Preview

Nagel's Perspective On Suicide

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
898 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nagel's Perspective On Suicide
The second idea that has affected individuals to feel that their lives are meaningless is demise. Some people who think that their lives are meaningless try to think that death is the right way for them to escape from absurdity in their lives. There is no difference either to die sooner or later since in the end individuals will face death. They are aware that death is a complicated situation that can be achieved by certain factors such as aging, disease, and accidents. The only way to die easily is by committing suicide. Suicide is considered as the way to escape from suffering in this mundane world. However, suicide is not the right path to undergo in human life. People are not obligated and suggested to commit suicide just because they are …show more content…
The absurd is actually a form of contradiction in which any attempt that individuals commit to reconcile this contradiction is an attempt to escape from this absurd. Similarly, Nagel is also against human instant perception about committing suicide as a facility to skip suffering from their lives. Some people try to commit suicide because they think that there is no option that they can choose in order to improve their lives. This situation is mostly caused by social discrepancy in society. Based on Nagel's perspective, suicide instead will make the absurdity come true. As creatures who are equipped by reasons, people should have not only choices, but also hopes. For example, in the The Stranger story, Meursault tries to rise up right after he decides to stop his intention to commit suicide. In The Stranger's story, Camus writes that even a condemned man should be given a chance to improve his life (111). Even if individuals encounter difficult problems in their lives, they should not give up and try to overcome the …show more content…
Individuals have no idea if they are going to find happiness in their lives or not. Camus believes that both in Meursault and Sisyphus' stories, the absurd heroes unfortunately undergo their lives with a constant struggle, without any clear hope that there will be an improvement. Camus tells that before Meursault is about to face his execution, he is hopeless about running the way he lives (110). Meursault used to think that there is no difference between live and death. Even if he is set to be free, people will treat him badly since they acknowledge him as a murder. Individuals are tempted to question why they were born, have to work, and live in this world. They doubt the meaning of their existences as they do not believe that there is an actor behind their lives that arrange the way they live. This situation happens because the truth that these individuals usually experience is all about bitterness in human life. They feel that it is futile to achieve their goals because they benefit that they will get is only temporary. They also do not believe that striving in their lives will always guarantee that their lives will be better. However, Nagel does not believe that the source of hopelessness in human life comes from nature. Nagel thinks that human's hopeless comes from doubt that individuals usually have in their minds. Nagel's perspective is convincing since individuals

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Meursault is sentenced to death by guillotine. He awaits everyday waiting for the footsteps of the men to come and execute him. During this time Meursault has done much thinking and begins to think to himself that death is inevitable. This realization of death’s inevitability constitutes Meursault’s triumph over society. Expressing remorse over his crime would implicitly acknowledge the murder as wrong, and Meursault’s punishment as justified. The chaplain tries to come to him and speak to him about God, but he still is unwillingly to accept that there is a God.…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Stranger by Albert Camus, the protagonist Meursault is a man who is indifferent to major events in his life which would deserve a "proper" reaction according to society. Also, the decisions he makes in his life are done carelessly and without a second thought about whether what he is doing is good or bad. As a result, Meursault is a stranger to society because of how differently his view on life is based on how he approaches certain aspects of life. Eventually, death is what connects Meursault to the society he was estranged from.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Although suicide has a poor social stigma, it is not always an attempt to “take the easy way out” as many people view it. It can simply be the decision to end life on a high note. We can simultaneously stimulate the economy and allow the terminally ill and…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    With this objection, there’s a belief that by accepting Nagel’s view that we are absurd creatures with no rational behind our values, we will lose the drive to actively pursue our goals due to the acceptance that our values have no significance to anyone but ourselves. I don’t think that this is a strong objection to Nagel’s view. I believe that we don’t need to prove beyond a doubt that our projects or goals have value to anyone but ourselves. If we believe that our pursuits are valuable, we should pursue them. In addition, we shouldn’t feel ashamed that we can’t prove the value of our projects, but instead embrace that our values are an integral component of our…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Phil 102 Paper

    • 4420 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Nagel’s paper opens by pointing out that people naturally provide an expression for the sense that life is absurd. He notes that the reasons that are ordinarily given for thinking that life is absurd are inadequate and then cites four examples. The first is that our existence will not matter a long time from now. He argues that if it is true that…

    • 4420 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout The Stranger by Albert Camus, the protagonist, Meursault, is worried about being judged. The reader does not realize that Camus sets us up to constantly judge Meursault. Meursault is very analytical and can seem to be insensitive at times. However, Meursault’s actions can be taken many different ways. The ending leaves the reader to give a final judgment on whether Meursault is a menace to society or not. Meursault should not have received the death sentence because he was judged for his behavior leading up to his crime, not the murder itself.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Negel’s main point on why life is absurd is due to the fact nothing that we do right now will matter in the future, and vice versa. An example that I can give to an absurd event; is school. Everyone has had the thought of: Is school really the best option to be successful in the future? Hearing how jobs are getting harder and harder to obtain, how everyone has a bachelor in some type of program, and how you need a PhD if you want to get anywhere in life. This idea and image that society creates that if you don’t go to school you wont be successful in life. Certainly that’s all in what you do as an individual. You decide your future, but sometimes society changes how you think and shapes you to believe like everyone else, just because they say so. But every now and then I will always have the thought of; does me going to school, staying up till 4:00am to do my reasoning and morality assignment, and paying seven thousand dollars a year to learn, really matter and have meaning in life?…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Meursault's Exile

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In part II of the novel, Meursault, is thinking about his situation and decide that it is time to for once attempt to understand his actuality and what it truly stands for. As Meursault is isolated in this jail cell, he has no choice but to reflect on his past and actions and it seem like the only fair-minded thing for him to do at the moment. In this dark time, Meursault’s eyes began to see. Meursault most certainly does suffer thinking about his execution that is to come, and because of his situation he began to think about his real purpose in society and his place in the world. As very much unwanted, Meursault, had to have his showdown with death and this was the thing that caused him to open his arms to the world. Meursault came to a conclusion that the only way that he can make these last moments of his life happy instead of dreadful, was to to maintain and stick to his beliefs. All throughout his life he was unable to find anything worth making an effort for until this moment. It was different for him because he has finally come to realization of how beautiful life can be if you let it take its natural course. Meursault miraculously used his death sentence as a way to redeem himself and his life. At the end of the novel when he was alone was when his eyes had opened up. His deep…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because Meursault does not conform to social norms, the audience can relate because they, too, do not want to conform to some of society’s norms, but do not see themselves reflected in Meursault’s action, for many people care too much about societal etiquette. Camus makes the audience ponder about a society with people who are existentialist like Meursault, who do not conform to society’s norms and do as they please. Would society be functional because everyone has one’s own selfish purpose in life? Or would society be similar to society now because all outsiders would be the same and are no longer considered strangers rather just…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Existentialists such as Sartre and Kierkegaard advocated for individual meaning and morality in a meaningless world, particularly through one’s actions and responses to consequences. In his essay, “Suicide and Atheism: Camus and The Myth of Sisyphus,” Richard Barnett describes the existential value of choice: “It is in making choices, in asserting our ultimate freedom in the face of an uncaring world, that human life can be lived in its fullest and richest sense” (2). This principle can be applied to many literary characters, including Jean Anouilh’s modern adaptation of Antigone in the eponymous play, Snowman of Margaret Atwood’s novel Oryx and Crake, and Albert Camus’ Meursault in The Stranger. Curiously, though all these characters display…

    • 2001 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    He is unfairly judged by society because he exhibits no emotions of any kind at his mother's funeral. In a community where the principle belief that emotional displays are the necessary and correct response to traumatic events such as in Meursault's case (his mother's death) means that there is a standard that is applied to all people. But because the protagonist is shown to be a rebel he does not obey the expected behavior of mourning that society wants him to show. Society asks “has [Meursault] uttered a word of regret for his most odious crimes? Not one word, gentlemen. Not once in the course of these proceedings did this man show the least contrition (Camus 126).” Meursault finally understands that he is in a paradoxical situation where he is judged for showing the lack of feelings rather than his murdering of the Arab man. In the courtroom, the jury represents society’s ethics in which Meursault is being judge while the spectators in the courtroom represent society who are there to pass views on him. He eventually is put on the death penalty because of his nonconformist attitude. Another example that shows the protagonist to be a social misfit is that Meursault believes all men are equal in a sense that no one can ever escape death even if they were a Christian or not. He explains that “every man alive was privileged; there [are] only one class of men, the privileged class. All alike would be condemn to die one day; his turn, too, would come like the others (Camus 152).” He even goes on to say that Old Salamano’s dog was worth just as much as Old Salamano's wife in view of the fact that like all humans, dogs will eventually die as well. So the life of a human can’t be more special than that of a dog since both organisms are made equal by death. The protagonist is an absolute rebel because he is passive, detached, and emotionless…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Suicide is the ultimate act of selfishness an individual can commit because it leaves those who care behind wondering why. Even though, at that point in time of one’s action one does not think of anything but them self. In the background there sits those who care and love you, such as parents, children, spouses, and friends. As loved ones left behind they wonder why you had to do what you did, why they never noticed any signs, and was there not something they could have done to prevent this from happening. Tragically most loved ones wind up being totally in the dark for the rest of their lives.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In most cases, committing suicides the choice of lunatic, short-sighted people that don’t have the means or courage to solve their own problems. People commit suicide when they face a problem they consider unsolvable, but such a problem does not exist. All problems have a solution, therefore no one should commit suicide. “Suicide is the tenth leading cause of death overall; third among 15- to 24-year-olds and fourth among 25- to 44-year-olds.” Some of the main causes of suicide are bullying, cyberbullying, financial difficulties, and the death of close ones.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Suicide is the intentional termination of one's own life with the objective being to cease living. For the purposes of this essay, self-sacrifice, or suicide for the sake of others, will not be considered a form of suicide as in that situation the individual does not possess the desire to die, they are instead putting the lives of others above their own. The standard position on suicide holds that all suicides are immoral and irrational except for in cases of terminal illness. This position on suicide is too restrictive and dismisses the suffering others experiences in instances beyond terminal illness. There are extreme situations in which most would agree that suicide is an acceptable choice. For example, someone trapped in a fire or subjected…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In North America, we are dependant on the idea of the American Dream; good jobs to pay for all our wants and needs. But when our ability to pay for our desires is threatened, some may turn to suicide as an escape from issues we cannot face. In recent years, suicide in North America has been on the rise, with all walks of life affected. From newly unemployed men and women killing themselves after the economic crash of 2008, to young girls killing themselves as a result of being publicly shamed on the internet, it is my belief that while death is not celebrated or encouraged it can be an alternative to failure in North America. Soceity discourages people killing themselves yet to some it is the best option. Suicide, act of one ending their own…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics