Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Midterm Paper

Good Essays
1625 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Midterm Paper
There is an old saying that goes, “Even the best laid plans can go astray”. This statement basically means that even when something is done with the best of intentions and preparation; it can still produce completely different results than what was originally intended. In America’s school systems, there are many examples of things being done with the best of intentions, but yielding less-than-desirable results. One of the largest and most prevalent examples of this can be seen when looking at the “Tracking System” that is often implemented in the majority of American schools. Although this system was brought about with the best of intentions and with no goal of hurting anyone, it is now an outdated practice that causes major problems in schools. When reading the article “How Tracking Creates a Poverty of Learning” by Mary Hatwood Futrell and Joel Gomez which examines the tracking system as it is currently, one can see that it causes and reinforces several negative attitudes towards students including the self-fulfilling prophecy, the lack of equality in the classroom, an unfair dominate culture influence, and the idea that one must assimilate in order to be accepted and do well. If one were to take a public poll about tracking systems in schools, it would be a safe bet that most people wouldn’t even know what a tracking system is, even though the majority of Americans have been a part of one at some point in their educational career. A simple explanation of the tracking system is the division of students into different “lanes” of education based on their academic. These different lanes often include an accelerated/AP lane, a regular lane, and then the slower-paced lane. At first this sounds like a good idea, and much like communism, it is on paper; it seems only natural to separate students based on their individual abilities so you can better fit each students learning ability. However, when this system is put into practice, several unforeseen side-effects arise and it can be seen that something needs to be done about this problem. According to the Article by Futrell and Gomez, the problem comes not in the idea of separating students based on their abilities, if fact the article argues that is a positive thing as it allows each students education to be more customized and focused to them. So what is the problem then? The article goes on to say that the real problem with the Tracking System as it is today is that it allows for much discrimination against minorities being placed into the more advanced track. Currently, students are placed into tracks based almost entirely off of their test scores and almost nothing else. The article explains that this is incredibly unfair as most of the people who place into these advanced classes come from wealthy, traditional white families. Since the testing is done so early, usually in the 6th grade, it allows students to be placed into their track before they are old enough to even have much of an influence over their education. It seems common to see that if a student comes from a family that is not as well off and does not emphasize education, they are just placed into the lower track and essential forgotten about. In Brown vs. The Board, it was ruled that separate but equal education is inherently unequal and therefore was made illegal. This decision single handedly ended the racial segregation of schools, but this tracking system still keeps it alive. When these students are separated into their lanes of education, the curriculum they will face is different in each level. The article tells that students in the advanced classes face a challenging, college-oriented curriculum where they are encouraged and pushed to do their best. However, the students that got placed into the lower level classes face a much more watered down curriculum that focuses more on preparing the students for a career after high school, essentially telling the students they have no reason to even try to strive for a college education. By not encouraging these students to attend college, or even really preparing them, schools are enforcing the self-fulfilling prophecy to these students. Studies show that most of the students in these lower level classes come from less-wealthy family where usually neither of the parents went to college. By putting these students in classes that do not challenge them, schools are ultimately doing a huge disservice to these students. They are not showing them that not only is college necessary and a very real possibility; it is something that every student should try to achieve. Although there will always be people who are naturally smarter than others, it is important to remember that just because a student doesn’t score high on a test or look like the typical honors student, they still can be and still deserve all the same opportunities that every other student receives. This separation of students also creates a huge lack of equity in the classroom. In the article, it spoke of honors classes usually being filled with white middle class students whereas the lower classes tended to be filled with more minorities and poorer students. I can personally attest to this from my own high school tracking experiences. I was placed in the honors lane in about the 7th grade and stayed in it all the way through graduation. In my classes, there was almost no diversity at all. Everyone was white; everyone lived in nice houses and came from nice families. I saw the other students around school, in the hallways or cafeteria, but I never faced class with them because they were seen as unable to completely the requirements to be in my classes. Not only is that a disadvantage to them but to me as well because I was not taught how to deal with diversity in the classroom which is a very important thing for schools to teach in my opinion. This tracking system essentially crated an unfair dominate culture within my classroom. Just because I was from a good family that placed an emphasis on my education when I was younger, I ended up in the advanced lane. Had I been from a family where education was not a focus, I may not have scored so high on my test in middle school. I could have essentially been one family away from being in the slower lanes. The biggest problem with the tracking system in my opinion isn’t the system; it’s how students get into it. This is also another issue brought up by the article. One major point that the article points out is that the reason many students can’t get into the classes they need is because there is not enough individual attention given to students by counselors when determining which lane they should be placed into. This is of course caused by the lack of funding for counselors and supportive staff within schools. When I was in high school, I was in the good classes and I still hardly ever talked to my counselor about classes. They never talked to me about college, class, how things were going; I couldn’t imagine if I had been placed in the lower level classes where even less attention is focused on the students. So what should be done about this problem? Should there be a flat curriculum for all students? Should the current system be kept in place? Well, as the article tells and I agree with, there needs to be a different focus towards the students. It shouldn’t be about sectioning off the privileged and giving them a better education than the rest. Rather, all students should be given an enriched, challenging, and future based curriculum so every student feels like they can succeed and they are important. Of course, this won’t be easy as the class system has been around since the beginning of the 20th century. Old traditions are hard to break, but if America wants to truly have equal education for all, it is necessary to change something. Several school districts around the country have already begun to implement new systems of their own to help eliminate the discrimination within their classrooms including a school district in long island. In my opinion, the key is to first off, make every student feel as though they matter. Unfortunately, many children have to grow up in households where they are not made to feel smart and important. Positive reinforcement to make students believe they can achieve must come first. Then, students should be placed into classes based on what they want to do. There should be more individual attention placed on each student and we need to realize that a standardized test does not accurately gauge a student’s level of achievement. Then, no matter what level of classes a student may be in they should be challenged. If a person is never challenged and forced to figure things out for themselves, they can never learn. No matter ones opinion on how to fix the discrimination caused by the tracking system, after reading the article “How Tracking Creates a Poverty of Learning” by Mary Hatwood Futrell and Joel Gomez it is clear to see that tracking systems within American schools are indeed creating discrimination between students. Although it was intended as a way to enhance student’s educations, it has become outdated and; therefore, needs to be revaluated and a new system needs to be put into place. Things are changing not only in America, but all around the world, and it looks that the traditional tracking system currently in place is just one of the next things to go.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    term paper 3

    • 11536 Words
    • 34 Pages

    To describe the specifics involved in the Magic Bullet Single Shot + appliance example and also relate information gathered from each perspective, basic legal principles are defined and applied to this context one by one. The breakdown of the analysis into understandable pieces that are then related to principles such as…

    • 11536 Words
    • 34 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Pedro Noguera’s “Unequal Outcomes, Unequal Opportunities: Closing the Achievement Gap in Berkeley” and the video “Off Track: Classroom Privilege for All”, both the video and the article talks about the negativities of the tracking system in the schools. They get into how the tracking system has divided the students in ways that we didn’t realize. Both the article and video shows how the students are put in this tracking system where not all students benefit in. There are some students, mostly minority students are put in lower level courses that is not beneficial to them or helps them reach their full potential. For a long time this tracking system has been here in many schools but yet there has not been any changes made to stop this tracking system from continuing in the schools. There are many factors that lie behind this system that would make it difficult for anyone to stop this problem.…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Analyze the specific element in the selections with some depth. Support points with appropriate examples from the selections and explain how the examples support those points. Think about what you wanted to read again, what struck you as the most profound, what you wanted to see in film, or hear aloud. Go with the impulse to study the works that were the most interesting to you. You do not need resources outside the course materials for this essay; however, you must cite the works you use from the texts.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Midterm 1 Essays

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1) Describe the three basic types of music heard in original scores during the silent film era and cites specific examples from The Birth of a Nation. (10 points)…

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Midterm Question Paper

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. (TCO 1) In the National Football League, the promotional ads are a(n) _____ resource. (Points : 5)…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two Papers For Midterm

    • 1537 Words
    • 2 Pages

    world today, where is full of exile, cultural conflict and displacement. As we discussed earlier…

    • 1537 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Jeannie Oakes's Keeping Track: How Schools Structure Inequality, her "Keeping Track" excerpt explains the way teachers estimate a students ability to learn. Tracking is a strategy used by school and teachers to separate the "cream of the crop." From an early age students are testing on their ability to learn and their overall knowledge. Students are broken down into categories, for example; fast, average and slow learners. Many times the segregation is not based on what students are capable of, rather what the teacher believes the student it capable of. Thus putting teachers (often only one) in charge of a students entire career in school. Rarely are students themselves allowed to choose their directional…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Midterm Paper

    • 3480 Words
    • 14 Pages

    When considering the moral issues of both cases of Roosevelt Dawson and the ten hour old baby, there are a few concerns that should be reflected upon. In Dawson’s case, he has lived for twenty-one years and the use of his limbs has been dramatically taken from him. His quality of life can be seen as a moral issue because he would have to relearn how to function without limbs. This could take place outside of the hospital setting and in an assisted living home, which would more than likely be frustrating. He would have to endure the stares and the stories of his paralyzed limbs. The moral issue of discharging Dawson from the hospital should be considered because he is suspected of leaving and committing assisted suicide due to his quadriplegic condition.…

    • 3480 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    School Paper

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages

    On the diagram below, what percentage of energy (from the choices in blue on the left) is transferred from a producer to a: (A) secondary consumer, (B) tertiary consumer, (C) quaternary consumer?…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    english midterm paper

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One class has really stood out to me and my grade proves it. This professor is helping to show me many different ways I can succeed here at Austin Peay State University. Thus far she has shown me several different ways to help improve my studying skills. The option of joining a study group is the best option I have made. I have joined a study group for my art class. In the beginning I was not doing so well, and then I caught drift of a study group that was being formed and I signed up. A few strengths that I have brought to my study group is that I record each of the lectures so that we can listen to certain parts. When we have the ability to re-listen to the lecture it helps us get a better understanding of what was being taught. I got this grade saving idea from my APSU 1000 instructor, Mrs. Bonnie Hodge, who suggested that we ask our instructors if we are allowed to record their lectures. My next highest grade is a two-way tie between my Art and Psychology class, both ranking in at a B. I have the opportunity to record both of their lectures, and I do so every day. Having the ability to listen to lectures at home has a huge improvement on my grades, because it allows me to listen for important information that I may have accidently missed during class. I feel that I can do better in all of these classes if I spend about another hour per week studying for each class. It is very important to me that I make the best grades possible, because I would like to be accepted into the Nursing Program. This program is very competitive because they only accept about 50 students per year. In order to be accepted into this program I must bring up my English grade to at least a B, which is satisfying to me. English is a subject that I have always struggled with throughout high school. I try to study to the best of my ability and I do well on the test, it’s just writing papers that get me. The only thing I can do is study on how to make my papers flow…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    No Child Left Behind was designed by the Bush administration to reduce the "learning gap" between different groups of students and to ensure better teacher equality. However, it sets fourth a method of measuring "Adequate Yearly Progress" which aims at 100% proficiency in 10 years time (from the start of the program) (Wood 4). These impossibly high standards cause greater harm than good. One adverse effect of these high standards is that they substantially weaken the safety nets for under-performing students in the nation's schools. As schools struggle to meet the act's impossibly high goals, many incentives to keep underperforming students out, or to hold those already in the school back present themselves. A disturbing example of this comes from King Middle School in Ohio. At this school the average scores increased from the 70th to the 72nd percentile from the 2002 to the 2003 school…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    High School and Act

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The No Child Left Behind Act is designed to raise the achievement levels of subgroups of students such as African Americans, Latinos, low-income students, and special education students to a state-determined level of proficiency. However, since its introduction in 2001, it has received a lot of criticism. Some argue the ulterior motives of the Act while others commend its innovation and timing. With the Bush administration coming to an end, it is difficult to determine what will happen to the Act or how effective it will continue to be. Hopefully future lawmakers will be able to evaluate the pros and cons of the Act and the impact it will have on our youth.…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    No Child Left Behind

    • 2624 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The No Child Left Behind Act has stacked the deck against schools with special needs. At this point in time with the 2004 elections right around the corner, it seems that this Act is taking a lot of criticism for it's rigid approach to the educational progress of our children today. No Child Left Behind has some wonderful goals and aspirations: to "close the student achievement gap, make public schools accountable, set standards of excellence for every child, and put a qualified teacher in every classroom". (http://www.NCLB.gov) In this paper I will be discussing how this new law closes "the student achievement gap" and setting "standards of excellence for every child" using some of the psychological principles that we have covered in this course. Also I will be addressing some of the flaws that this law has by not addressing some of the theories of psychological developments discussed in our text.…

    • 2624 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Common Core Standards

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Today the federal government has taken a role as a promoter of educational opportunity to students with numerous disadvantages. These disadvantages range from poverty to discrimination based on race and sex, to special education needs or even language barriers (Umpstead, 2008). Funds are supplied by the federal government for specific programs to improve educational quality; however, there may not be enough funds to cover all that is needed to make improvements. This is the controversial debate over the No Child Left Behind Act (2001). This act assisted in setting priorities when it came to education, but the accountability measures made it difficult to “use assessments as levers for good practices” (Phillips & Wong, p.38). The Common Core Standards, developed by the education team at the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation, is an education initiative that follows the basis of standards-based education. The purpose is to provide a clear and consistent understanding of what students are expected to learn. College ready is the goal. With this, parents and teachers know exactly what they need to do to help students succeed. It will allow states to work from the same core and share with one another not only what works, but also how best to teach the core.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No Child Left Behind Act

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Limited job opportunities sometimes arise because students often fall through the cracks of the school system because they are being shuffled through their school. Students are sometimes rushed through to the next grade because some teachers want to keep students in their age appropriate grade. Students are muddled through school without anyone considering whether or not these students have the skills to be promoted to the next grade. The testing associated with the No Child Left Behind Act measures a student’s skills to guarantee that the student is prepared to succeed in class. The testing forces school systems to be accountable for their students’ academic weaknesses. By increasing the level of accountability educators are now challenging themselves as well as their students to work hard to improve education.…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics