No Place to Hide

‘No place to hide’? The realities of leadership in UK supermarkets
SKOPE Research Paper No. 91 May 2010
*

Irena Grugulis, **Ödül Bozkurt and ***Jeremy Clegg

*

Bradford University School of Management, **Lancaster University Management School, ***Leeds University Business School

Editor’s Foreword SKOPE Publications This series publishes the work of the members and associates of SKOPE. A formal editorial process ensures that standards of quality and objectivity are maintained.

Orders for publications should be addressed to the SKOPE Secretary, School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University, Glamorgan Building, King Edward VII Avenue, Cardiff CF10 3WT Research papers can be downloaded from the website: www.skope.ox.ac.uk

ISSN 1466-1535

Abstract This article explores the realities of managerial work in two major British supermarket chains. While the prescriptive literature welcomes the displacement of bureaucratic management by rote with leadership, empirical accounts of what managers actually do underscore how the purported tenets of leadership tend to disappear upon closer inspection, even at the discursive level. This study observes and discusses the discrepancy between the rhetoric of leadership articulated by executives at the corporate head offices and the actual roles and responsibilities of managers in stores. Work was tightly controlled and managers had little real freedom. We draw on empirical evidence to argue both that while leadership in practice secured only trivial freedoms such freedoms were highly valued and that academic analysis should follow these managers in their ability to distinguish between rhetorical flourishes and reallife job design. Leadership in practice is mundane and local.

Keywords: leadership, leaders, managers, control, deskilling, supermarkets, retail

Introduction This article explores the realities of managerial work in two major British supermarkets chains. While the prescriptive literature

References: Alimo-Metcalfe, B. and J. Alban-Metcalfe (2005) ‘Leadership: time for a new direction?’ Leadership, 1, 51 - 71. Alvesson, M. and S. Sveningsson (2003a) ‘The great disappearance act: difficulties in doing leadership.’ Leadership Quarterly, 14, 359 - 81. Alvesson, M. and S. Sveningsson (2003b) ‘Managers doing leadership: the extra ordinarization of the mundane.’ Human Relations, 56, 1435 - 59. Arrowsmith, J. and K. Sisson (1999) ‘Pay and working time: towards organisationbased systems?’ British Journal of Industrial Relations, 37, 51 - 75. Baron, S., K. Harris, D. Leaver and B. Oldfield (2001) ‘Beyond convenience: the future for independent food and grocery retailers in the UK.’ The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research, 11, 395 - 414. Booth, S. and K. Hamer (2006) ‘Labour turnover in the retail industry: predicting the role of individual, organisational and environmental factors.’ International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 35, 289 - 307. Broadbridge, A. (2002) ‘Rationalising retail employment: a view from the outside looking in.’ International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 30, 536 - 43. 17 Burt, S. and L. Sparks (2003) Competitive Analysis of the Retail Sector in the UK. London: Department of Trade and Industry. Carlson, S. (1951) Executive Behaviour. Stockholm: Strombergs. Collinson, D. (2005) ‘Dialectics of leadership.’ Human Relations, 58, 1419 - 42. Dalton, M. (1966) Men who Manage. New York and London: Wiley. Delbridge, R. and J. Lowe (1997) ‘Manufacturing control: supervisory systems on the “new” shopfloor.’ Sociology, 31, 409 - 26. Edwards, P. and M. Collinson (2002) ‘Empowerment and managerial labour strategies: pragmatism regained.’ Work and Occupations, 29, 272-99. Etzioni, A. (1961) A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organisations. New York: Free Press. Felstead, A., A. Fuller, N. Jewson and L. Unwin (2009) Improving Working as Learning. London: Routledge. Freathy, P. and L. Sparks. (2000) ‘The organisation of working time in large UK food retail firms.’ In Baret, C., S. Lehndorff and L. Sparks (editors) Flexible Working Time in Food Retailing: a Comparison Between France, Germany the UK and Japan. London and New York: Routledge. Gadrey, J. (2000) ‘Working time configurations: theory, methods and assumptions for an international comparison.’ In Baret, C., S. Lehndorff and L. Sparks (editors) Flexible Working Time in Food Retailing: a Comparison Between France, Germany the UK and Japan. London and New York: Routledge. Gamble, J. (2006) ‘Multinational retailers in China: proliferating “McJobs” or developing skills?’ Journal of Management Studies, 43, 1463 - 90. Hales, C. (2002) ‘“Bureaucracy-lite” and continuities in managerial work.’ British Journal of Management, 13, 51-66. Hales, C. (2005) ‘Rooted in supervision, branching into management: continuity and change in the role of first-line manager.’ Journal of Management Studies, 42, 471-506. Hart, C., G. Stachow, B. Grazyna, A. Farrell and G. Reed (2006) ‘Employer perceptions of skills gaps in retail: issues and implications for UK retailers.’ International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 35, 271 - 88. Jackson, B. and K. Parry (2008) A Very Short, Fairly Interesting and Reasonably Cheap Book about Studying Leadership London: Sage. Kelly, S. (2008) ‘Leadership: a categorical mistake?’ Human Relations, 61, 763 - 82. Kirsch, J., M. Klein, S. Lehndorff and D. Voss-Dahm (2000) ‘The organisation of working time in large German food retail firms’. In Baret, C., S. Lehndorff, L. Sparks (editors) Flexible Working Time in Food Retailing: a Comparison Between France, Germany the UK and Japan. London and New York: Routledge. Korczynski, M. (2001) ‘The contradictions of service work: call centre as customeroriented bureaucracy.’ In Sturdy, A., I. Grugulis and H. Willmott, (editors) Customer Service: Empowerment and Entrapment. Basingstoke: Palgrave. 18 Korczynski, M. (2002) Human Resource Management in Service Work. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Mason, G., K. Mayhew and M. Osborne (2008) ‘Low paid work in the United Kingdom: an overview.’ In Lloyd, C., G. Mason and K. Mayhew (editors) LowWage Work in the United Kingdom. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Mason, G. and M. Osborne (2008) ‘Business strategies, work organisation and low pay in United Kingdom retailing.’ In Lloyd, C., G. Mason and K. Mayhew (editors) Low-Wage Work in the United Kingdom. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. McGauran, A-M. (2001) ‘Masculine, feminine or neutral? In-company equal opportunities policies in Irish and French MNC retailing.’ International Journal of Human Resource Management, 12, 754-71. McGauran, A-M. (2000) ‘Vive la différence: the gendering of occupational structures in a case study of Irish and French retailing.’ Women’s Studies International Forum, 23, 613-27. Meindl, J., S. Ehrlich and J. Dukerich (1985) ‘The romance of leadership.’ Administrative Science Quarterly, 30, 78 - 102. Moss-Kanter, R. (1977) Men and Women of the Corporation. New York: Basic Books. Nickson, D., C. Warhurst, A. Witz and A-M. Cullen (2001) ‘The importance of being aesthetic: work, employment and service organisation.’ In Sturdy, A., I. Grugulis and H. Willmott (editors) Customer Service: Empowerment and Entrapment. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Power, M. (1997) The Audit Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Protherough, R. and J. Pick (2002) Managing Britannia. Exeter: Imprint Academic. Pye, D. (1968) The Nature and Art of Workmanship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rainbird, H. and A. Munro (2003) ‘Workplace learning and the employment relationship in the public sector.’ Human Resource Management Journal, 13, 30-44. Robinson, S.K. and R. Kerr (2009) ‘The symbolic violence of leadership: a critical hermeneutic study of leadership and succession in a British organisation in the post-Soviet context.’ Human Relations, 62, 875 - 903. Rosenthal, P., S. Hill and R. Peccei (1997) ‘Checking out service: evaluating excellence, HRM and TQM in retailing.’ Work, Employment and Society, 11, 481-503. Smith, V. (1990) Managing in the Corporate Interest: Control and Resistance in an American Bank. Berkley, Los Angeles and Oxford: University of California Press. Storey, J. (2004a) ‘Changing theories of leadership and leadership development.’ In Storey, J. (editor) Leadership in Organizations: Current Issues and Future Trends. London: Routledge. 19 Storey, J. (2004b) ‘Signs of change: “damned rascals” and beyond.’ In Storey, J. (editor) Leadership in Organizations: Current Issues and Key Trends. London: Routledge. Taylor, P. and P. Bain (1999) ‘An assembly line in the head: work and employee relations in the call centre.’ Industrial Relations Journal, 30, 101-17. Tengblad, S. (2004) ‘Expectations of alignment: examining the link between financial markets and managerial work.’ Organization Studies 25, 583-606. Watson, T. (1994) In Search of Management. London: Routledge. Zaleznik, A. (1992) ‘Managers and leaders: are they different?’ Harvard Business Review 126 - 35. 20