Preview

Intercultural Communication: Video Analysis of Indians, Outlaws, and Angie Debo

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1211 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Intercultural Communication: Video Analysis of Indians, Outlaws, and Angie Debo
This study case analyses the video “Indians, Outlaws and Angie Debo” with respect to question number one: “What insights about intercultural communication is revealed when one considers the histories, power and identities documented in the intercultural interactions portrayed in the video?”. The following analysis shows the implications of power on people´s conditions of living in the present as well as on people´s perception of history in the past. Moreover it shows how history influences our understanding of who we really are and therefore shapes our personal identity. All those points are the cause of disparity between two culturally different groups. According to the similarity-attraction approach, people tend to avoid others who are unlike them (Colquitt, Lepine, Wesson, 2013), so that a huge barrier between the two diverse groups arises. But does this justify a discriminatory and even hostile behavior toward the inferior group?
The documentary “Indians, Outlaws and Angie Debo” shows Angie Debo as a 98-year old lady, reflecting on her experiences in life. In the documentary she talks about Oklahoma´s history of depriving its five Native American tribes of their land and resources in the 1930s from the perspective of the displaced. Native Americans during this time were seen more than ever as a bounded group by the European Anglo-Americans [in the following analysis, the dominant European Anglo-American group is referred to as whites to simplify the reading]. In comparison to whites who felt superior and avowed to themselves the power to dominate the inferior race, the Native Americans were ascribed a strongly subordinated position in society and were treated in a discriminatory way by the whites.
History is always about perceptions. Therefore there are generally two sides of history: the “winner´s” and the “loser´s” side. As history is normally written down by the winners, which is called grand narrative, only few people know which experiences the losers, or

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Native Americans have three underlining issues; nonnative crime, terminology differences and systemic and institutional racism, in America since 1492 to present that continue to plague Native culture and society. Research will show America, has shown neglect, disregarded, and systematically eliminated native Americans from their home and culture. Native Americans in the Americas have pushed deeper and father into no man's land in such haste and with abhorrence that it have society has robbed Native of identity, home and has embedded a negative image of what was and still is a great peoples.…

    • 92 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    considered to be ignorant and hostiles by the “White” settlers, forced to live on reservations, lost…

    • 1540 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    American Indian Movement

    • 3085 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Native Americans have felt distress from societal and governmental interactions for hundreds of years. American Indian protests against these pressures date back to the colonial period. Broken treaties, removal policies, acculturation, and assimilation have scarred the indigenous societies of the United States. These policies and the continued oppression of the native communities produced an atmosphere of heightened tension. Governmental pressure for assimilation and their apparent aim to destroy cultures, communities, and identities through policies gave the native people a reason to fight. The unanticipated consequence was the subsequent creation of a pan-American Indian identity of the 1960s. These factors combined with poverty, racism, and prolonged discrimination fueled a resentment that had been present in Indian communities for many years. In 1968, the formation of the American Indian Movement took place to tackle the situation and position of Native Americans in society. This movement gave way to a series of radical protests, which were designed to draw awareness to the concerns of American Indians and to compel the federal government to act on their behalf. The movement's major events were the occupation of Alcatraz, Mount Rushmore, The Trail of Broken Treaties, and Wounded Knee II. These AIM efforts in the 1960s and 1970s era of protest contained many sociological theories that helped and hindered the Native Americans success. The Governments continued repression of the Native Americans assisted in the more radicalized approach of the American Indian Movement. Radical tactics combined with media attention stained the AIM and their effectiveness. Native militancy became a repertoire of action along with adopted strategies from the Civil Rights Movement. In this essay, I will explain the formation of AIM and their major events, while revealing that this identity based social movement's…

    • 3085 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A minority is often repressed by the majority, which in many American cases is the Anglo Saxon. The minorities often grow tired of being treated as lesser than humans and take matters into their own hands. Identical to the Chicano’s background, the white American tried to “Americanize” the children and kill their culture (Skousen, 1). Similar to El Plan de Atzlan, the Native Americans advocated “strong identity,” “culture acceptance” and “legacy” amongst other things (Skousen, 3). The Natives took pride in their oral narratives, past and present tribal culture, and their ability to bridge cultures.…

    • 95 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this way, the focus in the film is less on Native Americans themselves and more on Americans and how they see themselves as a part of a history involving Native Americans that is in need of further attention. By stating that the film “continues to disconcert and disrupt,” Kugel also points to the fact that while viewed in a modern context, the film has the potential to be even more progressive and sympathetic towards the minority groups involved, including Native Americans as well as…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Various aspects need to be acknowledged while analyzing and interpreting a historical document, such as understanding and recognizing the bias, looking at history as a progress, and finally establishing the evidence of experience. In this case, Documents from The Destruction of California Indians have been analyzed, and it has come to the attention that the bias remains in the favor of the Indians throughout the article. Also, the idea of positive progress that many historical readings try to convey seems irrelevant to the documents. Finally, the evidence displayed throughout the documents proves unsatisfactory since the evidence of the experience came from a white male perspective, which may have altered the true happenings. All of these…

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Witnesses and historians are the two distinctive groups of people in recording important historical moments. Witnesses observe history by living through it. Historians observe history by gathering and analyzing witnesses ' accounts. Yet the major difference between witnesses and historians is the knowledge of what happened afterwards. Historians know more about the aftermath, and this awareness changes their view of what went before. Witnesses, on contrary, have a comparative advantage here: at a given historical moment, they do not know about the future. Thus their account seems less meticulous or anticipated but more natural and realistic.…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I want to investigate how Settler-Colonial Theory applies to both the Dawes Allotment Act of 1887 and the Native Lands Act of 1913, and how the theory can be used to explain the similarities of the consequences for the native populations despite the numerous differences in geography, native populations, governing nations, and attitudes between the colonizers and the colonized. Furthermore, I want to explore how native identities formulated native reactions to these acts, and if native identities were in any way shaped by the settler-colonial aspects of these acts. My specific research questions are further delineated…

    • 2062 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Paul Chaat Smith and Robert Allen Warrior’s Like A Hurricane sheds light on remarkable Indian activism that U.S. history textbooks tend to overshadow. Up to1996, they argue that this era was only illustrated through the perspectives of sympathetic non-Indians who disagreed with how Federal policy dealt with Indians. Though each author has special ties to the movement they write about – Smith, a Comanche, served on the American Indian Movement’s International Treaty Council, and Warrior, an Osage, founded the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association – the book is not written from their own perspectives. Rather, the pair effectively drew from accounts of “the eyes of urban Indian rebels, conservative tribal chairmen, Bureau of Indian Affairs officials, White House aides, and others” to portray the stories of the movement from a fairly objective point of view – and when the authors stray from objective, the subjective is presented from various vantage points to eliminate overt bias.1 The authors use the terms ‘activism’ and ‘movement’ to describe a short period of time between 1969 and 1973 when Indian people “staged a campaign resistance and introspection unmatched in this century”.2…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    At home and in class, we have watched 3 videos related to intercultural communication problems that can happen in real-life. We also read about Barna’s Stumbling Blocks in Intercultural Communication which is deeply related to the videos.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gung Ho film analysis

    • 949 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Living together with people from different cultural context will expose us to the differences of the culture clearer rather than its similarities (Pattiwael, 2015). This kind of situation is faced by the Americans and the Japanese people who have experienced an intercultural encounter in the movie of “Gung Ho”. Gung Ho is a movie that tells about the clash of cultures after a certain group of Japanese work together with American in order to reopen a car factory in a small town of Pennsylvania, America. The movie basically tells about the negative stereotypes and rivalry that are existed between those two groups while they are working together. In this paper, I want to address the issues on Gung Ho’s movie about the stereotypes and power distance that are shown, and then compare it with my own experiences that are related to the issues.…

    • 949 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Culture and Communication

    • 2027 Words
    • 9 Pages

    * Encounters with people from different cultures are not new, and neither are the various responses to differences…

    • 2027 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Native American

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Native Americans are an indigenous people throughout the world, simply misunderstood and ill-treated for centuries (Scheafer, 2012). History tells us, Native Americans were subject to land theft, controlled by others, and resistance to governance. This discrimination goes back to Christopher Columbus. He and his followers showed true hatred toward the Indian Nation. Europeans moved to extermination or genocide trying to distinguish this culture of people. The United States joined in that mission as time moved forward. Indian land would be taken, the people would be made to conform to the law of the white man causing them to build a defense mechanism of avenging their losses. During the nineteenth century the white man government made policy to give fairness to the tribes. This may have worked if it did not interfere with the needs of the non-Indian people.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Kimberly Roppolo’s article, she concludes the struggles American Indian face through analysis of history and contemporary incidents. She argues that we don’t learn much from the history, and what we learn isn’t a complete picture of the truth. She gives examples, such as Thomas Jefferson’s miscegenation, the beloved creator’s editorials“kill’em all”, to show us that we may learn only the good aspect of one incident, but not the other. Superficially, these incidents seem normal, but they actually indicate bad intentions. She writes about the murders in the 1970s “these murders go largely unnoticed by mainstream America”(193). When we look back into history, we don’t learn about the bad things America has done to American Indian. In fact, we can’t wipe up the history, but our society decides not to teach it. Kimberly criticizes America “Everything around us was made from stolen American Indian resources, our Earth is in danger of global disaster from imbalance greed”(190). Our country is a competitive country. We tend to compare with other countries and always want to be number one. Due to this reason, we take other people’s land and resources. Kimberly also said that we are not aware of American Indian racism. We think that their behaviors encourage the negative stereotype. Kimberly explains that “we must consider the kind of low self-esteem that both conscious historical racism and dysconscious contemporary racism”(195). They are not bad people, yet they just can’t face their past. Lots of American Indian are ashame of their history and…

    • 662 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    All human cultures tell stories about the past, deeds of ancestors, heroes, gods, or animals. Songs sacred to particular peoples were chanted and memorized long before there was any writing with which to record them. Their truth was authenticated by the very fact of their continued repetition. History which can be considered as an account that purports to be true of events and ways of thinking and feeling in some part of the human past stems from this archetypal human narrative activity.…

    • 3397 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays