Preview

"Man to Send Rain Clouds": A Compormise in Cultural Identity - exhibits how the loss of culture can happen in society.

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
541 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"Man to Send Rain Clouds": A Compormise in Cultural Identity - exhibits how the loss of culture can happen in society.
Culture instills a significant role in family life. Family traditions are often passed down from one generation to the next, and usually produce added complexity from outside influence over time. The original identity of the belief continues to be apparent, although more ideas have been added to the basic cultural belief. In Leslie Silko's short story, "The Man to send Rain Clouds", this predicament arises. Although a constant influence of Catholic beliefs are apparent in the Pueblo people's society, Leon and his family still display their Native American identity through their actions present throughout the story.

Silko explains that her people "were well informed about [culture]," and that "old traditions were dying out" (Silko, "Language" 772). The local Catholic Church's minister, Father Paul, attempts to incorporate the Church's teaching into the Laguna's way of life. He shows great concern for Leon and his family "miss[ing] [Mass] last Sunday," (Silko, "Man" 50), and requests the family to attend the following weekend. Father Paul successfully influences Leon's sister, Louise. When she finds out about her grandfather's death, she suggests incorporating the ritual of pouring holy water on his gravesite "so he won't be thirsty" (Silko, "Man" 50).

Although Catholic interference tries to influence the Native Pueblo culture, Leon constantly attempts to retain his Native identity. When Leon and Ken discover their Grandfather dead in the arroyo, they immediately perform the Native Pueblo customs. The customs included the painting of their grandfather's face, tying a feather to his hair, wrapping him in a red blanket, and tossing cornmeal into the wind. By performing these rituals, they "[keep] the family ... and clan together" (Silko, "Language" 766), showing the great importance they hold upon their cultural beliefs. When transferring grandfather Teofilo back into town, Leon and Ken deceivingly tell Father Paul that "[Teofilo] won't [be herding sheep] any more

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ceremony novel is full of emotions from the beginning to the end. It started with the trauma of Tayo when he thought he was shooting crowd of Japanese soldiers, in which his uncle Josiah was among. This novel portrayed the fearful feeling people show to change. For instance, the Night Swan showed a level of prejudice when she described some interracial relationships as “fools”. Also, this expression reveal the ignorance of the community toward mixed ethnic group. The lack of appreciation toward earth was expected to improve in the white community and increase within the Native Americans community. Tayo learned how to return the love and kindness that earth shows to us by providing rains, animals, and plants. Tayo example of respecting and loving…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Good morning, Father. We were just out to the sheep camp. Everything is O.K. now." (Silko 694) Silko alters the short story to accommodate the process of cultural assertion and adaptation. The simplicity of her style seems a strange, unconventional way of storytelling. Silko does not describe her characters physically or psychologically, or develop much sense of individual personality. Ken and Leon say almost nothing to each other and almost nothing about themselves. Ken and Leon say nothing when they find Teofilo dead, in spite of the devastating event. The only thing said is “Send us rain clouds, Grandfather” (Silko 694) Among the Pueblo characters, there is only one short exchange, in which Louise tells Ken that she had been thinking about having the priest sprinkle holy water for her grandpa so he will not be…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Killing / Fiesta, 1980

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Today, family is one of the most sacred values we share in the individualist society we live in. Every family is different and has different rules and values; but in most of them, fathers are supposed to be leaders of the family, and role models for their children. They are also considerate like the one who transmits the traditions of their ancestors in order to carry them on. “Fiesta, 1980” is a short story written by Junot Dìaz taken from his short story collection, Drown, (1996). “Killings” is also a short story taken from, Finding a Girl in America (1980), written by Andre Dubus. Both of these stories are dealing with the family’s subject and provide us different perspectives of it. In Dìaz’s story we can see the relationship among a foreigner family, while in Andre Dubus’s story we see an American average family. In both stories, fathers play an important role; they figure prominently and have a considerable impact on their family but on the story also. The father in Dubus’s story is more family oriented that the one in Dìaz’; moreover the family is more closely–knit in Dubus’s story than in Dìaz’s story. The difference between the behaviors of the two fathers can be explained by their cultural backgrounds, which are not the same. These stories also provide us another perspective of the father’s role in the family, through their strength and their weakness without compromise.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Santiago lived with his father who wanted him to become a priest. He tried his best to make his father felt happy but the time has come when he realized that being a priest was not his desire. He convinced his father that he wanted to travel around the world, search the meaning of every single step that he would take later on. He has made his father thinking harder but finally his father allowed him to go wandering. “I found this one day in the fields, I wanted them to be a part of your inheritance. But use them to buy your flock. Take to the fields, and someday you’ll learn that our countryside is the best, and our women the most beautiful” (pp. 9). He gave his son the precious thing that he has and “He gave the boy his blessing” (pp. 9).…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author starts off the story with “From the time was a small child, I was aware that I was different” (Page 60) stating that there is a problem and introduces the reader to it. Silko shows how the integration of the White people and Laguna Pueblo people lead to her difference as she’s half White and half Laguna. She spent a majority of her childhood with Grandma A’mooh nearly everyday because they lived next to each other. “”Not you,” he said and motioned for me to step away from my classmates.”(Page 63) is a scenario where Silko is treated as an outcast, different from her friends because she was different. She was ordered to move away from her friends based off her complexion and…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Laguna way” is a peaceful and harmony filled way to love one another and get along as well as possible. “In the old- time pueblo world, beauty was manifested in behavior and in ones relationships with other living beings, beauty was a much feeling of harmony as it was visual, aural, or sensual effect” The reader later discovers that the pueblo people are hard working and being different did not not matter, therefore imagine how different the mentality of the pueblos we're compared to ours and in the story there is controversy with a photographer where it was shown that being different was not a good thing and was an uncommon sight to see. Silko also states how she isn't even necessarily embarrassed of the situation but it was simply just the fact that it had happened and she had known why in the first paragraph. The way the pueblo people interact with each other as individual develops an idea and progression because it compares how different the culture of the pueblo people with people of the Western world. Cultures are very diverse and in parts of the story it includes interactions with grandma Amooh who is a good example of the way the pueblos would interact at home in another paragraph it states “I had sensed immediately that something about my appearance was not acceptable for some people, white and Indian but I did not see any signs of strain or anxiety in the face of my beloved Grandma Amooh, this is a good example of what it is like for someone to grow up in a peaceful culture it just looks past parents and accept everyone surrounded as individuals to develops that diverse…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Bless Me, Ultima, Rudolfo Anaya writes about a young Mexican-American boy named Antonio Marez who is very curious about all the lives and stories that surround him because he is faced with deciding who he will be in the future. Antonio’s mother wants him to be a Catholic priest and farmer. She is a Luna and wants Antonio to be like her family, the people of the moon and excellent farmers because they are quiet people who speak and listen to the earth. His father wants him to be a vaquero, or cowboy, upholding the last name Marez which represents a loud people who roam freely on the earth. Antonio’s future is ultimately his own choice, so he becomes very close to his grandmother, Ultima, and depends on her guidance because she is old and wise. After his family is honored to have Ultima move in to their home, Antonio learns of all the herbs and roots Ultima uses in her practice as a curandera. Antonio begins to ask Ultima many questions about life because each event in the story makes Antonio anxious about the sins and punishments of the souls of others and his own. First, Antonio worries about his father’s soul and if he would go to hell after the men of the town shot a man named Lupito who lost his mind from being in the war and killed the town sheriff. Ultima calms his thoughts saying she doubted that his father fired.…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bless Me Ultimas

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages

    With Ultima in the house, Antonio spends the summer with her, sitting by the river, and gathering herbs and flowers in the mountains, and learning the ancient ways and myths of his people. Ultima impresses Antonio with a sense of her powers, and he respects her deeply, and her ways excite his imagination, and his longing to make sense of his cognitive dissonance at growing up in two very different and incongruous belief systems, those of Catholicism, and those of the ancient Chican@ customs and myths.…

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    "La Llorona", the Crying Woman, is a tale of endless versions told over the centuries by an endless array of anonymous storytellers to scare curious children into doing as they are told. The literary form of orality, though fluid and dynamic, is in this case the force behind the cohesion of the contents of the various versions of this Chicano legend. I shall show that the different contents found in the multiple versions of "La Llorona" are of the same form, and further, that the variations depend on the locale of settled Chicano populations. In truth, the farther away a distinct Chicano population is from its cultural heritage, the more opaque and sinister the mystic tale of "La Llorona" is told within that local population.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexico Personal Narrative

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To begin with, the most incredible part of the trip was Mexico’s culture. The country was alive and booming with so many different traditions, I felt like I was being transported to another world every time I ate a new dish or saw a new dance. When we made our way to my father’s village, they were celebrating the harvest season. There was a whole festival to welcome the change of season. Men as well as women sported traditional white attire, consisting of stunning white, floral embroidered dresses for the women and simple white button up shirts and pants with rounded yellow straw hats and red handkerchiefs for the men. Both were dancing “El baile de la Piña” or “the dance of the pineapple”. The dancers were swaying with pineapples in hand, thanking the god of harvest and the fruit for providing them with food for the village. With this in mind, I wasn’t amazed at how deeply connected everyone was with the earth. They treated her with love and respect. The animals, they cared for them dearly, knowing the importance they served in their everyday lives. In fact, entire routines convey stories dedicated to animals and plants, love and war, life and death; everything remembered and…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Leslie Marmon Silko’s story entitled The Man to Send Rain Clouds describes a funeral service carried out by a Native American Pueblo family. Though many perceive the funeral service narrated in this story to be lacking in emotion and also lacking respect for the passing of their loved one, it portrays a ceremony that is quite common for the Native American communities. There is also a hint of conflict occurring between the characters in the story that are carrying out their traditions while including an outside religious figure in the ceremony.…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native American Hopi Tribe

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Thus, the kachina dancers play a significant role in the daily lives of Hopi children and also serve as an important rite of passage for children in the Hopi community. The kachina dancers often visit the children, leave them gifts and warnings, reward or punish them for their behavior, and provide a sense of security for the children (Gill, 2004). Hopi families ensure that their children never see the kachina dancers without their masks so that the children continue to believe in the Kachina until they are ready to impersonate the kachinas themselves. Starting when male Hopi children are about seven to ten years old, they go through an important rites of passage ceremony in which they learn the truth about the identities of the kachina dancers. During their initiation to the kachina cult in February, children are invited to a dance in which the kachina dancers remove their masks (Capps, 1976; Gill, 2004). The children become disillusioned as they learn that the kachina dancers they thought were real spirits are actually their male relatives honoring and impersonating the kachina. Then, the kachina dancer cult is explained to the child by their father, uncles, and older brothers, and the child learns that they will also have the privilege to participate in the kachina cult just as their older male relatives do so that they can honor the kachina spirits (Gill, 2004). The child is finally reintegrated into the community as a Kachina dancer themselves, and the child has a new identity and adult status due to their initiation into the kachina cult (Capps, 1976). After their initiation and reintegration back into the community, the Hopi child learns to distinguish between spiritual and physical realities…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cultural Analysis Paper

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages

    No matter how hard we try, or how much we study, it is pretty much impossible to become an expert on all the world’s cultures. It is possible however, to be enlightened on a few cultures through some effort and understanding. That is just what we did, through interviewing three people who were raised in cultures different from ours. The following are results from what we learned about different cultural dimensions.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cultural identity is a huge part of who we are. Not only does it define our interests, it also dictates why and who we interact with. It affects so many things in our life that it can be hard to find anything at all that isn’t affected by it. For me personally, the biggest parts of my cultural identity are the food I eat, the people I spend my time with, and the music I listen to.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Do people still care about their culture and involve themselves into it like as much as they used to? Or do they leave it aside like a rejected toy and forget about it? Today, the cultures and traditions of our people still play a big role in our society. Cultures and traditions are still important because they hold many history, defines our individuality, and it’s something for you and others to discover and enjoy.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics