Preview

Juveniles Must Be Tried As Adults Wilde Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1279 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Juveniles Must Be Tried As Adults Wilde Analysis
If one is old enough to do the crime, are they truly old enough to do the time? If so, does that time include being placed within a facility originally designated for those at a different age and mental capacity? There are countless disputes and problems regarding the justice system and its decisions. Among those decisions is the decision to sentence a juvenile as an adult and place them within a adult prison, rather than in a juvenile detention center. Just as in most things in life, the justice system is not black and white. Some agree with juvenile incarceration and others reckon children should be treated true to their age and as what they are, children. These academic journals, articles and opinion pieces attempt to make some sense of …show more content…
Wilde starts off their piece by directly stating their position on the matter. It becomes apparent that they side with no exceptions to be made for a criminal, simply due to their age. She believes in no excuses, as doing so is an insult to the family and is utterly unfair. By excusing a child’s criminal behavior, the justice system is deviating for what it stands for. Wilde uses the story of Jordan Brown to further fuel her argument. She suggests that Brown was fully aware of what he was doing when he murdered. Wilde claims Brown acted out of “jealously,” by included the quotes and implying negative connotations, it trivializes the situation in that it leaves Brown in a vulnerable position. No one other than those present know how they felt at the moment the murder was committed, however Wilde uses her loaded language to trigger a sense of anger from the audience. Following the mild anger, she wraps up by poking into the hearts of her readers. She then asks the audience to put themselves in the victim's shoes, wondering how they, too, would feel had the criminal who murdered their family member been given a lighter sentence due to their …show more content…
In “The Risks Juveniles Face When They Are Incarcerated With Adults” they conclude that juveniles with adult in prison is unjust and wrong. Therefore, they are reaching out to those who could make a difference in protecting children’s lives and preventing the incarceration in those facilities, such as politicians and lawmakers. The provide a simple and easy follow layout by providing an introduction, background information, their argument and a conclusion. The introduction helps their audience understand their position and what exactly they are going to discuss. They help bring their audience onto the same page as them by providing background information they deem necessary to understand the matter as a whole. They then discuss the risks, which is the main focus of their paper. The risks are rape and assault and the effects of it all. They include multiple studies for each point brought up which intensifies their claims, as it has all been studied and proven. At the end, they wrap everything up summarize their information into key points, which are the points the audience should take away from their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    At 16 years old, Jamal Vick was facing a 10-to-15 year sentence in an adult facility for Assault with Intent to Murder. Under the Youthful Offender Law passed in 1996, offenders as young as 14 years old could receive adult sentences for a wide range of crimes. Instead of a harsh adult sentence, Vick received a “blended” juvenile/adult sentence. In the traditional juvenile justice system, once the offender becomes an adult, his/her record is considered clean. Vick’s sentence, a combination of detention in a juvenile facility for five years (until he turns 21 years old), followed by four years of adult probation means that he will be under supervision until his mid-twenties. This practice is an attempt to operate in the middle ground between a “tough on crime” stance and the “reshape young lives” advocates. This is a core conflict facing the juvenile justice system. Striking the balance of satisfying the public’s desire for tough on crime, while still allowing for rehabilitation and support systems is an ongoing issue facing juvenile justice policies and practices. In recognition of the difficulties juveniles experience transitioning back into society, the Department of Youth Services (DYS) incorporates an approach that includes day reporting centers at which youths can get help…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order for juveniles to fully understand the affects and consequences to what they have committed, adult sentencing is a better and effective consequence. This is because juvenile sentencing is too lenient for kids and youths who commit heinous crimes. For example, “little girls who rob a bank was given a 26-years-to-life prison term,”(56) stated Margie Lundstrom in “Kids Are Kids-Until They Commit Crimes”. The sentencing of 26 years to life was understandable because these were little girls committing a…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Not a day goes by where our national media doesn’t report on stories involving heinous and criminal acts committed by juveniles in the United States. Juvenile delinquency is a fact of life – ranging from minor status offenses to unimaginable acts of violence. When dealing with young offenders, there are always difficult decisions to make concerning appropriate punishments that take both public safety and the needs of the juvenile into account. In response to a recognizable increase in youth crime, getting tough on juvenile delinquency and holding young offenders more accountable has been the national trend in the past two decades (Brinks, 2004). Many argue that removing juveniles from the environment in which their crimes were committed is the most successful deterrent of future negative behavior. But what does secure confinement provide these…

    • 3212 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this paper, I will look at current scholarly thought to determine the effectiveness of trying juveniles as adults in a court of law. In extreme instances, juveniles of a broad range of ages have committed violent crimes that the criminal justice system has determined to be impossible to have been committed by the accepted frame of mind of a juvenile. These juveniles were tried in adult court and sentenced accordingly. The purpose of my research is to examine juveniles who have been tried as adults and to discuss its strengths and weaknesses. I will analyze the information that I gather and will provide a strong case that this practice is appropriate. Many people believe that some crimes are so terrible that the courts should focus on the type of offense and not on the age of the accused.…

    • 1525 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harsh sentences’ have negative impacts on juvenile offenders. Being house with adults makes juveniles easy victims towards physical and sexual abuse. The court recognized that juveniles are immature, preventing them from the death penalty, but has not yet realized that juvenile offenders should not be housed with adult inmates because of the age difference, the adults easily manipulate the juveniles.…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Juveniles have been incarcerated in secure facilities since 1974. Juveniles are committing more heinous crimes and citizens have advocated for tougher penalties on crime. They want justice for the violence perpetrated on their families, businesses and communities. The Juvenile Justice system is charged with simultaneously protecting the public as well as reforming those juveniles who are convicted and sentenced to secure facilities. Barry C. Feld (1995) believes that there is a “desire to "get tough," fueled in part by frustration with the intractability of crime, that provides political impetus to transfer some young offenders to criminal courts for prosecution as adults and to strengthen the sanctioning powers of juvenile courts”(p.966).…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Civil Injuction Process

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Before the modern era, youth who committed crimes in the Western world received no preferential treatment because of their age. These children were adjudicated, punished, and confined alongside adult offenders. In more recent years the juvenile justice system has maintained different priorities than those that exist in the adult criminal justice system. However, there are still many get tough advocates of law and order, many of whom are fed up with violent juvenile crime, that are increasingly questioning the philosophy that underlies the juvenile justice system in America. Many people call for harsher punishments while others call for better rehabilitation programs for youth offenders. This paper will focus on the differences between the adult and juvenile justice systems, and whether rehabilitation or incarceration is the best method to assist in reducing the juvenile crime rate and help today’s youth become contributing members of society.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juveniles Tried as Adults

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “For over one hundred years, laws in the United States have distinguished juveniles who were charged with crimes from adult’s juvenile courts are structures to be less formal than their adult counter parts” (Huma Khan). No matter what the crime the juvenile is still a juvenile and should only be a tried as a juvenile. A juvenile court system allows for teens to be rehabilitated, one example is a boy named Tyheem J. Henery accused of beating another student to death and prosecutors want to try him as an adult. Officers from his detention center say he is model in mate and cab be rehabilitated. This proves that even the nastiest of young criminals are still too young to understand the…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Juvenile Justice System

    • 2095 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In today’s society, there are not that many distinctions between juveniles and adults when it comes to the criminal justice system. The main distinction between an adult and a juvenile is of course the age and the types of sentencing a juvenile may receive compared to an adult. The juvenile justice system has a tiered affect when it comes to sentencing but it relies heavily on the maturity and intellect of the juvenile. Due to that reason, there will always be a separate juvenile justice system to ensure the juvenile truly understands the nature of the crime and the consequences.…

    • 2095 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ten year old boy murders his family. Does he get out when he turns eighteen, because he knows not what he did? Or does he spend the rest of his life in prison? Sometimes teenagers are tried for crimes as adults and face equal penalties that are subject to adults. This is a controversial issue among americans. There are two groups of people. Those who believe that teenagers under the age of eighteen who commit serious crimes should be held responsible as adults for their actions. Courts are said to be too lenient and the young juveniles are evolving into violent youth criminals; And there are those who suggest that teenagers are less likely to understand the consequences of their actions and more likely to become productive citizens if the criminal justice system continues to treat eighteen year olds as juveniles. Juvenile death penalties and life sentences without parole have increased at an estimated rate of three times higher today than fifteen years ago. The youth are still growing to become fully developed, like an adult. There are many cases where tough decisions have to be made and choices must be made by officials. In my opinion all youths at the age of eighteen or younger should be tried as juveniles and all our juvenile courts need to focus more on rehabilitation for the lost of youth to criminal acts. Age should be a factor, not a determinant on how these youths should be tried.…

    • 2098 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many years, people have believed that the juvenile justice system was meant to serve as a way to protect the community. Juveniles who commit crimes are different from adults because many do not understand the complexity of the crime committed. In order to respond to these differences, many states have established a way to treat these adolescents through juvenile courts and youth-based recovery systems. While most states recognize that juveniles who commit crimes should not be treated as an adult there are still some that are skeptic that the juvenile justice system works.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    More than twenty years ago, youth violence reached an all-time high and America lost faith in its youth. Legislators across the United States responded to the crime spike by lowering the minimum age to be tried as an adult. Rehabilitation in juvenile facilities was no longer a valid option for violent offenders. Locking up these vicious criminals was the only reasonable alternative. However, harsher laws do not lower the crime rate, sending these children to prison does nothing to benefit society. It merely teaches youths to become better criminals and takes millions of dollars out of the taxpayers’ pockets. Juveniles should not be forced to face the harsh reality of adult criminal court and prison, but should be tried and sentenced as juveniles.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Campaign for Youth Justice (CFYJ) claims that placing juveniles in adult jails increases the likelihood that they will later be re-arrested for more serious crimes. Thus, the organization reasons, the practice of prosecuting juveniles as adults decreases public safety and should be abandoned”. This organization is stating that if a child is sent to an adult prison it will not help the individual or society. They claim that a rearrest is imminent. If the child is instead sent to a treatment facility they may gain the tools necessary to not become a repeat offender. Therefore making them less of a threat to themselves and the public. Another example of why children should not be tried as adults is jails are not a safe place for the youth and can give the child yet another traumatic experience. “It is extremely…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the topic of Juvenile offenders being tried, sentenced and jailed as adults, Researcher and Journalist Mike Allen claims that “report after report have concluded that trying teens as adults does nothing to deter crime -- and that sending teens to adult prison makes them more likely to become repeat offenders”. While I agree that sentencing a youth offender to a term of punishment to be carried out with adult offenders may continue the devastating cycle of violence in our culture, I do not agree that juvenile offenders should receive a smaller sentence or easier punishment on the basis of the affects of cross imprisonment. Instead I would argue that the justice system of America must evolve to adequately evaluate and implement punishment and reform that is conducive to the development of juvenile offenders. Youth crime in America is becoming an unavoidable circumstance that is poisoning our culture and hindering many of our youth from the ability to pursue fulfilled and successful lives. Just as Derrion Albert was an innocent bystander who loss his life to reckless and senseless acts of violence, our world has lost its viable claim of goodness to acts of hate against humanity.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults" is an essay by Laurence Steinberg, which expresses his views of if, when, and why youth offenders should be tried as adults. He compares the juvenile system to the adult system and point out hat the two differ in their respective forms of decision making for treatment or discipline. In the recent past, society has redefined the judicial system for juveniles and is striving to get more youth offenders trued and disciplined in adult jail systems (632). According to Steinberg, "[this] represents a fundamental challenge to the very premise that the juvenile court was founded on - that adolescents and adults are different (632)", and these forms of discipline are detrimental to the rehabilitation of young criminals. The author poses the question of how effective the judicial system is at determining when a child is to be tried as an adult and points out three very distinct characteristics of an adolescent individual between the ages of 12 and 17. First, he states that "there are dramatic changes in individuals' physical, intellectual, emotional, and social capabilities" between these ages (632). Secondly, he claims that between theses ages, individuals that have broken laws are still open to many positive influences that may help them abandon their criminal instincts and tendencies (632). Lastly, he points out that youth offenders who are sentenced to harsh punishments as adolescents often do not recover from the mental harm it causes because it is an important developmental time and these experiences may have lasting and disadvantageous effects on their adult behaviors (632). In a second argument, Steinberg explains that he doesn't believe that the age of a young defendant should be overlooked and, as seen earlier in the essay, uses three main points to illustrate this idea. First, he expresses that the legal system has a set of regulations and customs which differs from the individualistic and informal setting of a juvenile court…

    • 606 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays