Preview

Metamorphosis Cartesian Dualism Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1321 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Metamorphosis Cartesian Dualism Analysis
In the 17th century, Descartes presented the philosophy of Cartesian Dualism, with the trademark of “I think therefore I am”. Cartesian Dualism is fundamentally saying that the mind, which is an active substance, and the body, a passive substance, combine to make the living human. Thus, believing that the mind directly and absolutely affects the body, and any physical variation that may occur, while also believing that the body and physical aspects can have an affect on the mind. In Franz Kafka’s novella, The Metamorphosis, Gregor’s pessimistic mind proves to take a serious physical toll. Gregor’s life is spent as a walking salesmen to work off the debts that his family has acquired. However, although he is doing his family a great service, …show more content…
So, when Gregor’s metamorphosis occurs, and he becomes a bug, his physical state mirrors his mental attributions. However, as Gregor physically changes, there is an effect on Gregor’s mental state, leading him to further alienate himself from his family. Gregor's cycle, thus, exactly mirrors the idea of Cartesian Dualism. Therefore, in The Metamorphosis, Gregor’s ongoing metamorphosis leads to his ultimate demise, and increasing alienation from humanity.
To begin, the reader must first understand why Gregor’s metamorphosis occurs, which is simply that he is incredibly unsatisfied with his life. Before his transformation, Gregor expresses pure disdain for “the torture of traveling, worrying about changing trains, eating miserable food at all hours, constantly seeing new faces, no relationships that last or get more intimate” (Kafka 4). Here, Gregor is presenting his unhappiness in every part of his life. The interesting part is that Gregor seems to both dislike meeting new people, but is despondent that his human interaction is extremely limited. However, his need to be disconnected from society overshadows his desire to have new interactions, as Gregor explains
…show more content…
To begin, Gregor’s mental shift is seen when he begins embracing his new life as a bug. When the novella begins, Gregor explains the exasperating inconvenience of becoming an insect, but as the story develops, Gregor starts expressing less disdain and is “beginning to appreciate” some of his new features (Kafka 20). Gregor also starts to find enjoyment out things such as crawling over the walls, being in confined spaces, and eating rotten food- common attributes of roaches. Now, although Gregor is never completely content in his new state, he does seem to find a sense of warped peace, and is no rush, or even interest, in finding a solution to go back to his original state. In fact, Sokel argues that Kafka’s writing alludes to there being an “antidote” to the metamorphosis- Gregor coming to terms with the metamorphosis, as well as admitting to his secret desire to rebel against his familial expectation, which his conscious has hindered Gregor from doing (Sokel 212). Furthermore, Gregor’s mental metamorphosis continues when he stops seeking to pleasure his family, especially Grete. At the start of the novella, Gregor only seems to have love for Grete and cares deeply for her. In fact, he would conceal himself when Grete enters the room so that she will not have to see his undesirable state. But, by the end of the story, Gregor is showing tense rebellion against everyone, and even

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    He sees how much energy his family puts into him just because of his newfound situation. Gregor does his best to adjust to his new ways of life by learning more about himself, and also about his new form of outward appearance. Gregor not only looks back on himself and his new insect body, but he reflects also on his family relationship, as well as realizing how both him and his parents have now drifted further apart than before, as opposed to him and his sister’s relationship, which remains a strong bond no matter the situation. Gregor changes some of his habits as a repercussion to how he sees his family working hardly to maintain his life. In an effort to not be so much of a burden, Gregor devises a plan so his family does not have to do so much for him.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Metamorphosis,Gregor must work to support his family after they lost the company and lost all their money. One morning he wakes up and discovers he is a vermin. The first thing that occurs to him when he discovers this is how will he get to work and that his boss will come to his house and demand that Gregor come to work, meanwhile Gregor is locked in his room unable to get out of bed because he is a bug. Finally he is able to get out of bed, but the boss is gone the time he gets up. His family sees him and is disgusted and shocked by his transformatio. His sister brings him food and cares for him like no one in his family ever has, but even she becomes disgusted with him after a while. They all ignore Gregor. At one point Gregor is…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Part I of Metamorphosis, Kafka ends the part by illustrating the rejection of Gregor by emphasizing that even before his transformation in an insect; a situation which forces him to hid away from others, Gregor has always been isolated from others. Due to his job as a traveling salesman, Gregor is unable to make any friends or stay close to anyone at all for that matter, turning him into a very reclusive person (though Kafka never states is Gregor has always been this way or if is simply the job that caused this). When we come to the end of Part I, Gregor is also in extreme anxiety due to the fact that he was supporting his family and is now unable to work. This effect Gregor so much that even after he has transformed into a bug, he is still trying to find ways to be able to work. This conflict causes Gregor to feel trapped, like a bug locked in a room, hidden away under the settee.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The straightforward style of The Metamorphosis gives the story a nightmarish quality. Throughout the chapter, he struggles with the task of getting out of bed as an unidentified bug. In chapter 1 paragraph 14, it reads, “Should he really call for help though, even apart from the fact that all the doors were locked? Despite all the difficulty he was in, he could not suppress a smile at this thought” (ch1 paragraph 14). Gregor is in a serious situation, but his alarming new appearance doesn’t seem to faze him at all. His startlingly calm reaction to this bizarre situation gives the reader the sense that Gregor is emotionally detached. Gregor’s reaction is opposite of how we think he should reacted, he smiles instead of panicking. The strangeness…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gregor undergoes his metamorphosis without complaint.When he was transformed into an insect, he never questioned the cause, or attempt to take action to change his absurd condition back to normal. However, he accepts his metamorphosis by taking the physical comfort provided by his new body as an escape from his past suffering on his job as a salesman. After the removal of…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Metamorphosis If Gregor was to relive his life, he should try to escape the house instead of staying, since he brought the family down. When he became an insect, he lost his job, and the family no longer had a source of income, and they started to decline. However, keeping Gregor in the house meant the family couldn’t move to a cheaper home, seeing as they had no way to transport Gregor. Gregor’s father, his mother, and Grete all had to take on jobs and rent out Grete’s room to make enough money to stay stable. Grete was forced to clean Gregor’s room and feed him, as no one else would even try.…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gregor is also alienated both emotionally and physically after his transformation into a beetle. He at one point refers to this change as his "imprisonment." After his metamorphous, Gregor is no longer…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Franz Kafkas, “The Metamorphosis”, character, Gregor, represents, Kafka himself by symbolizing, how he was raised, his family, and his spiritual death. Just as Gregor did, Kafka had a rough relationship with his father. In 1911 Kafkas father pressured him to open asbestos factory, even through Kafka’s hated and believed he was wasting his time on this endeavor, he tried to please his father. This is represented in the book as Gregor’s attempt to provide for his family and father by taking the grueling traveling sales job he hates, in order to pay for his families previous debts he wasn’t even a part of. In the book Gregor stayed at his dreadful job, in an effort to prove his loyalty and worth to his family. Just as Gregor Kafka tried to prove himself, by educated himself more and more, by getting multiple jobs, and hiding from his true passion, writing, hoping that his worth may be measured. Another similarity shown was Kafka closeness to his sister, as was Gregor in the book. Grete was the only one of the family that would bear to see his hideous form; in order to make sure Gregor was eating. In the end Kafka died a slow death from tubercrulosis, still failing to fully please everyone. This is represented in Gregors death by, Gregor’s realization he was incapable of helping and becoming a burden on his family, he choose to die rather than live with the guilt and frustration. Kafka’s noticeable similarities give the piece a more realistic tone rather than just a made up story about a big…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Before dissecting the novella’s meaning and theme, it’s important to ask: What is the true metamorphosis which takes place? We can be inclined to state the obvious, namely Gregor’s transformation into a bug, but a deeper look into the story indicates otherwise. First of all, does Gregor truly become a bug? A look at…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gregor Metamorphosis

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Before anyone can change, they certainly have to go through a metamorphosis. Here is where life takes another form. In novels there are always certain events that make the characters change. These changes can be for good or bad. In “The Metamorphosis”, by Franz Kafka the protagonist, Gregor Samsa suffers a significant change. This novella is about a young man who has taken care of his family during the last five years. His life was limited to work and care for his family. None of the members of his family were used to work. In this family had to happen something really bad, so they can notice that they have to do something for themselves. The nature of Gregor’s reality changes insignificantly in spite of his drastic physical changes. Gregor’s metamorphosis leads an important change in the members of his family. The metamorphosis of Gregor eases the sudden change of his family, showing that a disgrace is needed in order to force people or even family, out of the stagnation and put them into life.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The tone of “Metamorphosis” is similar to the tone of “A Rose for Emily.”Gregor and Miss Emily are both isolated and alienated. The narrator says that Gregor has an “exhausting profession” as a traveling salesman. Gregor rides on a train all of the time for his work. He meets new people, but he has no affection for them. Gregor does not spend a lot of time with his family. The narrator is showing that Gregor is isolated and feels alienated from his family because he is working all the time to support his family. The narrator shows this by the other salesmen that Gregor sees at the “pension” having breakfast. Gregor states that he would “like to see what would happen if he were to try that out with his director sometime.” The narrator is implying that Gregor wants to be like the other salesman but he cannot because his boss would not allow it. Gregor always keeps his door locked whether he is traveling or at home. The narrator states, that Gregor uses “precaution” by “locking every door at night,” regardless if he is at “home or traveling.” The narrator says that Gregor’s father gave him a “truly liberating kick” back into his room and “Battered shut” the door with his cane. “Raindrops could be heard plunking against the tin window-ledges made Gregor quite melancholy.” The word “melancholy” denotes sadness or depression of sprits; gloom. Then when he wakes up as a cockroach, he is locked in his room. Gregor is isolated from his dad, mom, and sister Grete because they locked him in his bedroom at the end of the story.…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kafka's Metamorphsis

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Kafka writes in part two “Did he really want the warm room, so cozily appointed with heirlooms, transformed into a lair, where he might, of course, be able to creep, unimpeded, in any direction, though forgetting his human past swiftly and totally?” This is the point of the story when Gregor starts to come to terms with his new life as an insect. He has not completely and totally let go of human emotions, but he has started to accept his new body and embrace his new abilities. Gregor starts to feel torn between the choosing the insect life and the human life, as he still has a desire to help provide for his family, and into part three his desire turns to shame when he realizes that he financially and mentally burdening his family.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Since the Greek philosophers people have debated endlessly the extent to which the mind influences oneʼs personal reality, or even reality in general. In the Metamorphosis, the link between Gregorʼs mental and physical reality are in some way linked, and as Gregorʼs ability to function within the parameters of humanity dissipates, his physical links with the human world diminish as well. He loses his personal connection with his own body, and slowly but surely loses connection with the outside world; work and acquaintances progress along without him, and his family shuts him away as if he had never existed. But despite the authorʼs frequent superficial focus on Gregor Samsaʼs physical aspect, it is fundamentally the mental breakdown which Franz…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Metamorphosis

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the novel by Franz Kafka, “The Metamorphosis” one could say that there are many causes which leads to Gregor Samsa’s alienation. In examining Gregor’s alienation one has to review causes both before and after his metamorphosis. One has to note that Gregor could only be alienated by his family because he had no friends or significant other. Before Gregor’s metamorphosis the primary reason for his alienation was his job as a traveling salesman and the unfulfilling work schedule he had to maintain. After his metamorphosis Gregor’s physical appearance ultimately leads him to be isolated and alienated from his family. Although there are many reasons for Gregor’s alienation, his lifestyle and dedication to his family leads to his alienation and tragic demise.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The True Metamorphosis

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to Sokel, the change from human to insect occurred due to the alienation he faced from his family. That alienation continued throughout the novella, eventually leading to Gregor’s death. Several times, Sokel refers to Gregor as being a “prisoner”. For example, he writes “Gregor, an adult, is a prisoner in his own family…. On the other hand, he is a total stranger in the family and lives in their midst in the state of exile” (Sokel 164). This quote can be interpreted as saying that Gregor is trapped in his own house, and stuck there with little hope as he is not close with the rest of the Samsas. To further show his disconnect from his family, Sokel writes about Gregor’s decision to lock his door. He states “When Gregor wakes up as a vermin, his main problem, since he has locked the door of his room, is reaching the others out of his literal seclusion” (Sokel 164). For Sokel, Gregor locking his door shows that he is living in a different world from the rest of his family. Gregor did everything that he possibly could for his family, and they never really opened their arms for him. They enjoyed the rewards Gregor brought them from his labor, but never showed gratitude to him. The metamorphosis of Gregor into an insect did not just highlight how insignificant he was to his family after the transformation, but also proved the insignificance he had to them before…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays