Charmaine Larkin-Sullivan
CJ 370
Case Study # 4

Kirby v. Illinois

Facts: On February 21, 1968, a man named Willie Shard reported to the Chicago police that the previous day two men had robbed him on a Chicago street of a wallet containing, among other things, traveler's checks and a Social Security card. On February 22, two police officers stopped the petitioner and a companion, Ralph Bean, on West Madison Street in Chicago. When asked for identification, the petitioner produced a wallet that contained three traveler's checks and a Social Security card, all bearing the name of Willie Shard. Papers with Shard's name on them were also found in Bean's possession. When asked to explain his possession of Shard's property, the petitioner first said that the traveler's checks were "play money," and then told the officers that he had won them in a crap game. The officers then arrested the petitioner and Bean and took them to a police station.
Issue: Did the defendant have a right under the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments to have his counsel present at his identification process which took place before he was formally charged with the crime?
Law Argument: The court held that since the defendant in the current case was not formally charged with a crime when the identification process took place, the rulings of Wade and Gilbert do not apply here. The court ruled that the defendant had no right to the presence of an attorney in the current case because the police was just conducting normal investigation to solve an unsolved crime. The court further held that if the identification was "unnecessarily suggestive and conducive to irreparable mistaken identification", then the defendant could have claimed protection. But in the current case, the court found no such abuse of police power and the conviction was affirmed.
Decision: The Trial Court found Kirby and Bean guilty of robbery. They appealed. Kirby argued that based on United States v. Wade and Gilbert v.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Kirby vs. Carnival

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mock Trial for HFT 3603 Spring 2013 Catherine Rodriguez 4156924 In the case of Kirby vs. Carnival, I hold Carnival Cruise Lines responsible for her injury. There are several reasons why, first the bartender is responsible for her overall consumptions of alcohol, there is a history of guests that have either fallen or jumped over board and finally there is the fact that carnival never took it upon themselves to call for air lift transportation to the nearest hospital. Bartenders at Carnival…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Munn vs Illinois: The National Grange concern the Illinois legislation. Therefore, they put into law maximum rates that private companies can charge for storage of grain. Munn had infringed on the charge for storage of grain. He argued that the legislation of Illinois had taken property without the process of law. His company, legally sold grain due to not having a licenses and the prices were way above what was permitted in the states. The Supreme Court stepped in in 1867 declaring the National…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Escobedo Vs Illinois Case

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From 1960 until 1964 the Escobedo v. Illinois trial was taking place. This trial was over whether or not Escobedo’s rights were violated when he was arrested. Throughout Escobedo’s arrest and interrogation his constitutional rights were indeed violated, as he was not allowed to see his lawyer during his interrogation. Yet without a specific law in place it took various levels of the United States court system to come up with a final verdict for this case. As a result, Escobedo’s Rule was established…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kirby Harrison Case

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Case Synthesis Kirby Harrison owns and operates a local golf shop. His local point of sale program allows him to manage transactions with his customers when they come to the store to buy merchandise. He has all merchandise at hand. He manages the local golf course, which he handles all of the bookings, including groups. Harrison wants to figure out how he can use technology to promote his business growth. Another goal he has is to make current processes more organized and more machine-driven…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Presser V. Illinois was a landmark Supreme Court case in 1816. Herman Presser was part of a Citizen’s militia group, called the Lehr und Wehr Verein. They were a group of armed ethnic German Workers, they had formed in order to counter the armed private armies in Chicago. Herman Presser was indicted for arming a private army without having a license from the Governor. However, his charges were later sent to the U.S Supreme Court. Therefore after reviewing the case, and hearing Herman Presser’s testimony…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The case of Escobedo V. Illinois set the precedent for the sixth amendment, which is the right to a counsel. It guaranteed that if a person is arrested then they must be informed of their legal rights, which gives them the right to remain silent. When Danny Escobedo was arrested in connection for the shooting of one of his relatives he received an 18-hour interrogation and was later released for not making any self-incriminating statements. Another suspect was later arrested and told police that…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Supreme Court, in Escobedo v. Illinois, ruled in favor of Danny Escobedo. The Supreme Court explained that the interrogation process that Escobedo was placed under was biased and subjective. The verdict explained that the police department targeted Escobedo like he was the murderer and not as a suspect or a witness to the incident. Escobedo was treated like a guilty man; he was not awarded his rights protected under the 5th and 6th Amendments to the United States Constitution. These amendments…

    • 120 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shoplifting In Illinois

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There are different types of penalties for stealing in Illinois especially for minors because they are not dealt with in the criminal justice system, but rather through the juvenile system. This means they have their own courts, judges, prosecutors, and rules; however, the crime of shoplifting is the same for juveniles as it is for adults. The only main difference is that the juvenile court handles the case. Shoplifting is also known as larceny which divides into grand and petty theft. The difference…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The controversy that I’ve chosen is the Marvel/Kirby settlement agreement. The family of the comic book legend Jack Kirby sued Marvel for rights to the characters that he had created over the years. The Kirby’s had sought to terminate grants of copyrights to the characters, under section 304 (c) (2) of the copyright act of 1976. According to Jacob Reiser (2014), “This copyright act will grant an author or his/her descendants the right to recovered an author’s copyrights granted or transferred to…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Midterm Kirby Scotton

    • 3195 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Question 1: Although each early American writer had their own voice, many of them incorporated the same features in their writing. While some writers focused on their religious conviction and a need to connect to God, other writers desired self-promotion or they tried to spin narratives that would “sell” the New World to Europeans. Even though both versions explored different forms, structures and depictions of the New World, each author presented themes that resonated with the other. Many Early…

    • 3195 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays