Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Paper of Son and Lovers

Good Essays
1176 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paper of Son and Lovers
The characters in "Sons and Lovers" ——Tragedy of Paul 's Love 郁彩霞 Abstract: As the main character in this novel, Paul, shows the most struggle in his love: the love for hs mom, for Miriam and for Clara. My work is to analyze the complicated relationships among the women and the man. Due to the Oedipus complex of Paul, he always can 't balance his love between his lovers and mother. A pure pilgrim of Miriam and a feminist of Clara, Paul finds himself in love with both of the two. However, he can marry neither, because he can 't balance them with his mother, a possessive women. Paul 's love is not an occasionally tragedy, but an inevitable one. Key words: balance, son and lovers, Oedipus complex, feminism Introduction :
General idea about Paul and the Sons and Lovers
Conflict between Miriam and the mother and Paul
Conflict between body and soul
Paul 's self -reasons for his tragedy of love
Conclusion

Body
As one of the most outstanding masterpieces of D. H. Lawrence, Sons and Lovers is a magnificent novel which reflects the society of Britain as well as the whole world in the early 20th century. The novel tells several unbalanced lovers including Paul, the main character of the novel, reflecting the real life of D. H. Lawrence. Paul is a real contradiction who can not balance his love among his lovers and his mother. Reflected by parents ' endless conflicts, Paul tends to love his mother but hate the father, which seems to be the origin of his tragedy of love.
Mrs. Morel, a possessive women, who would never allow his beloved son to be robbed by other women. Such kind of emotion comes from her Phaedra complex towards her son. And her son, Paul, is born with the Oedipus complex. Dramatically, this pair of mother and son is more likely a pair of lovers. Mother always wants her son to be with her and the son thinks his mother a lovely woman that he even can not bear his mother 's being older and the fact that she is much older that him. This close relationship becomes the basis of the story and here comes the conflict between Mrs. Morel and Miriam. Miriam, is the woman who wants to take Paul away from Mrs. Morel, doubtlessly becomes the evil for Mrs. Morel. Since Paul falls in love with Miriam, he often returns home very late, much later than which Mrs. Morel can accept. So, the hatred towards Miriam grows. Moreover, in Mrs. Morel 's view, Miriam is not good enough for her son. Thus, she always stands the opposite of Miriam. For the lovers themselves, do exist conflicts. Miriam is a pilgrim that she is pure and "holy" with whom Paul presents his best in soul. But Miriam is a so shy and conservative woman that she never be positive to her relationship with Paul. When Paul requires the sexual relation with her, she seems to be unwilling with it which raises the disgust of Paul. And, Miriam is also a possessive woman that she wants to own Paul body and soul. However, Paul is more desire for the freedom. Though the spiritual communication with Miriam makes him comfortable, their relation becomes looser. The Oedipus complex of Paul certainly makes a great contribution to his breaking up with Miriam. His love for his mother is always over anything else.
The appearance of Clara is obviously the greatest enemy of the love between Miriam and Paul. Still, the relation between Paul and Clara can not meet with a happy ending. It not because of the feminism of Clara which makes herself more difficult to be controlled but also the old love she has towards her husband as well as the desire of sexual love of Paul instead of soul love. The relationship with Clara, for Paul, is more of a relationship of sex. They have little in common with each other. Though this time Mrs. Morel shows her mercy to Clara, it can not help to strengthen the relation of the two. Clara, goes back to her husband at last. Paul, he himself, obtains nothing but the happiness of sex from this beautiful lady. The same condition happens with Miriam. Paul has sexual relation with both of the lovers but finally he choose neither to be his wife. From the soul, he loves Miriam, but the beauty and charm of Clara catches his attention. He swings from Clara to Miriam, suffering a lot both body and soul. Decision is so hard for him to made.
Of course, Paul has several self-reasons that results in his failure of his love. Firstly, the Oedipus complex should be the greatest enemy on the way of finding love. Because of the abnormal love to his mother, Paul can be easily influenced by his mother 's emotion. Mrs. Morel hates Miriam, and finally, Paul does so. His mother 's emotion has a strong effect on him. He just can not escape from the shadow of his mother that he can not love any woman more than his mother. To be extremely, Paul can not love any woman except his own mother. Besides, Paul is always finding faults with his lovers. Since he has fallen in love with Miriam, he dose not satisfied with her. When she shows her strong emotion to her little brother or beautiful flowers, she can help herself to be immoderate. At this time Paul shows no forgiveness to his lover but disgust. If a man can not tolerate his lover 's defects, how can he truly love her? Above all, it is no wonder that Paul is a coward without sense of responsibility. When he thinks he has to marry Miriam because of their relationship, he actually dose not dare to do so. He can not afford a marriage and he even never thought to marry anyone but he still has sexual relationships with his lovers. Shouldn 't he take the responsibility of the sexual relation? Of course he should. But he doesn 't. Such a cowardly man surly can not get a true mate for him.
At the moment, it 's very clear for us to know Paul 's tragedy for his love and the reasons. Actually, Paul has not become a normal adult by getting over some problems like other children. That is not only determined by his mother’s abnormal maternity. His family atmosphere never gives him a chance to be normal. Never was a son more indentured to his mother 's love and full of hatred for his father than Paul Morel. It not only a tragedy of Paul 's love but also a tragedy of his whole life. Maybe his mother 's death can lead him to a hopeful life.

References:
On the Inevitability of the Failure of the Love between Paul and Miriam in Sons and Lovers by unknown writer
The Conflicts between Body and Soul in Sons and Lovers by unknown writer
Analysis of Paul ' Characteristic in Sons and Lovers by Xu Xintong
Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence 伊犁人民出版社
论劳伦斯《儿子与情人》中的女性主义 ——催更生

References: On the Inevitability of the Failure of the Love between Paul and Miriam in Sons and Lovers by unknown writer The Conflicts between Body and Soul in Sons and Lovers by unknown writer Analysis of Paul ' Characteristic in Sons and Lovers by Xu Xintong Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence 伊犁人民出版社 论劳伦斯《儿子与情人》中的女性主义 ——催更生

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Lais of Marie de France

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Marie begins her collection of lais with the story of Guigemar, a noble knight who is cursed with the task of finding true love to heal a physical injury. This lay introduces two types of love: selfish and selfless. Selfish love is not courtly love. It lacks devotion and true loyalty. It lacks suffering and self-denial. Marie de France portrays this kind of love in the old husband of the woman whom Guigemar loves. The man locks his wife away in an enclosure guarded by a castrated man. By doing this, the husband shows a mean, limited devotion to his wife; perhaps even worse, he limits her ability to experience true love. This kind of love does not last; in fact, the husband is cuckolded when his wife has a year-long affair with Guigemar. He is made a fool, the dupe of love.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Somehow her relationship with Robert can also be interpretted as a certain excitement beyond the norms, just as how she thinks her marriage with Leonce is romantic because of her father’s objection. She is also not a perfect artist who can earn a living on her own with her sketches, as an artist “must possess many gifts – absolute gifts – which have not been aquired by one’s own effort”. While Edna’s actions of leaving her home seem to bear the qualities of “the courageous soul” that “dares and defies”, her “gifts” seem not sufficient enough to lift her up from where she has been. Nevertheless, all these flaws of Edna have proved how ordinary women in the 19th century cannot realize their own selves under the social boundaries as a wife and a mother. In fact, the normalness of Edna suggests that this story can happen to any woman in the setting – who may live a loving married life depending on her own submissiveness to the occassionally-courteous husband, who may meet the love of her life after getting married and have no future in the relationship, who may possess certain skills but not yet good enough to achieve as the price is so high that achievement is almost unattainable. If Edna is a tragic heroine who has waken but not realized, then this tragedy might have repeated many times in…

    • 2202 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Oedipus complex phase the male child "…develops an object cathexis for his mother, which originally related to the mother's breast ..." (26). His mother becomes the love-object meanwhile "the boy deals with his father by identifying himself with him. For a time these two relationships proceed side by side until the boy's sexual wishes in regard to his mother become more…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Lover Duras

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is a multitude of complicated family dynamics in The Lover, especially in the mother-daughter relationship. Both in its content and its construction, the novel expresses a process by which the daughter discerns herself from her mother while staying connected to her. It is a continuous, unsettled and conflictual process in which the daughter never escapes the context of maternal body…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlets Oedipus Complex

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Various works of literature contain characters who embody the elements of the classic Oedipus Complex, that of a son with an undue and unhealthy attachment to his mother. D.H Lawrence’s Sons and Lovers, along with other early modernist works, shows how a son’s bond to his mother can lead to that character’s major downfall. Even earlier than works of the late 19th Century does the Oedipus Complex appear, in this case, William Shakespeare’s Hamlet. Shakespeare’s play about the Prince of Denmark shows the beginning of an Oedipal Complex, with Hamlet’s jealousy of his uncle Claudius for marrying his mother Gertrude and the rage that Hamlet’s emulation causes.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Klages explains that, “the Oedipus Complex explains how desires get repressed, how these repressed desires form the unconscious, how girls and boys learn to desire objects outside of their own families, how each sex learns to desire someone of the opposite sex, and how the superego—the reality principle, or what we call ‘conscience’—gets formed” (Klages 68). Then, Klages goes into analysis of the Oedipus Complex. She explains how people become attracted to the other sex, but men are protective of their mothers because of the bond that they develop with their mothers at birth. She also explains how their mother is their first love object and their mother’s body is their first experience of pleasure. I find this to be an interesting topic because it explains the closeness of infants to their parents and how man are protective of the women of their…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "The Horse - Dealer's Daughter" D. H. Lawrence The role of women in society is constantly an issue. D.H. Lawrences's story shows through passive natures, obedient attitudes, and shattered egos a woman struggling to live her life according to her three verbally abusive brothers.…

    • 523 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Collector of Treasures

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In this story, “The Collector of Treasures,” Dikeledi, a strong and resilient characteris married to a man named Garesego who is a womanizer. Garesego believed that everything had to be about sex. He did not take care of his responsibilities as a man. Head described him as the type of man who had sex with women like dogs, out of canal lust. Out of the four years that they were together, Garesego got Dikeledi pregnant 3 times and left her. He did not leave and go to another village, he stayed in the same village and did not take care of the sons he helped bring in the world. On the contrary, Paul is completely different from Garesego. Paul is portrayed as the man who cares about his woman and treats her like a person. He is there for his wife, Kenalepe, and their children. Seeing Paul treat his wife like a person was something new for Dikeledi and seeing that type of action from a man to his wife led Dikeledi to try to talk to Garesego.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sons and Lover Themess

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages

    ’’Sons and Lovers’’ is the first Freudian novel in the English literature. The Oedipus Complex is the centralized theme of the novel, It covers a large space and is a dominant factor in the novel.Paul is too much emotionally attached to his mother, Mrs. Morel and suffers from mother-fixation and mother image often pops up to stand between him and the objects of his love (Miriam and Clara ). The Oedipus Complex has been widely diffused over the canvas of the novel.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some literary elements in the short story that contribute to the theme are setting, characters and point of view. In this short story it was set in the 1970’s in South Africa, this was a historic period due to apartheid. By understanding the apartheid situation in South Africa at that time the actions of Paulus become more apparent. It was unacceptable for these two young people to ever have a relationship since Thebedi was an African and she was considered to be the lowest class. Having any type of relationship between Thebedi and Paulus was prohibited. As terrible as it was that Paulus killed his own child it is now understandable based on the laws of that time and what would have taken place if others found out (Owens, 2002)…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    These three women constitute a firm support from soul, spirit, and flesh, and help Paul to pursue his so-called perfect humanity, to become a real man. Daniel in his The Consciousness of D. H. Lawrence: “An Intellectual Biography” (1986), wrote “In fact, the three women, mother, Miriam, and Clara all made Paul feel that he was prisoned”. Towards the end, we see that when Paul ends the three relationships desperately, he moves on to pursue to his own future, and that is when we can see a patriarchal, self-centered, and sadistic male Chauvinist. What the three women have in common, however, is the dominance they have over Paul. And this ascendency, leads to his destruction is later life as well. The three women in this assignment will further be discussed in depth in order to understand the dominant role each played in Paul’s life. This assignment towards the end will further elaborate on the autobiographical air the novel had due to which Lawrence embedded on this narrative.…

    • 2666 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ‘Sons and Lovers’ is among one of the most autobiographical works of English Literature. D. H. Lawrence spent a troubled life in terms of relationships, economic conditions and the lack of a normal household. The novel mirrors its author in this respect. The protagonist Paul, who is in many ways a ‘counterpart’ of D. H. Lawrence, has difficulty in developing relations particularly with the opposite sex. We can see other autobiographical elements in terms of financial crisis, class difference and the infamous psychoanalytical theories at work throughout the novel. As the critic Kate Millett says:…

    • 1868 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    gijnoihd

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Lawrence's first great novel, Sons and Lovers, is clearly autobiographical: "there's no denying the closeness of the resemblance between Paul Morel's life and that of his creator" (DeMott vii). The novel tells the story of Gertrude Morel, a mother whose possessive love for her sons hinders their ability to establish fulfilling relationships with other women. Lawrence himself had an unusually close attachment to his mother. The novel also depicts the working class of England at the turn of the century, when industrialism was rearing its ugly head and was creeping upon the English countryside. Set in a town similar to the one where he was born, Sons and Lovers gives a detailed and realistic portrayal of the hardships and conflicts of the Morels, a mining family.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within D.H. Lawrence’s ‘Sons and Lovers’, Paul has been quite an unusual character. In the beginning of the novel, the reader witnesses William’s and Annie’s relationships with their mother and although William and Mrs. Morel’s bond was odd, it could not compare to Paul’s relationship with his mother. Throughout the first few chapters of the novel, the reader notices, through Mrs. Morel’s narratives in chapters one and two that she did not want to give birth to Paul because of the financial burden he would ultimately have on the poor family and the failing relationship between Mr. Morel and her.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Romance in Medieval England

    • 2433 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Bibliography: Jaeger, C. Stephen – “Ennobling Love: In Search of a Lost Sensibility” Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1999…

    • 2433 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays