Preview

Onward Christian Soldiers Speech Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
589 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Onward Christian Soldiers Speech Analysis
Onward Christian Soldiers

While reading a version of the speech given by Urban II at Clermont in 1095, I wondered why a pope would want to start a war. So I did some research found a few reliable sources on the internet about the same speech and including my textbook. My objective in this paper is to find out why would any Christian be willing to go to war for a piece of property and or did the pope have an ulterior motive? As it turns out, that piece of property I was wondering about is actually the holy land called Jerusalem (the birthplace of their religion) to which Christians have been making the sojourn for centuries. Well, they did until the Seljuk Turks took over Jerusalem banned them from the city. As if that was not bad enough, now those same Turks want to invade and take over Constantinople as well as the rest of the Byzantine Empire. Fearing the worst Emperor Alexius I made a plea to Pope Urban II for help against the Turk’s proposed invasion (Pope Urban II).
…show more content…
While at the Council of Clermont, the pope made this encouraging speech full of exaggerations about the Turks and what they were doing to Jerusalem to all that were in attendance (Ancient History). The pope encouraged all of the Christians with the exception of women, elderly, the feeble, and clergy (unless they had permission) to launch a crusade to take back the holy land in the name of GOD (The Council). In exchange for their service to the Lord our God, Pope Urban II made the following promises to those that chose to go on this endeavor: the absolution of their sins and everlasting life in heaven for their ultimate sacrifice (Ancient History). He asked those at the council to spread his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Even though the Fourth Crusade was misled and committed a lot of mistakes, Pope Innocent III still forgave the army for attacking and pillaging another Christian city. He acknowledged them and preached their accomplishments to secure the rule of Constantinople under the Holy Roman Empire. Although he expressed disapproval of their actions in the beginning, but soon changed his thoughts when they became successful. Using the actions of the Crusaders as an advantage, the Pope justified the Crusade by describing it as a righteous and absolute necessary journey. By restoring the power Constantinople to the Church, the change of their original objective to regain Jerusalem was overlooked. Pope Innocent III also changed his goal to capture the holy…

    • 159 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It was launched on 27 November 1095 by Pope Urban II with the primary goal of responding to an appeal from Byzantine Emperor Alexios I Komnenos, who requested that western volunteers come to his aid and help to repel the invading Seljuq Turks from Anatolia. An additional goal soon became the principal objective—the Christian reconquest of the sacred city of Jerusalem and the Holy Land and the freeing of the Eastern Christians from Islamic…

    • 4794 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alexie’s tone throughout the story impacts the reader’s perception of it. Throughout the text, there are many corrupt incidences told that ends with laughter. For example, there was one situation in which a Maori soldier had lost both of his legs but he tries to humor his condition by joking that his legs had ran away in heaven. Jackson’s grandmother then proceeds to be witty back and tell the soldier that “you have got to get your arms strong... so you can run on your hands” (Alexie 4). Another incident where something serious is met with happiness is when Jackson is saved from the railroad tracks by a white police officer. Once together and Jackson is awake, the officer asks, “how the hell do you Indians laugh so much?” (Alexie 7). Even though…

    • 251 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pope Urban II’s decision to launch the First Crusades altered Medieval Europe politically, socially, and economically. The Pope stressed the religious and economic importance of the Eastern churches and Jerusalem that had both been taken over by Muslim Turks. Previously Vikings and Muslims had been attempting to invade most Western European countries and were troubling them but were soon defeated. All across Europe countries were economically recovering and looking for ways to expand. With the growth of people entering the Catholic Church many people were looking for ways to honor God. Then Pope Urban II announced a Crusade and many countries were eager to assist in his religious mission into the East.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “We want rights, we want rights.” People in america after the war would protest against the government.Such protest is known as shay's rebellion. They were controversial for some people. Although Many people and documents state Shay’s rebellion are reckless rebels, Nevertheless they should be seen and recognized as freedom fighters because, they stood up for others, they aimed to help their country, and kept the gov’t aware of the needs of the country.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In November 1095 Pope Urban II, letter called upon the knights of France to travel to the Holy. Land and liberate the city of Jerusalem and the Christians of the east from Muslim power—considered heathens and enemies of the Church. The response to Urban's appeal was astounding; over 60,000 people set out to recover the Holy Land and secure this reward and, in some cases, take the chance to set up new territories. Four years later, in July 1099, the survivors conquered Jerusalem by killing many people. While most of the knights returned home, the creation of the Crusader States formed a permanent Christian “colony” of sorts. In 1187, however, Saladin defeated them and brought Jerusalem back under Muslim control. The French actually held onto other…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pope Urban was seeing an opening for power in 1095. Pope urban decided to assist the head of the Byzantine Empire by murdering the Turks. While the Turks are Muslim, and the Pope is Christian, the Pope desires the power to stay elsewhere and not in the hands of people who disbelieves in Christianity.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early 11th century, a Turkish ruling clan called the Saljuq Turks established themselves in Anatolia, and in 1071 the Turks defeated the Byzantine army at Manzikert, and took hold over the Byzantine Empire. The peasants were grateful for this change in government, as the Byzantine rulers were resented. Considering the fact that the Saljuq Turks were a branch of the Islamic Abassid Empire, naturally they wouldn’t want a famous Christian church tainting their capital at Constantinople. In the 16th Century…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crusades was a series of wars fought from 1096 to 1291, it was a result of growing tension between the Christians and the Muslims, which led to religious upheaval. The Crusades played a critical part in history as it was the Christian's response to Pope Urban II’s speech to reclaim the Holy Land, Jerusalem, in order to regain economical and autocratic power. However, it was the rising tension between the Christians and Muslims that caused the Crusades to escalate and impact the middle east in the way that it did. On November 27th 1095 Pope Urban II gave one of the most influential speeches of his time, ordering Christian men to join a fight against the muslims making them believe “God wills it!”.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pope Urban

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Secondly, Pope Urban may have called for a Crusade for his own personal gain. Pope Urban would have realized that if he didn’t take action against the Muslims then he would loose power to them, as well as land and security. Therefore, Urban would only become more powerful if he called for a Crusade. This is because if he defeated the Muslims they would have to respect him more, and he would be seen as more powerful in everyone’s eyes as he led a Crusade. Urban probably also realized that Crusades sometimes resulted in more riches and resources, which he would have kept for himself making him richer and higher up in the Feudal system.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    My fellow Americans, we stand today on the brink of war, grieving both for ourselves and for the people in Afghanistan, who have been hurt longer than we have. Ten days ago, the World Trade Center was attacked by a group of extremists based in Afghanistan. Since then, we have shown the strength of our people, who have intercepted the aims of the terrorists to prevent visions of democracy and self-government on which this country stands.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Louis in the tradition of Charlemagne, saw France as the eldest daughter and protector of the Church. The royalty is the defender of the faith and the secular arm of the Church (Le Goff 643). Louis instructed his son to “Be very diligent about protecting all types of people in your domains, especially the people of the Holy Church; prevent anyone from doing any wrong or harm to their persons or their property...You must honor them and protect them so that they can carry out the service of Our Lord in peace” (Le Goff 641). Additionally, at the time of the crusades the Church preached that war against Muslims were not just allowed, but rather recommended. War against Muslims was not a war of conquest but to retake possession of a land that belonged to Christendom (Le Goff 646). As Le Goff puts it, “The Holy Land was the cradle of Christianity, the site of Christ’s worldly existence, and the place where his human body lay from his death on the cross in the afternoon on Holy Friday to his resurrection on Easter morning (646). However, for Louis the more important reason for going to the crusades was to win the souls of the Muslims and convert them to Christianity. Louis after being taken captive in the Seventh Crusade, told his captor the Sultan of Babylon, “I take the Almighty as my witness...I have no concern about ever returning to my Kingdom of France as long as I can win your soul and the souls of other infidels for God, so that they can be glorified” (Le Goff 647). Le Goff cites two other accounts of Louis’ conversion of Muslims. One text Le Goff cites is from biographer Guillaume de Saint-Pathus. In this account, Louis command and order his people not to kill Muslim women and children, but to take them alive and baptize them (Le Goff 649). The other account is from biographer Geoffroy…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pope Urban II was the head of the Roman Catholic church from 1088 to 1099. He launched the Crusade movement, and strengthened the papacy as a political entity. “The push of the crusades came when the Byzantine emperor Alexius I asked the Europeans for help against… Muslims” (306). Urban II responded to this request.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After analyzing primary sources and what other historians say scholars started to come up with a few reasons for the pope’s obsession with gaining Jerusalem again. There are many theories with equally as good evidence backing them up, but one of the most common ideas is Pope Urban II hoped to unify all of Christendom under his jurisdiction to gain more power. Thomas Fuller In his History of the Holy War says, “First to reduce the Grecians into subjection to himself” and then “Ease them” under the “Mother Church of Rome”. To have all the Christians under the papacy’s control would not only make the Pope unbelievably powerful, but it would demonstrate to the European Monarchies that religion can add more order and peace to a country than a government system. Which would then end the investiture controversy with the pope as the winner. Another theory is that Pope Urban II thought that the Crusades would unite Christianity, vanquish the Arabs from “their” holy land, and transform Christianity into a very powerful religion. After the pope spoke at the Council of Clermont Christians started to have more religious enthusiasm and the number of sinners decreased. The Crusades proved to be influencing the Christians to do well and stand together. Pope Urban II had a vision for Christianity which involved a united religion with the papacy as the ultimate and all powerful ruler and the Crusades was the key to that…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crusades occurred in November of 1095 because Pope Urban II ordered a campaign to free Holy Land from the control of the Saracens at the church council at Clermont in France. They were motivated by the desire to help Christians in the East. Although the intentions were positive, the war did not turn out positively. According to Hoffman, the Crusades often lead people to believe that Urban wished to gain power or the power of the Roman Catholic Church. Despite the beliefs of many, the true intentions of Urban are unknown. The movie Kingdom of Heaven depicts the crusades with some similarities and differences. The movie is correct on its display of violence; however, the movie added fictional details for creative purposes.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays