Top-Rated Free Essay

National Education

Good Essays
National education is a subject that aims to increase the national identity of students and citizens in Hong Kong. There are several steps to help fulfill this subject's aims. As it is believed to have benefits to the students in studying as well as helping critical thinking. There are some, however, some people see the content of this subject is brain-washing which hinders students to learn the real history of China, so that this subject still remains as the non-core subject in the primary schools or secondary schools. In this essay, both the advantages and disadvantages of national education in Hong Kong will be examined before drawing a conclusion based on the giving evidence.

Moral and national education (MNE) is a school curriculum proposed by the Education Bureau of Hong Kong in 2012. Hong Kong government wanted to promote national education in both primary schools and secondary schools. There are several advantages while promoting national education for students. One of the benefits is helping students to increase the national identity. Consultation on Moral and National Education Curriculum (2011) has reported that one of the curriculums aims is to facilitate identity-building through developing affection for the country, this can help increase the national identity to students. Since the promotion of nation to Hong Kong students were not enough in their studying stages in the government thought, therefore the government propose this subject to students as well as the citizens to help them have a more accurate and clear mind of the nation which can help recognize the identity as well as raising students’ recognition and sense of belonging towards their family, society, nation and the world and help them to become responsible family members, citizens and nationals (Moral and National Education Curriculum Guide Primary 1 to Secondary 6 , 2011).

As well as increase the national identity, helping students to develop moral qualities and a positive attitude is also the other advantages of promoting national education. In the curriculum of the national education, students could have more time for critical thinking. According to Moral and National Education Curriculum Guide Primary 1 to Secondary 6 (2011)”The curriculum aims cover values and attitudes, knowledge and skills, and focus on: development of moral qualities, leading a meaning life, growth in knowledge, judging reasonably and being responsible and rational.” This can help students strengthen their moral qualities in preserving Chinese virtues, develop an affection for the country and help students develop positive values and attitudes. What is more, when students having their lesson of this subject, they may learn how to develop a positive and optimistic attitude (Education Bureau of Hong Kong [EBHK], 2002).This can help students having a better manage of their study and help the students to relieve their study pressure.

Apart from the above advantages, there are also some disadvantages in promoting national education. According to the curriculum of this subject, some history of China had been cancelled or changed. The "China Model National Conditions Teaching Manual" which is the model textbook of the National Education was found to be biased towards the Communist of China and the so-called “China Model” (Oriental Daily, [13 July, 2012]).The teaching manual called the Communist Party an "advanced, selfless and united ruling group, while denouncing Democratic and Republican Parties of the United States as a "fierce inter-party rivalry that makes the people suffer". Mok (2012) points out that the members of Scholar and Civil Alliance against the National Education against the brainwashing national education curriculum before school commences as most of the content were pretended to be brainwashing to both primary and secondary schools students. Parents thought that this may hinder students to learn the truth of their nation and change their minds when they learned. Thus, some of the parents were afraid their children would learn the wrong history and bad manner in this course without gaining any benefits.

What is worse, adding one more subject in the core-subjects to the primary and secondary schools students may increase the workload of the students and may increase their study pressures. There are different focuses in this subject for different forms of students. Education Bureau of Hong Kong (EBHK, 2002) mentions the moral and national education covers four Key Stages from P1 to S6 across primary and secondary levels. Each Key Stage comprises five domains including personal, family, social, national and global, with a view to promote the development of positive values and attitudes as well as identity-building in students. This reveals that students need to learn one more subject in their primary and secondary school lives. This will increase their workload and more study pressure will be released.

It is clear that there are both advantages and disadvantages in proposing National Education. Proposing National Education can increase the nation identity to students as well as citizens which help them to be responsible national in nations. Furthermore, this can help students to develop moral qualities and a positive attitude. Nevertheless, there are several disadvantages while proposing this subject. The content of this subject has not cover all the truth of China to students and this may brain washing the students and this may increase the workload of the students. Thus, national education still remain the non-core subject in schools.

Taking these arguments into consideration, National Education can increase the nation identity to the citizens and help students foster the positive attitude. However, these benefits can only be realized through proper teaching materials, ensuring that the teacher, students and subject are focus on the direct content and not just brainwashing the students. Students today are often have high study pressures they can release their stress when they having appropriate courses in National Education. No matter this subject would be proposed or not, there are both pros and cons to the students. More details of this subject should be consulted and examined by both Hong Kong government and citizens.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    They believe that education should socialise pupils into shared values, such as competition, and instil a sense of national identity…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aung San Suu Kyi's Speech

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One of my favourite dicta is that people should not be categorized as good or evil, wise or stupid. It would be much more sensible to divide them simply into learners and non-learners. In between the two extremes would be a broad spectrum graded on the degree to which individuals are capable of correct assessment and understanding of the learning material at their disposal. Here of course I’m giving a very broad definition to learning. It would involve much more than what could be acquired from any one institution or from any one formal teacher. It would mean a process of gaining such knowledge and experience as would help us to cope with the challenges that life throws at us and to find ways of enhancing our own existence, as well as that of as great a portion as possible of all the other occupants of our planet. To put it in another way, the highest form of learning would be that which makes us caring and responsible citizens of this world, and equips us with the intellectual means necessary to translate our concerns into specific deeds. Surely such a view of learning is in harmony with the idea of education as conceived in the motto of Hong Kong University – Wisdom and Virtue. One hundred years of furnishing the world with young people who have been provided with the capacity to think independently, to express those thoughts cogently, and to use them for the betterment of our world is an achievement of which this University can be justly proud. The hopes of its founding fathers have been more than realized. At the foundation laying ceremony Sir Frederick Lugard hoped that the graduates of The University of Hong Kong would exert an influence which will be immeasurable in the future among the 400 millions of China’s population. Little could he have envisaged such an institution as this one of today, internationally renowned and one that attracts students from all over the world, who will one day exert an ever-widening influence on the…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    3) By the children learning to behave in a good decent manner and being rewarded for this will also raise their self-esteem and self-worth as well as build their confidence. It teaches them to treat others with respect and kindness and to take other peoples feelings into account, thus helping their social and emotional skills.…

    • 2138 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Also, helps to encourage active participation, gain community presence, build self-esteem/ confidence, and develop choice, rights, individuality.…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1- Explain what the National Curriculum is and the key stages for Primary school in England.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Public Education

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Public education has been an important part of our country throughout history. After the Declaration of Independence, fourteen states had their own constitutions by 1791. Seven of those states had specific provisions regarding education. Thomas Jefferson was one of the first American leaders to suggest a public school system. He believed that education should be under the control of the government, available to all people regardless of their status in society, and free from religious biases. Before the 1840s, the education system was only available to the wealthy. However, many reformers wanted all children in the United States to receive the benefits of education. Two reformers, Horace Mann and Henry Barnard created the Common School Journal, which was a newspaper that brought the issue of education out into the public. Because of their efforts, free public education at the elementary level was available for children by the end of the 19th century. Throughout the 1900s, many schools were created due to increased demand for skilled workers. As the 20th century progressed, many states began to enact legislation requiring people to go to school, and enrollment soared. That is how our public education system got to where it is today. There are still many issues regarding our public education system, such as some areas teaching better than others, and some classrooms having better materials than others. Local and Federal governments have always been involved in schools, making sure that they teach to their full potential. There are many congressional bills that have been passed, and many that are fighting to be passed. A very important bill that is out there today is the Student Bill of Rights, or H.R. 1295.…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brian W Picking Up Trash

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages

    and it reflect on the image of the student body and the school. The main strategy for…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Public Education

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Some independent schools are particularly old, such as The King's School, Canterbury (founded 597), St Peter's School, York (founded c.627),Sherborne School (founded c.710, refounded 1550 by Edward VI), Warwick School (c.914), The King's School, Ely (c.970) and St Albans School (948). These schools were founded as part of the church and were under their complete dominion. However, it was during the late 14th & early 15th centuries that the first schools, independent of the church, were founded. Winchester & Oswestry were the first of their kind and paved the way for the establishment of the modern "Public school". These were often established for male scholars from poor or disadvantaged backgrounds; however, English law has always regarded education as a charitable end in itself, irrespective of poverty. For instance, the Queen's Scholarships founded atWestminster in 1560, are for "the sons of decay'd gentlemen".…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    YJD English 2014

    • 501 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As that we mentioned above, when Hong Kong government reforms the education system as there as only one major public examination which determines whether students can go to university or not, the government also promotes the concept “life-long learning”. Life-long learning is the “ongoing, voluntary, and self-motivated” pursuit of knowledge for either…

    • 501 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Education is a vital weapon of a people striving for economic emancipation, political independence and cultural renaissance. We are such a people. Philippine education therefore must produce Filipinos who are aware of their country's problems, who understand the basic solution to these problems, and who care enough to have courage to work and sacrifice for their country's salvation. Nationalism in Education In recent years, in various sectors of our society, there have been nationalist stirrings which were crystallized and articulated by the late Claro M. Recto, There were jealous demands for the recognition of Philippine sovereignty on the Bases question. There were appeals for the correction of the iniquitous economic relations between the Philippines and the United States. For a time, Filipino businessmen and industrialists rallied around the banner of the FILIPINO FIRST policy, and various scholars and economists proposed economic emancipation as an intermediate goal for the nation. In the field of art, there have been signs of a new appreciation for our own culture. Indeed, there has been much nationalist activity in many areas of endeavor, but we have yet to hear of a well-organized campaign on the part of our educational leaders for nationalism in education. Although most of our educators are engaged in the lively debate on techniques and tools for the improved instructions, not one major educational leader has come out for a truly nationalist education. Of course some pedagogical experts have written on some aspects of nationalism in education. However, no comprehensive educational programme has been advanced as a corollary to the programmes for political and economic emancipation. This is a tragic situation because the nationalist movement is crippled at the outset by a citizenry that is ignorant of our basic ills and is apathetic to our national welfare. New Perspective Some of our economic and…

    • 8171 Words
    • 33 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Can One Be Moral

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Especially in the education field our schools play a major role in developing and teaching moral and social values to our children.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is some controversy over the extent to which dominant ideology is considered an important factor in educational purposes. It is generally believed that education refers a social work activity, which can be defined as the propagation and studies of various knowledge which are human civilization achievement, the skills and social experiences of life. In this essay, the purposes of education can be interpreted as the effect of politics, economics, and dominant ideology whereas dominant ideology can be defined as the most tightly held system of common values and beliefs that both bring forth and base on the social and economic organization at a specific period of time (Education lecture, Anderson, 2007). This essay will attempt to demonstrate that the purposes of education and dominant ideology are firmly linked, and how different ideologies affect the various purposes of education. In order to demonstrate this it will be shown that the different purposes of education are reflected the education systems of the UK and Taiwan and will also come to a comparison between both education systems.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    National Curriculum

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page

    Throughout this short essay, it will be focussing on a change that had an impact on UK education which is known as The National Curriculum.…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    National Identity

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I agree that education has succeeded in fostering a positive sense of national identity. To both the citizens of Singapore and international bodies, a strong national identity of Singapore would be the multiracial society we have and still being able to live harmoniously with one another. From the 1960s, various schemes were introduced in bid to bring together students from the different language streams. One such scheme was the integrated schools, whereby schools from difference language streams were brought together on one compound and ran by one administration. The first integrated government school was Bukit Panjang Government High School, which managed to bring together the English and Chinese streams under one roof. Also, measures were taken to place the different language streams on equal footing, for example, by introducing common examinations. Before the scheme was introduced, there was no universal education for children of all races and background, resulting in lesser children attending schools then. However, with the scheme introduced, children of all races and backgrounds can grow and learn together in harmony, without any form of biasness.…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    POLITICAL MOVEMENT IN HK

    • 1295 Words
    • 4 Pages

    curriculum is compulsorily introducing the sense of national patriot to students, education will come down to be the tool of political brain washing to students. Therefore, various social networks organized an anti-national education movement, which resulted in a great ring of the public and the concession of the government.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays