Preview

Paul Is Arrogant. Discuss.

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
673 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paul Is Arrogant. Discuss.
In Peter Goldsworthy’s novel Maestro, the main character Paul Crabbe who is a young adolescent that narrates the story in two time-spaces as a memoir. First we see him when he is a self-absorbed, selfish arrogant teenager and then when he has matured into a young man.
Paul was one of the teenagers that had the feeling of being invincible and believing that he was better than everyone else around him, this being shown through the immaturity, self-absorption and selfishness of him. This image of Paul being a selfish, arrogant boy was reflected with the relationship he had with his piano teacher, Herr Eduard Keller, and the way he treated the people around him. ‘I became determined to expose Eduard Keller as the War Criminal I suspected he was.’ Paul shows his immaturity and ignorance by suggesting that Keller is a War Criminal and makes assumptions of things that he can’t prove. Paul Crabbe had been spoilt by his parents while he was growing up and quite possibly was the reason of his vain attitude. “Here’s to talent… properly harnessed.’ The parents of Paul have given him too much motivation that he is “talented” that he believes he is the best pianist.

Paul’s self-absorption and selfish attitude is more obvious in his relationship with Keller. At first music had been seen to be the only thing they both had in common but it caused the differences between Keller and Paul. The natural arrogance that grew inside of Paul rejects Keller and the way he teaches the piano and fails to accept his unique take on several composers. After one lesson, after a session of Keller’s forceful criticism, Paul “ran away, tears streaking from his eyes,” leading Paul to call him a ‘Nazi’. Paul also feels insulted when Keller has him play “Children’s Bach,” a piece he believed he mastered as a child. On their parting as student and teacher, Keller finally opens up to Paul, telling him of his past mistakes, however, Paul chose to leave Keller, to go on a date with Rosie. Finally,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Initially Paul is hesitant towards Keller’s teachings as he was patronising and never let him play, but as the novel progresses Paul ends up learning a lot from Keller about both piano and life. This is highlighted in the quote where Paul is expressing how much his initial feelings towards Keller will change throughout his life…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Paul Bäumer is a German, young boy, who, together with his classmates, enlists for the army to fight in the Great War. Full of enthusiasm and adventurous thoughts, they arrive at the front, but then are faced with the horrific and soul-destroying war. One by one the classmates are fall in action……

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an adaptation of “Territory,” The Page Turner showcases a mother and son and the effect that the son’s lover, has on their family. The novel begins, with eighteen-year-old Paul Porterfield, a student just finishing his last year in high school and preparing to enter Juilliard in the fall, has been engaged to turn the pages of the musical score for a piano virtuoso, during a chamber music concert event. A fan of Kennington’s (the virtuoso) work Paul relishes a chance to meet him. Pamela, Paul’s mother, sits in the audience in support of her son’s ancillary role.…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Goldsworthy’s maestro uses distinctively visual features to create an image of the charcters location & the charcters feelings. The novel is about paul crabbe and growing up in Darwin . pauls piano teacher keller is described at the beginning as having a “boozer’s incandestent glow”. This gives the image that keller is an alcoholic. The description of hand’s through out the novel, the way keller’s hands are seen as “swollen”, “wobbley”. pauls is interested in keller’s missing finger throughout the novel and that keller puts a ring on it “accentuate its existence” the use of this helps to gather images in the mind about what he looks like.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the novel's narrator and protagonist, Paul is the central figure in All Quiet on the Western Front and serves as the mouthpiece for Remarque's meditations about war. Throughout the novel, Paul's inner personality is contrasted with the way the war forces him to act and feel. His memories of the time before the war show that he was once a very different man from the despairing soldier who now narrates the novel. Paul is a compassionate and sensitive young man; before the war, he loved his family and wrote poetry. Because of the horror of the war and the anxiety it induces, Paul, like other soldiers, learns to disconnect his mind from his feelings, keeping his emotions at bay in order to preserve his sanity and survive. As a result, the compassionate young man becomes unable to mourn his dead comrades, unable to feel at home among his family, unable to express his feelings about the war or even talk about his experiences, unable to remember the past fully, and unable to conceive of a future without war. He also becomes a "human animal," capable of relying on animal instinct to kill and survive in battle. But because Paul is extremely sensitive, he is somewhat less able than many of the other soldiers to detach himself completely from his feelings, and there are several moments in the book (Kemmerich's death, Kat's death, the time that he spends with his ill mother) when he feels himself pulled down by emotion. These surging feelings indicate the extent to which war has programmed Paul to cut himself off from feeling, as when he says, with devastating understatement, "Parting from my friend Albert Kropp was very hard.…

    • 3207 Words
    • 92 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adult Paul's narration offers an interpretation of events from a position of maturity and self awareness. As a result, events at the beginning of the lone ls, such as Paul's first meeting with Keller, are recounted with the tone of ones self-criticism. The opening rhetorical question and immediate answer in 'first impressions? Misleading, of course" established our expectations that pails experience of Keller at the novels opening will be changes by novels end, and that thus changes perspective of the maestro will be reflected in change and perspective of himself.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An understanding must be made in order to emotionally develop. This is explored within Maestro, in this regard the misunderstanding of Keller’s past as a WWII survivor. Pages 11-14 of the novel, is essential in comprehending Paul’s immaturity. The reaction of “He’s A Nazi” is made after Paul, is denied by Keller to play Chopin. High modality is used to emphasise Paul’s frustration and impatience, consequently bringing attention to his immaturity, highlighted within the racist slur. It is made obvious the inconsideration Paul has when he makes judgements of individuals. Goldsworthy uses Paul’s parents to call attention to their son’s naivety. Using both the distinctively visual image of Paul’s mother shaking her head and the quote “You know so much for your age…and so little” highlights his mother’s knowledge of Paul’s immaturity, the use of ellipsis creates tension between Paul and his…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When one of Paul’s best friends Kemmerich dies, Paul is the one who has to tell his mom about the bad news. One quote that points to this is, “I must go and see Kemmerich’s mother… This quaking, sobbing woman who shakes me and cries out on me: ‘Why are you living then, when he is dead?’” (181). Paul had enough bravery to talk to his dead friend’s mother about how her son died. Paul has to lie to Kemmerich’s mother or else she would have been even more devastated than she had been when she heard the bad news. Paul was devastated when his friend died but stayed brave because he knew with war came death. An example that also proves this is, “Kat falls. We two are alone… Couldn’t I shoot myself quickly in the foot so as to be able to go with him… ‘he is stone dead’ … Do I walk? Have I feet still? … Then I know nothing more” (287-291). Paul is even more affected by Kat’s death than Kemmerich’s death. Kat and Paul were best friends and stayed together all the time. Paul did not know what to do when Kat died, he is at a loss of words, and wanted to hurt himself to stay with Kat and go wherever he went. He was courageous even though he witnessed an awful death. Although Paul is a good comrade and a smart decision maker, his best trait is that he is a brave…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shine Human Condition

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This part of the human condition has greatly affected David, as he, much like his father, can't let go of the past. We are presented with two extremes of David's reflections on his childhood, his success and mentors and his father. Ben, later David's piano teacher, is first introduced to us as a judge at a local competition. David's piano career begins from that point, as his reflections started from there. Although Ben was always arguing with Peter, he could not overpower or influence him in any way and this was shown by the physical height difference between the two men and Peter's large over powering voice. Many shots were also taken from relatively high angles, to minimalise Peter so the audience can clearly tell who is the dominating of the two. In the reflections, David is always repeating, echoing his father's words in a trusting way where he believed every word he said was true and sacred. We hear the same lines again " David, you are a lucky boy" and " no one can love you like me" but the older wiser David reluctantly repeats them in an untruthful tone. From this we can tell David, who has been stuck in his childhood reflections for so long has finally let go and moved on with his life. The music played in the reflections also indicates to the audience David's acknowledgement and ability to differentiate between the good and bad. When he spent time with Katherine, the music was light and peaceful yet when he was at home, the music was dark and suspenseful. From David's reflections, we learn not to dwell in the past, but rather learn from the mistakes as he has and move on. This component of the human condition enables us to self-correct and rediscover ourselves and people affecting our…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel begins in Darwin in 1967 and traces Paul's life through his childhood to 1977. During this time he travels to Adelaide, through Europe and ends up settling in Melbourne. The central concern of the novel "Maestro" is definitely the growth to maturity of Paul. The issues which arise in the novel, such as music, relationships, love, and betrayal, all contribute to lead to his developement to understanding. These issues portrayed in the commencement of the novel is what entices and sustains the reader to continue.…

    • 801 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Salda, Michael. "What Really Happens in Cather 's `Paul 's Case '?" Studies in Short Fiction 29 (1992): 113-19.…

    • 2816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two texts, The Pianist and Hotel Rwanda both explore the idea of war building character from ordinary everyday people to heroes. Not only this but also the qualities characters develop during war which helps us to survive. In Hotel Rwanda, the main character Paul only cares for his family even when as he watches his neighbor being beaten and taken away, saying “He is not family. Family is all that matters…” In this scene we see how the family man Paul is just an ordinary man doing his best to keep his family safe during the Rwandan civil war. Though later in the film we see the change in Paul’s character from a family man to a hero when he decides to stay behind at the hotel which he manages, along with the other refugees left behind while his family leave to safety saying “I cannot leave these people to die”. Paul is willing to sacrifice himself and the comfort of his family for the safety of complete strangers who he has grown to care for over time. There is a close up of Pauls face and we see his anguish and pain as he looks at his family for what he thinks will be the last time. This helps us understand the quality of selflessness which he develops during war. When everybody seems to be looking out for themselves and their families, Paul learns that sacrificing his own life for the good of others…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maestro is written in the first person with an adult Paul, the main character, reflecting back over his life. It begins with Paul and Keller’s first meeting and they are both presented to us as rather arrogant and insensitive. However, when the adult Paul then interjects into his story about how he can understand that it might be incredible to believe that he came to ‘love this man’, his gruff music teacher the reader is brought to the realisation that there is a lot more depth to those characters and to their emotions than we might have previously thought.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Piano Lesson Thesis

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Piano Lesson is a play based on a conflict between two characters, Boy Willie and Berniece. Boy Willie is persistent on selling the piano to buy land, while Berniece wants to keep the piano because it has a lot of sentimental value to their family. The piano stayed with their family for many generations and Berniece is not willing to give it up just for some land. In The Piano Lesson, August Wilson emphasizes that family is more valuable than money.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Roman Polanski’s The Pianist presents viewers with the story of one man’s desire to survive against all odds, as he endures terrible hardship and pain. Set in Warsaw, Poland, during the German invasion of World War 2, it follows the journey of Wladyslaw Szpilman, a Jewish piano player who tries to stay alive as the Jewish people are all forced into submission. The Pianist gives a very stark portrayal of the events the Jewish people endured because of the Nazi’s tyranny and also details a story of survival, and the desire to live, despite horrific circumstances. No matter what happens, Szpilman never loses the will to live, and as his world crumbles around him, he stays incredibly strong. The determination that Szpilman displays, the way that he never loses hope, and how he is willing to do whatever it takes to survive makes him a character of admiration for viewers.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics