Preview

Melville's "Bartleby the Scrivener": Humorous or Tragic?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
929 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Melville's "Bartleby the Scrivener": Humorous or Tragic?
If ever there are two opposite themes offered in the telling of one tale, it is in Herman Melville's short story, "Bartleby the Scrivener". As his perspective swings between the objective and subjective, so swings the theme from comedy to tragedy. Regardless of the two perspectives from which Herman Melville relates the story of Bartleby, the telling of a tragic story with humorous subjectivity, the story's plot and outcome determines the categorization. In fact, had Melville not peppered the story with his narrative, light-hearted, internal musings, and shared with the audience a "grasping at straw" style of rationalization, the main theme could only have been categorized as tragic. Regardless of the two perspectives from which Herman Melville relates the story of Bartleby, the telling of a tragic story sprinkled with humorous subjectivity, the actual story line, through its progression should determine its categorization. For this reason, Bartleby the Scrivener, is a tragedy.

Throughout the story Melville relates the many troubling incidents experienced with the mysterious copier. Bartleby's reactions to his superior are so unlike those which most of us have ever experienced, human nature causes the reader to attempt to apply logic to his eccentricities. When asked to proofread a copy, Bartleby's outrageous answer is, "I prefer not to". Having just been introduced to Bartleby and still formulating a first impression, the audience is required to grapple with a logical explanation for his troubling behaviour. At that point, Melville introduces his first bit of comic relief, enlisting the audience's empathy in stating, "To befriend Bartleby; to humour him in his strange wilfulness will cost me little or nothing, while I lay up in my soul what will eventually prove a sweet morsel for my conscience". Since there is no excusing Bartleby's behaviour, Melville finds solace in rationalizing his reaction and the reader is quick to empathize, having found no explanation

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The lawyer starts to feels sympathetic towards him while disliking the passiveness that he shows. His contributions to the lawyer feelings shows that he is starts to get a compassion for another human being who is less than he. Once a man about his business and the success he was gaining; he changes into a person of patience and compassion. Bartleby was taken to jail where he was held until his death and while he was there, the narrator visited and made it his priority to get Bartley the best care such as paying to have him get the best food. Despite the fact that he did not eat, he still received that care. The point of change was when the lawyer realized that he dies and cries out “Ah, Bartleby!Ah, humanity!” (174), which is when he felt a sense of change on how he see the human culture for the impact that it has on Bartleby while he worked at the Dead Letter Office. Though he will never understand Bartleby and his passive resistance nature, he sympathized with him as a person that once was he great scrivener worker. Bartleby contributed to this change because of his firm attitude throughout the story. The lawyer could not quite comprehend this man, but was eager to and in the process became closer to him. Many themes came to mind as I read this story, but only two stands out the…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Monkey’s Paw” written by W.W. Jacobs was not the best written short story using literary terms including characterization in many ways. For characters, it gives the reader hardly any details about the characters. This makes it difficult for the reader to make a good connection to the story. The reader only knows some of the relationships between the character’s, but barely any personality traits. “The Gift of the Magi” written by O. Henry was not the best written short story using literary terms such as conflict either. The conflict that was identified in this story was not very important. There were many other ways to solve their problem, and also avoid the situational irony that occurred at the end of the story. “Man from the South” written by Roald Dahl was not the best written short story using literary terms such as a strong situational irony as well. For situational irony, it wasn’t shocking that the old man was up to something suspicious. From the beginning of the story, you could tell that the old man was trying to mess with the young boy and trying to fool him and make him do something that he might regret later. It was no surprise to the reader that he was going to do something unexpected and that he would turn out to be hiding…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through showing this inner conflict within Captain Vere, Melville demonstrates one the major themes of this work. Throughout Billy Budd, we see the struggle of whether to obey the law. This is hinted upon early in the book when the narrator tells us of the “Great Mutiny” which had recently passed. This conflict was of seamen who revolted against their seniors. We see this again when Billy Budd is visited by an afterguard who asks for Billy to join an uprising. Billy is quick to decline, knowing that it is much better to obey the law than to appose…

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His corpse-like disposition is reflected not only in his pallid appearance, but in his strangely calm manner. “Bartleby’s strange inertness quickly transforms into an eerie question of life and death” (Reed). After his death, there is a reference to the Grim Reaper as the Narrator comments on Bartleby's previous employment in the Dead Letter Office. There is also the idea of undeliverable letters that "speed to death," even when they go "on errands of life” (Melville). While symbolically, Bartleby’s death was caused by his withdrawal into apathy, it is physically caused by his refusal to…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The lawyer is shocked and captivated by Bartleby’s responses, and he begins to monitor him closely. The lawyer finds Bartleby’s life to be entirely melancholy. Bartleby never seems to leave the office, meet with friends, or talk to anyone at all. Bartleby has completely isolated himself from society. In fact, the lawyer stops by his business one Sunday to discover Bartleby has been living in the office, which means he has most likely not left since his recruitment. Eventually, Bartleby’s hardworking attitude comes to an end when he tells the lawyer he will no longer write and begins to sit at his desk doing nothing all day. When the lawyer asks why he has stopped working, Bartleby indifferently replies, “Do you not see the reason for yourself?” Bartleby’s reply reflects the nihilistic thinking of a man who can no longer find a reason to live and is unable to act as he believes everything he does is insignificant. Bartleby’s somber…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    One day, when Bartleby is asked to help proofread one of the documents he copied, he answers simply, "I would prefer not to" (Melville 159). This is the first of many refusals. The Lawyer makes several attempts to reason with Bartleby and learn about him, but Bartleby always responds the same way when asked to do tasks or provide any information about himself by stating, "I would prefer not to"(Melville159). One weekend, when the Lawyer stops by his office, he discovers that Bartleby is living there. The loneliness of Bartleby's life struck the Lawyer, and he didn’t know whether to pity him or have contempt regarding Bartleby's bizarre…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many tales are told in Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales. Probably the greatest on is "The Pardoner's Tale". A greedy Pardoner who preaches to feed his own desires tells "The Pardoner's Tale". This story contains excellent examples of verbal, situational, and dramatic irony.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Authors use many literary elements, such as figurative language, to write out the theme of their stories. In the two short stories, “Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allan Poe and “The Most Dangerous Game” by Richard Connell, the themes are described by literary elements. “The Cask of Amontillado” is about a man trying to get revenge by tricking another man telling him about having expensive wine. “The Most Dangerous Game” is an eccentric short story about a General who lives on an island and hunts humans. The theme of irony delineate the themes for both of the short stories.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However Emerson used Bartleby’s isolation as a plot to express the narrators true feelings toward Bartleby. The narrator never faithfully cared for Bartleby, and was only favorable…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From “Bartleby the Scrivener,” we see that he is able to make his own decisions, not matter how illogical they seem, due to the fact he is male. Throughout his tale, Bartleby loiterers in the office of his workplace for an unrelenting amount of time, and when his boss begs him to leave the establishment, Bartleby only responds with, “I would prefer not.” He continues along this illogical chain of responses and eventually ends up in jail due to the grievances against him. Additionally, Bartleby chooses to not each one scrap or morsel when he is imprisoned, and he eventually starves himself to death. This chain of events was set into action due to the poor and illogical choices of Bartleby. However, Bartleby’s decisions were uncontested by his employer, or others, because he was thought to be just be a strange male. In addition to this, Bartleby is even offered an opportunity, but never forced to concede to it. In order to influence Bartleby to leave his business, his boss bribes him to leave the office and never return. He even says that he only “owe[s] [Bartleby] twelve dollars on account,” but in order to cure his Bartleby induced headache, he offers him a generous amount of “thirty-two [dollars].” This moment shows how Bartleby is being an unemotional or strong-willed man. In Bartleby’s situation,…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history many authors and their works of literature have been studied and pondered upon in order to fully understand them. Amongst these works of literature are two great pieces, Oedipus the King, by Sophocles, and A Doll’s House, by Henrik Johan Ibsen. Both authors tell empowering stories about unveiling the truth and empowerment in marriage yet the way Sophocles and Ibsen go about telling these stories is very different. A tragic hero is one that has many characteristics and through both of these plays readers gain insight on how these characters are true tragic heroes by them displaying a scene of suffering, a tragic flaw, and a tragic dilemma.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    -There’s only one story. “When a new work is created, it is set among the monuments, adding to and altering the order.” –T.S. Eliot…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The narrator attempts to learn about Bartleby and help him. No matter what the narrator does, even going beyond what most employers would do for an employee meet with failure. A similar situation exists in “Death of a Salesman” with Willy Loman being offered a steady job within Charley’s (neighbor and only friend) business. Charley has been loaning Willy Loman money since he started working on commission so that Willy’s wife would thing that nothing is wrong. Charley continues the offer of employment but the answer is always no because Willy is forever on the brink of moving up at his current company.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Todd F. Davis wrote a critical essay about Herman Melville’s story, “Bartleby, The Scrivener.” Davis critical essay is called, “The Narrator’s Dilemma In “Bartleby The Scrivener”: The Excellently Illustrated Re-statement of a Problem.” His thesis is, “Therefore, if we contend we know anything of Bartleby, it is only what the narrator knows of Bartleby, and if we are to have any insight into the narrator, it must be through the examination of his own words (184). Davis critical essay focuses on the relationship between Bartleby and the narrator through the narrator perspective.…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Marx, L. (1970) ‘Melville 's Parable of the walls ' in Bartleby the Inscrutable: A Collection of commentary on Herman Melville 's Tale ‘Bartleby the Scrivener ', (ed.) M.T. Ing. Hamden.…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays