Is Mill a Rule Utilitarian?

Topics: Utilitarianism, Morality, Rule utilitarianism Pages: 3 (904 words) Published: May 7, 2005
D. Vinson
Is Mill A Rule Utilitarian?

I don't believe so. I must begin my argument with two definitions and one assumption. First, Rule Utilitarianism states that right action is defined by whether or not a given action is an instance of a moral rule that tends to maximize utility. Second, Act Utilitarianism states that right action is defined by whether or not a given action maximizes utility. Finally, the Utilitarian Principle holds that right actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. I hope that my assumption will be granted as it is taken verbatim from the text. With these notions as a starting point I believe that I can now show Mill to be an act-utilitarian.

The case for Mill being a rule-utilitarian is a strong one. Mill certainly relies heavily on rules in his treatise and argues that they are useful to the point of necessity.
To consider the rules of morality as improvable is one thing;
to pass over the intermediate generalizations entirely, and to
endeavor to test each individual action directly by the first
principle is another.
Further on in the text, Mill even seems to minimize the importance of the first principle by declaring that it is only useful for settling disputes over secondary principles.
…only in these cases of conflict between secondary
principles is it requisite that first principles should be appealed
The problems with Mill being a rule-utilitarian begin to arise when we examine its method. When, in the statement of the Utilitarian Principle, Mill says that right actions tend to promote happiness, some have taken that to mean that Mill must only be dealing with classes of action. If this were the case, then an instance of a right action class, if in the wrong (of any infinitely complex) set of circumstances, may fail to maximize happiness but still be right.

Furthermore, an act-utilitarian may still make great use of moral...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • The utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Essay
  • Essay on The Utilitarian
  • Abortion and Utilitarian Essay
  • Utilitarian Ethics Essay
  • rules Essay
  • Kant or Mill Essay
  • Utilitarian Principles Essay
  • Utilitarian Arguments Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free