 # Nike Case

Good Essays
836 Words Grammar Plagiarism  Writing  Score Nike Case Any company’s assets are either financed by its debt or by its equity. The Weighted Average Cost of Capital is the average costs of these sources of financing, each of which is weighted by its respective use in the given situation. By taking the weighted average, we can see how much interest the company has to pay for every dollar it finances. Basically, the WACC is the minimum required return that the company must earn to satisfy its creditors, owners, and other providers of capital, or they will invest in another company that has higher returns. In this case, I will first address the issues with Cohen’s calculation, and then analyze an new WACC to decide whether we should invest in Nike Inc.
Many issues should be addressed regarding Joanna Cohen’s WACC calculation. First, to calculate the debt cost of capital, Cohen divided the total interest expense by the company’s average debt balance. This is an issue because she did not take into account the current yield on publicly traded Nike debt. Another issue that should be addressed is the calculation of the equity cost of capital. Using CAPM, Cohen took a 20 year Treasury bond as her risk free, the average Beta for the last 6 years, and a geometric mean for market premium. Also, Cohen calculated the book value of equity and debt instead of using market values.
In my analysis, I will argue about choosing different numbers than Cohen to get a more accurate WACC. For the calculation of debt cost of capital, I used the current yield on publicly traded Nike debt to get a market value for the debt and not the book. Having the 6.75% coupon rate paid semiannually, 20 years to maturity, and the current price of \$95.60, the debt cost of capital would be estimated at 7.17%. for the calculation of the equity cost of capital, I used CAPM. The three components are the risk free premium, the Beta value, and the market risk premium. I chose a 3-month yield on Treasury bills as the risk free premium since it is the safest and

## You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

• Better Essays

Cost of Debt can be calculated with the current yield publicly traded in the market, because we are projecting the future cash flows. Joanna calculated this by using historical data. However cost of debt should be calculated using current YTM of debt.…

• 801 Words
• 4 Pages
Better Essays
• Powerful Essays

The purpose of this project is to find the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) for Home Depot. Investopedia.com reveals that the WACC is “a calculation of a firm's cost of capital in which each category of capital is proportionately weighted. All capital sources - common stock, preferred stock, bonds and any other long-term debt - are included in a WACC calculation. All else equal, the WACC of a firm increases as the beta and rate of return on equity increases, as an increase in WACC notes a decrease in valuation and a higher risk” (Investopedia.com). We will attempt to provide information regarding the following: 1. Description of how we achieved the WACC. 2. Calculations used to obtain WACC. 3. Explanation of the results. 4. Sources of our data. 5. Discussion of confidence level in our answer, as well as any limiting assumptions if applicable.…

• 1079 Words
• 4 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Powerful Essays

Cohen calculated a weighted average cost of capital (WACC) of 8.3 percent by using the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) for Nike Inc. I do not agree with her figure, and the reasons to that are as follows:…

• 1534 Words
• 7 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Powerful Essays

In Nike’s case, when Joanna Cohen calculated the WACC of Nike, she made several mistakes and led to a wrong estimate of the cost of capital. The first mistake comes to the book value of equity used in calculating WD. Nike became a publicly traded company since December 2, 1980, the share price has changed significantly during 20-year’s time. So, the market value of equity should be used instead of book value. Then, Cohen calculates the cost of debt by taking total interest expense for the year 2001 and dividing it by the company's average debt balance. This is an approximation for the true cost of the debt, but is too inaccurate and may not reflect Nike’s current or future cost of debt. Thirdly, Cohen obtained the corporate tax rate 38% which is used to calculate the adjusted cost of debt by adding state taxes of 3% to the U.S. statutory tax rate 35%. In WACC calculation, marginal tax rate should be used as a corporate tax rate for the future estimate. Practically, if a company has a lower average effective tax rate which are generated from the average of past years actual taxes paid divided by earnings before taxes than the marginal tax rate, this will be more…

• 1696 Words
• 6 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Powerful Essays

Based on her calculations, Joanna Cohen estimated that Nike’s cost of capital was approximately 8.4%. Ms. Cohen used a single Weighted Average Cost of Capital to calculate the firm’s cost of capital, and we agree that only a single cost of capital needs to be used due to the similarities between more than 95% of their revenues. However we believe that the cost of capital calculation is inaccurate based on some of the information that Cohen gives while explaining the figures used in the WACC formula.…

• 1142 Words
• 5 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

To find Nike’s cost of debt, we used three different methods: the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) (Exhibit 7), the Dividend Discount Model (DDM) (Exhibit 5), and the Earnings Capitalization Model (ECM) (Exhibit 8). We decided that the CAPM gave us the most accurate estimate of Nike’s cost of debt, and we used that in arriving at our before-tax cost of debt of 7.173% and our final after-tax cost of debt of 4.447% (Exhibit 6). To find our WACC, we used the market value of equity and debt to determine our weights of equity and debt. Our weight of equity is 89.947% and our weight of debt is 10.053%. Using the above numbers, we calculated a WACC of 7.338% (Exhibit 9).…

• 393 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Good Essays

The valuation of Abercrombie & Fitch Co. is based discounting future cash flows and economic profit, for that the weighted average cost of capital is needed. The WACC is the opportunity cost when investing in Abercrombie & Fitch Co. opposed to other investments with a similar risk. Investors want their return to excess the WACC before it can be considered a good investment; since people in general are risk averse, they want compensation for taking on risk.…

• 3410 Words
• 14 Pages
Good Essays
• Better Essays

Through the use of past data, the average balance of debt, the 4.3% before-tax cost of debt does not accurately reflect Nike’s current or future cost of debt, and therefore a new WACC should be calculated to discount future cash flows.…

• 866 Words
• 3 Pages
Better Essays
• Good Essays

Joanna began her calculation of Nike’s WACC by finding the necessary weights of debt and equity to be used. To begin, Joanna found Nike’s debt by combining the book values of current long-term debt, notes payable, and long-term debt, which were all found on Nike’s balance sheet. The values were \$5.4 million, \$855.3 million, and \$435.9 million respectively. This calculation gave Nike a total debt of \$1,296.9 million. To find Nike’s equity, Joanna used the book value of total shareholders’ equity which was also found on the balance sheet. The value was \$3,494.5 million. Therefore, Joanna found Nike’s debt plus equity to be \$4,791.4 million. Dividing the values for debt and equity each by \$4,791.4 million gave Joanna the weights to be used in the WACC formula. Debt was weighted as 27% and equity as 73%.…

• 1321 Words
• 6 Pages
Good Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

There are several different methods that can be used to find the WACC and use it to decide whether a stock will be a good buy or not. The Earning’s Capitalization Model is not appropriate in this case because it does not work well for growing companies, as Nike is trying to do, and the Dividend Discount Model has several subjective inputs making it inferior to the CAPM method of determining WACC. Using this method Nike’s WACC is found to be 9.8%. Using this Nike is found to have very good returns on capital, with a reasonable amount of debt, at not too high of a cost. This WACC figure is higher than the one that Ford used, but it still shows us that the stock is undervalued, but by only about \$15. This leads to a recommendation that Ford’s mutual fund should add Nike to its portfolio, and from the financial and debt ratios calculated, we get information that says Nike should continue to grow to higher stock prices after reaching the price it was valued at…

• 276 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Good Essays

NorthPoint a mutual-fund-management firm is contemplating adding Nike Inc. stocks to its Large-Cap Fund. Kimi Ford a portfolio manager for NorthPoint has developed a discounted-cash-flow forecast to help make the decision. Kimi comes to the conclusion that Nike is overvalued at its current price of \$42.09 with a 12 percent cost of capital that she estimated. To determine if her estimation is correct about whether Nike was undervalued or overvalued Kimi has asked her assistant Joanna Cohen to estimate a cost of capital for Nike. Kimi has determined that if Nike’s cost of capital is under 11.2 percent Nike would be undervalued at its current price of \$42.09. Joanna breaks her estimation down into four different segments when calculating the WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital); Single Cost of Multiple Cost, Cost of Debt, Cost of Equity, and Weights of Capital.…

• 1210 Words
• 5 Pages
Good Essays
• Better Essays

What is the WACC and why is it important to estimate a firm’s cost of capital? Do you agree with Joanna Cohen’s WACC calculation? Why or why not?…

• 1762 Words
• 8 Pages
Better Essays
• Powerful Essays

The assignment is to estimate the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for an actual corporation as of the current time. Actual managers would need to know their company’s WACC as a starting datum to estimate the discount rate to use in the net present value analysis of new projects or of termination decisions. The student will later need to know the technique for application in some case study solutions.…

• 4786 Words
• 20 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

“Do you have the information I need to describe capital structure and to calculate the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)?” you ask.…

• 383 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Better Essays

b) Calculating the Cost of Capital WACC: Cohen is wrong using the book values for debt and equity weights; the Market values are the ones that should be used when calculating weights. The reason for using the Market value is that it is how much it will cost the firm to raise capital today. That cost is approximated by the market value of capital, not by the book value of capital. For market value of equity, \$42.09x271.5 shares = 11,427.4 Since we are not given the market value of debt, we use the book value of debt, 1,296.6 Therefore, the market value weight for equity is 11,427.4/(11,427.3+1,296.6) = 89.8%; the weight for debt is 10.2%.…

• 556 Words
• 3 Pages
Better Essays