Machiavelli's Cycle of Governance and 'Checks and Balances' Ideology (Discourses) 516 Word Summary.

Topics: Ancient Rome, Livy, Democracy Pages: 2 (542 words) Published: November 14, 2008
Nicolo Machiavelli's 'Discourses on Livy' written 1513-1517, is a commentary on the work of Titus Livy (59 BC - AD 17) a Roman historian who wrote a monumental history of Rome entitled 'Ab Urbe Condita' literally translating as 'from the founding of the city (Rome)'. What Machiavelli set out to detail within the Discourses in essence, is the refined knowledge gleaned from an in depth analysis of Livy's accounts, observations of the legislative, socio-political and military management structures that provided Ancient Rome such a stable and economically fruitful empire.

Concerning the structures of governance as it was in 16th century florence, Machiavelli expressed the opinion that only six forms of government exist that maintain a perpetual cycle of short lived power before sucuming to, what he viewed as a natural end. This is brought about either due to a successful insurection and instalment of a form of government which evolved out of oppression or a form of government that eventually grew to become greedy and corrupt through generational changes. The model Machiavelli presents begins with a society in a 'state of nature' or 'Anarchy' that exists until the people begin to realise strength in numbers and seek leadership from the foremost individual who assumes rulership, thus evolving into a 'Monarchy'. The good Monarch is however, succeeded by corrupt rulers who use their power for their own gain and control through 'Tyranny'. The Tyrant is eventually overthrown by a rebellion and the rebels retain control amongst themselves collectively producing an 'Aristocracy'. The Aristocrats are then succeeded by a generation that again, begins to use its powers to oppress the people and becomes an 'Oligarchy'. Like the Tyrant, they are overthrown by the oppressed who then form a 'Democracy'. As time progresses, order and control dissolve completely until we find ourselves in a 'state of nature' or 'Anarchy' once again.

As Machiavelli saw it, because of man's...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on Checks And Balances

    ... Checks And Balances When the Framers of the Constitution set out to create a government, they made sure that one of the fundamental principles underlining the government would be the separation of powers. This separation of powers outlines the numerous powers and functions of the government by dividing them into separate independent levels and branches of the federal government. The Founders believed that by creating separate branches of government, it would help limit the powers of the national government and prevent tyranny. Therefore, the legislative branch has power, under the Constitution, to make laws. The executive branch, headed by the President, executes or carries out laws. Last but not least, the Constitution established the Supreme Court to head the judicial branch, which interprets and applies the law in federal court cases. The principle of separation of powers, as implemented in drafting the Constitution, was based on several values generally held: the separation of government into three branches, legislative, executive, and judicial; the idea that each branch performs its own unique and identifiable functions that are appropriate to each; and the limitation of the personnel of each branch to that branch, so that no one person or group should be able to serve in more than one branch simultaneously. Since the judicial, executive, and legislative branch of the government all held power, the framers began to develop a system of...

    Read More
    1295 Words 6 Pages
  • Ideology & Discourse Essay

    ...Ideology, what is that? There are hundred answers and none of them is right or wrong. Most of ideology definitions are not compatible with each other, but I have found one that I like the most: An ideology is a set of ideas that constitute one's goals, expectations, and actions. An ideology is a comprehensive vision, a way of looking at things as in several philosophical tendencies, or a set of ideas proposed by the dominant class of a society to all members of this society. Ideologies are systems of abstract thought applied to public matters and thus make this concept central to politics. Implicitly every political or economic tendency entails an ideology whether or not it is propounded as an explicit system of thought.1 So ideology is a system of conceptualized views and ides, expressing the interests of different social classes, groups and societies, to evaluate relationships between people and reality, as well as authorized on a community form of domination and power (conservative ideology) or settle their transformation (radical, revolutionary ideology). It`s not a science, but it includes scientific knowledge of social and politic life, as well as assessing it. Good example of bad ideology was Nazi in Germany, when Hitler wanted to “clean” the Aryan race from “sub-human” – Jews, Gypsies, homosexuals and handicapped...

    Read More
    626 Words 3 Pages
  • Discourse and Ideology Essay

    ...The word discourse originates from the french word “discours” which refers to speech and dialogue. This, linked with “discursus” in Latin which means to “run around”, means we can take literally that discourse means “to run around speech” or in other words, to assess speech in all aspects. There are many varying meanings of the word “discourse” written by theorists and literary writers. These meanings all overlap in areas and provide several alternative meanings of the broad term. Despite being so widely used, its meaning or even its existence is often presupposed in society, due to its constant presence and relevance in everyday life and conversation. Put arguably simpler by Wetherell, Taylor, and Yates, discourse is “the study of language in use” and this is a sufficient starting point to begin defining the broad term. Discourse, as described by Foucault in his linguistic analysis, is how people in society act, talk, think, and communicate in general, and a common conclusion is that discourse both simultaneously shapes and arises from culture. In other words, discourse is shaped and developed by the everyday beliefs and assumed knowledge, but it also actively shapes them. As outlined by Mills, discourse is “frequently left undefined” despite being a term with a huge range of...

    Read More
    917 Words 4 Pages
  • Checks and Balances Research Paper

    ...Civilization. Checks and balances The Constitution separates the power of government into three branches: the legislative power is vested in the Congress, the executive power rests with the President and his bureaucracy and the judicial power is granted to the Supreme Court and other federal courts. Whereas each branch of government has separate and particular powers as listed in the Constitution, each branch is also given the power, duty and ability to control and balance the other(s) in a system of checks and balances. The Constitution grants all legislative power to the Congress. The Congress is bicameral and a bill has to pass both houses: the House of Representatives and the Senate. In this way the houses check and balance each other. Furthermore, both the executive and the judicial branch check and balance the Congress' legislative power. Although only the Congress can make laws, the President has the power to veto bills, in which case the bill can only pass with a 2/3 majority in both houses. Finally, if the Congress and the President agree on a law, the Supreme Court has the power of interpreting the laws and a power of review, i.e. the Supreme Court can declare a law unconstitutional and therefore void. Besides law making, the Constitution lists a wide range of congressional powers, I don't have the space to mention them all, but...

    Read More
    670 Words 3 Pages
  • Essay on Checks and Balances

    ...1)Discuss the theory of "checks and balances" as outlined by the framers of the Constitution in your assigned text. Analyze the concept of power in politics and why the Federalists were correct in diffusing the power of government in order to keep one branch or entity from becoming too powerful. How does this concept help us as a viable democracy? When the Framers of the constitution were in the process of creating a government, they had in mind a government that was ruled by the people. Where everyone had a voice and could have say in what the government was doing. In order to avoid a monarchy such as the one they had been used to under British rule, the framers came up with a system of checks and balances. Checks and balances keeps one branch of government from having too much power over other branches of government. The framers idea when creating the checks and balances system was to keep a balance between the different branches of government. They didn't want the president to have too much power , so the legislative branch looks over the executive branch and has some say in that actions of the executive branch. Times are definitely different than they were when the framers created the constitution, but their idea of not letting too much power get in the hands of one person, is definitely coming in hand with present day events. With the war...

    Read More
    887 Words 4 Pages
  • checks and balances Essay

    ... DBQ Essay Caitlyn Kiefer 11/7/13 Mr. Bacon period 2 There are many ways in which African Americans have been denied equality. As a result, there were many methods that individuals, groups and the government have used since 1950 to deal with the inequality faced by African Americans. Some of the methods included peaceful protest and withholding support of businesses. One way African Americans have been denied equality was segregation at lunch counters and in restaurants. For example, blacks and whites sat separate from each other in restaurants. There was a section for blacks and a different section for whites. When there were no more tables left for whites to eat at, blacks would have to give up their table to the white person. Also only whites were allowed to eat at the lunch counters. One method used to deal with this inequality was sit-ins, a form of protest where African American citizens sit and refuse to leave. For example, from the Greensboro area, there were many people who wanted to help through peaceful protest and civil disobedience by participating in the sit-ins. It got to the point where they had shifts, and where all the restaurant seats were taken which then excluded whites. This all relates...

    Read More
    957 Words 4 Pages
  • Machiavelli's Discourses Summary Essay

    ...side of the people, then why should the people should him? In the same way, talking about his second letter that he called The Discourses, where Machiavelli talks about the different Rome empires and takes them as examples in order to a solid government ruled by one individual. He believed that all periods of time are similar, that is why he used Rome as an example to illustrate what is wrong in a government and the good things (Machiavelli 84-85). One good example that Machiavelli gives in chapter seventeen is about “How corrupt people who came to be free can only hold on their freedom with the greatest of difficulties” (Machiavelli 124). Machiavelli explains that if an individual has become corrupted, there is no chance that they could be reformed, but the only way that a person can be healed from corruption is if they use virtu because they acquire liberty to have the intention to be good and change. “[I]t happens because of the skill [virtu] of one individual who is present by chance, not because of the strength [virtu] of the population as whole which is what is needed to maintain good intentions” (Machiavelli 126). This a totally realistic comment because if people want to change this, they need to change that way they are thinking, and using virtue helps people to use their wisdom and analyze what is good or bad for themselves. Machiavelli’s works is a recompilation of past historic moments, where real errors have changed the history of...

    Read More
    497 Words 2 Pages
  • Checks and Balances Essay

    ...Checks and Balances, the constitutional controls whereby separate branches of government have limiting powers over each other so that no branch will become supreme. Perhaps the best-known system of checks and balances operates in the U.S. government under provisions of the federal Constitution. Most national, state, and local governments have at least the mechanics of a system of checks and balances. Even dictatorial governments, otherwise scorning restraints on powers, provide internal checks to ensure proper performance by governmental agencies and to fix responsibility. Theory of Checks and Balances. The concept of constitutional checks arose as an outgrowth of the classical theory of separation of powers, by which the legislative, executive, and judicial powers of government were held properly to be vested in three different units. The purpose of this, and of the later development of checks and balances, was to ensure that governmental power would not be used in an abusive manner. However, in its original form the concept involved social classes rather than government departments. Classical political philosophers from Aristotle onward favored a "mixed" government combining the elements of monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy. The English theorist James Harrington in his Oceana (1656) derived a theory...

    Read More
    719 Words 3 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free