India and China Comparative Economic Analysis

Topics: Economics, Macroeconomics, Gross domestic product Pages: 15 (5875 words) Published: August 15, 2010
Economic models of India and China:
Looking back and looking ahead

[5400 words]

China and India are two of the world’s oldest civiliza¬tions, each with the quality of resilience that has enabled it to survive and prosper through the ages and against the odds. Existing in close proximity to each other, the ancient civilizations of India and China surprisingly had little political and economic interac¬tion for the past many centuries. Historically and culturally India never played second fiddle to China and so is the case with China. Therein lies the root cause of volatile and strained relationship. Both see themselves as great Asian powers whose time has finally come. There is no doubt that China and India will be dominant economic powers by the middle of this century but in many key respects they are quite different from one another. This is reflected in the position each has in the areas of economic and social indicators, where the score card is continually changing. Infact, the strengths of India are very often the weaknesses of China and the strengths of China are the weaknesses of India. Notwithstanding their recent economic growth stories, each has its weak point— regional conflicts, pov¬erty, linguistic and religious divisions for India; the contradiction between a capitalist economy and Communist politics, growing regional divide and growing unemployment for China. Both are plagued with domestic politico- economic troubles that could be their undoing if not managed properly. Yet, China and India also share remarkable similarities in economic outlooks and policies. Both are focusing on increasing comprehensive national strength on a solid economic- technological base. Both are major competi¬tors for foreign investment, capital, trade, resources, and markets. Burgeoning economic ties between the world’s two fastest- growing economies have become the most salient aspect of their bilateral relationship. Both have begun to behave like normal neighbors— allowing trade and investment and promoting people- to-people contact. But in the economic sphere Chinese and Indian econ-omies are still more competitive than complementary. More importantly, resource scarcity has now added a new dimension to the traditional Sino- Indian geopolitical strategy. The real issue, of course, isn't where China and India are today but where they will be tomorrow. The answer will be determined in large measure by how well both countries utilize their resources, and on this score, India is doing a superior job. Though India has inherited a more heterogeneous society and conflict ridden polity, but Indian heterogeneity and pluralism have also provided the basis for a better ability to politically manage conflicts, which China’s overarching homogenizing bureaucratic state has so far failed to acquire and this ability is likely to be sorely needed in the future years of increasing conflicts inevitable in a fast-growing internationally-integrated economy with mounting disparities and tensions. So, this requires looking at deeper social, economic and historical forces than simply referring to an aggregative comparison of an authoritarian and a democratic political regime.

China and India are the world's next major powers. They also offer competing models of development. Together accounting for 2.5 billion people, China and India are today the engines of growth in the midst of rapid economic transformation in the global economy. Since 1980, China and India have achieved remarkable rates of economic growth. The emergence of China and India as major forces in the global economy has been one of the most significant economic developments in recent economic history. It has long been an article of faith that China is on the faster track, and the economic data bear this out. The "Hindu rate of growth"-a pejorative phrase referring to India's inability to match its economic growth with its population growth-may be a thing of the...

References: 3. Nirupam Bajpai and Tianlun Jian, Reform Strategies of China and India: Suggestions for Future Actions, Discussion Paper, 1996.
4. Susan M. Collins and Barry Bosworth, Accounting for Growth: Comparing China and India, NBER Working Paper, 2007.
6. Pranab Bardhan, Crouching Tiger, Lumbering Elephant: A China-India Comparison, 2006.
7. Zhōng- Yìn guānxì, India-China Relations, Berkshire Encyclopedia of China, 2009
8. Yasheng Huang and Tarun Khanna, Can India Overtake China? Foreign Policy, July-August 2003
9. Pieter Bottelier, India 's Growth from China 's Perspective, The Journal of Applied Economic Research, 2007.
10. Manas Chakravarty, Why India’s Growth Story is Different? Business World, 2006.
11. Venkatesan Vembu, China’s investment-led growth a time bomb, DNA, 2009.
12. T. N. Srinivasan, China and India: Economic performance, competition and cooperation, 2004.
13. Meghnad Desai, India and China: An essay in comparative political economy, IMF conference on india/china, 2003.
14. S. Urata, India and China: Trade, Investment and Development Strategies, 2007.
15. Arvind Virmani, China’s Socialist Market Economy: Lessons of Success, ICRIER, 2005.
16. Renfeng Zhao, China and India: A comparison of trade, investment and expansion strategies, Chatam House, 2007
- ABHIJIT KUMAR
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • A Critical Analysis of the Structural Adjustments and Economic Reform in India: Essay
  • Comparative Analysis Between China Morocco Essay
  • India
  • Economics
  • HSC Economics: Globalisation- China Essay
  • CHINA AND INDIA ON FDI Essay
  • China Economics Essay
  • Comparative Analysis: Vietnam & China Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free