Preview

Logical Fallacies

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
386 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Logical Fallacies
1) In the first passage, the writer claims that sex-education should remain a family matters, that if kids are expose to sex-education at young age could prove detrimental rather than helpful for the children. They reasons that the issues[sex-ed.] at hand “removes family involvement with the children, put kids in an uncomfortable position, stripped any sense of morality, promote promiscuity, and encourages experimentation.” In the passage, I have identified the logical fallacies that the author utilized in their argument: personal attack(ad hominem), slippery slope, perfect argument, false dilemma, and wishful thinking. This argument seems to direct its argument toward a general surgeon about his recommendation about educating kids at young as third grader about sex, a personal attack. Secondly, the writer believes that by teaching kids sex-ed in school, they assumes that there is only consequences from the action[sex-ed. …show more content…
They wrote the argument with definite support for the dog breed that included personal experiment, and a credible source from a Dr., who is the direct of a dog clinic to back their thesis. This passage is a bit tough to identify the logical fallacy being used, but I came across two fallacies based on my understanding of the terms: straw-man and slippery slope. The writer is misrepresenting the opponent’s thesis because they implicit state the banishment of pit bull, but fail to clarify the extension of the ban—where, when, what kind of ban. Furthermore, the author claims that the petition to ban pit bull is the caused of idiot who tend to hate dogs, further discrediting their opponent claims. The second one is the fallacy slippery slope, the writer thinks that the ban should be avoided because “it would not totally prevent dogs” from attacking people, and the dog he has could never attack a human being—all of which he fails to prove with supported

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Over the past half-century, the reputation of pit bulls has grown gradually worse. The breed that once represented America’s dedication and determination on recruitment advertisements is now “a status symbol in drug and gang culture” (Reed, 2008). This trend can be traced back to the 1980s when dog-fighting attracted widespread media publicity. Since then, reports of pit bull attacks has significantly increased, and these breeds are labeled as vicious killers, restricted by the society’s stereotypes. As a result, this topic has stirred up controversy as to whether or not a pit bull ban is an effective way to reduce and prevent more dog attacks in a specific area.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pit Bulls Research Paper

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Unfortunately getting an accurate number of Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and other breeds traditionally considered dangerous that are currently living as beloved pets without incident, is impossible. So, what gives anyone that right to declare an entire breed unacceptable based on the actions of a few? Those in favor of BSL laws (Breed Specific Legislation) use “facts” and “statistics” reporting, “The danger of pit bulls and Rottweilers is well established, in that they account for 75% of all reported canine-inflicted human deaths in the past two decades.”, to support their argument (“Argument in Support of Breed Bans”). However, a statement by the American Veterinary Medical Association describes the flaws in the “facts”:…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first category discusses how absurd it is to assume that if gay marriage was legalized then eventually polygamy, incestuous, and even pedophiliac marriages would all have to be legalized. In the second category it is a reminder that the slopes can slip in more direction, so their theory could back fire and the slope could slip into more support for not only the LGBT community, but also for those who are mentally handicapped and those with sexually transmitted diseases. As the third category states slippery slopes in general are a bad idea and are illogical and the fourth category recognizes that states, “in addition to the aforementioned reasons, a distinction between gay marriages and polygamous and incestuous marriages can be made based on the concept of “choice.” This fallacy is extremely weak in any sort of intellectual debate because the tactic of it is to fly off into a many other situations that are, more often than not, ridiculous and do not usually relate specifically to the “top of the slope” issue, and this essay is a good argument showing the flaws in the slippery slope argument against legalizing gay marriage.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a lot of controversy between legislation and pit bull supporters over the banning of pit bulls. Pit bulls have been characterized as aggressive, dangerous, and vicious animals because of their genetic predisposition. For that matter legislation is trying to stop the breeding of pits in order to crack down on dog fighting and vicious attacks. Legislation should not just single out pit bulls because all dogs have the capacity to be aggressive. Owning a pit bull is a chosen responsibility and like a parent is responsible for their child, the owner should be responsible for the action of their animals.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pitbull Behavior

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Natalie Lima, an animals rights advocate created a whole novel about how the Breed- specific legislation ban creates more issues including the state losing money, the shelters being packed, bite rate not going down, and people would move on to a different “fighting breed”. The other main issue of banning Pit bulls is that dog fighting is presently illegal yet it still happens, therefore, it would pull Pit breeds away from loving family homes and put them in dangerous homes that will abuse their…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Banning Pitbulls

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page

    People label Pit Bulls as "Killer Machines.” Breed Specific Legislation, or BSL, are a set of laws that restricts or completely bans the breeds of a dog from an area. Pit bulls have been given a bad reputation because of all the publicity pit bulls have received. Many states of the U.S. are stuck between whether or not to ban the breed of pit bulls. People who agree with the BSL may have had a bad experience with dogs, or may fear that they’ll encounter an aggressive dog. Everyone needs to come to the realization that dogs behave a certain way due to treatment from their owners. People need to understand that the BSL is a form of breed profiling, in this case it discriminates against pit bulls. They also need to see that the label of, “Killer…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pittbulls in the media

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What do you think when you hear the words “pitbull?” I’m guessing aggressive, violent, or even dangerous? We can thank the media for all the negative attention focused solely on attacks on humans and other dogs from the pitbull breed, many Americans place a prejudiced on pitbulls, tagging them as dangerous and vicious. This stigma typically applies to all pitbulls, not just the ones that have actually caused harm. To try and take care of the issue of so called “dangerous” attacks, the legislative act known as breed-specific legislation is being debated and tried throughout the United States for one specific breed. We all know that there have been attacks by other breeds but we are focused on pitbulls.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the animal world Pit bulls are victims of discrimination. The second someone hears the word pit bull they become frightened. A lot of times you will hear on the news that someone had been bit by a dog. Know matter what kind of dog had bit someone, the news shows a picture of a Pit Bull. This is not fair. These animals are no different then any other large breed of dogs. Yet because of some foolish people who take a pit bull puppy, isolate it, starve it, antagonize it, and simply raise it for the sole purpose to fight it for money, there is now the concern to ban this breed. It is not the breed of dog that should be ban. It is the group of people that organize these dog fights. If you are a dog or even an animal lover, please hear…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moving right along, Pit-bulls haven’t always had the bad reputation they have today. Over the years, other dogs have been blamed for “dangerous” and “ruthless” acts. In the 70’s, the Dobermans were blamed. In the 80’s it was the German Shepard’s turn. Next, in the 90’s, Rottweiler’s committed the crime. Now it’s the Pit-bulls turn, and people are going against them head-on, and all I can say is that they are barking up the wrong tree. Blaming dogs for the wrong-doings of humans is inhumane itself.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every year hundreds of people within various communities are bitten by dogs. Some are bitten by wild dogs, while others are bit by domestic dogs. Each and every dog has the capability to bite a human but it appears that only one breed is being punished for it, pit bulls. The issue about the community supporting the council in prohibiting unregistered dogs for a safer community has been prominent in the media in recent years since poor Ayen Chol was brutally attacked. In the feature article ‘owners dump dangerous dogs to avoid penalties" published in the Herald sun, on the 07/09/11, by Grant McArthur and Alex White contends that pitbull are dangerous animals. In an outraged tone, the article targets pitbull owners, imposing the ideology that they should take more responsibility of their obligations.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dr.Wheeler created the Logical Fallacies Handlist and it states that fallacies are statements that might sound reasonable or superficially true but are actually flawed or dishonest. It is important to avoid logical fallacies as they undermine your argument. There are several types of logical fallacies and to keep track of all of them you can separate them into different categories. There are four different main categories that the certain types can go into; they are fallacies of relevance, component fallacies, fallacies of ambiguity, and fallacies of omission. The Logical Fallacies Handlist states fallacies of relevance are all fallacies that appeal to certain evidence or examples that have nothing to do with the specific argument given. The Fallacies of relevance help readers form a conclusion on the topic by distracting from the main point. The types of fallacies that…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I agree with your statement that the quotation is an example of logical fallacy. I think it is the fallacy of an appeal to popularity. Naomi Klein attempted to assume that the wealth has a larger emissions. I agree with your statement that not all wealthy families consumes more power and creates more emissions,ignoring the environment. Therefore, the writer should not conclude that taxes will rise for everyone except for the…

    • 72 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    the family” Sexual education is very important to learn in school and prepares students for the adult world, and is something that is not taught by all families to the students. I had learned things in sex education that my conservative family had not taught me or ever will. Some schools may not have the time to teach this subject without compromising time for other subjects. He states that we…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the new outbreaks of sexually transmitted diseases and the fact that sexually active persons are becoming younger, sex has now become a daily topic. Sex scandals in the media and talk such as 'who slept with who at last night's party' are making these daily conversations apparent in high schools, middle schools, and in a lot of cases grade schools. As the saying goes 'monkey see monkey do' one can only assume that this concept will pertain to these easily influenced children. That is why it is imperative that another side of this issue is presented on a regular basis, a side that demonstrates safe sex as well as no sex. Sex is a basic instinct in all-living beings; sex education in public schools should encourage abstinence because it is the only sure way to prevent pregnancy and disease, but not dismiss protective measures for those who become sexually active, because no matter much you emphasize abstinence, there will always be those who choose to participate in sexual activity. It should be the responsibility of our schools to protect them from these dangers because it is imperative that they are aware and make the right decisions.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Today many parents would not disagree with a sex education course in their child’s curriculum in school. A study done on if sex education should be taught in schools, only seven percent of Americans said that sex education should not be discussed in school ("Sex education in," 2004). The role of educators can be very important in giving information about abstinence, safe sex, or the combination. Millions of dollars over the years have been given to abstinence programs, but sexual activity, sexually transmitted diseases, and pregnancies seem to be increasing in teenagers (Banks, 2010). The main goal in teaching sex education in middle schools would be to explain thoroughly the heath risks involved, how to resist peer pressure, and safe sex.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays