top-rated free essay

Oiler/Winn-Dixie Case

By surraen Jan 14, 2012 598 Words
Peter Oiler/Winn-Dixie
Peter Oiler’s termination from his job by the Winn-Dixie Corporation was an outright and blatant violation of his employee rights. No company or organization is allowed to discriminate against an individual on the basis of sexual orientation and they are most certainly not allowed to discriminate against an employee due to the way he/she decides to dress. This decision would be akin to firing a woman truck driver for wearing a flannel shirt and a pair of jeans while off-duty; while this would be unheard of, the decision to fire Oiler based on his choice of wardrobe while off the job is absurd and completely unfounded. Oiler had a spotless record during his numerous years working for Winn-Dixie; he was basically the perfect employee and to violate an individual’s employee rights and invade his privacy as the company did exhibits a degree of narrow-mindedness and bigotry which is reminiscent of the Dark Ages. It would be easier to understand this decision, if Oiler had been dressing this way on the job due to the fact that numerous organizations must enforce particular dress-codes however; even if this were the case, Oiler would have been given a warning (by most other companies) and offered the chance to “conform” to policies, but the decision to fire him based on his behavior off the job is a major violation of numerous federal and state laws as well as his personal rights. Organizations which feel as though they have the right to punish workers for off-the-job behaviors run the risk of not only being faced with numerous lawsuits and accusations of prejudice and discriminatory practices, they also face losing customers, business partners and stockholders. While there may be a number of individuals who agree with these actions it is more likely that there will be a greater number of individuals who do not agree and decide to cut their ties with organizations who favor such practices. It would be safe to assume that many businesses who were previously a part of the Winn-Dixie Empire (financial institutions, suppliers etc.) made the decision to no longer be affiliated with a company that would practice such unethical and immoral standards of business. The consequences of such actions have the propensity to ultimately destroy both past and future business relationships and to completely obliterate the potential success of any business or organization. Any business organization must have rules and regulations which must be adhered to by all employees. Additionally, businesses must have particular methods in place to discipline individuals who do not follow the rules. The “hot-stove” approach punishes all unacceptable behaviors with identical disciplinary actions whereas the “progressive” approach, reprimands individuals depending on the severity and/or the reoccurrence of actions and behaviors which they have previously been warned against. For instance; an organization which uses the “hot-stove” approach may immediately terminate the employment of a worker for being late; the “progressive” approach would initially be used to warn the employee that if the behavior continues harsher actions will be taken. In the Winn-Dixie/Oiler case the “hot-stove” approach of discipline was used. The company did not warn Oiler, or give him a chance to plead his case etc. instead; they terminated his employment with no questions asked. The downfall to this type of discipline method is that does not differentiate between good employees, such as Oiler, and bad employees; each individual is reprimanded with no consideration of how important they may be to the organization.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Analysis Of The Winn-Dixie Grocery

    ...1. The Winn-Dixie Grocery Store- The Winn-Dixie grocery store is in Naomi, Florida and is where the first scene of the book takes place. When Opal walks in to get her groceries, she sees that it is very chaotic because there is a dog running around. When the manager is still on the floor after getting knocked down by the dog, he says to call the...

    Read More
  • winn dixie

    ...Winn-Dixie The main character is India Opal Buloni but everyone calls her Opal. Opal is ten years old. Opal's dad is a priest. Opal's mom left her and her father when opal was three years old. Opal never knew why her mother left and she was very sad about it. In the beginning of the book, Opal moved to a trailer park in Naomi Florida. Op...

    Read More
  • Winn Dixie

    ...Winn Dixie Kristina Wagner GEB4891 Brief History William Milton Davis and his four sons founded Winn-Dixie in 1925 in Miami, Florida. On February 18, 1952, Winn Dixie became the first Florida-based industrial corporation listed on the NYSE. In 2005, the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in “an effort to address fi...

    Read More
  • WINN DIXIE

    ...Here at Winn Dixie we are always striving to improve our customer relations and experience. What can we do a company to keep customers coming back and how can we go about targeting new customers to come into the store. We currently offer those who sign up with Winn Dixie a great reward program with the Winn Dixie rewards card. The card gives ...

    Read More
  • Because of Winn-Dixie

    ...she wrote this novel to prove that a dog can becom ea humans best friend.This novel showed me that not only a human can be your best friend but also an animal. The story is told by a ten year old named India Opal Buloni. The setting of the novel takes place in Naomi Florida. India Opal moved there with her father she did not know anyone in to...

    Read More
  • Because of Winn-Dixie

    ..., Over this Christmas Vacation I read the book, Because Of Winn-Dixie by Kate DiCamillo. The Genre of this story is Fiction. Some of the main characters in this story are India Opal Buloni, her father The Preacher, there dog Winn-Dixie, Miss. Franny the librarian, and ...

    Read More
  • because of winn dixie

    ...A 10 year old girl named India Opal had just moved to a trailer park in the small town of Naomi, Florida with her itinerant preacher father. While in the Winn-Dixie supermarket, she encountered a scruffy dog that was wreaking havoc in the store. She claimed the dog as hers in order to save him from going to the pound and named him Winn-Dixie. Wi...

    Read More
  • Case

    ...registered at the Ministry of Justice practice (particularly in Vietnams Ministry of Finance). Socially independent auditors have no common interests, no relationship with the audited firm. The work of independent external auditor Check the legality and validity of the documents, accounting data, the execution of policies, accounting practices,...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.