Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

miss

Powerful Essays
2221 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
miss
What do we learn when we look at our Western scientific notion of reproduction from an anthropological view?

In Western societies it has become common for people to seek answers and follow science as a way of understanding and dealing with many issues. In the case of reproduction, we are taught from a young age how the different genders have a specific role to play in procreation. When exploring reproduction ideologies in Western civilisations it is integral to assess the terminology of both. The definition of reproduction within Western dictionaries sees a scientific classification - ‘Biology The sexual or asexual process by which organisms generate new individuals of the same kind; procreation.’ (TheFreeDictionary.com, 2014) The Western world is made up of various countries including all of Europe, New Zealand; Americas; Israel; Australia and South Africa. It is not based on geography but more so political and economic. (Uk.ask.com, 2014) In majority of Western civilisation it is believed that human life begins at the moment of conception which contradicts other cultures situated throughout the hemisphere. Science has also brought answers and remedies for failure to reproduce, which in term contrasts with the ability to end unwanted pregnancies. The object of this essay is to examine the issues of identification of human life, the gender roles in reproduction and how far science has allowed us to create or end a human life in vitro.
In the Western world a foetus has legal rights and can be represented in a court of law. It is also entitled to property and inheritance. A case study involving a young woman in Washington DC explores the extent the legal implications involved in fetal rights. Angela Carder became pregnant while in remission from cancer however while pregnant another tumour was found. She made the decision to continue the pregnancy with no medical intervention for the cancer but the pain became too unbearable so she changed her mind. It was at this point the hospital involved their legal team. The debate pertained that the foetus had the right to live as much as the mother. The court ruled in favour of the foetus and an emergency Caesarean section was performed, the foetus died two hours later with Angela four days later. (Advocatesforpregnantwomen.org, 2014) This is a concise example in the Western world of how a non-persons rights are deemed substantially higher than what is defined as a person. However not every country establishes the label of personhood onto a foetus. In 2012 the Canadian Medical Association was part of a major debate on influencing whether to change the wording on their countries Criminal code. They believed that human life only began at the moment of birth. They emphatically backed up their claims by stating ‘a child becomes a human being within the meaning of this Act when it has completely proceeded, in a living state, from the body of its mother’. (LifeSiteNews, 2012) These two cases show contrasting beliefs in the Western world. Further contrast from the Western world can be viewed through the Pocobaya people of the Bolivian Andes. Andrews Canessa conducted a study which looked at the process of personhood within this community of 220 residents. The people who are part of this community are based around agricultural means and substantially live off the earth and give back to Mother Nature. Their ideals towards procreation show that they view pregnancy and birth as ‘raw materials out of which a person may be created’. (Canessa 1999:4:73) A person does not immediately exist due to the conception between man and women but instead a person is created through disciplines and extensive processes which branch into full adulthood. When a birth occurs it is not celebrated as it is in the Western world, there is no family gathering or cards and gifts showered upon the family. Once the product of the pregnancy comes into the world there is little attention paid to it, more emphasis is placed upon the placenta which must be buried immediately, failure to do so, from their perspective, can lead to the mother’s death. (Canessa 1999:4:76) A child is not fed for the first 24 hours after birth because the belief is this allows a hardiness to grow. Throughout the process the offspring through growth must relate to the others in the community, the land and then the world beyond. (Canessa 1999:4:83) Through these three examples we can therefore conclude that there is strong contrast between not only Western and non-Western countries but within boundaries too. Science can put a personal identity upon a foetus whereas in terms of Southern America science is not an imperative factor.
Gender roles in reproduction also differ from Western to Eastern civilisations. From how paternity is viewed in contrast to maternity. In Turkey, Carol Delaney (1986, pp. 494--513) found that within a small village the views of the roles in procreation between the father and mother differed greatly. The woman is viewed as a ripe soil for the implantation of a successful crop ‘Women are given to you as fields, go therein and sow your seed’ (Delaney 1986:496) is citied in the Koran, the Islamic bible. No science or textbook defines how a child is created biologically. The identity of the child comes directly from the father, the heritage to carry on the genes of the clan. The women’s role is to nurture and care for the child, in term is the incubator of cultivation while the father has one singular role, to sow the seed. ‘Children are the father’s seed therefore belong to him’ (Delaney 1986:500) this contrasts with Western world beliefs where specifically in the United Kingdom, the mother has full parental rights and a father must seek to gain them through a court of law. The rituals of this Turkish village see the women having to be married before conception and being secluded from others while at all times wearing a veil, only at this point is she viewed as being worthy of being suitable for pregnancy. (Delaney 1986:498) The Trobriander Aborigines in Australia have a similarity in the sense the mother must be married, however, the child once born becomes the mother’s clan and is related to their father through other avenues (Delaney 1986:507). In Western civilisation science provides the answers to conception through the use of biological terminology. The use of words such as menstruation, zygotes; fertility and gametes. The interaction of humans is not necessarily accounted for through science aspects. It follows typecasts of what the role of the female and male counts for. As Emily Martin (1991, pp. 485—501) discusses ‘The stereotypes imply not only that female biological processes are less worthy than their male counterparts but also that women are less worthy than men’. The reproduction process is described and labelled as the works of a biological timeframe and machine where ‘medical texts describe menstruation as the debris of the uterine lining, the result of necrosis or death of a tissue’ (Martin 1991:486) therefore menstruation being deemed as a failure. The average woman is fertile and of child bearing ability for approximately half of their life in comparison to the average male who will produce sperm up until his death. When stripping the science part away from Western beliefs, a mother and father play a far more intimate role in reproduction. A child is born as a product of love, the beginning of a new era for many and as a culmination of all the partnership stands for. Through analysis of these examples it can be concluded that there are differing attitudes to the roles both genders play in procreation. Western science explains the biological level of reproduction whereas other cultures place emphasis on one gender over the other.
Science has also provided parts of the world the ability to assist in reproduction or to eliminate the chances of it ever occurring. In- vitro fertilisation has been steadily available in many developed countries around the world for a few decades with the first IVF baby being born in the United Kingdom in 1978. Through comparison of the Western world to that of Vietnam we can witness the contrast in the use of IVF and the reasons behind decisions to seek help in reproduction. There are many women in the USA who have genuine medical reasons for not conceiving however there are the women who choose a different life path then seek help in later life. A woman now has the choice to choose a career over family, a promiscuous sex life rather than the relationship which leads to the point that when they do decide to have a family it has been left too late for nature to take the course. There are privatised clinics that will charge extortionate fees in order to provide IVF treatment for these women therefore making it a profitable business. In some cases there is the choice to make the designer baby, pre-deciding what colour of hair and eyes your child will have. In Vietnam, it is for far more legitimate reasons a women will seek IVF. Pashigan (2009) studied IVF treatment in Vietnam and found that ‘the assumption is that a childless married woman must suffer from unwanted childlessness, with negative implications for the stability of her marriage and the solidity of her relationships with her husband’s relatives, particularly his mother.’ The reasons for seeking help are not solely on a personal level but more so cultural. Infertility puts these women at risk of being expelled from the social status and being ostracized by their husband and his family. Their gender role is placed into question so IVF is a form of self-preservation. Contraception is another aspect in the Western world which is readily available through choice. There are many avenues to allow prevention of conception from condoms to sterilisation of either gender. Condoms are given out free to anyone who can walk into a chemist or clinic with no questions asked. A GP can provide a small tablet that will either prevent pregnancy or another which will do the same up to a few hours after unprotected sex. This allows free choice to the individual which is extremely integral in the cases of people who have conditions such as AIDS or HIV. In contrast to the Western world, in underdeveloped countries such as Africa it is seen as a sin to use condoms or any form of contraceptive. In 2009, Pope Benedict XVI visited Cameroon and delivered this message upon his arrival ‘HIV/Aids was, he argued, "a tragedy that cannot be overcome by money alone, that cannot be overcome through the distribution of condoms, which can even increase the problem". The solution lay, he said, in a "spiritual and human awakening" and "friendship for those who suffer". (News.bbc.co.uk, 2014) The church still holds this stance on contraception even though over 350.000 women and 3 million children die each year. (Allafrica.com, 2014) The contrast between Western society and other parts of the world show a significant difference in the scientific notions where underdeveloped countries such as Africa are ruled over by religion rather than science.
In conclusion belief systems differ across different countries in regards of reproduction and personhood. In the aspect of Western civilisation the basis falls to science. It explains how a life is conceived from biological aspects and allows us to understand the failings in it also. It can intervene to assist in pregnancies or to aid in unwanted conceptions. There are now legal implications involved in reproduction where the foetus can be considered a person before birth. This essay explored where there are similarities and polar opposites on certain aspects. The role of both genders has different features between Western and Eastern parts of the world with different emphasis being placed on each gender and the part they have to play. It fundamentally falls onto what is available in certain countries and how much they depend on science, their own faith and/or religion. Criticism cannot befall onto any separate belief as it should be the individual’s choice in where this belief should lie. With new scientific findings and different cultures evolving every day we have to be respectful that science and culture both have a part to play in reproduction.

Bibliography
Advocatesforpregnantwomen.org. 2014. The Rights of Pregnant Patients: Carder Case Brings Bold Policy Initiatives. [online] Available at: http://www.advocatesforpregnantwomen.org/articles/angela.htm
Allafrica.com. 2014. allAfrica.com: Africa: Beyond Contraceptive Controversy - Melinda Gates Bets on Pro-Life Policies (Page 1 of 2). [online] Available at: http://allafrica.com/stories/201207230079.html [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Delaney, C. 1986. The meaning of paternity and the virgin birth debate. Man, pp. 494--513.
LifeSiteNews. 2012. Canadian Medical Association: babies not human until after birth | LifeSiteNews.com. [online] Available at: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/canadian-medical-association-babies-not-human-till-after-birth [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Loizos, P. and Heady, P. 1999. Conceiving persons. London: Athlone Press.
Martin, E. 1991. The egg and the sperm: How science has constructed a romance based on stereotypical male-female roles. Signs, pp. 485--501.
News.bbc.co.uk. 2014. BBC NEWS | Africa | Pope tells Africa 'condoms wrong '. [online] Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7947460.stm [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Pashigian, M. J. 2009. The Womb, Infertility, and the Vicissitudes of Kin-Relatedness in Vietnam.JSTOR.
TheFreeDictionary.com. 2014. reproduction. [online] Available at: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/reproduction [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Uk.ask.com. 2014. What Countries Make up the Western World. [online] Available at: http://uk.ask.com/question/what-countries-make-up-the-western-world [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].

Bibliography: Advocatesforpregnantwomen.org. 2014. The Rights of Pregnant Patients: Carder Case Brings Bold Policy Initiatives. [online] Available at: http://www.advocatesforpregnantwomen.org/articles/angela.htm  Allafrica.com. 2014. allAfrica.com: Africa: Beyond Contraceptive Controversy - Melinda Gates Bets on Pro-Life Policies (Page 1 of 2). [online] Available at: http://allafrica.com/stories/201207230079.html [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014]. Delaney, C. 1986. The meaning of paternity and the virgin birth debate. Man, pp. 494--513. LifeSiteNews. 2012. Canadian Medical Association: babies not human until after birth | LifeSiteNews.com. [online] Available at: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/canadian-medical-association-babies-not-human-till-after-birth [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014]. Loizos, P. and Heady, P. 1999. Conceiving persons. London: Athlone Press. Martin, E. 1991. The egg and the sperm: How science has constructed a romance based on stereotypical male-female roles. Signs, pp. 485--501. News.bbc.co.uk. 2014. BBC NEWS | Africa | Pope tells Africa 'condoms wrong '. [online] Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7947460.stm [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014]. Pashigian, M. J. 2009. The Womb, Infertility, and the Vicissitudes of Kin-Relatedness in Vietnam.JSTOR. TheFreeDictionary.com. 2014. reproduction. [online] Available at: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/reproduction [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014]. Uk.ask.com. 2014. What Countries Make up the Western World. [online] Available at: http://uk.ask.com/question/what-countries-make-up-the-western-world [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Traditional or common portrayals of the fertilization process are inaccurately based on what truly happens because of typical stereotypes and biased information of male and female. Male biologists blow off the idea of the egg “controlling” the sperm by trapping it because they feel that it makes males appear less weak in comparison to women in reality. The limitations of Martin’s study yielded to reader’s wondering why there were small, but vital lies told due to chauvinistic…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medical Bioethical

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I was very shocked to read this newspaper article about this poor woman and everything she went thru for the state of medical and media views of her baby. This is a good view on medical ethics. I hope it doesn’t happen to another woman. We have the right to do what we will with our bodies and the state or hospital can’t force us to anything. I hope I covered everything in my paper. My paper is a bioethical and legal I believe. Thank…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    HSM 542 Week 3 Assignment

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In some ethical and legal respects a pregnant woman and her fetus can be considered separate. Both the woman and the fetus are ordinarily affected by the well-being of one another for as long as each of them live. The ethical and legal issues are challenged deeply in cases where the well-being of the fetus and the mother appear to be in conflict. Our society struggles with identifying cases where the pregnant woman’s interests and/or behaviors might put her fetus at risk. Criminal and/or civil commitments should be used to bar pregnant women from exposing their fetuses to risk.…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some pregnancies can have complications like disorders while developing. Some disorders that the baby could have is anencephaly which is a disorder where the brain is missing. Another disorder that the baby could have is limb-body wall complex which is a disorder where organs grow outside the body. It is the woman’s right to decide if they want their baby to come to this world to suffer with those disorders or not.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cited: Darwin, Charles. The Descent of Man in Relation to Sex. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1981. Print.…

    • 2150 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    been established that the fetus is a person or that it’s entitled to the Fourteenth Amendment rights…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The foetus has the moral status of a piece of tissue right up until birth.…

    • 911 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opponents of the decision to persecute pregnant women who exposes their fetuses to risk outlined several issues with this decision. Firstly, they believe that there is a number of ethical problems with prosecuting these women. According to them, this can have the opposite effect intended. These women because of their drugs and alcohol issues will avoid doctors out of fear of jail and both they and their babies will be in greater danger from a wide range of medical problems. Secondly, there is a problem with the prospect of these women losing the ability to trust their healthcare providers as doctors are forced to move from treatment to punishment as a solution to addiction. Thirdly, it is believed that because these women are persecuted, some addicts might seek late-term abortions rather than deliver a baby with signs of drug abuse. One question that has not been answered is whether women subjecting their children to increased risk of multiple births as a…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beck Vs Socrates

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Socrates: All right, let us consider what you have said. You said that the unborn fetus is not yet a human being, but it will be legally considered as a human being once they are born, so in other words, it is not yet a human being but it does have the potential to become a human being, correct?…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    License to Procreate

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The question “should people procreate” is a very opinionated one. There is no right or wrong answer just a personal opinion based on facts to support it, I happen to side with Hugh Lafollette in his essay “Licensing Parents”. I will argue that before people are allowed to procreate they should have to obtain a license which gives them the right to produce and raise children. Otherwise they should not be allowed any children until they have the license. First I will look at it from the child’s point of view and explain how it is rational for them. Second I will look at the reasoning and policies of this theory. Finally I will discuss how it would change the modern today and how it would be implemented.…

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At some point in everyone’s life they have probably heard an argument or a commercial about the ethical dilemma of abortion. Since the historical 1973 Supreme Court ruling in Roe v. Wade, the discussion of a woman’s right to have an abortion has been one of the most contentious moral and political debates in America. The Court decided that a woman’s right to an abortion fell within the right to privacy, protected by the fourteenth amendment. The decision gave a woman total freedom and control of the pregnancy in the first trimester, and defined different levels of state interests for the second and third trimesters. The laws of 46 states were affected by the Court’s ruling. Despite this decision, the ethical and moral question still remains, when does a human life begin?…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this paper I will discuss the relevance of J.J. Thomson’s argument in her article, A Defense of Abortion, to that of pregnancy reduction and if there is any relevance, if there are exceptions or situations where that might change. J.J. Thomson’s argument in A Defense of Abortion is that the one thing a person has rights to is his/her body and the right to control what happens with it. Thomson also states that there is an innate desire and need for self-preservation that we all have that must additionally be considered.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Miss

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Explain how the range of early years setting reflect the scope and purpose of the sector…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    miss

    • 2177 Words
    • 9 Pages

    An explanation of the concept of safeguarding and the duty of care that applies to all practitioners (6.1)…

    • 2177 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays