Preview

Phaedra as an Example of Enlightenment Values

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
802 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Phaedra as an Example of Enlightenment Values
Phaedra, originally part of the large body of Greek mythological works, has been adapted, modified and presented in new contexts in recent centuries. For example, following the original conception of this tragedy by Euripides, versions of it have appeared in Latin, Italian, French, Spanish, etc through the authorship of such great writers as Frencesco Bozza, Jean Racine, Miguel de Unamuno, etc. Eugene O’Neill’s incorporation of it as a subplot in his ‘Desire Under the Elms’ testify to the everlasting appeal of the story. This enduring appeal makes relevant its study in relation to enlightenment values.
It is especially relevant to read Phaedra’s life and events in the backdrop of values espoused by the Enlightenment. The Age of Enlightenment emphasized the importance of reason and scientific inquiry as means to progress. It was strongly against superstition and questioned the eminence of tradition in civic and social life. It is pertinent to ask if Phaedra, whose life ends in a tragic suicide, is the result of her overtly emotional responses to circumstances and interpersonal interactions. On the other hand is the tragedy of Hippolytus, who too eventually dies, but for a different set of reasons. (Berlin, 1981)
Phaedra, the wife of the temperamental Athenian King Theseus, falls in love with her step-son Hippolytus. Though this relationship would not have constituted as incest in a biological sense, it is nevertheless problematic on several counts. First, it violates her marriage to Theseus, however ill-tempered he might have behaved toward her. Second, it speaks ill of Phaedra’s impulsivity and lack of moral fortitude. Third, it drags Hippolytus into a lust-driven imbroglio when he has already committed himself to a life of celibacy. The Enlightenment value of reason pits a challenge to emotional and impulsive actions, claiming that the latter tend to be based on distortions and loose sense impressions. The fact that Phaedra’s life gets into ever



Cited: • Berlin, Normand. The Secret Cause: A Discussion of Tragedy. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts, 1981. • Chong-Gossard, J. H. Kim On. "The Silence of the Virgins: Comparing Euripides ' Hippolytus and Theonoe." Antichthon 38 (2004): 10+. • Disch, Thomas M. "Phaedra Britannica." The Nation 23 Jan. 1989: 100+.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    At one point during a philosophical debate between Socrates and Phaedo, Phaedo attempts to compares the human body to a lyre and the soul to the lyre’s harmony. Socrates, however, argues that this an inaccurate comparison. He explains that a harmony can be more and more fully harmonized or less and less fully harmonized, to which Phaedo confirms. Socrates then claims that a soul cannot be neither more nor less of a soul than another, a fact which Phaedo also confirms. Consequently, if the harmony of a lyre were to represent the human soul, then the harmony of all lyres must be the same, since no soul is greater nor lesser than another. Now, if virtue represents harmony and wickedness disharmony, then all souls must have the same amount of virtue…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    the havoc that she did towards the end of this play. Had she not of known this knowledge many…

    • 3058 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The selected text that will be examined in this essay is Oedipus the King and Plato ‘Crito’. Oedipus and Socrates play a major role in their own lives when it comes to their intelligence in resolving issues that are given to them. In contrast, there is a difference between our world and the Greek culture, which seems to be very alienating. The following discussion examines that Oedipus and Socrates stage mythical knowledge and autonomy in their presentation of themselves to the audience. It shows what implications self-reliance has for the authority of Oedipus’ and Socrates’ traditional beliefs.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lysander and Hermia, both young and well-off, are unpermitted, according to the Ancient Privilege, to wed each other without the approval of Hermia’s father, Egeus. However, not quite prepared to end their relationship, the lovers very ambitiously and suddenly run into a nearby forest. They have done so without considering the consequences, and as a result, find themselves lost. Lysander suggests this, when he says, “Fair love, you faint wandering in the wood, and in truth, I have forgot our way,” (II. ii. 41-42). Later in the play, the duke of Athens, Theseus, overbears Egeus’ will, and insists Lysander and Hermia wed each other on his marriage day. Hermia, in quickness and happiness, agrees, without considering her father’s reaction. By doing so, she may be sacrificing her relationship with him. In both situations, the young Athenians pay no attention to the consequences of their relationship, which supports the idea that love ignores all…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Both maintain differing views on what constitutes justice, and via them Sophocles’ juxtaposes the values of ‘polis’ with those of ‘natural’ law. However, we must not conclude that this is a simple binary opposition; though Antigone’s family orientation is one that appears resolutely at odds with Creon’s ship of state, in fact the duty observed to one’s family is an integral part of the Greek concept of ‘polis’. Edith Hall observed that “a Greek citizens family life was a component of his political identity. One’s private conduct was seen as indicative of the manner one would exert political power”, (Hall, p.104). This principle is still true today. The two are not separate, and therefore there is the potential for the two to co-exist if both exhibit degrees of…

    • 4322 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Initiated by the hero’s own inability to remain complacent, tragedies classically demonstrate a downfall through the ‘fatal flaw’ of the protagonist. “The flaw, or crash in the character is really nothing…but his inherent unwillingness to remain passive…”…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Morality is concerned with the theory of right and wrong characteristics or good and bad behaviors; its role can shape an individual’s personality which can affect his or her call of action. It is only natural that we should have some kind of moral laws since our experiences are dwelled from our sense of duty and physical forces. It’s an aspect in humanity which helps them make rational decisions and it also serves as guidance for mere goodness. Our existence defines who we are as an individual because of our values that help us see past our wrongdoing and helps improve our future. This can be seen in Sophocles’ story of “Antigone,” Antigone’s character portrays a strong individual who is loyal and values her family more than the society. This tragic heroic story demonstrates the…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: Plato. "Phaedo." Five Dialogues. Translated by Gube, G. Revised by Cooper, J. Hackett Publishing Co. Indianapolis, IN. 2002. 2nd Edition. 93-154.…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Remorse is the moral anguish, the sorrow and shame, and the regret and guilt, which may haunt even the fiercest, mightiest king. It is often accompanied with the consequences of the individual’s wrongdoing. Remorse takes a principal part in some of Greek’s classic tragedies. One could say, the tragic hero is likely to experience such feelings, likewise in the Greek tragedies Oedipus Rex, rewritten by John Bennett and Moira Kerr, as well as Antigone written by Sophocles, two characters Oedipus and Creon both display signs of remorse. Yet ultimately, it is evident through the emotions displayed, admittance of their sins, and further self imposed retribution, that Oedipus suggests a higher degree of remorse.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sophocles’ and Jean Anouilh’s versions of the famous Greek tragedy; “Antigone” raise some interesting themes, motifs, and topics. The most prevalent theme throughout both versions was Human law Vs. Divine law. This helped me conclude that; in both versions of Antigone, characters that only adhere or favour man-made law or divine law, lead unstable lives and themselves suffer through isolation, loss, and deterioration. Both versions have a tragic hero that only adheres to one spectrum of the two laws in discussion, causing them the abovementioned problems. However, in both versions of the play, there are neutral characters that adhere to both spectrums. Because of this balance, these characters avoid a tragic fate.…

    • 907 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Firstly, the character, Hippolyta whom has no choice on who to marry due a tragic loss in a battle against Theseus, the forcing soon-to-be husband. When Theseus strikes her with, "Hippolyta, I woo 'd thee with my sword, and won thy love, doing thee injuries," (1.1.17-18) he is referring how he had won Hippolyta 's "love" by defeating her in the battle and while keeping her captivated, Hippolyta has no excitement and pleasure to marry Theseus on the wedding day. Defeating her in a battle, then forcing her to marry him is unfair and unsatisfying to the heart of Hippolyta. Though she shows that she has a very horrible life, the daughter of Egeus, Hermia, is having it just as bad as her. Egeus is forcing Hermia to marry whomever Egeus thinks that has the satisfying appeal of Egeus himself, and not Hermia, whom owns her own heart. With dissatisfaction by Hermia 's response to his words, he goes to the Duke of Athens, Theseus. "As she is mine, I may dispose of her, which shall be, either this gentlemen or to her death, according to our law." (1.1.43-45) That 's Egeus ' reason why Hermia should have it his way, whether her heart likes it or not. Hermia has three life changing choices: agree with her father 's choice of marrying Demetrius, become a nun and never love a man again, or to be put down into death. With Hermia 's heart that has been stolen by Lysander, she disagrees to her father 's way of how to deal…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the Republic, Plato uses reason to model the ultimate form of civilization where everyone achieves his/her human potential. This should not be confused with individual equality, for Plato sees a harmonious and virtuous community where citizens are under a hierarchy and working together for the greater good of the state. The question, however, remains: How does one achieve Plato’s ideal state when there is evil and deception in the world? In answering this question, Plato puts forth two arguments: an allegory to describe the complexities and necessities of reality, and a royal lie to carry out the ideal form of civilization. In this paper, I argue Plato’s Allegory of the Cave justifies the need for a royal lie found in the Myth of the Metals, for the royal lie serves as an instrument towards achieving the ultimate polis. I examine this claim by describing and analyzing both the Allegory of the Cave and the Myth of the Metals, as well as depicting the philosopher’s challenges and the royals lie’s instrumental purpose.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Phaedo’s discussion of recollection suggests that the deficiency of the sensible world could be derived by the flawed abstractionist or empiricist concept. Being regarded as an unreliable source of information, the material world and the perception of it cause troubles that could be explained in different ways: with respect to Aristotelian account, the sensible world is changing. On the other hand, a concrete and determinate fashion manifests the abstract Forms. Here, perception is necessary to explain some aspects of the complexity of the material things. No sensible object would be accounted as an unqualified bearer of relative properties if it were addressed by the compresence accounts. It also seems that Plato considers the psychological…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Death and Grief

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The article goes beyond the tragedies that we see on the news or read in newspapers. It doesn’t focus on death tolls or statistics of violence. The article looks at the effects of tragedy on the lives of everyday people. In some cases it offers us a mirror to our own lives and perhaps allows us to reflect on what we would do or how we would act.…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mourning Becomes Electra

    • 64899 Words
    • 260 Pages

    The pessimism of the Greeks may have been equally black, their tragedies just as aware of the crime of existence, still “they would have despised”, as William James observed, “a life set wholly in a minor key, and summoned it to keep within the proper bounds of lachrymosity”. The unfulfilment, exhaustion, and apathy which O’Neill’s tragedy increasingly reflected were conditions completely foreign to Greek tragedy. The Greeks were never so contemptuous of life as to seek consolation in death, nor so afraid of death as t( calm their fears by promising themselves the fulfilment after death o .all that they had vainly yearned for in life. O’Neill is not to be censured for the predicament in which he found himself, or for the fashion in which he chose to extricate himself, but rather f misinterpreting his dream. For however ingeniously he substituted the premises of a rationalistic psychology, however adeptly h interpolated his allegory, however glibly he spoke of fate and destiny crime and retribution, guilt and atonement, his dream in tragedy was not the Greek dream.…

    • 64899 Words
    • 260 Pages
    Good Essays