midterm

Topics: Florence, Peter Paul Rubens, David Pages: 9 (787 words) Published: June 6, 2014

Tammy Moran
Art History 225
05/17/2014
All the David’s

Peter Paul Rubens 1577-1640
David Slaying Goliath
Oil on Canvas
123x99 cm ca. 1616
Norton Simon Museum, Pasadena CA

Ruben’s work is by far the most colorful and vibrant of the nine pieces selected. It is most similar to Michelangelo’s painting (9). Showing David about to decapitate a defeated Goliath. Ruben’s Goliath is not nearly as daunting inn size as Michelangelo’s. David is stepping on the head of Goliath after stoning him from his sling and preparing to behead him. This piece has a lot of movement and compares only to Bernini’s on that level in my opinion. The angelic colorful background is unlike any of the other pieces.

Caravaggio
David and Goliath
1599
Oil on Canvas
110x91 cm
Prado

This image is very similar to the other works listed here by Caravaggio (8) & (3). I would go as far as calling them before, during, and after. They are all similar in style and color and immense shadowing. In this image a slight looking David hovers over the head of Goliath, you can hardly make out David’s face or the body of Goliath. The wound on Goliath’s head is visible and actually seems to create an optical illusion where you can see Goliath’s face toward or away from David.

Caravaggio
David with the Head of Goliath
1610
Oil on Canvas
125x101 cm
Galleria Borghese

Here a very young looking David is holding Goliath by the head. Goliath’s eyes are open and the fresh wound from the stone is visible. David looks frail but his face seems proud and intent. Goliath does not appear beast like here, he looks like a slightly larger man. This Caravaggio is similar in color and extensive shadowing to the other two pieces being discussed. They all seem kind of haunting to me, not a victorious looking celebration as some of the statues portray.

Donatello
David
1430-1440
Bronze
158 cm
Bargello

Donatello’s David is unlike Michelangelo’s statue in that it portrays an almost womanlike David. His foot is resting on the decapitated head of Goliath. The sword looks too big for him to even pick up. The bronze statue is somewhat similar to Verrocchio’s in that they both appear slightly famine and both are post victory while Bernini and Michangelo’s are marble and portray David prior to the slaying.

Michelangelo
David
1501-1504
Marble
17ft
Florence, Galleria Dell Academia

Michelangelo’s statue is huge in comparison to the other statues being discussed here. He is carved from a massive chunk of marble while the Donatello was clay cast in bronze. This depreciation is prior to the slaying as is Bernini’s (7). This massive version is said to symbolize how Florence had overcome larger enemies in the past and would do so again in the future. Michelangelo’s lifelike anatomy are clinically accurate.

Verrocchio
Statue of David
1473-5
Bronze
Museo Nationale del Bargello, Florence, Italy

Verrocchio’s David is similar to Donatella’s bronze statue of David in being slightly feminine and after slaying Goliath. His sword is more to scale. Both statues show a confident victorious David. Hand on his hip and Goliath’s head at their feet. In contrast to its counterparts by Michelangelo and Bernini in that it is after defeating Goliath and it shows a slight and feminine David instead of a muscular statuesque version.

Bernini
David
1623-24
Marble
170 cm
Galleria Borghese

Bernin’s work is most similar to Michelangelo’s David state in that it is carved from marble and shows David prior to the battle. It also depicts a young, healthy and warrior like David. In Bernini’s David is in dramatic stance showing almost palpable movement only compared to the by the work by Ruben (1). The emotion on David’s face is intense and in my mind this statue is the most powerful and life like depiction of the story of David.

Caravaggio
David with the Head of Goliath
1609-1610
Oil on...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • midterm Research Paper
  • Essay on Midterm
  • Midterm Essay
  • Midterm Essay
  • Essay on Midterm
  • Midterm Essay
  • Essay on midterm
  • Midterm Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free