James Caird: An Analysis

Have you ever thought about dying suddenly without thought? Or, have you ever wondered why people risk their lives doing something ludicrous just to satisfy their thrill seeking obsession? Not only are these folks endangering themselves, but they are risking the lives of the men and women that come to save them in these dangerous and complex situations. For example, if you decide to go hiking up a steep, treacherous trail in which mountain lions are known to be present, is it wise to choose that particular route? There are several other safe trails, yet you still select the more precarious option. Out of nowhere, a mountain lion viciously attacks. Should this person be held accountable for making an unwise decision knowing the risks beforehand?
It doesn't matter if you are a generally cautious human being or a fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants thrill seeker. People should be accountable for their own decisions without exception.. If you knowledgeably and purposefully find yourself in a life or death situation, or even a slightly risky situation, you should be held accountable for being in that situation because you placed yourself in that position and consciously took that chance. An example of this is when the crew members on the James Caird decided to embark upon a dangerous journey despite the threat of horrific storms and rough seas. Soon enough, the sailors found themselves threatened and trapped in ice. Fortunately, luck was on their side and they survived and overcame this dangerous situation. Despite their survival, these sailors were not prepared for something as life-threatening as getting trapped in ice. They were also ill prepared for the journey in general because they neglected to bring proper supplies such as warm clothing. Consequently, when the monstrous waves crashed on the crew members, they had no sufficient way of making themselves warm. As a result, the crew members spent their days and nights freezing and unable to assist others. Although no one realistically expects to die doing something that they enjoy, you have to be prepared for any situation that arises. If something accidentally goes wrong and you perish, you have to be held
Someone could have a severe psychological issue causing them to act and do things that they wouldn't normally do. This opposing argument defends the theory that their mental state outweighs their actions. Some believe that a person in this condition is unable to see the bigger picture and should therefore not be blamed for their actions. According to this belief, they should not be blamed for endangering themselves or any of the first responders attempting to save this victim from doing harm to himself or any innocent bystanders. Even though the rescuer should expect and be prepared for any situation, it is not fair or just to the rescuer’s family that they are being put in this situation at the expense of a “crazy