Preview

Paine vs Burke

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
591 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paine vs Burke
These two writers are talked about together, since they differed in their reaction to the French Revolution. They also represent two opposing ideologies: conservatism and radical liberalism. Some would say that Burke is more a true philosopher than Paine, but in my view this is not fair, and both are important: Burke for warning of the dangers of trying to shape society according to abstract concepts and ideals, and as a representative of traditional English Conservatism; Paine for foreseeing the welfare state, as well as American independence from Britain.
Burke was born in Ireland, and went to London in 1750. Though Burke was a harsh critic of the French Revolution, he supported the right of America to gain independence from Britain. He supported the Americans because he believed revolution to be justified in order to regain or restore something lost. The slogan “no taxation without representation” was based on his arguments. He not only opposed the French Revolution but was deeply shocked by it. He agreed that the aristocrats had not been carrying out their responsibilities well, but thought it would be better to return to an order which did work than to bring in a new, untried system. In 1790 he wrote Reflections on the Revolution in France. Burke’s other objections to the French revolutionaries were that ideas of natural rights were dangerous, as they could be taken to extremes by anyone.
Tom Paine had the most extraordinary life – as an active political figure in Revolutionary America and Revolutionary France, and even spending time in prison. He was born in Thetford, Norfolk, and the son of a stay-maker. In Norfolk he saw the effects of the enclosures. His Parents were Quakers, and seem to have been somewhat puritan. His father would not allow him to study Latin as the Roman authors were thought not to be good examples. Although Paine was not a systematic philosopher, it is possible to draw the following ideas from his writings. Common sense was a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Reflections of the Revolution in France, Edmund Burke intellectually attacks the French for the occurrences that took place in their country during the late 1700s. Burke was strongly opposed to immense political reform. In this book, he voices his belief that it is counteractive to try new types of government because it can lead to the loss of the progress achieved by the past generations. Thus, he argues that all men are subject to a generational contract that embodies beings from the past, present and the future. This is where I begin to have a problem with Burke’s argument because, as stated in Paine’s book The Rights of Man, old forms of government cannot keep up with new elements that come about with changing times; thus, civilians…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    How did an English born man become one of the most influential figures in our nations fight for independence? Common Sense perhaps is not the catchiest of titles, but this man caught the attention of an entire nation with his writings. I’m writing about Thomas Paine, a man of many talents who found his calling in inspiring the nation to join the revolution. This man was not known to be a writer. Little is known about where he honed his writing skill, because it was almost too good to be natural. So, a man with so many shortcomings eventually becomes one of the most important people to the revolution. A man starting with nothing comes to fame in his forties and dies penniless and largely forgotten.…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom Paine’s Common Sense was most important because it advocated not only American independence but a republican form of government based on consent of the people.…

    • 2457 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Founding Father Thomas Paine , England born political philosopher and writer (1727-1809). He helped shape many of the ideas that marked the Age Revolution. In 1776, his high popular “Common Sense” was published and it was the first pamphlet to advocate American Independence. No other figure played a great role in moving the American People from a spirit of rebellion to one of revolution.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Instead of having a drift between these two countries, Britain can benefit and gain revenue from America He also argued that the Britain government’s stands on America may be denied of its freedom because of conflicting with the English standards of freedom to which it is devoted to. He states that, given the intensity of American's commitment to their freedoms and devotion to it, that for Americans to come to an alternative reconciliation that it may not be too appealing and may result in violence. He states that people that are free are easier to control than those people who are persecuted by dictatorship. I do think that Burke was ahead of his time. I believe that due to the political revolutions in today’s date, it proves Burke’s mistrust of grandiose promises and rational faith. He left a legacy in his books that until this day, it’s still a full of rich source for academics and intense…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although some may see it as a disadvantage, I believe that Paine had neither an advantage or disadvantage to being born in the colonies. He spoke from the heart and addressed issues that all colonists could relate to. What made him the most successful was the way he wrote to people, not where he was born. Maybe the perspective he had as an immigrant gave him a slight advantage, but that's it. In Common Sense, the language is common and normal, using strong connotations instead of fancy words.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Considering Burke's stance on the American Revolution, it is quite surprising that he strongly opposed the French Revolution. In his most well known work, Reflections on the revolution in France, Burke argued that the revolution went against the rights of all the people involved and against the conventions that held their society together.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Common Sense was considered by some to be one of the most influential works of the revolutionary time period. The fifty page pamphlet was written by Thomas Paine, an English immigrant, who was a newspaper editor and a non-pacifist Quaker and who, some believed, possessed ideals and values that were radical for the time period. Just one of these ideals was the inhumanity of slavery. He wrote Common Sense to express an idea to those common colonists who were rebelling against or were frustrated with the tyranny of the British government. Paine also wished to reach those who were still on the fence and undecided about rebelling against the government. The main idea that Paine introduced to these colonists, using Common Sense, was the revolution…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first contrasting point between Paine and Burke’s political views is that Paine believed in a system where people can govern themselves and Burke believed that there still needed to be a higher power to tell people what to do. Paine thought that people should be able to tax themselves, therefore saying that people can fend for themselves. He did not think that all the power should rest in a center government. He thought maybe there could be a central government so things did not get out of hand, but it would not have much executive power. His encounters with the indigenous peoples of the Americas made a deep impression. The ability of the Iroquois to live in harmony with nature while achieving a democratic decision making process, helped him refine his thinking on how to organize society. On the other hand, Burke still believed in a monarchy system. He thought that there needed to be a king and a queen to rule over the nation. All…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Paine was an English publicist and a propagandist. He is most known for being one of the utmost radical enlightenment political theorist in the 18th century. Paine’s racial side did not appear until he grew an interest in the stimulating and new political world of revolutionary America. He shamelessly published his broad opinions in some of his influential books at the time, “Common Sense”(1776) and “The Rights of a Man”(1791). In “Common Sense”, Paine talks about America gaining its independence from Britain. He goes into detail about freedom, equivalence and rationality. Boldly, he states his feeling on some of the systems of government. However, in “The Rights of a Man” Paine expressed vital idea’s similar to those in the enlightenment.…

    • 178 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The American Revolution embarked the beginning of the United States of America. A war that lasted eight years, 1775-1783, was able to grant the thirteen colonies the independence they deserved by breaking free of British rule. The war was an effect of the previous French and Indian War, which forced England to tax the American colonist, compelling them to rebel against parliament. From the 1760’s to 1775, many factors lead up to the American Revolution such as the various acts the British Parliament passed to pay the war debt, no representation in parliament, and the American people wanting to gain their independence. “No Taxation without Representation”, a slogan used by the American colonist, was the most important cause of the colonists declaring war for their independence on the British government.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    He was removed to New-Rochelle, and buried on his estate, and this inscription, at his own request, placed on his tombstone. " Thomas Paine, author of Common Sense : died June 8th, 1809, aged 72 years and 5 months." Probably no man ever was more abused by writers than Tho mas Paine. Nothing like an impartial history of his life and writings has been published : he seems, according to his biogra- pners, a rara avis—a man without one good quality ; who lived more than seventy years without ever performing one good action with a good intention. Some occurrences, on which it would be ridiculous in men of sense not to bestow praise, they have, wisely for their plan, passed slightly over. But invariably, where there was room to hang a doubt, they have attributed the worst of mo tives to him. That his publications during the American revolution, were of eminent service to this country, cannot be disputed. And al though now every one is familiar with, and advocates the senti ments contained in them, it should be recollected that they were nearly original, and dangerous to be acknowledged at that…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He believe that man is born to a “sate of equality.” Everyone should have equal rights and freedom. Nobody is in a higher authority than one another. But under the British government, people are born to state of inequality. Society is divided into two; the king and the subjects. He says that “palaces of kings are built on the ruins of the bowers of paradise.” In front of British government, American colonies are their subjects. We have to bow down in front of them which makes us more inferior. Paine says that there are no king in the world. He used reference from the bible stating how Jews wanted a king and how they are considered sinful by the God. According to the Bible, there should only be one ruler; the God. Paine says that man is not supposed to have any other person like the king, who is ruling over them or making decision for them. He cited biblical evidence to explain the fact that the idea of having a king is sinful. He also disagrees to the act of hereditary monarchy. He states that man is born to a state of equality. So no family can inaugurate power forever. Hereditary succession will lead to civil war within the society and the ruler won’t know the interest of the fellow citizen. This will lead to discomfort and distress of the people. Sovereignty of the king and hereditary succession will only led to a bad authority which don’t give any rights to the…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of his best write ups was “Age of Reason”. This story works hand to hand with Thomas Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence, Ben Franklins “An American Guesser”. When everything adds up, it creates that actual foundation creating a world full of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Common sense relates to reasoning but this section from Paine would make this understandable. The most formidable weapon against errors of every kind is reason. I have never used any other, and I trust I never shall. (Paine). Instead of using weapons to solve problems, using reason to deal with situations can help get out of worse situations. Utilizing reason where both parties understanding show great levels of respect, in which helps create stabilization amongst…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Thomas Paine

    • 1756 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Its time to see the reasons why we know Thomas Paine to part of our revolution, but not that well known amoungst the average student. The rise and fall of this man can be an example to all of us if you read and learn from his endeavors. There was a lot of tension building up during the 1760's and 1770's between Great Britain and America and something had to be done about it. Is it worth the risk declaring independence from the most powerful and feared country in the world. Our forefathers were in a confusing situation and had to come up with something to do to solve the problem. In our history classes we always hear about all these founding fathers for what they did founding this country. Of course we all know improvement for todays learning can be increased and with this paper I hope to shed some light on why. After my research and findings there is more to the life of Thomas Paine that isn’t in our current textbooks. Over the last 20 years there has been a resurgence of interest in both Thomas Paine and his life. This new social interest from American citizens is more in tune with his works, and his underdog status is welcome by many. You will see a very interesting story of the rise and fall of a very smart, influential man in a critical time during our American history.…

    • 1756 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays