Preview

Analysis of Manet’s Dejeuner Sur l’herbe Commenting on Composition and Relationship

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
665 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis of Manet’s Dejeuner Sur l’herbe Commenting on Composition and Relationship
Ned Hillsborough 24th September
Analysis of Manet’s Dejeuner Sur l’herbe commenting on: composition and relationship between the figure and setting, depiction of space and depth, light and shadow, use of colour

Manet composes the painting in such a way that the subject matter and general acquisition of mood are addressed immediately. The mood seems controversially relaxed at once due to the casual seating of the men despite their formal wear, as well as being sat with a nude woman – a rare sight as her clothes are messily in a heap at the front right part of the picture. Any potential visual imbalance is countered by the space towards the back right of the picture, despite it appearing there are more elements on the left side of the picture. The picture is further balanced by the lines of trees, creating two rows back into the distance, and the river being at the centre of the photo harmonises the sense of balance. Not only do the trees suggest equality, but they direct the eyes toward the centre of the photo where the three people sit in conversation; the absence of a near tree on the right hand side is made up for by the man in black, who points the eye towards the naked lady in the middle. The colours are more detailed towards the front of the painting, and there is also a clear contrast between defined figure and more lax flowing ground throughout the painting. The real contrast in colour is from foreground to back, as the foreground has more blacks (although it seems no darker) whereas the background is lighter; this suggests a sense of recession in light intensity as the front is surrounded by trees whereas towards the back there is more space, therefore appearing lighter. Manet uses various techniques to create space and depth, as well as his variation of light and dark colours. The trees become smaller as they go towards the difference, and their trunks become less defined suggesting they are out of the immediate sight of the painter

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Even though she uses one mountain as the main focus, in the background there are other mountains and road leading into the distance. In the forefront of the painting there are trees and the road. I think that balance is more informal or asymmetrical because of the main focus of the one mountain, but somehow…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Battcock Analysis

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The contrasting colors have a major effect in this painting. The light blue wall in the back looks like a dazzling blue sky on a sunny day, but directly behind the men two darkened shadows lurk like massive storm clouds. The…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The contrast in this painting is used to draw one’s attention to the center of the photo, where the light is illuminating the objects around it. The type of balance in this painting is radial, since the candle light radiates outward from the center in a circular fashion. The emphasis of the candle light makes it unavoidable to the viewer. Also, the woman’s deep gaze into the light draws attention to it as well. The space around the focal point allows the viewer to focus only on that, because it is plain with no distractions.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this painting, Thomas Cole used the Monocular Cues Relative size, Interposition, and atmospheric perspective to represent depth in his painting. Relative size is perception that occurs when objects that a person expects to be of a certain size appears to be much smaller and is therefore assumed to be much further away. The trees and people are an example of that. While they seem to be of normal size in the front of the picture, they get smaller and smaller as the picture gets “deeper“. Since the normal human mind knows that trees do not have the size of a thumb, it is assumed that the other people and trees in the painting are further away, creating depth.…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One can see his interest in light and reflection through his use of blues to create the many shadows. Dow uses atmospheric perspective heavily throughout the top third of the painting. This helps enhance and further the illusion of depth. The middle and foreground have weight to them and are relatively realistic in rendering. However, the background loses its form and rather becomes somewhat abstracted and more about color. There is only the impression of the remaining canyon. The lines of the rock formations lead the eye diagonally across the entirety of the canvas towards the foreground. The most contrast is found between the foreground and the background, and this reinforces the sense of depth. Therefore, the immensity of the canyon pushes the idea of awe.…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first thing to note is the overall composition of the painting. First and foremost it is a landscape painting. The colors are very monochrome; the space is stretched to reveal a depth to the painting that the eye cannot capture; and there is stillness to the art that embraces nature and serenity of life. In the right-hand corner of the painting there is calligraphy. The calligraphy lacks the precision, but is very clear in its form, much like the depiction within the painting itself.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Red Tree depicts a young girl moving about her days almost consumed by depression and sadness. However Tan indicates that even when things seem overwhelming there is hope for a better day. In illustration ___ we see the salient image of a young girl trapped in a bottle by her oversized diving helmet. Her posture clearly indicates that she is unhappy and the bottle is slowly filling with water. There is no chance of escape as her oversized helmet clearly will not fit out the narrow neck of the bottle. Tan’s effective use of dark blue and grey further conveys the sombre mood and difficulty the young girl is facing. Through effective use of vector lines the viewer’s eyes are drawn along the horizon to contrasting white clouds, symbolising perhaps that there is hope on the horizon. Tan further emphasizes the sadness consuming the protagonist in illustration __. The salient image of a gigantic fish hangs over the young girl walking alone along a city street. The fish’ gaping mouth creates a vector line to the young girl who is hunched over and clearly unhappy, as she remains in the shadow of the fish while everyone else goes about their business ignoring her. Again, Tan’s…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This piece of art was created by Claude Monet. He is known as the classic impressionist. In this painting, he captures the ever-changing nature of light and color. Unlike a lot of paintings, you can see the brush strokes in this painting. But I believe that the brush strokes used help create the piece of art and they help show the leaves and flowers on the trees. Also, it helps make the clouds in the sky look more hazy and beautiful.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the left-bottom corner of the painting, the viewer is presented with a rugged-orangish cliff and on top of it, two parallel dark green trees extending towards the sky. This section of the painting is mostly shadowed in darkness since the cliff is high, and the light is emanating from the background. A waterfall, seen originating from the far distant mountains, makes its way down into a patch of lime-green pasture, then fuses into a white lake, and finally becomes anew, a chaotic waterfall(rocks interfere its smooth passage), separating the latter cliff with a more distant cliff in the center. At the immediate bottom-center of the foreground appears a flat land which runs from the center and slowly ascends into a cliff as it travels to the right. Green bushes, rough orange rocks, and pine trees are scattered throughout this piece of land. Since this section of the painting is at a lower level as opposed to the left cliff, the light is more evidently being exposed around the edges of the land, rocks, and trees. Although the atmosphere of the landscape is a chilly one, highlights of a warm light make this scene seem to take place around…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    mlk paper

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the upper left hand corner of the painting it has darker hues, warm temperatures with contour lines, and it causes a feeling of darkness. As you move to the right side of the painting it starts to lighten up with bright cool hues such as yellow. The painting seems to brighten up as you move along the right, seems less chaotic and has more of a happy feeling. The contour lines moves your eyes right along…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dorothea Tanning

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From the muted, sickly green of the walls, to the stark contrast of the blood-red carpet, color plays an important role in setting the tone of this piece. Correspondingly, the colors used in the chief subjects of the painting (young girls, sunflower, carpet) are less organic than the hues used for the more subtle areas of the painting (walls, door, steps). The neutral tones of the background help to “corral” the viewer's eye into looking at the focal point and the action happening around it. In the same token, Tanning’s use of complementary colors allows the red carpet to seemingly “cut” through the painting, providing a perfect backdrop for the vibrancy of the yellow sunflower. The two girls are dressed in white, yet, the figure against the door frame carries semblances from the sunflower and the carpet, represented in her cardigan and the petal she holds. The two lost petals at the foot of the stairs become almost an afterthought when compared to the stark hue of the sunflower, as they are slightly more muted shade of yellow. Finally, the open door at the end of the hallway leaves the viewer with many unanswered questions. Upon first glance, the hazy warm tones may convey a sense of an emblazoned fire, but upon further inspection, it could simply be the light of a hotel lamp flooding the hallway. What is happening behind the door? Is this where the girls came from, and if so will they return? Tanning leaves all these questions up in the air with her use of ambiguity in the focus and color of the final…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Passing Storm

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In oil paintings many layers of colors are layered on top of one other and brush strokes are usually visible, but in this particular piece they are barley visible to express a realism of a photo. The landscape is extremely detailed to idealize nature in a painting with imperfections shown in the crooked shaped trees and rough texture of the rocks and shore. Albert’s perspective was designed to draw the viewer in, so the landscape was most likely altered to create an ideal view that wasn’t present in reality.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Marvelous Sauce

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What first catches the viewer 's eyes are the vivid colors used in the painting. Ultimately what jumps out the most is the man on the right 's red robe. The artist intended this for a reason, discussed later. The room where the men are standing is front lit. Also the atmosphere is not hazy. There is no hint of sffumato. It is very much unlike the Romantic works produced earlier in the century. Rather the edges of the figures and of other objects in the picture plane are clearly defined. The artist "renders every object in the painting with meticulous clarity" (Smith 1). To see this work in person is really quite impressive. The painter has achieved a great sense of depth in the painting, as well as a strikingly realistic quality. The picture taken for this paper from the Albright-Knox 's web page simply does not do this work justice. One 's experience of standing in front of this painting is that of awe. The artist has depicted everything in the scene so realistically, and yet has made it look better than it probably did in real life. Everything in the painting has a rich, glowing quality about it.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Art App. Paper

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is a painting on the wall in the background that balances the table of the lonely woman who sits at the front of the picture. Her table top is light in color showing us, like the light of her blouse, which these objects are in the direct of a light source. The further back you look into the painting, the darker the surfaces, with the exception of the light colored table that the two men are sitting at. It makes you feel that there is may be a connection between the lonely woman, who is looking in their direction, and them. The room is smokey, as painted with the off white diagonal lines going across the painting over the four people in the background.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Scream Analysis

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The bold curved lines of the sky flow directly into the figure and endure to form the body of the individual. Van Gogh uses long, heavy yet equal brushstrokes to express feelings and motion. Motion is the main element in this painting Vertical lines such as the tree and church tower delicately breaks up the composition without withdrawing from the powerful night sky. Van Gogh's use of white and yellow creates a twisting result and draws attention to the sky. And the usage of color to send emotion. Munch also used colors that were contrast between hot and cold colors, contrast of complimentary. By using artless forms, Munch is able to force his viewers to focus on the emotions that the sight and subject secrete rather than simply viewing an exact picture of one particular scene. The cautious use of balance also helps the viewers understand the indirect consequence of The Scream. Munch placed the unpleasant figure in the focal point and attains a sense of balance by inserting two smaller figures who are walking into the scorching sunset in the distance on the left side and by creating a dominant arch in the upper right hand corner. But the focal point created by Van Gogh is the tree-like structure projecting out on the bottom…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays