Love Is a Fallacy Revision

Powerful Essays
Laken Sutton
March 20, 2013
English 102 Gompf
Revised Paper
Women vs. “Love is a Fallacy” “Love is a Fallacy” is often viewed as an anti-women story. To many this piece exploits females by insulting women using stereotypes that have been around for a long time. The female sex, as a whole, has been fighting to overcome these degrading assumptions. This story uses a girl named Polly to display all women. She depicts them as ignorant and gullible individuals. During the Story, Polly is treated like an object or mere possession, rather than a human being with emotions, ideas, and thoughts of her own.
The men focus mainly on her physical beauty. They also suggest that she could be trained, in the same way wild animals are usually trained, to think and act for herself. The end of the story leads you to believe that Polly, still representing women, is only interested in shallow material items when choosing relationships. The men in this story are shown in a way that makes them seem superior to women using intelligence, wittiness, and patience along with physical and material attractiveness.
In the beginning of “Love is a Fallacy”, the two men make a deal to trade Polly as if they owned or had rights to her. What is even worse than the act itself is the object she is being traded for, a fur coat. This implies that Polly is only worth a useless, stinky, old fur coat. When evaluating her worth, the man judges her physical beauty and how useful she could be to him. He then decides to take her on as a project for him to improve. Then to show Polly’s ignorance, the writer has her follow the man to be “trained” or taught to think. As he instructs her and becomes increasingly rude and impatient with Polly, she continues to use ignorant phrases and gestures to comply with the man’s commands and to please him.
In the end, even though Polly stands up for herself and uses his teachings against him, she still is only speaking from what he had taught her and not from her

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Unit 8 PA253 Assignment

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Polly knows both Mr. and Mrs. Smith and is considered a friend to them, the likelihood of her…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    accepted and popular. Dr. Pipher feels that she is the only one saddened by Polly's…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is love? Often enough, as a hormone-struck teenager, I am lectured on what love is not. According to my mother, father, grandmother, aunts, uncles, and every adult figure that has ever made a guest-star appearance in the long-winded romance novel that is my life, love is NOT the warm cuddly feeling I get when I see a cute boy at school. Love is NOT holding hands on the playground; is not caring an abnormal amount for a favorite pair of shoes. I feel as though a vast amount of time is spent describing the negative space of a person’s heart, and not long enough spent defining its shape. Although Pastor Ostrum follows suit with his anti-definition of what love is not, he definitely strikes a chord in my heart when he says that “love is not something we wait to have happen to us, but something we do.” Many might disagree, might argue that love is a two-way street; that in order to give we must first receive. However, in the novel “Until They Bring the Streetcars Back,” by Stanley Gordon West, Cal Gant demonstrates this principle of giving time and time again.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    About Love Essay 6

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The use of critical thinking is imperative when trying to persuade others. One must effectively use the three types of appeals in order to be successful. I have noticed how Danielle Crittenden and Judy Brady have used the three appeals in their essays “About Love” and “I Want a Wife.” Crittenden and Brady’s use of tone greatly effects how the audience perceives their writing.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the reading “Love is a Fallacy”, Max Shulman writes about a character named Max who attempts to have a relationship with a girl by trading his roommate a racoon coat for the girl in exchange. Max Shulman’s piece is neither anti-women nor anti-men and is, therefore, meant to be irony. This piece is rather ironic because of fallacies appear throughout the piece, the main character Max has fallacies in his thinking, and the character Polly speaks of the fallacies in Max’s reasoning. Out of all the characters, there are only three characters, these three have at least one fallacy in their reasoning.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the end of the film Polly gave Romeo a ring. And Romeo really like it. And Polly told him that the ring is, so you will remember me (Polly). And Romeo said okay. And afterwards Polly and her Dad left the hotel. And Romeo and his Brother where still at da hotel. And Polly and Romeo haven’t seen each other for a long time.…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1). Throughout Cooper’s entire paragraph are numerous examples of the kind of misogyny that Child spoke out against. In the end, a perceptive reading will have no trouble realizing that Cooper’s paragraph perfectly embodies the masculine portrayal of women in literature that Child so greatly despises: women are worth anything only so long as they are pleasing to…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The female perspective is a critical element that has been persistently neglected throughout cultures due to the prevalence of the patriarchy. This has meant that literature itself manifests as a male institution, shaped by men 's minds and voices who view the female experience as trivial and unworthy of consideration. Therefore, being unable to express their own perspectives and discriminated against in their writings, women are a marginalized group. But, in their portrayal, are they truly victims of a patriarchal society? Certainly Sylvia Plath 's Daddy (1962) paints a despairing picture of suppression and inner anguish, a woman driven mad by the men in her life - though is this really the case? For Ania Walwicz challenges this concept of a helpless damsel in distress by subverting the traditional fairytale in Little Red Riding Hood (1982), thus undermining masculine values about women and their sexuality. Through the examination of these two texts, the extent of women 's victimization by a patriarchal society can be determined.…

    • 1812 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gender Stereotypes

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the texts of ‘The Chrysanthemums’ by John Steinbeck, ‘Folk Hero’ by H.M. Tolcher and ‘Ode to Barbie’ by Romanie Moreton the concept of gender is supported and challenged in a variety of ways. Men are typically portrayed as hard-working, rebellious and fulfilling a job in a male dominated profession. In contrast to this, females are depicted as fragile and emotional, having the role of the housewife. The authors of the following texts have made use of descriptive language, imagery, figurative language and many more to communicate the themes of relationships, betrayal and identity. More so each author represents their perspective of gender, based on stereotypes.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading this short tale of two men in college, and one not-so-bright college girl, I have learned many things about fallacies. In our powerpoint presentation, it says that each generation is to learn these fallacies. This tale of the college students and the teaching of fallacies was in a much different generation than we are in now. Some fallacies I learned of in this story that were different from the ones stated in my course text were, Dicto Simpliciter, Contradictory Premises, Ad Misericoriam, Hypothesis Contrary to Fact, and Poisoning the Well.…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading the two short stories, Love in L.A by Dagoberto Gilb and What We Talk about When We Talk about Love by Raymond Carver, I have realized that a common feeling like ‘love’ can be painted into so many different pictures. Each one of these short stories is written by two different authors and sees ‘love’ at different angles. The character Jake in Love in L.A. has this vision of love that is more of a mockery. Then, Terri’s ex-husband in What We talk about When We Talk about Love has so much passion, but the kind of passion that can be interoperated as obsession. The lies and misconceptions of ‘love’ that Jake and Terri’s ex-husband display reveal that ‘love’ does not exist in a world filled with nothing but cruelty and evil actions.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compare the views of relationships in ‘The Unequal Fetters’ with those in ‘To his Coy Mistress’. What is suggested about the different ways in which men and women view love?…

    • 2031 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “When it was said that it was done to please a woman, there ought perhaps to be enough said to explain anything; for what a man will not do to please a woman is yet to be discovered” (Chestnutt 30). In the “Passing of Grandison” and “Editha” both authors bring to light the ideas of women and the impact they have on the actions of men. Both Charity and Editha have used their influence as women to convince their partners, Dick and George, of completing tasks they would not have done, other than for the love a woman.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This sonnet attempts to convey to the reader that love is not tangible, though it is necessary for life and well being. It investigates situations of pain and misfortune and find none where love would make any difference. "Love Is Not All", explains that love is not a necessity, but that it's absence will cause a man to exist closer to death. Love is not an object, an act, a spirit, or a thought; it is a silent motivater of life.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Love is undoubtedly one of the most frequently explored subjects in the literary world. Whether the focus is a confession of love, criticism of love, tale of love, or simply a tale about what love is, such literary pieces force readers to question the true meaning and value of love. Raymond Carver accomplishes this in his short story “What We Talk About When We Talk About Love.” As the unadorned setting and the personality of each character unfold, the reader realizes that Carver is making a grave comment on the existence of love. Carver utilizes strong contrast, imagery, and diction to ultimately suggest that love cannot be defined concretely and therefore cannot be defined in words, and because of this, it is better off unexplored.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays