"Motherhood: Who needs it?" An Evaluation

Better Essays
While motherhood is not the stereotypical home making occupation that it was in the 1970 's, it is still one of the most important roles women play in this country. In "Motherhood: Who Needs It?" Betty Rollin openly expresses her negative opinion of motherhood. Throughout the essay Rollin elaborates on many reasons why motherhood is overrated in America. Rollin says that, "The notion that the maternal wish and the activity of mothering are instinctive or biologically predestined is baloney." She first touches on the subject of motherhood as a science. "Women have childbearing equipment. To choose not to use the equipment is no more blocking what is instinctive than it is for a man who, muscles or no, chooses not to be a weight lifter." Rollin then refers to God as the cause of the "motherhood problem". "... the word of God that got the ball rolling with 'Be fruitful and multiply, ' a practical suggestion, since the only people around then were Adam and Eve." Rollin quotes psychologists and doctors who support her theories, not ones who do not. She says that most mothers are unhappy, but do not admit it. Rollin rambles on throughout the essay telling how the motherhood myth is affecting the children and their mothers. She manipulates statistics to make them reflect her theory and does not give both sides of the argument. This essay while being outdated is full of fallacies and one-sided information influenced by the authors ' social points of view, which misinform the reader.

Rollin refers to an experiment using baby ducks as support for her thesis. "...baby ducks who lovingly follow their mothers seemed, in the mother 's absence, to just as lovingly follow wooden ducks or even vacuum cleaners." This may be true but wooden ducks and vacuum cleaners cannot teach baby ducks how to swim, and how to survive. The previous is an example of a misleading analogy and hypostatization, which uses abstract concepts as concrete authorities using scientific experiments. The



Cited: Rollin, Betty. "Baby Blues: How I stopped mourning the child who never was." AARP. 24 November 2003. "Sex and America 's Teenagers". Alan Guttmacher Institute. New York: 2003. 24 November 2003. "Sexual and Reproductive Health: Men and Women." Alan Guttmacher Institute. New York. 2003. 24 November 2003 < http://www.agi-usa.org/pubs/fb_10-02.h

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the essay "Motherhood: Who Needs It?" Betty Rollins does not use the most effective structure and style to argue against what she believes is the "motherhood myth" (203). Rollins opposes the idea that having children is something that all women should want, and need to do instinctively. She feels that women are having babies for all the wrong reasons, and attempts to set a few things straight about motherhood itself. Though her argument may be passionate, the organization, diction, and overall…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    October 2014 “Motherhood: Who Needs It?” Reader Response Asking who needs motherhood is a bit of an understatement, in my opinion. Instead we should go deeper into it. What needs motherhood and why? Is it people, males, females, society or the planet as a whole? In the essay “Motherhood: Who Needs It?” written by Betty Rollin in 1970, I find so many unanswered questions and issues and my goal now is to find the answers to them. What is motherhood? Why exactly do, or don’t, we need the myth? Should…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Role of Motherhood

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages

    SOZIOLOGIE SEMINAR: GENDER INEQUALITY WS 2012/2013 DOZENTIN: PROF. DR. LEEN VANDECASTEELE COMMENTARY PAPER THE ROLE OF MOTHERHOOD Getting a Job: Is there a Motherhood Penalty? The main topic in the text written by Shelley J. Correll, Stephen Benard and In Paik is the discrimination…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Who Needs College

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “Who Needs College?” College education is one of the major characteristics of our society today. It is a controversial topic, discussed not only by politicians, professor, and sociologists, but also by ordinary people, who are affected by it directly. The need of a college degree and the process of education through our higher educational system became painful for some and still unclear for others. Today’s statistics and research data provides information on quantity and quality of our education…

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who Needs Theology

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    theologians simply confusing Christians and missing Jesus? These themes and questions are thoroughly unpacked and dissected in Stanley Grenz and Roger Olson book Who Needs Theology. In fact, they point out that every person is indeed a theologian by stating, “No one who reflects on life's ultimate questions can escape theology. And anyone who reflects on life's ultimate questions-including questions about God and our relationship with God-is a theologian.”1 By stating and proving this point completely…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who Needs Theology

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ben Schupanitz Professor Richard Smallie Theology 216 28 January 2010 Who Needs Theology? Theology is defined as “any reflection on the ultimate questions of life that point toward God” (Grenz and Roger pg. 13). Theology makes up everyone’s life whether they know it or not. Everyone is a theologian in their own way. This book takes us through the process of understanding theology and putting it to practical use in our daily lives. It gives step by step instructions on how to practice theology…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ideology for motherhood

    • 2020 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Explain why motherhood is difficult to define using one of the three perspectives from the module i.e. history or ideology or policy: The following essay is going to discuss why motherhood is difficult to define from an ideology perspective. It will discuss motherhood in general and what surrounds motherhood and why it is difficult to define from an ideology perspective and also explain what ideology means. The essay will also discuss motherhood and how mothers can be mothers other than through…

    • 2020 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Balancing Motherhood

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    circumstances arising in my life, I am unable to comply with my Family Care Plan at this present time. Balancing motherhood and being a Sailor is tough, but balancing motherhood and being a Sailor as a single parent is tougher. For four years, I have been struggling to find a stable support system and caregiver for my son while I complete my tour as an active duty member. It is my son who suffers the most from it when I am compelled to place him in a home with outsiders because my relatives are not…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Motherhood Essay

    • 2009 Words
    • 9 Pages

    violating women to destroy the lives growing inside them. An abortion will always be abortion, and it will never be safe for the pre-born child (“Abortion Regulation”). These activists as well believe abortion was sold as liberating women from "forced motherhood." On the other hand, others such as mothers, are against these statements and pro-abortion. Mothers believe that the abortion right is discussed as a negative liberty, a right of privacy, a right to be let alone (Yale). The abortion right is also…

    • 2009 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Motherhood In Carmilla

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Carmilla written by Sheridan Le Fanu, has many motifs ranging from homosexuality, to motherhood. Naturally, motherhood is a great time of bonding and growth between mother and child, with the child feeding from the mother, and the mother providing fo the child. Carmilla’s motherhood theme is instead unnatural and a different sort of version than what many individuals may be used to and comfortable with. Motherhood in Carmilla twists woman’s natural role into an unnatural parallel based on the motif…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays