Preview

Obedience Vs Conformity

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1136 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Obedience Vs Conformity
I think the morality of someone is not giving at birth it is something that is learned and directly influence by their surrounding and role models. People will sometimes go against their moral compass because of harsh situation they have been put into. The minds of people are easily manipulated due to the overwhelming power of peer pressure and environment. So when does one lose their identity in a group and become a vessel that follows every order. How does one decide that the obedience in hand is justify and when to go against obedience for the sake of a better or safer outcome?
The group mind is a powerful thing. Is it even able to change people morale completely opposite from what they believe in? We as humankind have always been a pack
…show more content…
So as in today society when we find a group of people that work for us, we want to maintain that connection. People may find themselves modeling others in the group. The group subconsciously will elect a leader and then that leader will be the heart and mind of the group. Question is though where is the line drawn so that we still maintain one image and self-thinking status? When one is in a group it is a need to be liked by the members and expressing feeling that could contradict other members would be suppressed. This is where we could start losing our own individuality. The group will only follow one mindset that has been decided on and deemed right by whatever way. When someone is weak minded, he is …show more content…
Parents demand obedience for kids as a way to teach them respect to authority figures. Everyone though follows authority in his or her own way. Erich Fromen wrote” During most of human history obedience has been identified with virtue and disobedience with sin”.(577) How much obedience though is the right amount given a certain situation? I have witness first hand to both extreme side of the spectrum. When one gives complete obedience he or she turns into a puppet for whoever is pulling the strings. In the military the person are shaped into a way that they fear going against authority even if it’s unlawful. I have seen a man physical assault another just cause someone in a high authority told him too. The reward was not there but there was plenty to risk because he later on was criminally charged. What makes someone just so blindly go into a situation without question? Trust in that person but someone people don’t deserve that trust. Military though is so tightly wrapped around instant obedience that this happens. Not having obedience is in the same boat though. When you don’t listen to higher authority who deserve the respect then it can and mostly likely will get someone killed in a combat zone. So it is needed but people need to find the line of listening and disobeying. Experiment done by a Yale psychologist named Stanley Milgram back up the theory that people will listen even when they

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    PSY 301 Week 3 DQ2

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For this discussion, please review Solomon Asch’s (1958) study of conformity. The results of this study, demonstrate how many of the individual participants conformed to the group despite the fact that the group was clearly wrong, and the individuals were clearly right. In addition, watch the video on the ABC New Primetime: Milgram Experiment Update video. Through this experiment we observe how perceptions of authority directly influence obedience. For example, even when the action ordered by the authority figure caused physical harm, the participants were still obedient. What are some explanations for this type of behavior? Can you think of an example of when you disregarded your own desires or values for the sake of obedience or conformity?…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    It seems as if within a group we act as single entity instead of a group…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Milgram Aims and Context

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Obedience is a direct social influence where a person complies with orders without questioning a person with perceived authority and does a task voluntarily. In the presence of a person of authority, the said person has an option of either complying with orders they are given or to disobey, and as consequences may be unknown if they do not follow what they are asked to do, fear of punishment may influence the person to then respond by submitting to what they have been told to do.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Diffusion of Responsibility: weakening of each group member's obligation to act when responsibility is perceived to be shared with all group members…

    • 2860 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Visible Status - seeing authority (cops in uniforms or teachers having a larger desk in grade school or professors speaking on a stage like set up)…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Group norms can affect the development of a team When individuals are in groups there are forces at work that shape their behavior. All individuals have their own separate traits, way of thinking and doing tasks, however when they are contributing together as a team they enviably start to exhibit different behaviors which are based on the group norms. For example a team member may not be a brave outspoken individual on their own but when in a group may exhibit more aggressive outspoken tones feeling they are stronger united so to speak as they are trying to fit in as individuals we become influence by others whether this is consciously or subconsciously done this can cause conflict within a team environment. In most team dynamics especially…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Obedience shines a light on the negative aspects of humanity, whereas disobedience shines a light on the positive. It has been revealed how people will deny their own senses in order to remain indifferent from the majority (Asch). It was also exposed that some people are okay with possibly killing another human being as long as the victim is not considered their responsibility (Milgram). Both of these examples were a response of the individuals who chose to conform and obey rather than know the difference of what is morally right and wrong. Yet in the midst of it all areas of disobedience allows for different groups of people to come together and fight to evoke incredible change. However, disobedience is much more expensive than obedience. People willing to disobey must first find factors that will lead them to want to disobey and then pay the consequences after. On the other hand, suffering the consequences is a small price to pay compared to living with years of injustice. The factors that were discovered to aid in a person’s willingness to disobey, deception, education, and responsibility, all stimulate a certain degree of reflection. In contrast, members subject to obedience follow blindly with no reflection on the authority’s demands. This evidence directly relates to the findings by both Asch and Milgram. In their cases, the subjects were stripped of their individuality, which resulted in their conformity.…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Understanding these concepts is essential to humankind based on the fact that if we could control these factors we could make decisions based solely on what is right and wrong, and not who tells a subject what to do. Obedience to authority has a vast variety of pros and cons. Whether it be from the psychological stress that the people being ordered are put under, or a structured society that runs smooth because of the people willing to follow any commands. Obedience to authority has been a part of every society since the beginning of time, whether it continues in our future depends on each individual and how they view the…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Perils Of Obedience

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Philip Zimbardo and Stanley Milgram conducted controversial experiments that had to deal with obedience. Zimbardo conducted an experiment in a mock prison that showed the roles of the guards and prisoners. Milgram conducted an experiment that tested how much pain a teacher would inflict on someone else at the command of an experimenter. The experiments that they conducted have been called wrong and unethical. Although the experiments vary from each other, they both changed the way the world looks at obedience and Authority.…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    1) Do you think conformity with norms in general is a good or bad thing? Why? Conformity can come in useful when we are in unfamiliar surroundings or activities. Everyone has done it in some way or another throughout their life and it really can come in handy with unknown situations. I would say it can be good and bad, if there is a social norm that is meant to keep order and peace, then conforming to this standard can be considered good.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a child growing up, everyone was told “respect your elders” or “listen and obey”. As children grow into teenagers, they start pushing the boundaries to see who they really need to obey. Throughout adulthood, though people have fewer and fewer authority figures as the years go by, everyone must obey someone. Though we all have someone to obey, when does the respectful obedience cross the line into dangerous territory? Obedience becomes dangerous when it becomes physically or mentally harmful to one’s self or society.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Obedience with Authority

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages

    According to the article “Opinions and Social Pressure”, Solomon Asch writes about how the affects of group pressure can alter a person’s decision. During the investigation, Asch describes how everyone in the group agrees with the answer that they have chosen except for one in which the author calls him the “dissenter (Asch 656)”. Solomon Asch stated that the person who disagreed to the answer quickly became “more and more worried and hesitant as the disagreement continues in succeeding trials (Asch 656).” The dissenter is placed a position where he has to choose the correct answer as a minority of one and this eventually clouded his judgment, which caused him to choose many answers incorrectly. The assumption of that the author has made is that when a person is standing alone without succumbing to the majority tends to have their minds alter due to the social pressure.…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Humans are often hindered by society's expectations to the point where reaching our creative potential is nearly impossible. Conforming to society does not prove anything about character, and in Emersons words “Your conformity explains nothing. Act singly, and what you have already done singly will justify you now” (Emerson). Conforming to a group leaves people mimicking one another. Acting singly will take a person farther in society than just going along with the crowd. When big figures are present a person's inner voice stops contributing because others are doing the talking. Questioning the influential and powerful people may cause a disturbance in the status quo, but elevating ones voice to a higher level stands out and is necessary…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Obedience, as well as disobedience, has been ingrained in our culture since the beginning of time, so it is no surprise that so many people obeyed Hitler and killed millions of Jewish people. In the Christian religion disobedience is viewed as bad and obedience as good. In the story of Adam and Eve, they disobeyed God by eating from the tree of knowledge and were exiled from Eden. In the story of Noah, he obeyed God and Noah and his family were rewarded and lived through the great flood. These same stories are found in many cultures and religions throughout history. After hearing these stories your entire life, how can one be expected to disobey an authority without, at least, the subconscious fear of negative consequences? Our natural fear of disobeying authority can turn normal, mentally stable, everyday people into genocidal killers.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout history people have followed directives given by other people, such as ‘do this’, ‘follow these rules’, ‘listen to me’, and ‘do as I say’. In fact, governments have rules, laws and norms of their society so that people will obey the laws and behave in a civilized manner. How is it then that individual’s will go against and contest their own values and morals and conform to the directives given by an authority figure, even to the degree of causing harm and/or death to an individual? Stanley Milgram devoted the majority of his latter research on investigating this question (Burger, 2009, Cherry, 2013, McLeod, 2007; Milgram, 1974). The purpose of this paper is to briefly summarize Milgram’s seminal research on obedience to authority and describe Milgram’s methodology, research and interpretations of his findings. Additionally this paper will discuss the current research available regarding conformity to authority, specifically focusing on whether or not…

    • 2044 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays