Preview

Luther And Zwingli Comparison

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
992 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Luther And Zwingli Comparison
As Reformers, Zwingli and Luther agreed on most of each other's doctrines. Both rejected the authority of the Pope and held to the authority of Scriptura sola; rejected the view of the Catholic Mass as a sacrifice; rejected the doctrine of Transubstantiation; agreed to the principle of justification by faith alone; and agreed liturgy should be in the vernacular. But among all these similarities, at the heart of their disagreement was how to interpret the nature of Christ’s presence in the bread and wine in the Eucharist. On this Zwingli and Luther could not agree on, and became the dividing factor between Lutherans and Zwinglians.
Zwingli accounts in the expression, “This is my body,” that the word “is” must not be understood literally,
…show more content…
Thus, Luther disagrees with Zwingli and says Christ’s body is everywhere, and furthermore, the right hand of God is everywhere. Contrary to Zwingli, Luther did not believe that God and man were two separate beings that could be divided, but were in fact one supernatural being. Luther speaks of three modes of the one body of Christ: 1) physical/circumscribed, the body of Christ when he walked on earth; 2) supernatural/uncircumscribed, the body of Christ when he left the grave, came through closed doors, or became the substance in the bread and wine in the Supper, and 3) the body of Christ that is one with God, the divine and heavenly body. However, Luther said that the words, “This is my body,” is what is meant in that Christ is in heaven, and his body is in the Supper. He asserts that the right hand of God is not a specific place but is everywhere which means God is in all places and in all things. He further develops this claim by explaining, what Luther calls, the “modes of existence.” For Luther, understanding these modes of existence requires faith, and if others cannot disprove this knowledge then they cannot say that it is not true. In the modes of existence Christ is able to occupy varying spaces. He can take human form to occupy a certain space with specific measurements as well as occupy an entire space such as a room which

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Ap Euro Chapter 15 Summary

    • 2936 Words
    • 12 Pages

    2. The author of the sixteenth century literary work that describes a utopian society based upon communal…

    • 2936 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    How did both John Calvin and Sebastian Castellio respond to Luther’s paradoxical skepticism? By asserting the supremacy of scripture while simultaneously advocating for the reliance and utilization of one’s consciousness and reason to fully understand and believe such scripture, Martin Luther triggered the Northern European quest for religious knowledge and Truth. John Calvin provided an additional element to Luther’s paradox—an inner persuasion, given to us by God, guiding us towards the true meaning of God’s word (Popkin 10). Calvin adopted Luther’s ideas regarding scripture’s supremacy yet amended and elaborated upon Luther’s stance on conscience and reason. In my opinion, Calvin’s addition of the notion of inner persuasion was an attempt…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ap Eurp Ch 14 Outline

    • 1980 Words
    • 8 Pages

    5. Luther’s answers as delineated in the Confession of Augsburg to the four basic theological issues were the following. When asked how a person is saved, Luther said by faith alone. When asked where does religious authority reside, Luther said in the Word of God, as revealed in the Bible alone. When asked what is the church, he said the entire Christian community. Luther said there is no highest form of Christian life, all are equal.…

    • 1980 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reformation DBQ

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the history of Europe, people’s lives revolved around the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church taught its beliefs through the clergy and exercised its authority. In 1517, corruption, false teachings, and the challenging of Martin Luther led to a split that created the Protestant Church. During the Reformation, the Protestant belief in “sola scriptura” and “sola fides” was a major source of conflict with the Catholic teachings of a Church authority and salvation through good works.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Luther's 95 Thesis

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the 1600s there was a man named Martin Luther. He was the son of Saxon Miner. Martin Luther had a good affect on his society because he made the 95 thesis, he devoted his life to the catholic church, and publshed the Smalcald Articles. Martin Luther was a good affect on his society because he made the 95 thesis .…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Luther made radical statements challenging Papal authority, the deliverance of relief of purgatory via a monetary gain by the church, and exposing the corrupt dogma that exemplified the Roman Catholic Church. Luther, after stating the errors of the church, established what he believed was justification by faith. Luther reduced the amount of sacraments to those that were plainly supported by scripture verses the church’s use of sacraments by conjecture, he denounced the sale of paradise, and propounded that the Bible was the true religious authority, whereas, the church gave authority to a fallible man. Furthermore, Luther’s original intent was not to initiate a reformation, but was to allow for academic debate. Luther found questions regarding the church and theological misconduct that would force him to separate from the church in Rome and establish…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Protestant Reformation partook so much of past and future theology that it may best be viewed as a transition between the medieval and modern periods in church history. As such, it was a significant break with the past. One of the most remarkable aspects of the Reformation’s break with the past was its emphasis upon the Scriptures as the sole source of authority and rule of faith in the believer’s life. This was a radical departure from the medieval attitude that tradition, as well as the Scriptures, as interpreted and promulgated by the Roman Catholic hierarchy is the rule of life. Although the early Reformation leaders did not fully appreciate or apply the implications of their principles, the effect of their movement was to unfetter man’s mind and allow him to think for himself. No longer was it enough for man to simply obey what he was told God’s word said; he had to understand God’s word for himself. No longer was his faith to be in a hierarchy of men but in Jesus Christ and His written revelation of Himself.…

    • 783 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two that he was especially fond for were the stability of the social realm, and Eucharist as part of the church. Luther's' ideas became popular very fast due to the ability of the printing press to print in mass production allowing Luther's ideas to travel through Europe at a very high speed. Though much of Luther's work was for the good it did have some bad side affects. In some cities the people fought/revolted for what they wanted using Luther as the theologian to back up their revolts thinking that Luther would be all for his ideas spreading, but to their dismay Luther was sound to the old-fashioned beliefs of little social change and no peasant revolts. Although Luther saw many flaws in the Roman Catholic way of worship, and seeking forgiveness, he did see a point to Eucharist (Holy Communion/Lord's Supper). He did see a relevance in performing the Lord's Supper as a reminder of the Last Supper that his lord Jesus Christ performed before he died on the cross. He thought of it slightly differently though, he saw it as after the consecration of the bread and wine the later undergo a spiritual change whereby Christ is really present but the bread and wine are not transformed like they are in the catholic…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1524-1526, many peasant revolts were held within the German states. This was predominately due to a strong influence of Lutheran ideals, as well as, peasants standing up for their belief of fair and reasonable authority under Christian rulers. There was a broad range of responses to the revolts. Many viewed with a compromising, open-mind, while others were brutally pessimistic toward the peasant’s attempts. Although, a fair number of nobles in the German states recognized the peasant plea of grievances against their lords as rightful, the founder of the Lutheran branch of Protestantism, Martin Luther, sided harshly against the peasants.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    By the 1500’s many issues shows signs of disorder within the Church. The idea of selling indulgences (forgiveness for sin) for clergy benefit began to negatively spread throughout the people, along with opposition to pluralism (holding more than one office). This sparked many attempts to reform the church through individual groups, one of which being the Brotherhood of Common Life. One of their accomplishments was starting schools for the poor, in which educated none other than Martin Luther. By the time he became a priest, many people had already failed to reform the church. When Martin Luther entered Rome, he briefly supported the church before realizing the hidden corruption, and his optimism towards converting the Jews was accounted for before realizing their stubborn views of God. While his loving ideas towards peasants turned into hatred of rebellion, it proved to be a consistency because he had always believed peasants belonged in their place. These ideas changed due to the naïve spirit he entered with before being awakened by the truth.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The beliefs of Martin Luther stated that every individual possessed their own relationship with God. This statement is prevalent in Luther’s work, “The Sermon on Good Works”. In this piece of writing, Luther stated that only faith in God would get an individual salvation. Good works, acts made throughout life to better something or someone, would not help a person receive salvation. This went against the Catholic Church’s doctrine, which stated that an individual would receive God’s grace and salvation by accomplishing these Good Works. Essentially, Luther’s statements were revolutionary. To rally against a prevalent theme in the popular religion was a brave, if not inspired way to introduce a different method of thought.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Luther, Anti-Semitism

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When discussing Martin Luther (1483-1546), a German monk, priest, and professor, we usually think of his importance to the Protestant reformation. Martin Luther sought to reform the church, which believed money could wipe away sin, and have people focus more on faith. He created the Ninety-Five Thesis in 1517 which resulted in the Pope excommunicating him from the church. In turn he created the Lutheran church in hope that people would find salvation through faith in Jesus rather than indulgences. However, what most people do not know about Luther is his hate for the Jews.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. According to Luther, Sola File (faith alone) should be enough to get you into heaven where as the church said you need to be good as well. 2. Luther’s position of Sola Scriptura, saying the Bible alone is authoritative while the church also believes in the church’s teaching. 3. Luther’s “Priesthood of all Believers,” arguing that individuals did not need an intermediary between himself and God. 4. Communition, also the consubstantiation, Luther thinks that bread and wine is still bread and wine and not literally the blood and body of Jesus. He just believed that there is a miracle because Jesus is present at…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Luther Influence

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Through the 95 Theses, Luther was not just reacting against the full Pelagian as the purpose of justifying his works rather than faith. Instead, he was entirely reacting to what seemed to be the reasonable Catholic teaching on what entailed faith. The Catholic Church by Luther’s time was not using God’s sacraments and good works as part of faith. To Luther, it was all a matter of God’s grace into offering people paths of salvation, but no man had a secure opportunity because living such a life required maintaining high principles of faith before God…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While continuously more Christians of Europe were beginning to lose their faith in the church’s leadership and were developing a feeling of doubt or mistrust, it was the Reformation and Martin Luther who came in and gave the people a sense of direction and feeling of hope. This new Protestant tradition at the time lifted this overwhelming cloud of misused power over the Christian community and provided a time for change with new opportunities. The Protestant reformation ended the religious unity of Europe and the church and furthermore started a new era in the history of western…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays