Preview

Part Time Indian Book Should Be Banned Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
496 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Part Time Indian Book Should Be Banned Essay
Books are selected to be banned or challenged because people believe the book teaches no lessons or gives the reader no educational value. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie is about a 14 year old Indian living on the reservation seeking a better education. This book is consecutively challenged every year by parents concerning this book being inappropriate. In some cases this book has been successfully banned in some school districts. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian should be banned because there is abusive, violent, and racist material which overtakes the educational value.
In the book, Junior’s friend Rowdy deals with abuse from his father. This quote is from Junior at the end of the second basketball game. “And I knew that Rowdy’s father was probably going to beat the crap out of him for losing the game” (Alexie 196). Rowdy is beaten for no reason from his abusive father. Physically abusing your child is messed up and can be inappropriate for some readers. Reading about abuse in a school environment from a fictional story gives the reader no educational value. Therefore, abusive material is not the only reason for this book to be banned, there is also violent content. The books gets violent when Junior’s friend Rowdy punches him in the face. Junior is punched in the
…show more content…
The quote is from Junior after transferring schools, he arrives to school and is made fun of and called names for being a reservation Indian. “But I knew I’d have to put a stop to it eventually or I’d be known as Chief or Tonto or Squaw Boy” (Alexie 64). Junior is racially called stereotypical Indian names. The students at his school are being racist by calling him Indian names. There is no educational value in reading about racism and can be considered inappropriate. Finally, reading about racism and racist slurs shows no educational value to the book and should be banned from

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Outsiders Summary

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It contains very strong theme about dysfunctional family, use of drugs and crime. I guess the board of education was afraid that the students will imitate the events in the book. However, I understand why they decided to re-allow it in schools. The author, who wrote this book around our age really wanted to deliver that we can all live together in peace and conflict only bring more conflict. Although the family in the Outsiders wasn’t the best family you could ask for, they had so much love inside them they didn’t actually portray to each other. They just didn’t know the right way to express it. I would rate this book 4/5 because of the effectiveness of the author trying to deliver her message in a coherent manner. I highly recommend all teenagers to read this book. Overall, I think this compelling story will grasp even the most reluctant readers thanks to the deep bond of sympathy. There is also a movie “The Outsiders”, although I happen to feel that it fails to deliver the strong message as realistic and in sequence as the…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Imagine the feeling of living in a Jim Crow south after the Civil War. In Richard Wright’s autobiography “Black Boy”, he illustrates his life as he tries to understand the segregated and white dictated world he lives in. Throughout the story he asks questions to others and himself to attempt at understanding the world. Since the book is an autobiography it allows the reader to take a front row seat with the story. “Black Boy” is one of the many books that were challenged for a myriad of reasons. Those reasons ranging from political to religious. Although the book was accused for multiple offenses some teachers and students think the book still holds value.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “ If You Assign My Book, Don’t Censor It” published in the Washington Post on November 28, 1999 Mark Mathabane argues that the decision taken by officials of Kearsley High-School in Flint, Mich. of censoring “Kaffir Boy” is unnecessary and disrespectful. He gives a series of examples of how it is a bad decision to censor the content of a book since most of the times this distorts the main ideas and the purpose of the text itself. Kaffir Boy is a novel about Mathabane’s life in South Africa, during the apartheid period. Although Mark agrees that some of the content is a little harsh and might not be suitable for a younger audience, he greatly disagrees with the idea of censuring sentences in the book, he later defends this by stating that books are not written with the comfort of readers in mind. Mathabane also suggests that if the important and mature scenes in the novel are taken out, the most important aspects for the knowledge and significance of the story will be destroyed. At the end he offers some possible solutions like the creation of reading-list guidelines. Mathabane’s article makes a good use of logic, establishes credibility by using some of his personal experiences and by using a positive attitude. He emotionally appeals the audience and offers a good, clear solution that provides the reader with alternative points of view about the subject.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The absolutely true diary of a part-time Indian” (PTI) is a novel written by Sherman Alexie. The novel follows a Native-American teenage boy named Arnold who lives on a reservation that has to suffer through the troubles of being the only Indian teenager in an all white school at Reardan. The challenges that confronted him when he started at Reardan seemed menacing, but through his personal spirit and courage he was able to achieve success at the school. Some of Arnold’s successes include his triumph in the Varsity basketball team as their “secret weapon”, his academic efforts and his charismatic persona which helped him blend into the all white school.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an attempt to rebuke the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People’s claim that controversial books damage the self-esteem of African-American children, Hentoff recounts an experience where he talked with a group of eighth-grade students who were studying Mark Twain’s Huck Finn alongside a history of cities with a reputation for having a high tolerance for racism. One student in the class was bold enough to comment that his class was taught that the “bigots” Twain referred to in his novel commonly referred to African-Americans as “niggers,” stating that just because of Twain’s over-zealous use of the term did not equate to an assumption that Huck Finn was a racist novel (Hentoff). On the contrary, this particular student claimed that as evidence that Twain was expressly critiquing the word and people who used it in order to write a very anti-racist novel.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A trashy and racist book wouldn't be allowed in classrooms. The novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, written by Mark Twain, is receiving negative attention. The dominant problem that students, parents, teachers, and even professors, face , is the usage of the n-word. After reading this adventurous story, it is hard to find the problem that is upsetting many people. Therefore, this incredible novel should continue to be in the high school curriculum because it offers students a realistic historical background, it receives numerous positive reactions, and the meaning of the word nigger, (referred to as the n-word) is changing over time.…

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Part Time Indian Hero

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He is very sentimental and sensitive. He is afraid of being by himself in a new world. Not having Rowdy in Reardon High School, makes it a little bit harder for Junior because people will make fun of him and could also hurt him. On page 54 Junior says, “I’m scared dad.” Dad replied, “You can always go back to the Rez School.” Junior does not want to go back to the Rez School because he could get hurt and he also won’t be able to get a good education. Junior already made the decision of going to a different school and he was not going to give it up just because he was scared. Junior has conquered some of his weakness. An example in which show us that Junior has overcome one of his fears is when Roger made a racist comment about Indians. He said, “Did you know that Indians are living proof that niggers fuck buffalo?” Junior punched Roger in the face and then challenged him to fight but instead Roger walked away from Junior. This is a big achievement for Junior because this time he didn’t have to depend on Rowdy to help him out. Little by little, Junior is defeating his…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every one hundred years dialects change and what is considered “politically correct”, or socially acceptable, changes. “David Bradley argues that ‘if we'd eradicated the problem of racism in our society, Huckleberry Finn would be the easiest book in the world to teach’” (Zwick, Jim. “Should Huckleberry Finn Be Banned?”). If we, as a nation, make it a point to rule out all books that could possibly offend students, then every hundred years or so our library of American Literature will be completely different. Even today, modern day authors use vulgar language, lurid sexual content, and racial slurs to get their point across. If The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is taken off of required reading lists across the country, then that could create a never-ending cycle of books being taken off of school shelves every time words and ideas become unacceptable. If this is the way that American society is turning then something must be done, and the Superintendents, Deans, and Principals of every High School around the country must take it upon themselves to do it because the students will not.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This story takes place around 2007. The story still depicts the discriminatory views and actions as like in To Kill a Mockingbird. However the story isn’t nearly as racist and unjust as the other. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-time Indian is about this about a boy named, Arnold Spirit Jr. Junior is a fourteen year old Spokane Indian that lives on a reservation in Washington. Junior is an unusual kid. He is very strange and everyone thinks he has major problems. I mean Junior does have a problem, he was born with water on the brain. Everybody makes fun of Junior for the way he is. They don’t make fun of him because of his brain condition, but of his appearance. Junior is a very scrawny, nerdy looking boy. However, Junior makes one of the most risky decisions of his life. He decides to leave his reservation school at Wellpinit and transfer to an all white school at…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Banning the books that address ideas that parents’ do not agree with does not solve or hid the problems away. Comparing to the parents in the book how they at first did not acknowledge the protagonists problems she could have been saved earlier. What parents and school administrators need to realize that banning the books does not solve the problem. The issues that the book covers surround the kids from every other aspect of their lives, they will still be able to witness others using drugs or be involved themselves…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Some people would like to ban To Kill a Mockingbird from schools, but they should carefully rethink that. This book is valuable because it teaches students about racism, which is a very real thing in society. It also teaches about the history of the era and authentically shows how they lived, although it was cruel at times.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever read something in a book or an article and found yourself wondering about how much that could affect readers? For some reason, whether due to a personal disagreement with the message, or academic dissatisfaction with content, or something else entirely, you ask yourself ‘How is this allowed to exist, to be circulated and available for our posterity?’ In some form, that sentiment, and the censorship of information which results from it, have both been around for as long as information itself has existed. Whether it be the Church’s rejection of the spread of heresy, or the Third Reich’s manipulation of propaganda, information has always been controlled and taken advantage of. And yet, it may still surprise some to find that information…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book “To kill a Mockingbird” was recently banned from the Biloxi school district due to the use of the “N” word. There are mixed arguments with the decision as it is considered a masterpiece of American literature but still remains No. 21 in the most banned in the last decade. The book teaches a valuable lesson through real life events without changing anything to make it not sound as bad as it really was. The high schoolers reading it are mature enough to understand the meaning and look past the language so school districts have no need to ban it.…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Part-Time Indian

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Overall, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian written by Sherman Alexie encompasses the protagonist’s struggle to adapt to his change of schools. He effectively displays this by using detailed visuals that support his text. The images also give the reader a better understanding of how the main character feels and how he views the situation at hand. Some of the many significant illustrations include Arnold’s portrait, his emotional experience with Rowdy, and his comparison of Indians and whites. If you were a minority, how would you accustom yourself to a new…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Huck Finn Essay

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Teacher-student collaboration is a fundamental one should have before reading Huck Finn. In the Seattle Post “Huck Finn’ a masterpiece – or an insult” Gregory Roberts states that, “Before the language-arts students turned to chapter 1 of “Huckleberry Finn”, their teacher, Hilari Anderson, led the class in two weeks of discussion about the controversy surrounding the book and its terminology. The class viewed videotapes addressing the issue, researched the definition of the n-word and hashed out ground rules for its inclusion in the classroom.” (Roberts) Hilari Anderson explains the controversy of Huck Finn, and asks her class whether they feel comfortable using the n-word, and depending on how her class reacts, she teaches accordingly. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn should remain mandatory because teachers can prepare their students for the book and read the book according to how the class feels.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays