top-rated free essay

Is It Possible To Feel Sympathy For Macbeth

By Mithun16 Apr 20, 2015 898 Words
Is it possible to feel sympathy for Macbeth?
In this essay I will be considering whether we can feel sympathy for Macbeth after analysing Act one and the beginning of Act two (up until Duncan’s death). I will analyse the viewpoint of Macbeth at the start and how he changes and how our opinion can change and evaluate whether we can feel sympathy for Macbeth. The first scene in Act one is a very short one, which consist of the three witches discussing when and where to meet Macbeth. We can take a quote from this scene where all the witches chant: ‘Fair is foul and foul is fair,’ this quote is hinting towards Macbeth future, with the quotes meaning being that things don’t look the same as they actually are on the inside. In the second scene, king Duncan learns the rebels, led by traitor Thane of Cawdor Macdownwald, has been crushed by Macbeth, Macbeth is praised for his bravery shown in this quote: ‘for brave Macbeth (well he deserves that name, disdaining fortune, with his brandished steel’ this shows his bravery and loyalty, at this point he is a soldier with good intentions and no aspiration for harm. After Duncan hears this news he orders for Mcdonwald’s execution and announces Macbeth to be the new thane of Cawdor. Duncan’s condemns Macdownwald by saying ‘no more that Thane of Cawdor shall deceive our bosom’s interest,’ meaning that he won’t receive matters close to his heart. In scene three the witches appear and discuss putting a horrific spell on a sailor just for being rude to one of the witches, this is hinting towards the way they treat Macbeth and what Macbeth is going to be dragged into. The witches then come to Macbeth and Banquo to give a prophecy in which they hail Macbeth as ‘Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor and King hereafter,’ the three witches then disappear. After, Angus and Ross tell Macbeth he is the new Thane Cawdor, this tells Macbeth the prophecy is true. Macbeth is very interested and tempted in the crown now we know this from this quote: ‘why do I yield to that suggestion whose horrid image doth unfix my hair, and make me my seated heart knock at my ribs.’ Macbeth has just thought about killing Duncan but the thought makes him feel an odd sick feeling, his humanity provokes us to feel sympathy for Macbeth. In scene 4, King Duncan thanks Macbeth and Banquo personally. You can tell that Macbeth wants the crown as he flatters Duncan as he says ‘The service and loyaltiy I owe in doing it, pays itself, Your highness’ part is to receive our duties.’ However Malcolm, Duncan’s son, is announced as the next king, you can feel sympathy for Macbeth here because what he has been promised by the witches has been taken away from him. However this quotes tells us that Macbeth wants to kill Duncan: ‘that is a step on which I must fall down, or else o’erleap, for in my way it lies,’ he is saying he must either forget about his ambitions or plan to do something about the obstacles in the way of his future, his decision is made: ‘stars hide your fires! Let not light see my black and deep desires.’ He is asking God to not let anyone discover his ambitions; we lose sympathy for Macbeth at this point. In scene 5, Lady Macbeth reads a letter from Macbeth of what the witches have predicted, Lady Macbeth becomes desperate for the crown and will now stop at nothing to get it. However she doubts Macbeth’s drive for this throne: ‘yet I do fear thy nature. It is too full o’ the milk of human kindness’ so she decides to persuade by ‘pouring her spirits into thine ear.’ When Macbeth arrives home she persuades and manipulates him into killing Duncan when he comes to spend the night at their castle. We can feel sympathy for Macbeth at this point because he has thinking about killing Duncan and he is vulnerable but Lady Macbeth causes him to change his mind. Scene 6 is a very short one in which Duncan and others arrives at Inverness and is greeted by Lady Macbeth, and flatters him by saying: ‘all our service, in every point done twice and then double, were poor and single business to contend against those honours deep and broad wherewith Your Majesty loads our house’. In scene 7 Macbeth debates with himself whether he should kill Duncan. But his wife goads him, manipulating him, she questions his manhood ‘Was hope drunk wherein you dressed yourself.’ She even questions his love for her ‘From this time, should I account thy love.’ Macbeth still questions himself, but she begs him to tighten his courage to the limit. Lady Macbeth his pushing and pulling at a weak and vulnerable mind, so we must feel sympathy for him. Macbeth goes ahead with the plan to murder Duncan. In conclusion, I do feel sympathy for Macbeth at some points of Act 1 due to his wife being so ruthless and his loyalty and humanity at the beginning of the Act, but I feel as though this means hardly anything because his does think about killing Duncan and Macbeth knows what he plans to do is wrong, and fully acknowledges the future consequences.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Sympathy for Macbeth

    ...Do we have any sympathy for Macbeth at the end of the play? Our first impressions of Macbeth are that he is a hero, he is brave and fearless, and although we get this impression we also get the feeling that he is ruthless. We get this impression from the way he is referred to when his name is first mentioned. Macbeth has just been in battle aga...

    Read More
  • Macbeth- Sympathy

    ...How does Shakespeare retain a degree of sympathy for Macbeth through to the end of the play? In order for this play to be a tragedy, we must feel some sympathy for the protagonist through to the end of the play – that is one of the features of the genre. So, how does Shakespeare retain a degree of sympathy for the “hell-hound” who murde...

    Read More
  • I Have No Sympathy for Macbeth

    ...Macbeth: essay of argument Practice assessment task 2012 Mode: essay of argument Due date: end of term 2 (ask your teacher for the day and period you are expected to submit this task) Criteria: Students will be assessed on how well they: 1. Demonstrate they have developed a personal, informed reading of the play 2. Write a well-s...

    Read More
  • To What Extent Do You Feel Sympathy for Lady Macbeth?

    ...To what extent do you feel sympathy for Lady Macbeth? Refer to at least two scenes from the play in your answer. In the play “The Tragedy of Macbeth” written by William Shakespeare, we see a very complex character which is Lady Macbeth. Lady Macbeth's character throughout the play changes as she experiences the misfortunes that are brough...

    Read More
  • “‘Worthy Macbeth’ Unworthy of Sympathy”: the Lack of Sympathy for Macbeth in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth

    ...Macbeth, written by playwright William Shakespeare, is one of the most famous and beloved plays of all time. The play, a tragedy revolving around the tragic hero Macbeth, is about a regicide and its aftermath taking place in Scotland. The play begins with Macbeth along with his best friend and fellow nobleman, Banquo, successfully defeating two ...

    Read More
  • Macbeth

    ...Act 2, Scene 2 of Shakespeare's Macbeth is one of the most violent and intense scenes of the play. This scene is essential to the plot because it produces and develops Macbeth’s character as well as showing the first signs of guilt. It also presents a powerful and different side of the duo, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth after the death of King Dunc...

    Read More
  • Macbeth

    ...Macbeth Essay Macbeth is a play filled with murders and lies, but it is not the murderer who is responsible for the most evil in the play. The main character Macbeth kills two important characters in the play, and is responsible for the death of a third. Macbeth is still only the instrument carrying out these evil actions. Other main characters...

    Read More
  • Macbeth essay

    ...The texts I have chosen to compare to Macbeth are; The Laboratory by Browning and Summer of 1969 by Seamus Heaney. The laboratory is about a woman who discovered that her partner was having an affair with another woman. She went to an apothecary and asked for a poison to be made to kill the woman who her partner had cheated with. This can be lin...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.