Preview

Paris Is Burning Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
753 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paris Is Burning Analysis
In today’s society doing gender has been made a focal point examining the social traits of masculinity and feminity. Society thinks that if you do gender your practicing a performance. I have noticed in my studies that judging people gender practices can reinforce gender equality as well as take for granted the human body. Have you ever watched the film Paris is Burning? Paris is Burning is about the 1980’s and queer culture. Paris is Burning describes how queer communities survived during this time. In Gender is Burning Butler writes “Paris is Burning documents neither an efficacious insurrection nor a painful resubordination, but an unstable coexistence of both.” What does she mean?
Addressing this question, I will argue that drag women are only acceptable when they are to entertain heterosexual bodies on television. I will draw from Butler’s Gender is Burning and the 1980 film Paris is Burning and then define my findings in the summary. In the film the success of drag is being judged by the extent to which ball contestants must pass meaning to be read as normal opposed to being read meaning for the queens in Paris Is Burning, to read by another queen is also to dis her.
In addressing a lived experience of ball culture I will describe the performances of feminizing black
…show more content…
The film showed fascination with feminism, it also showed how society exposes sex, gender, and racism. Butler’s argument that the ball participants fantasy to escape poverty, homophobia, and racism is just that a fantasy. The film also identifies that the ball exposes that the desires of the contestants falsely idealize womanhood. In the quote “Paris is Burning documents neither an efficacious insurrection nor a painful resubordination, but an unstable coexistence of both”(137) Butler is implementing that society has deep rooted constraints on what it means to be male and female, but gender is much more than societies outdated

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Story “The Black Ball” written by Ralph Ellison is about a man named John, born around the civil war that goes through difficulties and challenges in his life him being an African American. In the story, it seems like it’s just a straight forward story but if you take a real close look at it you can see that there is a message within the story. Through Metaphors and allegories and other literary terms like characterization, you can see the negative of how racism and discrimination affects people in a big way of there thinking. The theme of the story would have to do with Persistence and doing hard work through the tough times.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In both of their respective texts, Marjorie Garber and Roger Baker discuss the ever-increasing prevalence of “transvestism” (or what is modernly known as “drag”) in popular American culture. Although the American public typically disapproves of individuals blurring the boundaries of gender, the use of cross-dressing as entertainment has generally been embraced and met with great acclaim. In Vested Interests: Cross-Dressing and Cultural Anxiety, Garber argues that films like Tootsie (1982) is significant in that it portrays a heterosexual man living as a woman. While many enjoyed the movie believing that Tootsie was commentary on the relationship between men and women, Garber claims that the film is actually about transvestism. To ignore this…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Little Egypt Summary

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Carlton offers several collections of historical photographs and illustrations that make her book worth reading for historians, as well as oriental dancers and choreographers. She critically studies the nineteenth century’s period of arts and traces it to the contemporary Eastern dance, looking for possible clues to find likely lineage to Little Egypt, but all to no avail (84). Carlton also presents thought provoking ideas on the issues of racism and the marginalization of women. In this regard, Carlton claims that the white supremacists view Middle Eastern and other cultures from a very ethnocentric angle. According to Carlton, the president of the Board of Lady at the fair says on one occasion, in protest, that oriental dancers “are ignorant and I think we owe it to our cause that we visit these women … [and] teach them our ways and manners” (25). The general public perception regarding Middle Eastern dance is flawed and Carlton takes a bold stance against such a perception. This is considered as a remarkable feat in enlightening the general Western populace with the true principles of Middle Eastern cultures and art…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    English 124 Paper 2

    • 1189 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As we enter into the dissection of the novella at Breakfast at Tiffanys, the reader must be skilled to understand ways to interpret this book. This book is multilayered which can direct the reader into different directions based on their beliefs or background. Cultural Context can be described by a person’s upbringing and cultural background. This includes referral to the person’s thoughts, opinions and feelings that result from experiences they have had. As the author of this paper, it will be my focus to correlate the book to the ideology of Separate Spheres. This is defined by Wikipedia as separate spheres for women and men. Culturally located in Europe and North America, it emerged as a distinct ideology during the Industrial Revolution, although the basic idea of gendered separation of spheres is much older. The notion of separate spheres dictates that men, based primarily on their biological makeup as well as the will of God, inhabit the public sphere – the world of politics, economy, commerce, and law. Women's "proper sphere", according to the ideology, is the private realm of domestic life, child-rearing, housekeeping, and religious education. The separate spheres ideology presumes that women and men are inherently different and that the sex differences as well as the resulting separation of spheres are "natural".1 Therefore, though this text can be interrupted in many different fashions, it will be the focus of the author of this paper to focus on the separate sphere theory.…

    • 1189 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the speech, “The Crisis,” by Carrie Chapman Catt is portraying the empowerment of women and urges women groups to join the fight for equality and the fight for Women's Suffrage. Carrie Chapman converses of a sexual bias in the society that lives even in the modern day. From having our first female candidate stand for election for the post of President to a President that is that opposite of everything good in America. We live in the society where we think the society has got past the racial & sexual discrimination but deep down in this vicious societal norms demons still haunt over the bright light. Many women acquiesce because of the gender role they play in an abhorring closed in earth The speech uses an abundance of rhetorical devices imagery, metaphors, parallelism to impasses on the point she wants to convey.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Society has created a set of norms and standards which imply that you are supposed to behave, dress, and do things based on your gender. However, Queer theorist, Judith Butler, does not agree with society. Instead, Butler believes that gender roles are not biologically constructed. Butler’s 1990 novel Gender Trouble, examines the extent to which gender and sexuality are performative. Butler’s concept of performative gender is depicted in Michael Chabon’s novel Summerland. The fantasy novel revolves around the protagonist, Ethan, and his friends, who all play baseball and must stop the Coyote from ending the world. In order to stop the trickster god Coyote, Ethan travels through Summerland with a small troupe of friends, playing baseball in…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    I identified this group of poor, gay, minority men who participate in balls as a microculture. This microculture’s distinguishing aspects are that these men all seem to live for balls, with dreams of fame and fortune, “The balls are our fantasies of being superstars,” (Pepper Labeija). This group also has an extreme love for, and competitive drive to be successful at vogeuing. Another trait this group shares is a love for fashion. They use fashion and style in order to appear “real.” This subculture wants to appear to be authentically white, straight, and female (Levy). This is depicted throughout the film Paris is Burning. Another microculture that I identified in the film is the transvestite microculture. This microculture defines itself by dressing up like the opposite sex, in this case men dressing as women, but who do not wish to become women. They could be considered androgynous, (Solomon, 186). While they do not identify with females, they wish to look female. The third microculture I identified in the film is the transvestite microculture. This group’s ideal self (Solomon, 177) is female. They identify with females and wish to eventually become female.…

    • 2134 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The documentary Paris is burning is an important source for focusing on issues regarding race, gender, drags, and transsexual. The documentary emphases on the life of drags which are reflected as a significant implements to understand issues related to gender. It explores the drag ball culture of the New York City concentrating in the Latino, white, black, homosexual and transgender community. In the documentary Livingston articulates thoughts about sexual identity, homophobia and racism.…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the second section of her speech, the largest paragraph, she explains what will happen to men if women are not liberated. She looks at the pressures men are under, and using humorous, sarcastic and hyperbolic language she ridicules the stereotypical image of masculinity, making it seem wrong and in need of change. She then moves on to describe the present, the ‘sexual revolution’ that is taking place, and what it really means to her. By comparing it to ‘cheap headlines’ she makes her view seem important and revolutionary. She ends this section by saying ‘And it is the emergence of men’, too, which gives the impression that it is a happy ending for all.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In order to fully analyze the sexes in this book, the micro, meso and macro levels need to be looked at individually to observe where sexuality is imagined and experienced by both genders. On the micro level, the sexes are very different from one another in this book. The women are expected to be large in weight and wear pants and shirts. The men are often wearing skirts and blouses with a contraption called a peho which holds their genitals in place. This can be compared with a bra to women in society today. When Patronius Bram has to buy his first peho he’s struck with much anxiety and wondering. This means he’s beginning to enter adulthood and will attend the Maidmen’s Ball. Here is where boys expect to be “swept off their feet” by a certain woman and taken into a maidmen-room and engage in some sort of sexual activity. The boys expect it to be a wonderful experience and hope to have actual intercourse. The women on the other hand appear rather rowdy and in it only for the sexual relations. The whole goal of this ball is for the boys…

    • 1697 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Bodies that Matter, Butler uses drag as an example of potential subversion to traditional gender performativity, stating: “Drag is subversive to the extent that it reflects on the imitative structure by which hegemonic gender is itself produced and disputes heterosexuality’s claim on naturalness and originality.” According to Butler, drag is one of many ways to resist the power structures that regulate gender identities, mainly through the ridiculing of normative cultural and social expressions. Drag destabilizes the “truth” of sexual and gender mainstream ideology by pointing to the fact that there is no obligating reason that necessitates the constant repetition of normative behaviour. Drag exposes social coercion at the base of the performative…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Harriet Jacobs a True Woman

    • 2422 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Bibliography: Dickerson, Glenda. The Cult of True Womanhood: Toward a Womanist Attitude in African-American Theatre. Theatre Journal, Vol. 40, No. 2 (May, 2988): 179. Accessed February 2, 2013, URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3207655.…

    • 2422 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Drag Analysis

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Butler (1993) builds on this argument, expressing that drag culture questions gender identity, in the sense that it perceived as an imitation of gender and whilst the sex of the individual is deemed the original. According to Butler (1993), drag culture is often viewed as a parody of the gender divide, as it draws attention to elements that are falsely normalised even though the the culture is intent on portraying women. Furthermore, drag culture reinforces this notion by providing insight as the construction of an image in addition to questioning what makes a woman. Thus, gender is not inherent, it is but a performance or a…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Dennis Schep, a doctoral candidate at the at the Free University of Berlin, discusses the argument on how Butler’s theory can be interpreted as a hindrance to women’s fight for quality: “although gender performativity is certainly a powerful tool in the battle against homophobia and other types of sexual discrimination, it may also inhibit certain strands of feminist and/or transgender politics by foreclosing the essentialist coordinates that serve to ground them.” However, queer theory must be interpreted to explain the fluidity of gender roles, norms, and constructs through the exaggerated performance of gender roles. His main argument lay in Butler’s theory becoming a “hegemonic framework within the field of gender studies… lead[ing] to the foreclosure of certain possible gendered identities.” The limiting of gender identity can be seen in Jay Poole’s discussion on the representations of gay males in the media. Poole, Ph.D., analyzes the portrayal of homosexuals in television shows and “straight media.” He specifies that queer characters are being typecast and that it enforces gender roles by mentioning the social constructs of femininity and masculinity in application to gay couples: “the consequence of adopting gender characteristics that truly blend traditional gender boundaries seems to place people in the margins even within marginalized groups, e.g.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although power itself is immaculate and invisible, the effects of power come alive in a mother-daughter struggle, a male-female tug-of-war, a conflict between Asian and American values in an immigrant family, and the opposition between black and white in a chess game. Throughout this story (and various other stories from the Modern Voices unit), a theme that is evident is one surrounding female empowerment. There were many instances in the story when the theme of female empowerment could be seen, but a specific example in the story is when Waverly is describing how why won multiple chess tournaments and became famous, “They ran a photo of me in Life magazine next to a quote in which Bobby Fischer said, ‘There will never be a woman grand master.’ ‘Your move, Bobby,’ said the caption.” This shows how Waverly (a female) is challenging a man’s statement about chess, which was primarily a man’s game. By winning many tournaments, Waverly is showing the world that women are as strong as men (if not stronger) and supports women in their ongoing struggle for equality with men. This theme can also be depicted through a work of art with various elements that contribute to a greater understanding of the theme. Through this analysis, three elements of a work of art (created by the author of this analysis) will be discussed: the queen (chess piece), the red color of the queen, and the black and white checkerboard…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays