Is There a Moral Obligation to Obey the Law?

Good Essays
‘Must we only obey a just law; should we obey a law because it is just to do so; or else can we not obey at all?'
ESSAY

The questions that shall be answered in this essay are ‘Must we only obey a just law?', ‘Should we obey a law because it is just to do so?' and ‘Or else, can we not obey at all?' Before we can answer these questions it is important to establish what is meant by the term ‘just'. ‘Just' in this case means ‘morally just', I think, but differences of opinion exist as to its meaning. For the purpose of this essay, I shall take ‘just' to mean ‘fair' in the way Rawls indicates when he writes about the veil of justice in 1971: the every-day-sense of the term the average person would agree about.

Should we obey a law because it is just to do so?

The first question I shall address is whether one should obey a law ‘because it is just to do so'. Woozley in 1979 states: If political leaders and police chiefs had their way, all of us would believe that a powerful reason (possibly the principle, if not the only, reason) that we should obey a law is that it is a law. In fact, with the exception of a special class of laws, it is no reason at all.

This is the core of discussion whether there is a general moral obligation to obey the law.
This discussion started in the 1970's in the United States. The background to it was the civil rights movement in the United States, and the Vietnam War with its political scandals. People who disagreed with the governments' policies started arguing that sometimes, a citizen is justified in acting illegally.
The question is: does a citizen have a moral duty to obey the law and if so, why?

In the writings of Honoré, Raz, Smith, Finnis and Bix there are many arguments for and against a general moral obligation to obey. Often, they take each other's ideas as a basis and develop or counter argue them.
I shall give a synopsis of five arguments in favour of a general moral obligation to obey, and give my own and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Many philosophers have pondered the immense question surrounding the prima facie moral obligation to obey the law. Do we have a moral obligation to do as the law tells us, outside of the fact that the law deems it illegal? There are many opinions on this, such as Wolff’s idea that there is in fact no moral obligation for anyone to obey the law because there is no legitimate state with control over people. This is one of the many viewpoints discussed throughout time, but there is a more level headed…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Moral Obligation

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the chapter, Genetic Choices, the issue of moral obligations in regards to genetic information about potential disease and illness. Upon review, I find individuals to have a moral obligation to warn others if they have knowledge about their genetic predisposition in regards to disease and/ or illness. The first case I will discuss is when an individual knows their family members are either at great risk or are certain to have a specific disease and/ or illness due to their diagnosis or…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moral Obligations

    • 1064 Words
    • 3 Pages

    into account when it comes to helping. He argues that it makes no moral difference whether the person you help is a neighbor ten yards away or a person in another country (Singer, 1972, p. 231-232). Singer also wants you to take into consideration that the principles don’t make a distinction between people. It doesn’t matter that it is just you or you and a million others in the same position. If someone is doing nothing, in moral terms, it is no different than the absence of people doing something…

    • 1064 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Affirming achieves the value of morality defined by the American Heritage Dictionary as, “conforming to the rules of right conduct; moral or virtuous conduct.” This is the proper value for the round because of the word ‘ought’ in the resolution which the same sourced defines as, ‘Used to express duty or moral obligation’ meaning the resolution is asking us to determine the more moral means of providing drinking water to people. Morality is also the proper value because…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Is Moral Obligation

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is moral obligation? What is the extent of our moral obligation to other people and other living things? By definition moral obligation is the belief that an act is one prescribed by a persons set of values (Wikipedia, 2005). It is also a duty, which one owes, and which one ought to perform, but is not legally bound to fulfill. David Hume 's moral theory hinges on a distinction between psychologically distinct players: the moral agent, the receiver, and the moral spectator. All actions…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    courage or piety) fit in to the overall definition of doing good and living by the correct moral standards. The dialogues of the Apology and the Crito deal with the trial and sentencing of Socrates, facilitating a discussion about an individual's morality in abiding by the law. Socrates does show us that civil law should be treated as a moral obligation, by proving that to ignore the rule of law would be to commit moral wrong. He then qualifies this by illustrating that lawfulness is not always equal to…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    My Moral Obligation

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Nicole Swires Mrs. Matayabas ENG 101 2:05 18 February 2010 My Moral Obligation to the Poor Have you ever stopped to think about all the general essentials you have access to and all the material possessions you have been blessed with? Often times I see people around me who seem unhappy with what they do have. There is nothing wrong with wanting or buying more than what we need; luxuries are nice. The problem comes in when we only think about ourselves and not about other people. Some people can…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    To obey or not obey

    • 1539 Words
    • 4 Pages

    101-E111 18 September 2014 To obey or not obey, that is the question? A summary of a piece written by Erich Fromm Erich Fromm (1900-1980) was a noted psychoanalyst, philosopher, historian, and sociologist that lived a long life over some very troubled times in the history of the world. He authored more than 30 books and was a studier of Freud and Marx, both offering different insights on the subject matter of Fromm’s piece “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem.” Mr. Fromm wrote this…

    • 1539 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    elected by representing a political party has a moral obligation to obey the party’ There are many reasons as to why this is an issue, the main reason being party whips. A party whips are people or methods that by which a given party informs their MPs what position or way the party is taking or voting concerning a particular issue. A local Croydon Newspaper in September headlined, ‘Party whip or conscience?’, the article concerning the amendment in the laws regarding abortion, suggested that the general…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    statement that there is natural duty to obey the law even in reasonably decent democratic societies in order to rescue others from the dangerous conditions of the state of nature. To do this, I will explore a world in which there is a natural duty to obey the law to evaluate if it is the best way to protect us from the dangerous conditions. Next, I will explore the ambiguity in the natural theory to sufficiently justified a duty to obey the law simply because it is a law. Through these analyses, I will…

    • 2080 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays