I think Postman's main argument is that Television is not meant for education solely which is reflected in various different academic studies in his article. That tv can have educational qualities while being entertaining but that it is not the means to end, edutainment is what Postman dubs Sesame street early on. As seen with the research he has duly noted is very conclusive. When we watch tv the average tv watcher only retains 20 percent of what they have watched. Just from reading that it made me realize how many hours I have wasted on Netflix binge watching certain tv shows just to find out what happens. To know I only have retained 20 percent of what I have watched, from each episode is sad. Another point Postman points are that once an hour has passed we retain even less. Which means if I was to go back and re-watch all of the tv shows I have binge watched on Netflix that I would find things I had totally forgotten and possibly forget them again later on after not watching them. Which to me seems like wasted time for entertainment. Even though at the time it doesn’t seem like a waste of time.
As Postman points out in the topic of “The Voyage Of The Mimi”, the government was willing to shell out massive amounts of moment. A few million actually to get a new program going that is using books as a supplemental visual aid along with video games. While the main attraction is the tv program. Visual aids are usual a snippet of a specially made tv program or movie. To think that books are supplemental visual aids are very sad. Postman also argues that even though he does not find Sesame Street non educational he is the unpopular opinion that “kids will only learn to love learning and school if school is like tv.”
Education has taken many hits then and even today. With social media easily at our fingertips it is easy for us even to think that by watching videos we can learn, when really it takes much more than that. Books can be opened and reread over and over again at your own pace. Tv programs where education a paramount can be re-watched but it isn’t the same and cannot necessarily be slowed down to the pace we always need. Another student pointed out in class their child has a v-tech tablet, which I agree with her, is useful and helps very much to young children. The classmate also pointed out how the time on it is monitored which is very important as well. An educational tablet is a fun and useful took for kids and I think can be a great learning tool, like Sesame Street. Except, I think that it is more educational, than say a tv program. It is entertaining but it is reminiscent of a children’s toy that helps kids to learn as they grow which has always been sold in the market place for years. Many parents are always looking out for the latest and greatest to help their young children learn as early as possibly before even entering school. “Thou Shalt Have No Prerequisites” a tongue in cheek commandment but very true as well shows that while a class may have prerequisites a tv show does that, showing that continuity and sequence does not matter for tv programming. Integrating “Three Media”, or more commonly known as “multi media presentation”, is not new has always been used modestly to enhance learners education. Years ago the Office of Education supplied funds to WNET for a program titled “Watch Your Mouth”, which is a series of televised dramatizations of students having programs with the English language while having social issues. While the show was very good, there exists that solid fundamental evidence that the show in any way helped the learners to improve their use of English where in writing or speaking. Which serves as further proof that the Education system was deeply flawed for believing that a tv series specially made for the classes would show any sort of improvement. Leading back to the point that while television is fun and can be educational it is best to leave the majority of tv watching outside of the classroom, except in specific cases where it does not take up too much of the valuable class time.
Can social media be used for the greater good in the classroom and to help political and environmental awareness while not taking away from the learning process if used in a high school social experiment? If so explain how?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Postman believed that television is a medium for show business and that topics like politics, education,…
- 530 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Amusing Ourselves to Death by Postman (Chapter 10) is a hypothetical counterargument response to various ways in which television and other media can be used for education rather than causing distraction to children. The author posits that television is not interactive. Therefore, the chapter gives a moment of reconsideration of digital technology advances since the publication of this book. Postman highlights that there can be no complete education without the social element: if a child can count, write, and read but cannot develop a conversation, socialize, or question, then he or she is not properly educated. Using the Internet, students are able to interact via various media channels or even with online tutors, but Postman would probably see this system inferior to the traditional setting of a classroom.…
- 667 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The television is a widely available communication apparatus. In recent years we have seen the television rise and involve its self in political discourse, with talk shows and the nightly news being a main part of society, this is what Postman was afraid of. He had several opinions regarding the television; he embraced it as an effective use of communication but disliked its involvement in social and…
- 811 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Television is the predominant media-metaphor of this generation. Television shapes the way people think, act, and communicate; however, this powerful apparatus does not always disclose the whole truth. In fact, television often hides the whole truth from the public, but, ironically, most people love the media and blindly believe what the media says. As Alford Huxley says, people will “adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think.” Unfortunately, Huxley’s hypothesis is slowly becoming a reality. In Neil Postman’s “Amusing Ourselves To Death,” Postman argues that the many facets of television people love will actually ruin them. Of these many facets of television, three are predominant. Television is ruining people’s lifestyles…
- 674 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I believe that watching T.V supported my literacy. Televisions helped me build my literacy by supporting my critical thinking, problem solving, reading and writing skills. Ever since I was younger I would watch a ton of television. Some of my favorite shows growing up are Sesame Street, Wish Bone, Reading Rainbow and Bill Nye the Science Guy. Because of television, I would always be inquisitive and drive my family crazy with questions. However, I had to face a several barriers as a reader. My First barrier as a reader is that I’m a slow reader. Second barrier, is my reading comprehension is terrible. Ultimately, reading has become very time consuming.…
- 214 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The issue is that these have been infected by the imperative to entertain. He believes media such as these needs to be engaged in a different form, because they each hold a value of a better tomorrow, and growth in human beings. Television is not an “amplification of discourse but merely a replacement”, and this is problematic for Postman because he finds that our societies’ importance of knowledge has been valued as a commodity due to the universality of television (P. 108). Postman seems to evoke an image of a public-spirited humanist who simply wants to benefit the better man and allow people to reach their full…
- 1618 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
For most Americans, watching television is a part of everyday life. According to the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, Americans spend more than 5 hours everyday watching television (Bls.gov, 2015). When Sesame Street first appeared on television in 1969, there were more than 12 million children in the United States. Many of those children “did not attend any form of school” (Ball et al. pg.1 para.1). In order to accommodate the delay in public education for all students, private and public agencies created the Children’s Television Workshop. The goal of the Children’s Television Workshop was to “entertain children and foster their intellectual and cultural development” (Ball et al. p. 2 para.1). Agencies decided to create a television show for the following reasons: Firstly, Television was accessible to many Americans. Secondly, children learn from television. This is evident when children sing jingles from commercials, or can recognize words they see on television. The Children’s Television Workshop launched in 1968 and began setting instructional goals for it’s educational program entitled “Sesame Street.”…
- 1138 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In his article “Television as Teacher” scholar and critic Neil Postman gives his views on what exactly educational television is teaching children. For example, “Parents embraced Sesame Street for several reasons, among them that it assuaged their guilt over the fact that they could not or would not restrict their children’s access to television.” Postman is well known for his claims that television causes people to want more and more entertainment out of life, so much that people begin to expect the news to be entertainment as well. Also, Postman argues that educational television does not teach children things like math, letters, or science, but instead it teaches them to expect entertainment out of their education, and because of this, schools must now try to be more entertaining because that is what children are used to. Postman is correct when he explains that parents can have some wrongs on how children are embrace or eager to hope that television could teach children basic knowledge on TV.…
- 635 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
After listening to and reading lessons 1-3, for why Christians need to read secular literature. The point that I agree the most is how electronic media, mainly television is not as valuable to learning as studying literature. In lesson 2 it states that when you watch television everything is done for you. You only tap into the emotional side of your brain and you lose your ability think logically, because you are living in the present and not thinking about the past or the future. People are becoming dependent on over using electronics. It’s making society lazier by the day.…
- 570 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
She does not think that watching television makes you smarter. However, she does not think it makes you dumber either. She believes that there are certain shows acceptable for children and some that are not. She believes that children, being young and vulnerable to the advertising industry, should be directed in the right path of choosing which television shows to watch and which not to watch. Children are susceptible when it comes to media. They almost act as a sponge; soaking up everything they see and hear and repeating it later on. Therefore, I cannot help but to agree with Stevens on that aspect of media except she then takes it too far when she asks , “Shouldn’t grown men and women be trusted to judge their own dosages, just as they would decide on the number of drinks they can handle at the bar?” (234). I disagree because I can see how some might react to this by saying that sometimes people don’t know their limit and can’t stop. This is 100% accurate when it comes to most things such as drugs, alcohol, and media. People might read that and think that media shouldn’t be placed into such a category, but all three of these things can start as small doses and turn into addiction within the blink of an eye. Parents who watch a lot of television as a child will most likely end up watching more and more television as they get older. If parents are not too concerned…
- 1174 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Many parents are guilty of blaming the television for making their kid obsessed with the wrong things, or for distracting them from school. On the other hand, National Public Radio suggests that television actually makes children better readers. They argue that literacy not only means being able to read, write, listen, and speak, but also to understand the different dimensions of these features. These dimensions include digital media and complex skills building to create a more well-rounded individual. They state that to achieve this, television can be used as a medium for kids to experience the “new” literacy while their parents help them achieve the “old” literacy goal. National Public Radio also believes that adults need to get past the more traditional approach of "no screen time" and use more modern approaches for their children to understand since they live in the 21st century. This shows that the author believes that the parents are at fault at times for underdeveloped children literacy, which is the opposite of what other people believe. Television should still be used in moderation, but adults have to understand that keeping their child from this device only hinders their development of what is called a “21st century” literacy. “21st century” literacy refers to being able to interpret other things such as images and emotion, not just being able to read, write, listen, and…
- 1644 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Television does contain educational shows. According to Palmer, television is a way that people are educating their children. Preschoolers and young children can learn many things from channels like Nick Jr. From my personal experience, I have worked with children who have watch educational shows like Dora and Mickey Mouse Club House. The children that have watched these shows can communicate better, know the alphabet, knows the colors, knows the shapes, knows animals, and much much. I have found that children who have not watched these educational shows are behind the other children. Now let's look at the consequences of watching too much television.…
- 663 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When watching a program, people are focused on the plot, make inferences, and create relationships with characters. Therefore, develops a cognitive exercise for the audience. Johnson informs his readers that there is an interaction between people and a television screen. Some examples he describes are when TV shows allow the viewer to develop a mental outline of a show, when a characters encounter social issues, and giving someone a cultural experience through a TV screen. He includes visuals that show different threads of TV programs, displaying the complexity of their scenes overtime, and how much it challenges the brain. Those graphs associate with Johnson’s term the “Sleeper Curve” (279), which according to him is the most debased form of mass diversion. He says that even if it is just reality television, violent content on TV or video games, and children shows, it still helps people become perceptive. Johnson concludes that instead of people having a negative attitude or having fears of their children being influenced by content of TV or video games, he insists that they both should share the experience. Parents and children will continue to interact with the TV screen mentally and therefore develop skills no matter what they watch. This essay presents in argument that television is good for…
- 1170 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Most people have adjusted to the improvements, thus expanding their knowledge on technology and techniques within the last century. The government also has to keep up since the majority of America has been updated with the latest of these advancements. For example, people now use computers, tablets, online instruction, etc. to help them extend their knowledge on a subject or multiple subjects. It has become the bare minimum to know how to work with the current establishments of today. In the video, “2 Million Minutes”, students from America, China, and India are all in a sort of “competition” with each other that is primarily focused on their education and futures.…
- 825 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
As a result, Postman then goes on to say our media has become an epistemology. Our media teaches…
- 698 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays