Dear Mr. Mendel, I am very interested in your study of genetics. I also am a Naturalist and we share the same passion for God’s creation. I have known, from your studies of genetics, organisms may only pass down traits to their offspring that they were born with. This proved Lamarck’s theory to be incorrect. Your studies show many helpful genetic facts. One of which is all members of a species are all different in some way. This ties together part of my own theory called Natural Selection. I too believe that all organisms are born with different variations. Variations that help to get food or escape from predators will help that animal survive. Then, those animals will reproduce offspring with the helpful variation. Your genetic studies reinforce my theory of Natural Selection. One of our few differences is that you conduct controlled experiments, while I simply observe nature. Much of my work took place while sailing on the Beagle around South America and Africa. I observed the natural life and took notes. You seem to like working in a laboratory while I like to explore the world and see nature as it happens. Our methods of study are almost opposite, but both reveal much information.
Every organism’s difference is a variation. While I traveled to the Galapagos, I noticed many variations in the finch species. From island to island, each finch bird has a different type of beak. I hypothesize this is because each island has different food sources so each bird adapted to their environment. Some have sharp, thin beaks to separate insects while others on different islands have shorter beaks to pick seed off the ground. I understand that in your research with peas you have found out that offspring inherit only traits that the parents were born with. I formed similar thoughts about the finches. As you may be thinking, my theory is very controversial within the church. Most people think low upon me for believing my theory. Some say Natural Selection is going against the churches belief of the Genesis written in the Bible. Fortunately for you, you are part of the monastery. You have your colleagues to support your ideas and thoughts. I am in the process of writing book to express my ideas to the people. I hope my ideas will be revolutionary and change the thoughts of evolution. My wish is that society will someday find value in my research, even if it is rejected by the church in present. Sincerely, Charles Darwin
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Evolution, ever since its introduction by James Hutton in the early 1700s, has been a very controversial topic with many people opposing the various theories presented by scientists throughout the years. In modern science, evolution has come to be accepted by many scientists around the world, with significant amounts of evidence from various fields of science provided to support Charles Darwin’s theory of naturally selective evolution - “survival of the fittest” and adaptation.…
- 1072 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
There have been many theories that explain how evolution occurred. Charles Darwin, on the book Origin of Species, spoke about how traits are passed on from generations to generations by natural selection. In addition, he stated how there are four objections to the theory of natural selection, how species can win the struggle for existence through natural selection, and how the origin of species challenges religion.…
- 652 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The finches on Darwin and Wallace Islands feed on seeds produced by plants growing on these islands. There are three categories of seeds: soft seeds, produced by plants that do well under wet conditions; seeds that are intermediate in hardness, produced by plants that do best under moderate precipitation; and hard seeds, produced by plants that dominate in drought conditions. Evolution Lab is based on a model for the evolution of quantitative traits–characteristics of an individual that are controlled by large numbers of genes. These traits are studied by looking at the statistical distribution of the trait in populations and investigating how the distribution changes from one generation to the next. For the finches in EvolutionLab, the depth of the beak is the quantitative trait. You will investigate how this trait changes under different biological and environmental conditions.…
- 4577 Words
- 19 Pages
Good Essays -
Conclusion: The purpose of this lab is to be able to work with different tools that will serve to model finch “beaks” and compete with other “finch” species to see which “beak” best adapted for obtaining specific food. Characteristics of my “beak” that interfered with the feeding success on the original island was that I had to use two hands and the “beak” would lock up. Three traits other than beak characteristics that could contribute to the ability of a finch to compete successfully would be speed, body size, and eye-sight. It’s very unlikely that all of the beaks within a species of finch are exactly alike. Random mutations and new gene combinations resulting from sexual reproduction are the source of beak variations. Three beak variations that could randomly appear and improve my species’ chances of survival when feeding would be a long beak, a scooped beak, and a wider beak. Some “beak” types survive on the new island (with large seeds) when they could not survive on the original island is there was more surface area to latch…
- 299 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
-Lamarck hypothesized that organisms evolved through inheritance of acquired characteristics, where the body is modified due to use or disuse or parts & that all organisms have innate drive for perfection. He was incorrect in that acquired characteristics are not inherited as Mendel and genetics had not been discovered yet.…
- 2651 Words
- 11 Pages
Good Essays -
A controversial concern was brought fourth by Stephen Gould n “Nonmoral Nature”, by posing the question: “If God is good and if creation reveals his goodness, why are we surrounded with pain, suffering, and apparently senseless cruelty in the animal world?” (Gould) Gould utilizes existence to illustrate the idea of evil being restricted to human beings and that the world of nature is undisturbed with it. To some extent, Gould may be accurate in his hypothesis that nature is undisturbed with evil. The implication of nature’s cruelty has stirred our understanding for some time. It undoubtedly weighed deeply on Darwin as he developed his theory of evolution by means of natural selection.…
- 795 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Darwin’s theory of evolution is based on the theory of natural selection. Natural selection is the the process whereby organisms better adapted to their environment tend to survive and produce more offspring. This theory is now widely believed by many people throughout the world. Charles Darwin’s theory includes the idea that fossils of extinct animals turn up where similar animals live today. Darwin came up with this theory when he discovered fossils of animals that were very similar to the animals that were living today. Darwin also observed that the Galapagos tortoise’s had different shapes of their shells depending on which island they came from. Darwin believed that these tortoises were adapting to their environment by changing their shell…
- 235 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
So the first thing I did to conduct this experiment was go the Evolution Lab website. From there, I manipulated the traits from each population of finches, as well as their environmental conditions. Then I adjusted the traits and environment of the finches. For the finches on Darwin…
- 954 Words
- 4 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection more independent,they are produced by each generation that can continue to live. Also Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection phenotypic change exists surrounded by single and the difference is heritable. Which those individuals with the heritable traits can be better acceptable to the environment by willing to survive. When the Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection reproductive isolation take place when new species will form. Variation is a characteristic of natural populations and every population make more progeny than it is in our environment that can…
- 97 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In EvolutionLab, beak size is a trait that affects survival. Birds with small beaks are more efficient at utilizing small soft seeds whereas birds with large beaks are better at utilizing large hard seeds. Therefore, when more small seeds available, birds with small beaks have a higher rate of survival than birds with large beaks. Conversely, when more large seeds available, birds with large beaks have a higher rate of survival than birds with small beaks. Thus, beak size satisfies the first condition listed above. In EvolutionLab we can control for the variation in beak size and the heritability of beak size. This allows us to experimentally test Darwin’s second and third points listed above.…
- 512 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The founder of genetics, Gregor Mendel, showed that parents passed genes to offspring. Genes code for traits. For example, Mendel demonstrated that a single gene codes for the color green in peas. A single gene also codes for the color yellow in peas. The geneticists who followed Mendel had no difficulty extrapolating his findings to the rest of life. Of particular interest was the role of heredity in humans. In a casual way, people had long appreciated the importance of heredity, noting for example that a child looked strikingly like his or her mother. Geneticists sought to formalize observations of this kind, tracing, for example, the transmission of the gene for brown eyes through several generations of a family. In the course of this work it was natural for geneticists to wonder whether intelligence and traits of character were inherited with the lawlike regularity that Mendel had observed with simple traits in…
- 14350 Words
- 58 Pages
Better Essays -
Comparison of Darwinism and Lamarckism Charles Darwin and Jean-Baptiste Lamarck had a scientific debate about the process of evolution. Darwin’s theory of evolution is by natural selection. Organisms change over time as a result of heritable physical and behavioural trait changes. The changes were due to the genes in the gene pool due to environmental pressures. For example: skull shape, fur colour, teeth shape, digestion of seal fat etc. The changes allow organisms to adapt better to the environment which will help it survive and have more offspring. Lamarck’s Theory of Inheritance of Acquired Characteristics is the use and disuse of an organism. An organism changes during life in order to adapt to the environment, those changes are passed on to its offspring.…
- 1075 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
~Mendel's hypothesis of inheritance supported Darwin's theory of natural selection because Mendel's theory accounts for the more subtle variations within a population that are central to natural selection.…
- 1633 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Gregor Mendel was a very determined, well-knowledgeable man, who grew up to do many great things. Mendel had an extraordinary life filled with amazing discoveries and achievements, but just like many other people he had his ups and downs in life. Gregor Mendel was faced with many things that could've brought him down and not let him exceed in life, but he did not let that get in the way of his future.…
- 876 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Have you ever wondered why people resemble their parents? The answer to this and other questions about inheritance lies in a specialized branch of biology called genetics. Geneticist found that most aspects of life have a hereditary basis and that many traits can appear in more than one form. For instance, human beings have blond, or red, or brown, or black hair. They may have one of several different types of blood, one or several colors of skin. Their ear lobes may be attached or free. They may or may not be able to manufacture certain enzymes. Some of these traits are much more important to the life of the individual than others, but all of them are hereditary. The geneticist is interested not only in the traits of man but in those of all other organisms as well.…
- 1801 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays