Every student has had to deal with the traditional letter grading system at some point throughout their educational career. While I do think that the pass/fail grading system would help students be less stressed in school, I do not think that it is the proper way to grade. Letter grading keeps competition in the classroom, not always among all the students but also among oneself; it rewards the students for their hard work and dedication, and it could help them get the career they want later in life.
While I do think that many students could benefit from a pass/fail grading system, I think that taking away letter grades at a high school or college would do nothing but hurt the students. Letter grades are the measurement of the students’ performance and students who actually try their best to do the work and succeed, would not want to be placed in a class with students receiving the same grade as them who are only doing enough work to get by. Many of the students who are getting the good grades in school take pride in their work and make sure they are doing their best to get the grades they get.
The only good way to look at taking away the letter grading system is for students who aren’t trying their hardest to succeed, or ones that are trying their best but aren’t quite getting it. But just because the standards are lowered and these students are passing just like the best students in the class, it doesn’t mean they fully understand the material and these students wouldn’t get offered much help because teachers would see them as passing, not just barely passing.
Grades are a great way to get students motivated. If students knew they could pass a class by just doing the minimum and get the same grade as everyone else, they wouldn’t try as hard. I know if it were me, I wouldn’t put a ton of hard work into something just to get the same grade as someone who is only doing half the work that I am. The letter grading system forces the students to do their best and worry about the grades they get at the end of the semester. Students attend class, do homework and study for tests to receive good grades but if those grades are taken away, students won’t be as worried to do those things; they’d do only as much as they would have to, to pass.
Competition in the classroom is also a great way to keep students motivated. It keeps them focused and encourages them to strive to do better. If a student gets a C or B on a test, the next time they’ll study harder to try to get that A. Students always want to better their grades but if they only get a grade of ‘pass,’ there’s not much there to motivate them to get anything better. Sometimes there’s also competition amongst the students which keep them striving to do better. For example, I took an AP psychology class in high school and I sat next to one of my friends, after every test we would compare our grades to see who scored higher. It didn’t matter which of us scored higher, the next test we would both study even harder and longer to try and get the highest grade. Both of us passed each test, but it was just our competitiveness that made us strive to achieve our goal. With a pass/fail grading system you can’t really do that.
When someone applies for a job, the employer may base each applicant on their academics to see who is better fit for the job, but if transcripts only say whether the person passed or failed, the employer will have a much harder time deciding who is better suited for the job and may decide on something totally different than how well one did in school.
Grades can tell us everything, or they can tell us nothing. The pass/fail grading system wouldn’t tell us our real grade, it would tell us only whether we had passed or failed. Students wouldn’t try as hard and as a result, they wouldn’t fully learn the material. The traditional letter grading system lets the students know where they stand. It lets them know if they should push themselves a little harder to achieve their goal of getting that A. With letter grading, it can also show students that they can achieve their goals if they push themselves, unlike with pass/fail grading; it only pushes students to get the minimum of passing.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
I embrace Alfie Kohn’s ideology that by grading a student’s work one actually hinders the process of learning. Having three school-aged children myself, I see the effect grades have on their mindset. If they do not achieve an “A” they feel less than their peers. I also have seen instances where they will pick the easiest assignment or not bother to complete extra credit assignments for grading. Therefore, in this regard I do agree that grading does play a factor in their learning experience. However, the practicality of overcoming the mindset of a nation of people is a daunting task that may very well take years to persuade. As much as I may agree with Mr. Kohn’s ideology, I do not see this becoming mainstreamed within the educational system any time in the near future. His ideology would have to be fully embraced by the educational system for steps of improvement in grading students to take hold. This may very well take a grass roots effort from the parents and citizens themselves before ideology could be changed, which would take much time in educating the public on this subject. As much as I personally would love to see this type of learning be prevalent within our educational system I do not see it happening in my lifetime. One can only hope.…
- 809 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
A student who argues the point that they tried very hard in a course, therefore they should receive a higher grade, does not receive the value of what their work is worth. If one professor changes a students grade for the effort they put into the class they are teaching that student to expect the same leniency from other professors. A strict grading policy will teach students what their work is worth and to receive a better grade, they need to work harder.…
- 472 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the article, The Case against Grades, Alfie Kohn talks about how the grading system is deflecting the actual purpose of why students are interested in classes. He speaks on how grades tend to diminish students and create a preference for what a student has to aim for in his or hers course. I myself have experienced this in my academic life.…
- 784 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
I also think there should be a second chance for those who do not make the grade. Perhaps a year later, the students could be allowed to take the testing again. If they cannot make the grade, then they would obviously not be as attractive to the best colleges.…
- 341 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the essay, “What Our Education System Needs is More F’s”, Singleton suggests that educators should embrace the grade letter F instead of adopting a system of leniency that allows a student to not fully master his assignments and still obtain the opportunity to pass his grade level. The author feels that by adopting a black and white grading system, awarding students who meet academic standards and presenting F’s to those who don’t, will call the attention of students, parents, and teachers. He doesn’t claim that giving out F’s by the dozens presents a solution, but he feels that handing out F’s sends out a message and draws a starting line towards a more active and responsible education system. Singleton identifies the lack of student motivation, the absent parent involvement in education, and poor teaching skills as results of America’s poor education system.…
- 961 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Paul Goodmans` career, he proposed the idea of abolishing grading in colleges\universities. He analyzed the process; and he expressed, the immense pressure the students felt towards the Standardized Grading System. He noted how their primary, was just to do good on the test and get a good grade. Goodman suggested that they implement a pass/fail grading system. In the end many disagreed with Paul Goodman. They believed grading to be a process, that was not easily…
- 463 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Grades are a terrible way to evaluate a student’s knowledge and so is the pass-fail system. The pass-fail system does not give any room for separation. With the pass-fail system, there would be no difference between a 4.0 student and a D- student, and that is not fair. Farber offers the idea of a credit system, and I think that is a good idea. The credit system does not show if you failed, so there is nothing against you for trying. I think we need a new way to evaluate students, and the credit system would be a good step to try taking.…
- 1006 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
more of a status measure than a real reflection of understanding, and recognizes that the main objectors will be students and parents, both of whom see grades as a way to combat laziness. However, the proposal will bring greater purity and maturity to university schooling.…
- 1248 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Introduction Many colleges and universities have adopted or are considering adopting a grading system that provides a larger number of marking choices than the A through F whole-letter system. This usually takes the form of a plus-minus (+/-) grading system in one version or another. While a variety of reasons have been put forth for the move to +/- grades, a key motivation is the belief that a +/- grading system can either reverse the progression of grade inflation or counter its effects by establishing more grade choices so that performance can be more effectively differentiated. This paper first reviews studies of the prevalence in American colleges and universities of +/- grading systems and, perhaps more importantly, the prevalence of schools not using +/- systems who could potentially benefit from a shift to use of this form of grading system. Because of limitations found in available data, a targeted analysis of grading systems of a selected set of universities has been conducted. The results of this secondary research are briefly reported in the second section below. Results of the first two sections indicate that there remains a substantial set of schools that do not currently utilize +/- grading and might be considering a shift to this form of grading system. Next the paper reviews literature dealing with faculty and student perceptions of +/- grading systems and the effects of these systems on the level and distribution of grades and on student effort. Substantial differences in the perceptions of the two groups are found. The major focus of this paper is the analysis of how faculty and…
- 6727 Words
- 27 Pages
Good Essays -
In “What Our Education System Needs Is More F’s” the author, Carl Singleton, states that even though most high paying jobs require higher education we [America] need to get back to the basics. Which is giving out letter grades that are rightfully earned. Although, "sending students home with final grades of F would force most parents to deal with the realities of their children's failure..." think about all the negative effects giving an F might have. Such as it may lower self-esteem, as well as self-worth, and increase grade retention.…
- 481 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The current test based system is a joke to the students who only care about what they receive on the exam. Especially in High school, everyone’s trying to get into the best college they could. Grades are all that matters to colleges and kids will do what they need to do to get them. Once they have them, they no longer care about the material they needed to achieve those…
- 504 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Some are attacked for grading too harshly because the school needs to maintain a certain amount of passing students. The teachers are told to change and doctor the grades so that the students will pass (Mehta, 2005)! Oftentimes students will storm their instructor 's office at the end of the quarter to ask for extra credit when lost scholarships and credits loom on the horizon (Slay Jr., 2005). Not only this, but many people argue that the grading system itself is unbalanced and they have taken steps to readjust it. Many would assert that grades are necessary for students to produce their best quality work, but I would argue that grades are the cause of unhealthy habits and excessive stress in…
- 1829 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
If there is one thing that all students can relate to, it is grades. They are used throughout numerous countries, although each country has a slight difference in grading systems. Grades are a tool to measure how well a student is doing academically. But the real question is “Do they work?” The answer is no. Getting rid of the grading system currently in use in schools across the nation would benefit students, allowing them to really succeed by understanding and becoming involved in what they are learning, as opposed to spending more time worrying about grades.…
- 1562 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Every student is different. I believe that schools should not just have one specific way of grading for each student because each student learns differently and processes the information differently. Schools should give students placement test to see what they need to be taught and how they should be taught the class.…
- 353 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Getting a D gets you just as much credit as getting an A. Students are passing high school, but learning almost nothing in the process. One school district in New Jersey is trying to push those D students to get C’s by getting rid of the letter D from the grading system. Parent fully support this change but teachers, students, and some schools are against this because of graduation rates. Many believe that if you take away the letter D then the students that are at a D range are going to fail; as a result graduation rates will fall. Getting rid of D’s in schools will cause a decrease in graduation rates.…
- 288 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays