top-rated free essay

Inequalities in Health

By bettyyellow Jan 19, 2014 738 Words
Inequalities in Health Appraisal

Inequalities in health have many factors but these can be argued against as to whether they are the actual cause. Social class is a factor, along with region, age, gender, ethnicity etc. Measuring the impact of social class is difficult because social classes have changed over the years, eg) working class living conditions have changed, and there is a delay in the onset of diseases, eg) Asbestos related illness. (NICE 2009)

However the Black Reports (1980) finding was that the death rate for men in the lower social classes was twice that for men in the higher social classes, and the gap between the two was increasing not reducing. It also showed that some people in the lower classes were experiencing worse health than in the 1950s, maybe giving evidence that the change in working class living conditions wasn’t such a contributory factor. The report showed that British rates of infant mortality were in some cases higher than those in many developing countries, which doesn’t point towards a class inequality. The Black Report identified four explanations of health inequalities, the artefact explanation, natural or social selection, the cultural/behavioural explanation and materialist or structural explanation. The artefact explanation stated that the relationship between class and health is artificial rather than real, arising either through the inadequate measurement of social class and health, or in the measurement of the relationship between the two. (UCEL 2003) The natural and social explanation involved the idea that health was a cause of social class position rather than a consequence, and that individuals are selected into higher classes, while the weakest go down the social scale to occupy the lowest position. The cultural/behavioural explanation defined culture as a set of specific behaviours (smoking, excessive drinking, unhealthy diet and physical inactivity) which have consequences for health. These behaviours were regarded as cultural because of the understanding that they are within the control of individuals. The materialist or structuralist explanation explained the role of economic and structural factors in the distribution of health and well being. Research was conducted to provide evidence for the materialist/structuralist explanation. It found a link between low birth weight and high blood pressure in adulthood which leads to increased coronary heart disease. (UCEL 2003) The Inverse care law stated that working class people receive poorer treatment from the health service. It stated that in poorer areas, qualified doctors are less likely to set up practices so people in lower classes are less like to receive efficient healthcare, when in fact they may be the ones that need it most due to bad living conditions & housing etc. The postcode lottery refers to this suggesting postcodes in richer areas tend to have more money to spend on health care than poorer areas. (DH 2011)

The Acheson Report (1998) showed many similarities with the Black Report. It found that there are still inequalities in different class groups, with evidence it is still growing. The report put forward several solutions including policies to reduce stress at work, improved access to health services for all classes, improve nutrition in schools, improved benefits and access to benefits for the most needy families. (DH 2011)

In summary the evidence shows there are social class based health inequalities, however there are problems in measuring class and health. The issue of social change, and delay in the onset of diseases should be taken into account when looking at this inequality. Evidence shows life expectancy is lower in poorer, less developed countries. The Acheson Report is in depth, but prefers to advise how funds should be allocated and not what should be done to solve the problems.

Some evidence for social class health inequality is more conclusive than others, however social class can involve status, wealth, culture, background and employment. There is not a simple relationship between class and ill health. Everyone will experience a number of different influences on their health. 

References
BBC (2005), Health inequality. [online] Available from: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4139440.stm [Accessed 21/06/2012] Department of Health (2011), Health inequalities. [online] Available from: http://www.dh.gov.uk/health/tag/health-inequalities/ [Accessed 21/06/2012] Kings fund (2009), Health inequalities. [online] Available from: http://www.kingsfund.org.uk/topics/health_inequalities/#keypoints [Accessed 21/06/2012] NICE (2009), health inequalities. [online] Available from: http://www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/documents/smoking_and_health_inequalities.pdf [Accessed 21/06/2012] UCEL (2003), The Black Report. [online] Available from: http://www.ucel.ac.uk/shield/black_report/Default.html [Accessed 21/06/2012]

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • health inequalities in ireland

    ... S Issues arising Wiley (2005) on NTPF See ntpf.ie BARRY, J ET AL – INEQUALITIES IN HEALTH IN IRELAND HEALTH INEQUALITIES ON THE ISLAND OF IRELAND 2007 PUBLIC HEALTH ALLIANCE in relation to health services there is a need for The 2005 C and AG report on NTPF ch 14 dept of health and children The Waiting Lis...

    Read More
  • Health inequalities

    ...Inequalities in health exist, whether measured in terms of mortality, life expectancy or health status; whether categorised by socioeconomic measures or by ethnic group or gender. Recent efforts to compare the level and nature of health inequalities in international terms indicate that Britain is generally around the middle of comparable western...

    Read More
  • Health Inequalities

    ...health Health Inequalities 1.1 Our much dated concept and measurement of health has generally focused on ill health form a physiological point of view. By the mid twentieth century, the health pictures had changed, people as a whole were no longer looked upon as disease ridden and ideas of positive health emerged. The WHO formulated its defin...

    Read More
  • Inequality in Health completed essey

    ...Inequality in Health Health is not just the outcome of genetic or biological processes but is also influenced by the social and economic conditions in which we live. These influences have become known as the ‘social factors of health’. An inequality in social conditions rises to unequal and unjust health outcomes for different social grou...

    Read More
  • Inequalities in health and illness

    ...Explain patterned inequalities in health and illness. Evaluate sources of evidence with regards to class, gender, ethnicity and age There are many different reasons why health inequalities exist due to many factors one extremely important one is social class. Socio-economic inequalities have been researched in the UK for many years. In the...

    Read More
  • Sociology Inequalities in Health and Illness

    ...Task 3 – Inequalities in Health and Illness (P3,M2,D1) Gender (P3) - Mortality rates: In gender men generally die earlier than women because of many aspects of their life, for instance in general women tend to take care of them self more physically. A lot of women go on diets and a lot of exercise DVDs and detunes are mainly aimed at wo...

    Read More
  • The Inequalities Surrounding Indigenous Health

    ...The Inequalities Surrounding Australian Indigenous Health Inequality in health is one of the most controversial topics within Australian Health Care. Inequality in relation to health is defined as being “differences in health status or in the distribution of health determinants between different population groups” (World Health Organizati...

    Read More
  • health

    ...Revised Proposal AWARENESS OF NUTRITION AND HEALTH ISSUES AMONG PREGNANT AND LACTATING MOTHERS: A CASE STUDY OF DISTRICT BASTI, U.P. ABSTRACT It is a well-known fact that the growth and development of a child begins from the mother’s womb. Right from the development of the child in the mother’s womb even at the time of birth a...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.