Preview

Individual Criminal Defense Case Analysis Paper

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2165 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Individual Criminal Defense Case Analysis Paper
Individual Criminal Defense Case Analysis
Ora Howe
CJA/354
November 18, 2013
Peter Lukevich

Individual Criminal Defense Case Analysis
This paper will locate two cases that discuss various types of criminal defenses. The two choices are: (1) The Jeffrey Dahmer Case, and (2) State v. Fisher Involuntary Manslaughter Case. The two cases analysis in which this paper identifies and examines the types of criminal defenses that were used. This paper will also explain the nature and types of defenses used in the cases and what evidence was used to demonstrate the defense. This paper will describe how justification and excuse play a role in the cases. This paper will also describe the outcome of each case.
The Jeffrey Dahmer Case/Early
…show more content…
Although Jeffrey Dahmer succeeded at first in the systematized and well-organized structure of the military, he was discharged after two years of service due to heavy drinking. In 1982, after being arrested for disorderly conduct and public intoxication, Jeffrey Dahmer went to live with his grandmother in West Allis. During this stage, Dahmer’s manners grew progressively stranger; his grandmother regularly found weapons in his room and Dahmer was arrested twice for indecent exposure in 1982 and 1986 (Laws, 2013). As one can see Dahmer criminal defenses started at an early age, whereas any individual think sometimes at what point could the parents have stopped Dahmer’s behavior and what measures could have stopped these brutal killings from …show more content…
Succeeding this attack, Dahmer continued to kill periodically: Dahmer committed two murders in 1988, one in the early part of 1989 and one later. Dahmer normally picked up his victims in gay bars, drugged them and then brutally murdered them. Dahmer, as a psychotic post-humorous ritual, would often keep his victim’s body parts or skulls in his apartment refrigerator. Jeffrey Dahmer picked up his murdering pace in the early 1990s. Using his own residence as the central hub for his devastation, Jeffrey Dahmer averaged one murder a week during the summer of 1991.
Explain the Nature and Types of Defenses Used in the Cases and what Evidence was used to demonstrate the defense
The nature of this case is the insanity defense, types, legal and psychological issues, due process, postpartum psychosis. On July 13, 1992, Dahmer disregarded his lawyer 's advice and changed his plea to guilty, but that he was insane. According to Don Davis in The Milwaukee Killings, "the statement turned the case on its head. Now, instead of having to verify his man did not commit the killings, defense attorney Gerald Boyle would undo one of the gruesome tapestries ever seen in an American courtroom. Boyle task was to prove the jury that Dahmer was imprudent, because only an insane individual would do the things he did." Mike McCann, on the other hand, needed to show that Dahmer was not lawfully insane — that he knew what he was doing

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer

    • 1204 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Most crimes that are committed during the normal daily activities of people’s lives is indicative of the Routine Activities Theory that gives insight onto how Jeffrey Dahmer was so successful in luring, raping, and murdering unsuspecting men from the local gay nightclubs in Milwaukee. Jeffrey Dahmer had willingness and the ability to commit such heinous predatory crimes. He was motivated by a strong sexual desire for sexual gratification that deviated from the norm, evident by his method of killings and the amount of times these acts occurred. Dahmer never used aggression in the commission of his crimes but rather a method of attack that would con his victims into lowering their guard making them main targets for him. Dahmer’s primary targets were drifters, locals, and prostitutes often exchanging alcohol and money for sexual favors. This can be the sole reason why so many men became Dahmer’s victim because he targeted individuals who would voluntarily leave with him. As stated in the biography Dahmer’s hot-spot for possible targets revolved around the gay-night clubs depicted in the film catered to Dahmer’s sexual preferences. Typically in the night-club scenario possible targets for violence are typically females making males not likely to be subjective to violence and as an onlooker in a club setting it is difficult to differentiate the victim from the assailant in a gay male couple. Dahmer’s character towards his victims was very routine and cunning making his victims typically prostitutes and locals susceptible to his method of persuasion. His targets were individuals who were easily persuaded by money and their non-awareness towards a possible harmful target made them even more likely to become one of his many victims. It is reasonable to infer that an individual could have decreased their chances of victimization if they were more self- conscious and aware of the situation they were putting themselves into and not so trustworthy of a complete stranger.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jeffrey was not very popular in high school. He played the clarinet, tennis, and wrote for the school paper. He also had a history of alcohol abuse, which will continue for the rest of life. A classmate recalls Jeffrey drinking cups of scotch at his desk. Though unpopular, he was known for a lot of pranks including bleating like a sheep, shouting out things at strange times, and faking epileptic fits. In addition around age fourteen, his compulsions in regard to necrophilia and murder began. Dahmer claims that, “around age fourteen or fifteen, I started to have obsessive thoughts of violence intermingled with sex.” Throughout high school, he continued to collect dead animals. Jeffrey remembers in ninth grade during a biology class, “…we had the usual dissection of a fetal pig. I took that ham and kept the skeleton and I just started branching out to dogs,…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    At about the same time as his first murder, Dahmer began drinking heavily. In 1979, after only one term at Ohio State University, he dropped out due to his alcoholism. His newly remarried father insisted that Dahmer enlist in the Army and he was soon posted in Germany. Jeffrey’s father assumed that the strict regulations of the army would ‘cure’ his son’s alcohol problem, but not even two years later the Army discharged him. Upon his return home, Dahmer unearthed Hicks’ remains and pulverized them with a hammer, then scattered them even more widely.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Criminal Defense

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In order to convict a criminal, prosecutors are required to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The most common criminal defenses fall under two categories, excuse and justification. An excuse is when a person admits to committing a criminal act but believes that he or she can’t be held responsible because there was no criminal content. Some excuses used in court today are; mental disorder, infancy (age), mistake of fact, mistake of law and automatism. In justification defenses, the accused admits to wrongdoing but argues that he or she should be freed from culpability or assessed reduced liability for the crime due to mitigating circumstances surrounding offense. These defenses are factors that excuse a competent person from liability for…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Serial Killers

    • 6319 Words
    • 19 Pages

    Increasing more than ever, American society is fascinated with serial and mass murderers. Throughout the decades, people have celebrated killers who have reached the peak of success within their field by glorifying them in movies, documentaries, magazines, and even on trading cards. In 1991, a trading card company in California created its first mass and serial card collection, which included notorious murderers such as Jeffrey Dahmer who killed 17 men between 1978 and 1991. Dahmer was known to have sex with the corpses of his victims, kept body parts of others, and ate some of the parts as well. Eventually, Dahmer was sentenced to 15 consecutive life terms and was killed in prison in 1994. . Television programs have also increased people’s fascination with serial and mass murderers by creating documentaries and mini series about them. Many popular actresses and actors who play serial and mass killers in movies unfortunately infuse these murderers with humanity and attraction (Fox & Levin, 2005). In this unit we look at the differences between serial killing and mass killing and investigate some of the motives that are behind the predominantly white middle class males who commit some of the most gruesome and legendary volume killing of other humans.…

    • 6319 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jeffery Dahmer

    • 1992 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Jeffery Dahmer, the Butcher of Milwaukee, is one of America’s most well known serial killers. Routinely, Dahmer would pick up men, usually from a gay bar, bring them back to his house, sedate them, and then murder them. However, he is distinguished mostly by his gruesome interactions with his victims after their deaths, particularly necrophilia, mutilation, and cannibalism of their bodies. The amount of forensic evidence found at his apartment is stifling, including the remains of 11 of his victims. Dahmer claimed responsibility for 17 murders, within the time range of 1978 and 1991.…

    • 1992 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer was born in Milwaukee on May 21, 1960, to Lionel and Joyce Dahmer. Despite the difficulties of Joyce's pregnancy, he was wanted and adored as a child. By all accounts, Dahmer displayed traits of a happy, bubbly youngster. However, several events from his childhood indicated that the young boy was becoming more and more disturbed. When Jeff was four, his father swept out the remains of some small animals from under the house. As his father gathered the tiny animal bones, Dahmer seemed strangely entertained by the sound they made.At the young age of six, Dahmer suffered a double hernia and needed surgery to correct the problem. After the operation, he was never the same socially. (biographychannel)…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Criminal Law Paper

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this essay I will be discussing the case of David Bobby, Warden vs. Archie Dixon, I will express my feelings of the case and what caught made me interested in the case I selected. The sources, purposes and jurisdictions of the criminal law related to this case will also me mentioned within this essay, I will define accomplice liability and criminal liability and express how it relates to the case that I will be discussing. The difference between the various elements of crime, including Mens Rea, Actus Reus and Concurrence will be included in this essay with the relations of the within this case.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dahmer grew up in Bath, Ohio and went to Revere High School before moving to Milwaukee where he garnered the infamous nickname the Milwaukee Cannibal. Dahmer is, without a doubt, the most abnormal and notorious criminal in American history. On top of being a serial killer and registered sex offender, he was committed for being a rapist, a cannibal and a necrophiliac who would hide the body parts of his victims throughout his house and in the walls and store the skulls and heads of his victims in freezers, apparently collecting them as trophies. Yoon (2012) explains that in the trial, Dahmer was found to be legally sane during his crimes and pled not guilty by reason of insanity. The plea was subsequently rejected and Dahmer was convicted of all fifteen murder charges and sentenced to fifteen consecutive life sentences. Yoong (2012) states that the case was seen by many as the death of the insanity plea. The argument was that if someone as deranged and psychotic as Dahmer were to be rejected the insanity plea, then no other criminal following his case would meet the qualifications of the defense. If offenders like Hinckley Jr. and Steinberg walk free for single murders however, Dahmer is denied any possibility of being insane then it displays the wrongfulness and the lopsided nature that is the insanity…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer Case

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In June of 1990, Jeffrey strikes again. This time his victim’s name was Edward Smith. He was twenty-eight when they met a bar. They went back to Jeffrey’s, had sex, and Jeffrey killed him. Then in July 1990, he murdered Raymond Smith, with the usual modus operandi, drug, strangle, dismember. He kept the skull of this victim. On September 13, 190, he kills Earnest Miller, age twenty-four. Dahmer keeps the entire skeleton and his biceps, which he later eats. On September 24, 1990, Jeffrey kills David Thomas, age twenty-four. This time he takes photos during the murder. On February 18, 1991 he murders nineteen-year-old Curtis Straughter. He picked him up a bus stop, offering him money to take picture. They went back to Dahmer’s and he drugged, murdered, dismembered his body. He keeps the skull of this victim. Jeffery Dahmer’s eleventh victim was nineteen-year-old Errol Lindsey with the same modus operandi. He keeps the skull. Tony Hughes was the next victim. He was deaf and mute. Dahmer passed him a note in a…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “After his first murder in 1978, Dahmer did not kill again for 9 years. Over the next 4 years Dahmer would take 15 more lives in horrible and cruel ways. His strategies were to go to gay clubs and pick up men since in the gay community Jeffrey would be considered a "desirable" man” (Weebly, 2016). Dahmer was not clueless when it came to picking out who he was going to take back next to kill. He chose victims that were recognized as criminals because that way it would not bring suspicion to himself or the criminal if they were missing because people would be less likely to notice. He would bring them back to his grandma’s house at the time or even his own apartment after he got kicked out of his grandmother’s house. He would promise those men sexual acts or favors and even put money down in order to secure them for the…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jeffrey Dahmer was a serial killer. He killed more than 17 young men and teenage boys during the late 1970s to the early 1990s. The nature of hid killing was unseen in American during that time. After killing his victims he stored their body part in his home. Dahmer ate these human remains. This is known as cannibalism. By 1991 authorities caught up with Dahmer. One of his victims was able to escape and inform authorities. The police found the remains of 11 bodies at Dahmer home. Dahmer started long before he became a serial killer. He was molested a child by a neighbor. Then he was face with the divorce of his parents; in which he was later abandoned by his mother. This caused him to have the feelings of loss and rejection. His stepmom stated as a child Dahmer would impaled the heads of animals. He would use acid to graze the meat off the dead animals. This was the start of his usual behavior. It has been stated as a child he fantasized about mutilating and killing men. Many believe his issue with abandonment and mental illness allow him to commit these horrible crimes. His first murder was at the age of 18. He killed Stephen Hicks with a barbell; then smashed his bones with a hammer. It has been stated he did so because he did not want him to leave. It took another nine years before Dahmer would kill again. He started going to gay bars to pick up men and…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer Analysis

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As he is dragging his victim to the bedroom a few feet away, he whispers to himself with a smile on his face, I have something special in store for you! Surrounded by his souvenirs of freshly cleaned skulls, decomposing body parts with family photos hanging on the wall. He places the body gently on the bed, turns the lamp on, removes the clothing and starts cutting off his head. The smell of blood arouses him, the sexual urge for this victim is over whelming but he’s not ready yet, he has to stay in control. The head rolls off onto the floor as he positions the body into a more comfortable position and disemboweled the victim. He smells the blood up close has he’s kissing the intestines, the urge is too strong so he licks the organs still maintaining control of his sexually desires. As he swallows the victims blood he say’s your apart of me now. Right at that moment he knew it was time. He rapes the corpse repeatedly undergoing intense sexual gratification each time until he is too tired to continue. He places the head on his dresser and says, don’t worry we’ll do it all again tomorrow…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer was a very shy and isolated at an early age. Dahmer had fantasies about killing men and having sex with their corpses. Despite these early tendencies during his childhood, Dahmer didn't fulfill these fantasies until after he graduated from high school in June 1978 (Schwartz p 33). Dahmer picked up a hitchhiker by the name of Steven Hicks, and eventually Hicks became Dahmer's first victim. Dahmer enrolled at Ohio State University, only to flunk out within one semester. Next, Dahmer joined the army at the end of 1978, but was discharged for alcoholism and went to live in Florida.…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jeffrey Lionel Dahmer was born May 21, 1960 in West Allis, Wisconsin, US. His mother, Joyce Annette, worked as a teletype machine instructor while his father, Lionel Herbert Dahmer, was a student at Marquette University. From all accounts Dahmer was a happy child who loved typical toddler activities. Unlike the average toddler, at the age of four Dahmer had began killing animals and bringing them home to dissect.(apa- http://www.freewebs.com/serialkillerfacts/jeffreydahmer.htm) It was not until the age of six, after undergoing hernia surgery, that his personality began to change from a elated social child to a loner who kept to himself and became withdrawn.(apa-crime.about) Dahmer had an interest in animals from an early age, in his pre-teen years he began to collect road kill; his favorite hobby. He had a fascination with stripping the animal carcasses and storing the bone away. His father, Lionel was intrigued by fire and made bombs as a child. He wrote a book about his life after his sons conviction. "A dark pathway had been dug into my brain", he writes. Young Jeffrey is transfixed by a pile of bones, which only seems macabre after the adult Jeffrey's deadly deeds. At the time, Lionel saw it as normal curiosity.(apa-trutv) Dahmer attended Rivere High School where he continued being a loner. During this time, he developed a…

    • 3011 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays