Mccaskey Case

Powerful Essays
Topics: Ethics
Analysis: Martha McCaskey

Harvard Business Review

The Issue:

This case focuses on Martha McCaskey. McCaskey is a relatively recent Harvard B-School grad on the fast track at Seleris Associates. She is a consultant who specializes in competitive analysis for corporations.

McCaskey has been assigned as lead on project Silicon 6. She has a strong track record for delivering quality on her projects, which is why she was chosen as lead for this project. The focus of the project is to reverse engineer cost structure and manufacturing processes for the competitor of a key client of Seleris. This unnamed client is responsible for 20% of the revenue for this division. Therefore, the head of the division is invested in making this customer happy. The top managers promised McCaskey a promotion if she could successfully complete the project to the satisfaction of the client.

McCaskey is extremely resourceful, but in the case of Silicon 6, she was having trouble gaining access to the required information. That is, until she tripped across an ex-employee of the competitor company who was eager to share proprietary information. McCaskey found this unethical.

McCaskey brought the situation to the attention of her management. The managers, eager to please the clients, have encouraged McCaskey to “pay off” the ex-employee in exchange for the necessary information. Management has challenged her to come up with an action plan for the project and to meet with the head of the division to review the plan.

Analysis and Opinion:

McCaskey is faced with an ethical dilemma. In this case, she must decide whether to accept proprietary information, which will result in a satisfied client and a promotion or follow her moral compass and attain the information using ethically acceptable industry standards.

This is a clear case of an organization with a questionable ethical climate. An organization with high ethical standards encourages and shapes the behavior of its

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Mccaskey Case Analysis

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Martha McCaskey case analysis Background McCaskey, 29, a HBS graduate, worked in the Seleris’s Industry Analysis Division (IAD), a consulting firm in San Francisco branch. Her jobs were to analyst and report the competitive advantages of competitor companies to her clients. The employees of this company were separated into two groups, old and new guard. The members in old guard such as Rendall and Kaufmann often paid ex-employees of target companies to obtain highly sensitive information. IAD’s…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    McCaskey

    • 720 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Martha McCaskey: Is business bluffing ethical? 1. What is troubling Martha McCaskey? Do you agree with her assessment of the situation? Martha McCaskey is facing an issue easy to solve for those who have no sense of morality: she needs to decide to compromise her values, or not; to cross the line separating hard-working employee and industrial espionage between companies, or not. McCaskey is a woman with an outstanding resume who has demonstrated several times that is able to work at 110% for the…

    • 720 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    McCaskey Case Analysis

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Martha McCaskey is a recent employee of Seleris Associates’ Industry Analysis Division. She has been working for the consulting company for the past eighteen months. Throughout this time, her supervisors and managers have been very satisfied with the work she has been performing for their company. Not only does she perform group assignments by herself, but she also conducts thorough research, and completes her assignments in an outstanding, and timely manner. As a result of her outstanding work,…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Martha McCaskey

    • 1555 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Introduction Martha McCaskey had arrived at an impasse in her career requiring her to confront a decision which put her integrity and possible career advancement in opposition. McCaskey’s choice came down to how she handled Phil Devon, an ex-employee with knowledge of proprietary information McCaskey needed for a client. Obtaining the information through Devon would earn McCaskey a significant promotion and salary increase. However, doing so under the false pretenses she had constructed challenged…

    • 1555 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Martha Mccaskey

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages

    San Francisco mainly because much of the demand came from California and Silicon Valley, the senior vice president; Richardson was well connected with California. IAD was staffed entirely with outsiders. Intro about the members in the case study: Martha McCaskey: completed her MBA from Harvard University and joined Seleris as project lead for silicon 6 study. Ty Richardson: senior vice president Tom Malone: vice President Bill Davis and Bud Hackert: group managers Phil Devon: he had been vice…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Martha Mccaskey Case Study

    • 3391 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Martha McCaskey The Seleris Associates Industry Analysis Case Study Abstract For the past 18 months Martha McCaskey has been an exemplary performer with high integrity and been assigned as a project leader to a crucial high profile project named Silicon 6. Upon successful completion of Silicon 6, McCaskey has been promised a promotion to group manager. McCaskey is being pressured by senior management to finish the project and have an action plan to present to the client. Now she has some options…

    • 3391 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mccaskey Summary

    • 2163 Words
    • 9 Pages

    6/12/2013 Martha McCaskey Marco Rangel lEADERSHIP AND BUSINESS ETHICS The following is a summary of the case study which narrates the ethical problem that Martha McCaskey, faces during her work or a particular project she is heading. She has to decide between paying Devon (another consultant) for information she needs for her analysis on the Silicon 6 project, or abandon the project altogether to maintain the integrity of her company and in the process loose the recognition from her…

    • 2163 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martha Mccaskey Case

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages

    After analyzing the case, I believe that Martha should not pay Devon $7,000 for the proprietary information. Even though Martha has been promised a pay raise, a promotion and a bonus by her managers to close the Silicon 6 deal, she must stay true to her consciences and not proceed with the meeting. In fact, I recommend that she resign as a member of the IAD division of Seleris and search for a job at a different consulting firm. As an outsider looking in on this situation, I believe that Martha…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    James Mccaskey Case

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages

    James McCauley has over thirty years of financial services industry and management consulting experience. Throughout his career he has leveraged his deep industry expertise to help a wide variety of financial services clients to develop new products, transform business operations, implement technology and manage risk. His past consulting engagements include work in business lines such as payments, wholesale banking, treasury/cash management, custody banking, retail banking, private banking, mortgage…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martha Mcaskey Case Analysis Akshay Shende – IS 578 The Problem The major parties involved in this case are the group managers and executives within Seleris Associates’ IAD division, and Martha McCaskey (senior associate). From the management’s perspective, the problem is to find the most effective way to glean useful competitive information for the division’s clients. This is essentially the mission of the division and its very raison d’etre. Martha McCaskey being a part of the IAD division is…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays