Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Jihad and the Conflict between Islam and Christianity

Powerful Essays
2057 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jihad and the Conflict between Islam and Christianity
THE SHADE OF SWORDS

Jihad and the conflict between Islam and Christianity

M.J. Akbar

Book Review

By
Mehr Islam (BSMS5)

Introduction

Jihad is a religious duty of Muslims. In Arabic, the word Jihad means "struggle". Within the context of the classical Islam it refers to struggle against those who do not believe in the Islamic God. However, the word has even wider implications. Jihad means "to struggle in the way of Allah". The "greater jihad" is the inner struggle by a believer to fulfill his religious duties. The "lesser jihad" is the physical struggle against the enemies of Islam. This physical struggle can take a violent form or a non-violent form. The violent form translate jihad as "holy war".
The profession of faith is the shahada: Lailaha il-Allah, Muhammad ur Rasul Allah. There is but one Allah and Muhammad is His Prophet. Those who become martyrs for Allah are the shaheed. The martyr smiles his way to death and death opens the door to paradise. Jihad is the trademark of Islamic history. Allah promised victory to the Muslim, but only if the believer kept faith with him. Most Muslim governments now are undemocratic and unrepresentative about the needs of the community. In the 19th century Indian Muslims declared jihad against the British which made them think that rebellion was compulsory in Islam. The British protected their empire by playing Muslim anguish off against Hindu anger. Which resulted in a partition and Pakistan was born in 1947. Pakistan should have become a model modern Muslim nation. But it became a civilian chaos after which there was martial law which resulted in military chaos and another partition. After 1971 there was democracy which was so dictatorial that the citizens happily agreed to the return of military rule.

Life of Prophet Muhammad SAW

The first chapter briefs us about the life of the Prophet, from the day of revelation till the battle of Nehawand against the Persians in 642.
In between it explains that the inheritance of a powerful history influences the political consciousness of Muslims. A community that is spread across so many geographical locations through different cultures will readily unite for any threat from powerful enemies. It was the Quraysh before now it is the Christian West, this conclusion has been formed over a millennium. All empires rise and fall, but the Muslim believes in a three-phase cycle: rise, fall, and renewal. Since an empire is the achievement of man, corruption is unavoidable. The Prophet foresaw this when he said best Muslims were those who saw progressive decline of their empire. He understood the ability of power to corrupt, he said: ‘the closer you are to government, the further you are from God.’ The chapter also mentions what the Prophet said about jihad. As he was once asked if it was true that the ones who died for the cause would go to heaven, the Prophet agreed that it was true and added, ‘Know that paradise is under the shade of swords.’ He said that a single spell of fighting in Allah’s cause was better than all the world, and a place in paradise as small as a bow was better than all the world and whatever was in it. The Prophet urged Muslims to seek Firdaus, the highest and brightest part of paradise, just bellow Allah’s throne. Allah had reserved one hundred grades of paradise only for the martyrs.
Islam’s principles are clear: La iqra fi ad din (there shall be no compulsion in religion) and Lakum dinakum wa layeddin (your religion for you, and mine for me).
The lessons of jihad enumerated by Abdullah Yusuf Ali:
1. Numbers do not count, but faith, determination and the blessing of Allah;
2. Size and strength are of no avail against truth, courage, and careful planning;
3. The hero tries his own weapons, and those that are available to him at the time and place, even though people may laugh at him;
4. If Allah is with us, the enemy’s weapon may become an instrument of his own destruction;
5. Personality conquers all dangers, and puts heart into our own wavering friends;
6. Pure faith brings Allah’s reward, which may take many forms; power, wisdom.
The parallels with the twenty-first century are not hard to find. The Quran scorns those Muslims who shy away from a just war. Fighting does not mean selfish aggression, and the highest censure is reserved for the bully and the oppressor. Conversely, there is no higher form of sacrifice than death in a jihad. The Muslim who turns his back during a war of jihad has only one destination, hell. The sermon dwells in detail on the rewards of the bargain: the souls of martyrs could live wherever they liked in paradise, all their sins forgiven; the martyr could intercede with Allah for seventy of his relatives.
In one of the chapters M.J. Akbar states, The last injunction that the apostle gave was in his words ‘Let not two religions be left in the Arabian peninsula’. (The apostle died on the twelfth Rabi-ul-awwal on the very day that he came to Medina as an emigrant, having completed exactly twelve years in his migration.) When the apostle was dead the Muslims were sore stricken. Within the brief two and a half years that he was Caliph, Abu Bakr fulfilled the last injunction of the Prophet.

After the Prophet SAW

Blood and confusion travel together in this phase of Muslim history, as they tend to do at times when the rudder is lost. Within fifty years of the Prophet’s death, there were three men in close proximity to one another, each claiming to be Caliph. For Muslims, Muhammad is a man and the last prophet in a sequence that begins with Adam and includes Jesus; for Christians, Jesus is divine, and the final redemption of mankind. It is consequently incumbent upon the Church to declare Muhammad an impostor. To do anything else would be to make Christianity a 611-year-old religion and Christ’s mission could not be deemed eternal. The Quran repeatedly tells Christians to return to the monotheism of Abraham, renounce the concept of the Trinity, and accept Muhammad as the Last Messenger. The Quran venerates Jesus; for the Church to return the compliment would be suicide. Ideologically, Muhammad and Jesus also offer two radically different constructs of the ideal, a fact that has been used to spawn a swarm of negative images about the former. The Quran explains that different Prophets were relevant for different times, with different degrees of honour. Allah spoke directly to Moses, who spent forty years in the wilderness fighting the disbelief of his own people. Moses was given the Book, but not mastery of the sword. David was born a shepherd, but became warrior, king, musician, poet, and Allah’s Caliph. Jesus was given the holy spirit, but no weapons for war, his mission was peaceful. Muhammad, as the last Messenger, combined the characteristics of all the Prophets, as his mission was greater than that of any of his predecessors. Christians, on their part, sullied Muhammad as an impostor, a libertine and an evil counselor who tricked the Arabs. Equating Muhammad with the devil and anti-Christ.
'The first eight chapters explain the doctrinaire and historical roots of the conflict between Islam and Christianity: the wars that began from virtually the lifetime of the Prophet for political control of the known world, and the spill of hatred into literature and rhetoric, leaving wounds more permanent than the fortune of battle...'

Mughal Empire and British Rule

Afghan warlord Mahmud of Ghazni's sacking of the Somnath temple in AD 1026 was based not just on jihadi logic but on the belief that the pre-Islamic idol. "In destroying Manat, he had carried out what were said to be the very orders of the Prophet. He was therefore doubly a champion of Islam." When Babur ordered a jihad against Rajputs at the battle of Khanwa in 1527, his intention may have not been mere looting and iconoclasm, but the language for galvanizing soldiers was the same as Mahmud's. Babur gave orders for two jihads: one against the ‘pagan’ and the other for spiritual cleansing. He renounced alcohol and prayed to Allah. Last, that he was father of one of the greatest emperors of India, Akbar, who was Babur's grandson, wrested victory against Hemachandra from the jaws of defeat in the second battle of Panipat, leading Abul Fazl to exclaim later that it was "Allah's divine wrath against the infidel, a victory for jihad."
When the British finally eliminated fellow European competition for India, the Sultan of Bengal, Siraj ud Daula, suffocated 43 Englishmen to death in Calcutta (infamous as the "Black Hole" incident). Even though the British were less crusading in their expansionism, Akbar notes that the Black Hole "added a moral zeal to their cause".
Akbar claims that the Muslim separatist claim in the Indian subcontinent was a direct result of the faltering fortunes of political Islam in South and Central Asia. Muslims in India began viewing themselves distinctly as a minority only after the Christian takeover of Delhi. "Jinnah fertilized a fear from the Islamic subconscious" and successfully spearheaded the partition of India that led to the creation of Pakistan in 1947. Gandhi had attempted harnessing jihad into a non-violent path during the Khilafat agitation of the early 1920s, but "the Muslim mind could not understand the sanctity of non-violent jihad for the liberation of the holy places".

The Age Of Osama

President Musharraf asked for an end to the culture of jihad that had wounded Pakistan more than it had hurt anyone else. He told the extremist clergy that they must stop encouraging gullible young men into martyrdom. Pakistan had not taken the responsibility for jihad across the world. He would not allow mosques to be misused and seminaries to become schools for hatred; he would end the rule of the Kalashnikov. Pakistan would not become a theocratic state, he asserted. No one would be allowed to carry on any jihad, including the jihad in Kashmir, from the comfort of Pakistan, he declared; that era was over.
Osama emerged out of the Afghan experience with an unshakeable conviction, which he repeated to anyone who would listen: with insignificant numbers and limited capability, a jihad could defeat even the greatest empire in the world. If the Soviet Union could be humbled, then the same spirit could renew Muslim power and confront Islam’s more powerful enemy, America, the superpower that had usurped the oil wealth that Allah had given to Muslims. When Osama returned home to Saudi Arabia, he was welcomed as a hero by its government and the people. Osama began to see himself as a new Caliph, or imam, who would safeguard Muslim interests across the world. The Taliban, and Al Qaida, and many organizations with a similar dream, can survive without a government, or even a country, because the recruitment is done in the mind. You cannot fight a battle in the mind only with special forces and cruise missiles. On 7 October 2001 the United States of America answered 11 September. It declared war on the Taliban, Osama bin Laden, and terrorism. The defeat of the Taliban and Osama was complete, but not decisive. Conclusion

The book concludes by providing a background on Iraq, Iran and Saddam Hussein. Akbar explains that the conflict between Islam and Christianity has acquired myriad shapes over fourteen hundred years: indoctrine, culture, and of course on the battlefield, from the fall of Jerusalem to the Caliph Omar in 637 CE to the presence of British and American troops in Pakistan and Afghanistan in 2002. The cause of bitter wars between Christians and Muslims has also been unearthed. Lack of sensitivity and respect towards each other’s religious figures fuelled war after war between Christians and Muslims.
Akbar has resolved any doubts about the contemporary relevance of perceived injustices of history and set at rest apologist arguments that the "revealed religions" do not in themselves contain the sparks of bitter hate and that only a few "misguided" zealots have distorted peaceful faiths. The only stance that MJ adopts is that of his conclusion- knowing Muslims the world over, jehad, not in its first meaning, as the struggle to know God, but in its second, that of fighting the unbeliever, is not yet done.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Christianity and Islam Dbq

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Christianity and Islam are the two most recognized religions in the world today. And their attitudes toward merchants and trade has had a major effect on the worlds economy even dating back to the founding of the religions. Islam's firsts views on trade where very positive most likely due to the fact that it's founder, Muhammad was a merchant himself. However Christianities first views on merchants and trade were more negative. Jesus the founder of Christianity was a carpenter and thought that the only way to reach heaven was through spiritual means rather than through the shady arts of merchants and trading. Although the first attitudes on merchants and trade were negative from Christianity and positive from Islam over the next 1500 years their views had changed into the opposite of what was first conceived.…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christianity and Islam

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In our society from the earliest times to now there has been religion. And these religions consisted of people who had a voice in how the organization in a way viewed something. In views and opinions there are both disagreeing parts and parts that agree. Christianity and Islam both had agreeing and disagreeing views on merchants. The higher classmen of Christianity and Islam agree and the scholars agree with each other, but the underclassmen of these religions disagree.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I think the French Wars of Religion was more about religious differences because ever since the French nobles became Calvinists, they would show independence from the central power. It created the conflict between Catholics and Calvinists where power was the main struggle making religion become a way bigger issue. The last of the wars would be the war of the Three Henry’s where it showed the overall religious differences between the Catholics and the Protestants. Which this was between Henry III and Henry of Guise versus Henry IV.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever wondered what sets Christiantiy from Islam apart or even what brings them together? The similarities between the spread of Islam and Christianity they both had a significant number of people in higher classed who help spread the religions. The differences between the spread of Islam to Christianity wasInside the time period c. 600 CE to 1250ce and first century to 1000ce Islam and Christianity were spread. The two religions spread socially and monetarily comparative however politically diverse. While both Islam and Christianity were spread Christianity had a larger number of governments in control than Islam.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trade as well as religion has always been a part of world history. However when you put the two side by side, it is often questioned whether trade is encouraged or advocated in a specific religion or not. Within the time period of 600 CE to about 1500,Islam and Christianity were able to be the world’s dominant religions. As both religions rose to power they began to develop their own attitudes towards merchants and trade itself. The two religions differ in their initial attitudes towards trade and merchants. While Christianity’s initial attitude did not accept trade and merchants, Islam’s initial attitude did accept trade and merchants. However both religions’ attitudes were similar in the fact that over time, they both changed their opinions…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From reading The Book of Contemplation I feel that the Franks are Inferior to the Muslims, in the eyes of Usama Ibn Munqidh. Throughout the literature when Usama refers to the Franks, a “may God curse them” usually follows. Usama rarely sheds a positive light on the Franks’ beliefs, actions, or practice of medicine.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lesser Jihad

    • 3046 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Jihad, or "holy war", though a new concept to the western world has a long-standing…

    • 3046 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Islam and Isis

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ISIS is a terrorist group that has brought much drama and fright to many of late. ISIS stands for Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. They had actually begun as an al Qaeda splinter group. The aim of ISIS is to create an Islamic state across Sunni areas of Iraq and in Syria. It’s mainly known for killing dozens of people at a time and carrying out public executions, crucifixions and other acts. The group controls hundreds of square miles. It ignores the international borders and has a presence from Syria’s Mediterranean coast to south of Baghdad. ISIS rules by Sharia Law, the custom-based body of law based on the Koran and the religion of Islam.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cited: Bellany, Alastair. "Christianity Faces Islam." Lecture 7. Rutgers University, New Jersey. 27 Sept. 2005.…

    • 2304 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion: Jihad and Peace

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Jihad has been interpreted by Muslims in different ways. The Muslim sect of the Kharijites has elevated Jihad to one of the Five Pillars of Islam, making it…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    How and why did the Second and Third Crusades fail to match the enthusiasm and success of the First?…

    • 1929 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jihad, which some people refer to as the sixth pillar, means struggle for your religion. This is a religious belief and practice that Islams take very seriously. Sometimes known as holy war, many Islams use this as their reason to fight. In document #4 it is showing that Muslims, at the Battle of Tours saw the resistance to convert as a struggle, so they fought. Not always did they use force, but sometimes propaganda to get people to convert. People were promised that if they did, they could go to Paradise. Document #2 a qoute from the Quran, states that if you follow Allah and his Apostle(Muhammad) then he’ll bring you there. But if you turn away, if you don't accept, then you will be punished or go to Hell. Though acceptive of Christianity and the Jewish religion because they followed God and were People of the Book, they were still heavily taxed and threatened, shown in document…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Due to the vast expansion of Islam and Christianity in the time period from 700-1000 CE both religions flourished. While quite similar with their expansions, they developed with various unique characteristics, such as their tolerance for other religions.…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There have been many conflicts between different religions throughout history. This is an important matter because wars relating to religion have impacted the world around us and imposed many different ideas or opinions that people, still to this day, debate about. A series of wars that occurred during the 11th and 12th centuries over opposing religions, known as Christianity and Islam, are called “The Crusades”. While individual soldiers mostly fought in the Crusades for religious reasons such as being rewarded with eternal life and granting God’s wishes, those in power mostly started the Crusades for political gain, like in the case of the Pope who desired power over Jerusalem.…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    But, Jihad may have a meaning of acquiring maturity spiritually against devil, or a blast “against injustice” on earth. So, this blast against…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics