Preview

Nicklinson Right To Die Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
932 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nicklinson Right To Die Analysis
Throughout Jerome Taylor’s article the reader is introduced to Tony Nicklinson, a man suffering from a disease called ‘locked in syndrome’ which means he is ‘paralysed from the neck down’. Taylor explains Nicklinson’s argument for his ‘right to die’. Initially Nicklinson ‘once led an active life’ until he suffered from a stroke six years ago in the Athens and become ‘trapped in his own body’. This caused many upsets which lead to a downfall emotionally and physically as he was left disabled and unable to provide and care for himself.
Due to these tragic events Nicklinson’s fight for the ‘right to die’ is argued by the high court. Although, it may be his wish; but the court see his it as he is using euthanasia is taking advantage of his vulnerability. …show more content…
As Nicklinson has stated that id he had the opportunity and if he knew that he was going to be a victim of ‘locked in syndrome’ then he would have let ‘nature take its course’ and let himself die. The case is the ‘latest right to die’ plea that has come before the courts to determine whether Euthanasia should be legal in certain circumstances. The judge, Justice William Charles states that ‘he was inviting the court to cross the Rubicon’. In contrast to this if euthanasia was legal then it could be more fanatically beneficial for families that can hardly afford the pricey treatment. During Taylor’s article it is clear that keeping Nicklinson alive is causing him to be ‘completely dependent on others’; which is costing a lot of money and time. Fundamentally if the patient is terminally ill and does not want to be alive for any longer, then they should take in to consideration the money and time it costs to keep alive and how it can help many others in this situation.
Overall, if Euthanasia were to become legal then it could cause many issues such as the approach society and parliament would have to take. It could cause serious exploitation to vulnerable patients, and have very ‘harrowing’ physiological effects. I personally, think that Euthanasia should only be legalised for terminally ill patients that are in despair, so people like Nicklinson can get their one and only wish in life. In Taylor’s article it is clear that he is the victim, It means that the public can now come together and maybe help him get his
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Assisted suicide for terminally ill pat
    • 953 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Assisted suicide for terminally ill pat

    1. Being able to choose when to die is a human right. This exact point is presented in the article “Perhaps I’ll say goodbye on Twitter”. According to Tony Nicklson, who is a 58 year old, patient who has been able to move only his eyelids since suffering a stroke in 2005, it is the most fundamental human right. He told the journalist and former nurse Nina Lakhani, that: “he was simply seeking the same right to die that able-bodied people were able to exercise independently”. However, if he is provided this right, it would be a change of law as Alison Pearson claims, in the article “Do any of us, however ill, have the right to die?” She believes in the exact opposite. She is oppose assisted suicide, and her article is kind of a response to the argumentations of Tony Nicklinson. She starts out her article by explaining how only a complete idiot would put cancer on their top of their wishlist: “Other than that you would have to be seriously warped, mad even, to choose a brutal, life-threatening illness. Yet Tony Nicklinson says he wants to get cancer. Cancer is Tony’s best hope”. If Tony cannot be offered the opportunity to commit assisted suicide, he would rather die by the hand of cancer, because Tony Nicklinson’s only desire is to leave this world of suffering. Alison Pearson is contradicting Tony Nicklinson by saying that it is wrong to give doctors the right to kill patients, and on the other hand, she devises other alternatives to die. For example she brings up the fact, that you could just refuse medical treatment, as it is legal, and she further explains that: “I certainly plan to have one of those handy when I’m old and at the mercy of our marvellous “care” system”, explaining that she might use this method herself without having to change the law.…

    • 953 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Should Euthanasia Be Legalized in the Uk? Essay Example
    • 5500 Words
    • 22 Pages

    Should Euthanasia Be Legalized in the Uk? Essay Example

    The word Euthanasia derives from the Greek words Eu and Thanatos which means easy or good death. Euthanasia is is defined in the Oxford Dictionary as the painless killing of a patient suffering from an incurable and painful disease or in an irreversible coma[1]. Euthanasia exists in various forms, each one specific in its criteria. Firstly there is active and passive euthanasia. Active euthanasia involves the use of direct action in order to end the patient’s life whilst passive euthanasia is the withholding of medical aid in order to allow the patient to die naturally such as not performing life-extending surgery or turning off a life support system. The next distinction is between Voluntary and Involuntary euthanasia. Voluntary euthanasia involves the patient’s termination at their own request whilst involuntary euthanasia occurs when the patient is unable to ably make a decision and therefore a suitable person makes the decision for them. Indirect euthanasia involves treating the patients pain but with the side effect of death, the primary intention is often used to justify the outcome. This is often referred to as the doctrine of double effect and in reality is not considered euthanasia given that the real purpose of the treatment is pain relief and death is merely seen as the side-affect. Finally there is assisted suicide which involves a patient incapable of committing suicide themselves asks for assistance in doing so. Euthanasia is a controversial topic that contradicts the age old moral injunction “thou shalt not kill”[2]. But similarly denying patient’s of this choice is defying medical practice cornerstones such as the patient’s autonomy and promoting their best interests. Different countries hold varying stances on Euthanasia but it is currently illegal in the UK. Most recently the case of Tony Nicklinson, a man totally paralysed by locked-in syndrome requesting euthanasia, has come to the forefront of the debate. Given the right to take his case to…

    • 5500 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    “With reference to the decisions of the Courts and Parliament discuss whether the government should change the law on assisted suicide and allow mercy killings in some circumstances.”
    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “With reference to the decisions of the Courts and Parliament discuss whether the government should change the law on assisted suicide and allow mercy killings in some circumstances.”

    “With reference to the decisions of the Courts and Parliament discuss whether the government should change the law on assisted suicide and allow mercy killings in some circumstances.”…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Terri Schiavo Case
    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Terri Schiavo Case

    Recent cases have drawn attention to the issue of individual autonomy, and what is sometimes referred to as ‘the right to die’. Adult patients who are mentally competent have the right to refuse medical treatment even when that refusal can lead to worsening ill health and even death. This refusal of treatment may only be ignored when statutory law provides for treatment without consent, or a judge makes an order that overrides the patient’s consent. While this is largely accepted when patients are physically and mentally competent, it becomes a complex issue when a person is mentally competent, but due to physical incapacity are in care because they are unable to care for themselves. A person may be mentally competent but due to being a quadriplegic…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Whose Life Is It Anyway Brian Clark
    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Whose Life Is It Anyway Brian Clark

    In 2015, 57-year-old Simon Binner was diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease and was given 6 months to two years to live. Initially, he accepted this and wanted to make the most of his time with his wife and family. However, his condition deteriorated immensely within the first few weeks, and resulted in Simon losing the use of his voice. Faced with the prospect of a rapid decline physically, Simon decided to tell his family that he was considering ending his life at a suicide clinic in Switzerland. Similar to Ken’s realisation that he was not living but was existing, Simon came to a similar conclusion and also had to fight for what the best was for him. Enduring similar moral, emotional and legal obstacles on his journey, Simon was granted the right to assisted suicide in a clinic in Switzerland where he took his own life with a lethal l injection. He died at peace, with integrity and with dignity. Similar to Ken, Simon’s right to decide his path was restored by the law and I am so pleased that the law is able to bring reason and justice to those truly…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Case Study Of Locked In Syndrome By Tony Nicklinson
    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Case Study Of Locked In Syndrome By Tony Nicklinson

    According Tony Nicklinson, 58, suffering from Locked-In Syndrome, describes his case, “I can’t tell you how significant it would be in my life, or how much peace of mind I would have, just knowing that I can determine my own life instead of the state telling me what to do - staying alive regardless of my wishes or how much suffering I have to tolerate until I die of natural causes.” (Miller, 2012) Mr. Nicklinson had experienced a massive stroke that left him paralyzed from the neck down. From the accident, Nicklinson had lost all hope in the world and feels that the only way he will truly feel at peace with his own self is the act of ending his own life. Since the very beginning, Mrs. Nicklinson and their two daughters have supported his decision…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide
    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

    There are two factors that have contributed to euthanasia’s distinction with how the world is today. They are both an increasing sense of self-determinism and medical revolution that have the potential of prolonging human life (Michigan, 2006). People think that just because there are things like hospice and medication that euthanasia shouldn’t even be an option. But what people don’t know is that even with the best medication and the patient being made completely comfortable, it is not the pain that causes people to ask for what people call a “hastened death”, but the humiliation and suffering that accompanies most terminal disorders.…

    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Analysis
    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Analysis

    Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) and euthanasia is a widely debated and controversial topic in our society. It is believed that the principle of PAS and euthanasia portrays, “merciful acts that deliver terminally ill patients from painful and protracted death” (page 477, column 2). In the paper, “Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Tragic View,” John D. Arras discusses the subject and states that while he agrees with patients making decisions, implementing laws supporting PAS and euthanasia is a huge threat to our social order. However, John D. Arras also concludes that he does not disapprove with the possibility of having a legislative policy in favor of PAS/euthanasia, only if there is “sufficient evidence of reliability of various safeguards” (page 477, column 2).…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Mandatory Euthanasia In Australia
    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mandatory Euthanasia In Australia

    The first person to be legally voluntarily euthanised in Australia was Bob Dent in the Northern Territory, in the year of 1996. This controversial issue has raised many dilemmas throughout society, and so far it seems there is no clear solution. The implications of euthanasia will be discussed herein. Defining the issue and exploring both sides of the controversy has proven to be a difficult task.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide
    • 2793 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide

    The argument that has sent the world into a tailspin is whether or not people suffering from terminal or excruciatingly painful illness have the right to take their own lives by way of physician-assisted suicide. Proponents contend that what one does with one 's life is of no consequence to anyone else -- that it is humane to allow someone to be relieved of constant – if not unbearable – discomfort. On the other hand, critics claim that the act of euthanasia is nothing more than a fabricated form of murder. Indeed, both sides have pertinent points when it comes to understanding and assessing the conflict, but euthanasia supporters have a significantly stronger argument when considering the bigger picture. Clearly, physician-assisted suicide is not only the right thing to do for someone seeking such a decision, but it is ethical and humane for a physician to abide by the patient 's wish.…

    • 2793 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Euthanasia In Australia
    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Euthanasia In Australia

    Euthanasia is often a controversial topic around all areas of the world. The idea of ‘assisted suicide’ has sparked debates and many countries, including Australia, are still hesitant or reluctant in allowing legislation for legalising Euthanasia to pass. This inquiry will aim to provide sufficient evidence as to why and how Euthanasia should become legalised while also evaluating and examining other cases and laws in other states regarding this topic.…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Euthanasia Ethical Dilemma
    • 2102 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Euthanasia Ethical Dilemma

    Euthanasia is a social issue in today’s world because not only does it affect the lives of those who are terminally ill and/or comatose, and the physicians who have been entrusted with their care, but it also affects the patient’s ability to have control over their own life, whether they are aware of this decision or not, which is one of the reasons why euthanasia has become such a controversial issue around the globe. Caddell and Newton (1995) define euthanasia as “any treatment initiated by a physician with the intent of hastening the death of another human being who is terminally ill and in severe pain or distress with the motive of relieving that person from great suffering” (p. 1,672). Even though the concept of great…

    • 2102 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Contemporary Ethical Issues In Health Care Analysis
    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Contemporary Ethical Issues In Health Care Analysis

    This framework would also take into account what legal definitions need to be considered in terms of unwanted treatment versus the decision of suicide, it will identify what the core values involving the patient are, who are the other relevant people involved and also the duty of care that affects the hospital staff, whilst still protecting the individual’s autonomy (Euthanasia law is no cure-all for Dutch doctors, 2009). What is interesting to note, is that the Catholic perspective is that life should not be preserved at all costs if it does not take into account the dignity of the individual and their decision on whether they wish to take part with treatment and whether they have been given the opportunity to think and discuss if the means of treatment is morally disproportionate, does not offer any reasonable therapeutic benefit, is overly burdensome or, in some circumstances, not readily available. Catholic moral rationale believes that God has given us intelligence to think things through, yet the Church will never advocate the taking of a human life (Dr Joe Parkinson). On the other hand, the law takes the view that duty of care is higher than the individual’s autonomy. These laws impact on carers and hospital staff alike, as in the case of Christian Rossiter, a 49 year old man who was left quadriplegic after being hit by a car. A Western Australian landmark court decision ruled in favour of Mr. Rossiter, stating that a patient had the right to refuse treatment and to choose not to receive nutrition and hydration and any person or care group providing palliative care would not be criminally responsible (Physician-assisted suicide the same as euthanasia? 2014).To safeguard the autonomy of the person, the Catholic Church endorses the use of Advanced Care Plans and appointment of an Enduring Guardian to ensure that the patient is…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Privacy Rights of Individuals
    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Privacy Rights of Individuals

    Van Biema, D., & Lafferty, E. (1997, January). Is there a right to die? Time Canada, 149 (2),…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Written Analysis Based on Bbc Euthanasia
    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Written Analysis Based on Bbc Euthanasia

    For relevance, this article tells us about a brand new option for euthanasia that is carried out through mobile clinics in the Netherlands. So far, euthanasia is legal in only the Netherlands, Switzerland, Belgium, Australia and Oregon in the USA. This can be seen as a ‘controversial’ new option that makes euthanasia even more accessible in the Netherlands. It raises questions whether this new ‘convenience’ could result in an abuse of the legislation with doctors and patients going too far. The debate over the whether it should be a right for people to choose when and how to die, with dignity, has been going on for a long time in many countries, especially in developed countries. This is also relevant to us locally as we have an ageing population in Singapore. Although we have other measures in place such as the Advanced Medical Directive, euthanasia has not been legalised in Singapore. With greater attention being given to palliative care in recent years, the different perspectives in the euthanasia debate around the world is not far removed from us. The question remains as to whether our society is ready for measures such as euthanasia.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More

Related Topics