John Berger Essay- Ways of Seeing

Topics: Impressionism, Post-Impressionism, Art critic Pages: 5 (1846 words) Published: November 13, 2008
While in the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, I traveled through the different galleries and their various cultures; discovering all sorts of arts from Contemporary art, to American art, Japanese art, and even the Egyptian art where I could appreciate the complexity of mummies. Throughout all these diverse cultures of art, I was questioning myself and started to wonder how I could understand art beyond others’ opinion about them. Moreover, I realized that it was a question John Berger, critic of art and author of the Ways of Seeing, raised in his essay, and it is a question that will always be raised while demanding how to understand a certain art. Walking through a room where various French artists had their paintings exposed, I fell in front of the artwork (see above) painted by Paul Gauguin. I did not choose a French artist to make me remember the French culture that I am missing here in Boston, nor to pretend that the French are advanced in art, but a way to analyze and understand, with the experience of a famous art critic, an artwork from an artist who astonished me in my previous art classes. D'où venons-nous, Qui sommes-nous, Où allons-nous?

By Paul Gauguin
I chose a painting that had a warm expression, and complex story emanating from it. As the title of my essay indicates, the title of the painting translated in English is “Where are we from? Who are we? Where are we going?” So many questions in the title and the painting, but there were as much coming through my mind while studying this image. This artwork is very ambiguous because I do not know how to start looking at it. I can observe people appearing half naked in the foreground, but we cannot really tell why they appear there. The statue in the back makes the questioning more obscure. It seems like an Oracle that gives people their destiny, and that is maybe why they all look so sad. Truly, I felt that this image was a representation of my origin country, West Indies, by the color Gauguin used. He used the blue to symbolize the ocean surrounding the island, and the mixed race of the habitants by the warm and beige color or the characters. I felt as if I was in the center of the painting, more precisely in the position of the child being observed in the right corner, and waiting to be reassured. I also felt like the person in the middle of the painting, standing up and waiting for answers while traveling through this painting. Gauguin’s artworks are extremely complicated to decipher, so are they to analyze. Gauguin is an artist I studied back in France in my art classes. Consequently, I had seen many of his works, and even the painting I chose; However, I had never asked myself how knowing about his life could help me study his paintings. I was taught in my art classes how to analyze art in a more technical way than in an analytical way like Berger supported. Indeed, when we were looking at the entire structure of the painting with my art class method, we were focusing on the brush strokes, the color, the tone, lines and forms, and the composition of the painting. If I had to describe the work of art I chose based on technical features, I would examine the painting saying that the brush strokes could express many emotions at the same time, and describe the painter style and art movement. Gauguin was also part of the post-impressionist painters with artists such as Paul Cezanne or Van Gogh. Post impressionist art was more focused on color, lines, outlines and perspective. Concerning Gauguin, the complexity of shapes is very important in his paintings due to their abstract significations. In fact, the lines were not straight; they were round and suggesting bodies that we did not see in art before. Moreover, the color had its importance. Post impressionist artists like Gauguin used color and color combination in order to create ‘vulgar’, ‘calm’ or ‘bold’ impressions (Robert Hughes). The analysis of the painting I just did was very technical and structural, but in...


Cited: Book references:
• Berger, John. “Ways of Seeing.” Ways of Reading. An Anthology for Writers. 8th
Edition. Ed. David Bartholomae and Anthony Petrosky. Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2008.
97-123.
• Hughes, Robert. “Paul Gauguin” The Shock of the New. NY: Alfred A. Knopf, 1980.
Painting:
Gauguin, Paul. D’ou venons nous? Qui sommes nous? Ou allons nous? 1898.
Museum of Fine Art, Boston, MA, United States.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • John Berger, Ways of Seeing Essay

    ...Finding the Meaning of an Artwork According to John Berger in his essay “Ways of Seeing” the way that a painting is viewed by some may already be distorted prior to analyzing it because we are not viewing the original piece. The information that comes from the silence of a painting is only truly experienced when looking at the original work rather than a reproduction of it. The original work speaks to you in a way that a reproduction is not able to. Berger says this clearly when he states: Original paintings are silent and still in a sense that information never is. Even a reproduction hung on a wall is not comparable in this respect for in the original the silence and stillness permeate the actual material, the paint, in which one follows the traces of the painter’s immediate gestures. This has the effect of closing the distance in time between the painting of the picture and one’s own act of looking at is. . . . What we make of that painted moment when it is before our eyes depends upon what we expect of art, and that in turn depends today upon how we have already experienced the meaning of paintings through reproductions. (116) The paintings may first appear as silent pieces but one can change this. Becoming familiar with a painting requires that one submerges himself/herself in it and ask it questions. Asking the right questions...

    Read More
    1355 Words 6 Pages
  • The Ways of Seeing by John Berger Essay Example

    ...Looking at Pictures [Berger] Original paintings are silent and still in a sense that information never is. Even a reproduction hung on the wall is not comparable in this respect for in the original the silence and stillness permeate the actual material, the paint, in which one follows the traces of the painter’s immediate gestures. This has the effect of closing the distance in time between the painting of the picture and one’s own act of looking at it. ... What we make of that painted moment when it is before our eyes depends upon what we expect of art, and that in turn depends today upon how we have already experienced the meaning of paintings through reproductions. (Berger 116) While Berger describes original paintings as silent in this passage, it is clear that these paintings begin to speak if one approaches them properly, if one learns to ask “the right questions of the past.” Berger demonstrates one route of approach, for example, in his reading of the Hals paintings, where he asks questions about the people and objects and their relationship to the painter and the viewer. What the paintings might be made to say, however, depends upon the viewer’s expectations, his or her sense of the questions that seem appropriate or possible. Berger argues that because of the way art is currently displayed, discussed, and reproduced, the viewer expects only to be mystified. For this assignment,...

    Read More
    632 Words 3 Pages
  • John Berger Ways of Seeing Essay

    ...In John Berger’s article, ’Ways of Seeing’, it explains European eighteenth century art and how it relates to many of todays cultural transitions. Before Berger begins explaining the art itself, he tells us about the cultural constructions that exist today. These cultural constructions are enforced and were highlighted through European eighteenth century art. He began by explaining the difference between a man and a woman’s presence. Men’s presence depends how much power he is able to successfully portray. This power can be social, economical, sexual, etc. A woman’s presence expresses her attitude toward herself and in turn how she will allow other to treat her. This explains why women are so critical of them and critique their actions no matter what the situation may be. Berger begins to explain how the art ties into this when he says, “men act, women appear.” He further explains how men look at women, while women watch themselves being looked at. Thus, a woman is turned into an object. He even provides an interesting example of how women supposedly became subservient to men. In the book of Genesis Eve gave Adam an apple they weren’t supposed to eat. After they ate the apple they became aware and self-conscious of the fact they were naked, so they made clothes for themselves. Eve was punished for eating the apple and giving one to Adam by being made subservient to the man. This relates to...

    Read More
    390 Words 2 Pages
  • John Berger Seeing Comes First Essay

    ...October 28, 2010 Seeing Comes First One of the most important senses that we human have is the ability to see things. We see the image of the object first before the image is send to our brain and processes it. The essay “Ways of Seeing”, written by John Berger took art as an example, to show the way how modern people view art and the influences that traditional oil painting has had on society and modern day society. The way people now a day perceives an art image is different than the way it was seen before. People nowadays have the idea that a painting is an image that the painter painted and whatever it is there is always a reason for it. And most of us going to art museum have the assumption of wanting to find the truth within the image, trying to link history to the present. These assumptions only make the past more unclear and does not clarify, but mystify. According to Berger, most painters are not searching for fame, such as the painter Frans Hals, who lived off public charity in order to be able to produce works. This has changed over time too due the birth of camera, since paintings are widely accessible; people go to museums viewing art because of its fame. More painting are being seen in public now, and the more people who seen it the more fame it will gain. This will eventually lose the value of art....

    Read More
    1161 Words 5 Pages
  • Comparative Critique Ways Of Seeing By John Berger And There Is No Unmarked Woman By Deborah Tannen Essay

    ...David Cohen C.J. Jackson W131 19 September 2012 (In blue are all suggested changes or additions.) (In red with strikethrough are all suggested removals, red underlines are points needing nonspecific revisions, and red italics are commentary.) I know I’m pretty harsh, but just remember if I didn’t want you to do well I would do less… Comparative Critique: Ways of Seeing by John Berger and There is no Unmarked Woman by Deborah Tannen Once upon a time, (I’d stay way from this… perhaps) a group of dodo birds inhabited an island in the Indian Ocean. The men (males—men refers to humans) were large and colorful with fearless attitudes(,) while the women (smaller females) were smaller and represented (wore comparatively—stay away from were and was, try to use unique descriptive verbs allowing for imagery) neutral colors (plumage). As the population grew smaller (dwindled), the number of females decreased more quickly than the males (deteriorated much faster than that of the males). The last female later died which (The death of the last female) left the population without the ability to mate and ultimately led to their extinction. Throughout written history men have expressed their dominance over women. It has been a battle of equality for centuries, and the outcomes are quite obvious. Men are stronger and leave women to manage the home life while women are constantly trying to please them. Society sees that...

    Read More
    2029 Words 6 Pages
  • John Berger Research Paper

    ...In John Berger's essay "Another Way of Telling," Berger argues that photographs contain a "third meaning." Berger claims that the third meaning is personal and relies almost completely on the individual viewer. As a result, no photograph can convey the same message to any two people and no two photographs can convey the same message to any one person. Here, the validity of Berger's assumption crumbles. All photographs communicate one absolute truth. Berger states, "All subjectivity is treated as private" (100). Yet, claiming that anything subjective within a photograph, its past and future, is personal only supports an absolute truth. The truth, however, is beyond the viewer's conscious interpretation and the photograph becomes ambiguous. Berger becomes mislead when he compares an individual's opinion of the past or future of a photograph to the actual truth of the photograph, thus surfaces "ambiguity." Even Berger agrees that ambiguity is the result of the viewer's personal experiences and psychology, but he ignores what the viewer cannot see. When discussing the ambiguity of the photograph of the horse and man, page 85, Berger can only guess as to why the photograph was taken and to what the meaning is. Berger describes this process as, " . . . a game of inventing meanings" (86). Here, Berger admits to...

    Read More
    950 Words 4 Pages
  • Essay about John Bergers

    ...John Berger definition of mystification through Hal’s painting In John Berger’s reading, he states that “Mystification is the process of explaining away what might otherwise be evident” (pg 103). To my understanding, Berger is saying that mystification is a way of what we think may be clear to our understanding of something. It seem as though Berger express mystification in ways that one may not grasp something clearly even though it may seem to be evident. By expressing this, Berger used the passage Hals’s unwavering commitment to his personal vision, which enriches our consciousness of our fellow men and heightens our awe for the ever-increasing power of the mighty impulses that enabled him to give us a close view of life’s vital forces. as an example of mystification. This passage shows that Hals may use his painting to influence us by what we are aware of and how we perceive certain things. This allow us to believe what the painting may mean even though it is not exactly what it seem to be, which then explains why the lack of clarification on a painting causes confusions. This is what you call mystification. Followed by Berger definition of mystification, Berger mentioned “Today we see the art of the past as nobody saw it before. We actually perceive it in a different way.” Pg 103 Art from the past may never...

    Read More
    877 Words 4 Pages
  • John Berger Essay

    ...Berger's "Ways of Seeing" VS. My Own There are numerous ways to "see" a picture. One person's life can, and will affect the way in which they view the painting. I do not agree with Berger's way of thinking throughout "Ways of Seeing". I feel that his opinions are contradictory, and opposite of mine. One reason I don't like this reading is because he notes, "The way we see things is affected by what we know or what we believe. In the middle Ages when men believed in a physical existence in Hell, the sight of fire must have meant something different from what it means today" (106). I get from this that what he is saying is somewhat hypocritical of what he notes later in the article. Berger later states that part of the image is lost by its replication, "Having seen this reproduction (Virgin of the Rocks), one can go to the National Gallery to look at the original and there discover what the reproduction lacks" (116), the only thing the reproduction lacks is the price tag of the original. I disagree with this, if replication was not possible, people would not be able to view the piece of art and make their own conclusions of it. The ways the image and texts are interpreted are based on interpreter's perception, belief, past history and interpretation of events. In John Berger's book, ‘Ways of...

    Read More
    715 Words 3 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free