Preview

People In Power Lie To Persuade Soldiers

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1330 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
People In Power Lie To Persuade Soldiers
We only see what we are shown but not what the soldiers know. The theme “People in power lie to persuade civilians to do their their dirty work without them knowing the true aftermath of war”, is seen evidently throughout the four texts I have chosen. The song Hero of War by Rise Against, the song War Pigs by Black Sabbath, the film Rambo by Ted Kotcheff and the film American Sniper by Clint Eastwood.

The song Hero of War portrays the theme of “People in power lie to persuade civilians to do their their dirty work without them knowing the true aftermath of war”. At the start of the song the lyrics say, “Have you seen the world? What would you say if I said that you could? Just carry this gun, you’ll even get paid.” These lyrics inform the
…show more content…
At the start of the film when Chris Kyle is watching tv at home. A news report comes in that “Terrorists” (Islamics) have bombed a car park is his local area. This what caused Chris Kyle to join the US Navy Seal’s at war. What this scene shows is that whoever was in charge of writing what the reporters were to say was most likely told to by the government, though is could of been someone else of high power.So in reality this government or someone with power towards the media would be lying as from what is shown, there is not enough information to conclude that it was “Islamic Terrorists” who did the bombing. All they want to do is show civilians who the enemy is but in reality there probably is not one. Nearer the end of the film Chris Kyle is faced with PTSD after he has done his duties as a SEAL. We see a few scenes where this occurs, one where Chris Kyle and his son are at the mechanics and he hears the sound of a drill which triggers a flashback to when the “Butcher” killed a kid using a drill.The other was at a birthday where a dog was licking a child frantically, for some reason causing Chris Kyle to attack the dog, but was stopped very quickly by the shouting of his wife. Before joining the SEAL’s and going to war he was most likely not aware of the aftermath of war. This shows what war can do to a man, physically for the better but mentally for the worse as he will have to live with these PTSD’s for most of his life. I think that the director Clint Eastwood wanted to show how media can make people think there is an enemy so they go to war without realizing the aftereffects, such as the many PTSD’s that u can gain from

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Perception of the Enemy The everlasting commotion of bombshells, gunshots, ear piercing screams, and the rumble of tanks began with the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. To say the least, hell broke loose in 1914, the mental and emotional scars that the soldiers of World War I bare is utterly incomprehensible to the common man. Through all the chaos, the soldiers never quite knew what they were doing, they were drafted, and from that point on for the next four years came the nonstop misery and false hope of the war ending. The soldiers of the war never had a hatred for the opposing side, it was forced murder; they saw each other with pity from time to time which the authors Erich Maria Remarque, August Stramm, and Tim O’ Brien exemplify…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As Mr. O’Brien states, a true war story is never believable. One example is Sanders’ story about a six man patrol group. Sanders tells, how while on patrol, the men were not allowed to make a sound. They were supposed to be silent as death itself. They were camouflaged in a bush for seven straight days, and had to be invisible. Mr. Sanders describes how spooky this seemed because the patrol took place in a mountain jungle with a fog that was so thick, “you can’t find your own pecker to piss with” (72). Within this…

    • 1546 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the beginning of the book private Archie Lemon thinks about the war that suppose to “end injustice,” and that he doesn't mind getting killed, because the people coming after him will live in “happiness and peace” (23). Such a false propaganda is recognized by soldiers fifty pages later. They realize that the war “was brought about moneyed interests for its own selfish ends,” because idealism and patriotism have nothing to do with the war. They call it brutal and degrading, and, “fools who fight, are pawns shoved about to serve the interest of others” (96). March in the 30s recognizes of what the war becomes in the twenty first century; a character name Sergeant Theodore Donohoe back then sees the war as a business (because today it is fought for the territory or land resources); he states that in order to get anywhere in it, one has to adjust oneself to its peculiarities and “play the cards the way they fall” (30). Unfortunately, not a lot of soldiers have learned or will ever learn how to play this game…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’ Brien’s “How to tell a true war story” construes the relationship between the war experiences and the ways of storytelling. O Brien’s story telling as a narrator shows that the storyteller has the power to form his listener’s experiences and opinions. His way of describing situations are unique because his story distorted the reader’s perceptions of beauty and ugliness by making different situation and scenes seem pleasing, even though it contains improbability…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly O’Brien insist that a true war story is never moral and hints to us not to always believe each story that is told. O’Brien states “You can tell a true war story by the questions you ask”(83). And gives an example as he asserts “For example, we’ve all heard…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What is a true war story? Is it a collection of memories, pulled from the ragged and weary brain of a soldier, and stitched together to form literature? Is it a fictitious (albeit perfectly accurate) account of battle, formulated by a civilian English major for his dissertation? One might argue that a true war story cannot be defined, for it will never exist. A thorough and valid account of battle, sticking without fail to the truth of the story, will inevitably be changed by either the soldier’s aggrandizement, or the loss of memory needed to translate the brain’s images into words. This results in there being a very thin line between…

    • 5301 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Sniper Theme

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The texts of ‘American Sniper’ and ‘Tama Tu’ also portray the theme of violence while exploring how conflict leads to warfare which ultimately ends in death. In the text ‘American Sniper’, violence is shown in three significant scenes. In this extended film Chris Kyle, the most-celebrated sniper in American military history, decides to become a Navy SEAL to serve his country after the event of 9/11. The first significant scene, the opening scene, starts off with a variety of shots of the American infantry walking through a war-torn village in Iraq with dead bodies and soldiers with hand held weapons. The shots are from a low angle to help emphasize the position Chris is revealed in. We see Chris up on a highrise building spying on the soldiers with his gun at…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    According to O’Brien, “a true war story is never moral” (O’Brien 68). The war stories that have morals are often fabrications of the truth. The mark of a true war story is the difficulty in telling the difference between what happened and what seems like it happened. The details of a story can be vague, something that cannot be understood, and can still be considered a true war story. Believably of a war story must also be taken into account when discussing its credibility. Some scenarios, O’Brien says, are too far-fetched to be considered true, and yet those are the stories are the ones that could not be further from the truth. The author’s stance on this subject is that, “in many cases a true war story cannot be believed. If you believe it, be skeptical.”(O’Brien 71). A war story that is mundane is often times the ones that have falsities in them. As seen by Mitchell Sanders, it is his drive to make the other soldiers believe his story that makes it believable. O’Brien gives an outline of how to tell a proper war story in this chapter, so that the common pitfalls in storytelling can be subverted. He condones the seemingly useless nature of stories by saying that, “a true war story is never moral.”(O’Brien 68). It is less about the quality of the story and more about its accuracy of what seems like it happened, that separates a true war story from one that is…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    War is a very controversial topic for many people. Depending on the person’s outlook on the war, it can be depicted as something good or bad. War brings destruction wherever it goes, whether it is on a place or the people, and it ultimately is inevitable. War also protects a country from having further destruction and keeps the people at home safe from any danger. As a person can see in many recordings of war, there are many comparisons and contrasts that are expressed through soldiers, veterans, and civilians. Some comparisons seen in many of the testimonies given by effected people are dehumanization, dislocation, and alienation; but they also have contrasts that can be seen through nationalism, technological advancements, and the coming home for many…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Song of the Tra Bong

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There always exists a time when war is present in our lives and one must act with honor to do what is needed to survive and live together as a nation. The human instinct to survive and build confidence is instilled in individuals within the daunting atmosphere of combat; where inherently good people are asked to kill other entities. However, the effects that come with the act of war are inevitable and one must struggle with the predicament of keeping one’s sanity intact. Humans are inherently good until thrown to the darkness and dysfunctional effects of war. Similarly, In Tim O’Brien’s “Song of the Tra Bong”, a story about how a young man from the Vietnam War pays to have his significant other sent to his station unfolds as a dramatic turn for the worse. The young man, Mark Fossie, deals with the pain of seeing his significant other, Mary Anne, animate a drastic transformation to the ultimate obscurity and frightening notion of war. At first glance, one may have the impression that O’Brien’s short story might shroud the idea of love and relationships, but underneath the surface, Tim O’Brien paints a grim picture of the effects of war on human nature and how it can distance humans from moral and emotional anchors, both physically and psychologically, and perhaps result in the loss of innocence.…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    How to Tell a True War Story

    • 2231 Words
    • 64 Pages

    In the essay, “How to Tell a True War Story,” Tim O’Brien tells several stories of war to illustrate to his readers the criteria for truth in storytelling. O’Brien offers his readers a guide to telling and determining war stories that are true, for the author, true does not necessarily mean actual or real. Instead, O’Brien tells us what a true war story is, but his requirements are not always clear precise—a true war story “never seems to end,” (O’Brien 273) “embarrasses you,” (270) “are contradictory,” (275) and have an “uncompromising allegiance to obscenity and evil” (270)—they are defined and given context by the author through the telling of his own accounts. The essayist Jon Krakauer offers up his own version of a war story, of sorts, in his telling of the story of Chris McCandless, a young man not participating in a war of nations, or a conflict with others; he, in his own words, was involved in “the climactic battle to kill the false being within and victoriously conclude the spiritual pilgrimage” (Krakauer 207). The battlefield for McCandless was not a booby-trapped jungle, saturated with enemies and soldiers for the opposition; no, McCandless’s battlefield was the Alaskan frontier. Like a soldier going to war, McCandless knew that where he was going was dangerous. Krakauer remarks that “he was fully aware when he entered the bush that he had given himself aperilously (emphasis added) slim margin for error. He knew precisely what was at stake” (Krakauer 219). One can draw many parallels between the essays, or war stories, of Krakauer and O’Brien; they are both provocative, and both use descriptive language and paint vivid pictures in the minds of their reader, they both write of young men in the midst of a conflict—emotional or physical—but the stories differ as well. O’Brien presents his ideas of what makes a true war story; based on these ideas, we can determine that the war story told by Krakauer is not a true war story because it is committed to…

    • 2231 Words
    • 64 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Universal Soldier

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Five foot two and six foot four were the height parameters for soldiers in 1961. Fighting with missiles and with spears symbolize the future and the past, soldiers are soldiers: only the equipment is different. The ages 17 to 31 were age parameters to be a soldier during the 1960s and soldiers have been around for centuries. Soldiers are also religious people and not confined to just one religion and though religion forbids it, he chooses to be a killer. No matter what side he’s on, it’s still absurd. Soldiers are not just from some far away enemy country but from “our” country too thinking that fighting will end all fighting. Soldiers are on all sides using violence as an act of peace having a responsibility overlooked for humanity. Soldiers learn nothing from history so do not see obvious outcomes of repeating it. We can't blame just the leaders and each individual has a choice. We are all responsible – civilians, voters and…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This playing around with the truth is what makes the soldiers skeptical of what is true and what isn 't. They see things differently as they are happening. They know what is happening at that point in time but their mind sees it in a different lighting. O 'Brien tells a story about a fellow soldier killed by a land mine. His name was Curt Lemon. He and another soldier were playing catch with a smoke grenade and Lemon takes a half step too far and steps on the land mine. However, that 's not how O 'Brien sees it. He sees Lemon step out from the dark tree canopy and into the sunlight. The sunlight seems to carry him up into the tree and he disappears. O 'Brien calls it beautiful. There 's nothing beautiful about a man being killed but that 's how he saw it. That 's how his mind saw it. During the war a soldier can get so used to death and killing. Maybe by just seeing it happen so often that they start to critique it and see the beauty in it. This is what the soldiers see then in that moment but when they go back and retrieve that memory they don 't know what is true and what isn 't true. The war has affected…

    • 1717 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Is War Ethical

    • 1871 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The insurgents’ war is an unethical war. They use tactics of manipulation, deceit and media propaganda to brainwash vulnerable and desperate individuals into becoming suicide bombers. Analyzing these three tactics through events in The Sirens of Baghdad” by Yasmina Khadra with “Eros and Thanatos” by Chris Hedges and “Just War Theory” by Alexander Moseley and then comparing these events to real life stories such as “Abandoned in Iraq; We did our job as interpreters; why has the U.S reneged on its promise?” by Tariq and "Iraq 's Young Blood" by Christian Caryl provide insight.…

    • 1871 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Masters of War

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In this song, there are some lyrics talked about the weapons that solider would used to kill people and gain victory by those weapons. “Big guns”, “death planes”, “bombs”, “bullets” were the words that Bob Dylan used to described the war. All this things, can easily took away people’s life in one second, it’s was some killing weapons that use to fight in a war. Though this song “Masters of War”, Bob Dylan wanted to carry out the message and values of peace.…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics