that allows them the execution to follow through with their beliefs. And furthermore, women are ruled by emotion rather than reason. Men let the reasonable solution win and act accordingly. It

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The cities of Athens and Sparta were both advanced for their time, but differed in their idea of appropriate women’s roles. While Spartan women were relatively important to the social and political spheres, women in Athens were considered nothing more than breeding machines to produce men for the society’s powerful army. Aside from the fact that both groups of women were married for the sole purpose of bearing children, there are hardly any similarities between the treatment of women in Sparta and Athens.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates does not fully begin his discussion of women until Book V, where he states that they are allowed to be guardians with men, if they are deemed capable. In Book V, Socrates states “women share by nature in every way of life just as men do, but in all of them women are weaker than men” (Plato 129). So other than the fact that women are slightly weaker, Socrates feels that men and women are no different than a bald man and a man with hair. (Plato 128) He explains that they will go through the same guardian training together, although in the end women will receive somewhat easier tasks.…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In today's society, most men often take some type of dominant role over women, varying from higher paying jobs, certain real life stereotypes, education, etc. Although it is like this today, some societies and cultures in prehistory varied from patriarchy to matriarchy and even to gylany. Throughout my essay I will be touching on how vital women were, the roles they played in ancient times and the switch between cultures from equalitarian to patriarchal. One quote that supports one of my ideas about today's societal norms is from The Language of the Goddess by Marija Gimbutas “We are still living under the sway of that aggressive male invasion and only beginning to discover our long alienation from our authentic European heritage-gylanic,…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women In Classical China

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages

    One thing that could have influenced women’s roles in society is the philosophy and the religion of the time. The religion of a society can dictate everything about people’s everyday lives, from what they wear, to what food they eat. Moreover, religion can especially influence how people treat and perceive others. The main religion of Ancient Greece at the time was the polytheistic Greek mythology that revolved around the twelve major Olympian gods and goddesses. While women did have a strong presence in the mythology with some of the most prominent gods being goddesses, such as Athena, the goddess of wisdom and the patron of Athens, the women in Greek myths were often very archaic stereotypes. They were usually either trying to stir up trouble for the male heroes or they were undyingly loyal to their husbands. “Myths and literature abound with female characters trying their best to derail the plans of male heroes, from the supreme witch Medea to the deadly, if lovely, Sirens. They can also be represented as ruled only by wild passion and ecstatic emotion such as the Maenads. In contrast, the ideal chaste woman loyal to her absent husband is epitomized by Penelope in Homer’s Odyssey” (Cartwright). Besides religion, another thing that greatly influenced society’s thinking was the philosophy of the time. In Greece, the most notable philosophers were…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antigone Gender Roles

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Ancient Greece is arguably the birthplace of democracy, a society built on principles of equal rights and privileges. Ironically equality did not exist in this democracy because women could not vote. Woman had no say in government because they were not considered citizens. Women were treated as inferior to men, subjected to stay at home, marry and bear sons. This was a much maculated society. Sophocles lived from 497-406 B.C.E in Ancient Greece during this form of democracy. His plays reflect the ancient Greek society such as gods, kings, and woman. In the tragedy Antigone the male gender have a dominate role in society symbolizing power and dominance whereas women are believed to be beautiful and submissive. Sophocles in his tragedy demonstrates the imbalance of genders and the consequences of men who abuse their power and women who step out of the boundaries society place them in.…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout Greek tragedies, there is a well-defined line between male and female gender roles. The men are seen as money makers, punishers, and protectors; whereas women are seen as caregivers, peacekeepers, and nurturers. A man’s job held more importance than a woman’s. In the patriarchal society seen in Greek culture, women were expected to follow orders and adhere to men . Defying men would cause consequences because in ancient times reputation was everything; being defied by a woman would ultimately destroy a man’s reputation. Due to this factor, women have been oppressed throughout history by men attempting to solidify their status in society. Influential women that resisted objectification and the patriarchal society caused such a drastic change that women today are now able to vote, work, and step away from traditional gender roles.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Plato and Aristotle both understood the importance of wisdom and virtue in founding a good regime. In their writings, they suggest the effect they felt a ruler had on a regime and vice versa. Where Plato saw a linear slope of five increasingly misguided and degenerating regimes, Aristotle saw six regimes: three true and three corrupt. Each regime has a ruling political good. This will be more apparent in Plato’s Republic, but is also present in Aristotle’s Politics. They agree that a good ruler will yield a good regime, but differ in their opinions of how the perfect regime should be managed. It’s important to note which people qualify as citizens and their status relative to the regime. Both philosophers set out to identify the capabilities and dynamics of all regimes and devise a way to achieve the best possible regime to channel human ambition and desire.…

    • 1866 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although women in fact play virtually no public role other than a religious one in the political and social life of ancient Greece, they played many other important roles that made their society better all together. Both men and women of ancient Greek culture lived very different lives and had different customs. Many of the cultures maintained similar views of what women’s roles were. Unlike in the prominent and high classed women in Greek mythology women were powerless and inferior to men. Men were considered the most important people in Greece due to the responsibility they carried and the way of Greek life. They held high positions and played a major part in politics with in Greece while women took no part in politics. Women in ancient Greece…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In general, “women had to obey their fathers, husbands, brothers or sons” . This gave to power to the men, allowing them to control the women how they wanted to. If that be in isolation or in public. In Athens civil and legal activates was strictly off limits. According to O’Pry, “Men though women were incapable of the understanding required for making decisions in polities” . In order to vote in Athens you had to be a citizen and, “A citizen of Athens had to be male and born of parents who were both born in Athens. No women, foreigners, or slaves were considered citizens” . Although sometimes a woman could talk her husband into bringing or voting on something this rarely happened. In the home the women had a few more freedoms, Alexandria wrote that, “In a virtuous household every activity is performed by husband and wife in agreement with each other, but it is never the less clear that if is the man who is in charge and has the power of decision” . For Athenian women like politics land was also off limits. Only the men were allowed to possess and own land. The Athenian government went through great trouble to make sure that in no case a woman could own land. According to Alexandria, if the male died the land would go to a son or male guardian. If no son then the dad would, as Alexandria states, “encouraged his daughter to marry a close relative in hope of keeping the land” . On the other hand in Sparta the rules were very much so laid back. Women could own land. According to O’Pry women could, “own property; they could dispose of it how they willed, they could inherit equal shares form their father’s estates” , women also owned a major part of the land, around two-fifths. In Politics the best way they could get there ideas out was thought there men like the Athena women. O’Pry states that women, “were able to influence the community and make their opinions known…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Antigone Role of Women

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout history, cultures from around the world has set hat standards for women to abide to. Up until the twentieth century, women were viewed as second class citizens by society and had less freedom and rights than their male counterparts as compare today in the modern world where women can be more involve in society. Although women still face discrimination such as the glass ceiling in the business corporate world, the quality of life of the western woman today has drastically improve from what women used to face on a daily bases for example a Greek woman from the classical era of the tragic play Antigone by the Greek writer, Sophocles. Antigone portray the role of women of in a Greek society by having two opposing characters, Antigone and her sister, Ismene, with two different contrasting perspectives of morality vs. law on opposite sides of the spectrum in addition having a male view of how women should and should not act .…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ancient Greek Women Essay

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In a society that was purely patriarchal and misogynistic, women in the ancient world had few rights. Men and women were usually separated into different worlds, each with their own set of responsibilities and rules to follow. It is hard to fully define what women were like in antiquity simply because there can be no such thing as a “typical woman”, women differ from polis to polis and depended on social and economic background. The one thing that was expected of any woman was to belong to citizen families and maintain that family by giving birth, preferably to future male citizens.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    WS Notes

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sexual orientation: Ireland: lesbians may be denied pap smears because it is believed that they cannot get some disesases or infections…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women of most cultures are secondary to men. Because women can’t work in the fields and don’t have the same strength, they generally come second in the hierarchy. Even today, though it may be unintentional, that’s how it is.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the ages, many people feel they have a statement to make, and make this statement through literature. Although at first glance, Homer's "Iliad" may not seem to be a criticism of society, underneath all the violence and deep storylines there is a message dying to get out. In the culture of the Iliad, mortal women are treated as property rather than human beings. While the gods attempt to treat the goddesses the same way, the goddesses are quick to assert themselves and claim equal power. This is Homer's way of saying that the attitude towards women in his time period is wrong and unjustified. While men worship goddesses, they still treat women as lesser beings.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plato's program for women

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    First of all, Plato insisted that women would be inferior in performing the same task as men. Although Plato was a progressive in the view of the role of women in an ideal city, he was still influenced by the traditional view of women’s native culture. Plato’s vision of an ideal society was based on the necessity for productivity from all of the members, which women were expected to work as much as men. In this ideal society, individuals were valued based on their abilities to produce rather than their sexual roles (454d). As a result, women in this society had a chance to be valued outside of their traditional roles of being wives. Plato insisted that women were capable of the same tasks as men, but stated that women would definitely be weaker in performing them (466c). According to Plato Republic, Plato thought women were somehow physically weaker than men that even though they could do the same job, such as cutting down the trees, they still could not perform at the same level as men did. (467b)…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays