organ sales

Topics: Human anatomy, Source, Organ Pages: 3 (467 words) Published: June 24, 2014
Leah Beak
Suzy Nachtsheim
Academic Preparation 5 section 2
28 May 2014

Library Tutorial Assignment
Work Cited
Surman, O.S, R. Saidi, R. Purtilo, M. Simmerling, D. Ko, and T.F Burke. “The Market of Human Orangs: A Window into a Poorly Understood Global Business.” Transplantation Proceedings (2008): 491-493. Print. Meckler, Laura. “‘Kidney Shortage Inspires A Radical Idea: Organ Sales.’ As Waiting List Grows, Some Seek to Lift Ban; Exploiting the Poor?” The Wall Street Journal 13 Nov. 2007: 1-5. Print. Cohen, I. G, “Can the Government Ban Organ Sale? Recent Court Challenges and the Future of US Law on Selling Human Organs and Other Tissue.” American Journal of Transplantation (2012): 1983-1987. Print.

An Evaluation of Sources
Surman, O.S, R. Saidi, R. Purtilo, M. Simmerling, D. Ko, and T.F Burke. “The Market of Human Orangs: A Window into a Poorly Understood Global Business.” Transplantation Proceedings (2008): 491-493. Web. 1. This source includes a Works Cited/References.

2. It discussed both sides of the issue.
3. The evidence in this source is sufficient.
4. The author considers opposing arguments.
5. There is a sponsor. The copyright belongs to The American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons. Conclusion: The source is suitable for an academic paper.
Meckler, Laura. “Kidney Shortage Inspires A Radical Idea: Organ Sales.” The Wall Street Journal 13 Nov. 2007: 1-5. Web. 1. This source includes a Works Cited/References.
2. It discussed both sides of the issue.
3. The evidence in this source is sufficient.
4. The author considers opposing arguments.
5. There is a sponsor. The copyright belongs to Elsevier Inc. Conclusion: The source is suitable for an academic paper.

An Annotated Bibliography
Meckler, Laura. “‘Kidney Shortage Inspires A Radical Idea: Organ Sales.’ As Waiting List Grows, Some Seek to Lift Ban; Exploiting the Poor?” The Wall Street Journal 13 Nov. 2007: 1-5. Print....

References: 2. It discussed both sides of the issue.
3. The evidence in this source is sufficient.
4. The author considers opposing arguments.
5. There is a sponsor. The copyright belongs to Elsevier Inc.
Conclusion: The source is suitable for an academic paper.
An Annotated Bibliography
Meckler, Laura. “‘Kidney Shortage Inspires A Radical Idea: Organ Sales.’ As Waiting List Grows, Some Seek to Lift Ban; Exploiting the Poor?” The Wall Street Journal 13 Nov. 2007: 1-5. Print.
In this article, “Kidney Shortage Inspires a Radical Idea: Organ Sales.”, Laura provides possible pros and cons to organ sales by the opinion of two doctors. These days, in organ sales market, many patients need kidney, but there are not so many donators. It means that demand is higher than supply, so almost price of kidney keeps rising. It also explains that organ sales would attract people who were only looking to make money, rather than save a life. Therefore, Arthur Matas claims that kidney sales should be allowed by government. Then anyone, who are in waiting list, can get a kidney according to priority controlled by the government. Otherwise, Dr. Delmonico opposes his opinion. If the organ sales allowed, it could be abused by the poor or in developing countries. In common, they both agree with that the government should encourage the donation and check all donators aptly after surgery. This article is similar with my other sources, which the organ sales allowed, but it focuses on some experts’ thought to support the author’s opinion.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay about Organ sale legality
  • Should Human Organs for Sale? Essay
  • Sale of Human Organ Essay
  • The Ethics of Organ Sales Essay
  • The Sale of Human Organs Essay
  • Essay about Ethcal issues of Human Organ Sales
  • Legalize the Sale of Human Organs Essay
  • Market for Human Organs Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free